The Effects of Prolonged Stress in Dogs

Stress in dogs may have long-lasting results.
Stress in dogs may have long-lasting results. | Source

The Effects of Stress on Dogs: My Experience and How it Enticed me To Become a Dog Trainer

When dogs experience very intense, prolonged stress, this stress may have after effects that may last even after the direct cause of the stress has been removed. As a dog trainer and behavior consultant, I have seen this happen quite often both in my dogs and the dogs of my clients.

For instance, my male Rottweiler, is more reactive than my female and tends to take more time to unwind from intense stress. I have seen this several times. The first time this happened, I really had no idea what was going on. For a moment, I seriously thought he had lost it and I had a hard time figuring out why all of a sudden he was so weak nerved towards certain stimuli he never reacted to before.

It happened the first time when we moved from the United States to Europe. Obviously, my dogs had never been on an airplane before and never were at an airport. On departure day, my dogs were exposed to loud airplanes taking off and landing and unusual beeping noises. They were taken in and out of the crates as security looked inside. Not to mention, they most likely felt our tension. Normally, I would have exposed them to the noises and possibly taken to the airport days prior to get them used to all these novel stimuli, but everything happened so quickly (my hubby's dad got gravely ill) and we had no airports within 3 hours to practice.

Fortunately, all went well, our dogs were safe and the flight was smooth. That night our dogs met my hubby's parents and seemed to settle in their new place. Until.... My husband's dad slowly came upstairs with his flashlight and came to tell us where our blankets were. That's the first time I saw my male bark, growl and show his pearly whites to a person. The next day, things didn't get better: he started growling at hubby's mom every time she came inside from the door. Then it was my hubby's brother-in-law turn, and soon, my friendly dog had a whole new reputation of being aggressive.

I had never seen this behavior before and was really stressed about it. Every time he growled like that, my stomach felt like a rock and I felt terrible, especially because prior to our arrival we had told everyone how friendly our Rottweilers were since my hubby's family always thought they were dangerous due to the media. Now, my Rott's behavior was proving them right....and that felt just awful, awful,awful...I often cried just thinking about it; I wanted my friendly dog back so bad!

For a while, I thought his behavior was possibly due to his second-fear period, but the issues methodically took mostly place after a stressful event and soon a pattern was seen. Out of desperation, I purchased Patricia McConnell's book "The Cautious Canine" and followed the step-by-step guide to a T. Some nights I fell asleep reading about how to cope with this behavior. The methods used though appeared to start working after some time. Day after day, my boy's old happy-go-lucky behavior started to resurface and soon everybody felt better being around him.

On the way back to the United States, after another 8-hour plane flight, my male barked again at an airline employee at the airport as she moved towards him. That same lady, later on, placed a tag on his cage while he was inside and her face was right next to him. Thankfully, he cared less this time.

I learned my lesson though; my weak-nerved male didn't handle stress well and it appeared to have a prolonged effect on him. Now, I know how to manage him better and screen subtle dog signs of stress before they escalate. I also use powerful, force-free behavior modification methods to help him cope with triggers better. But back then, I grew so interested in dealing with dog aggression and the implications of stress, that I seriously started studying dog behavior, reading books, attending workshops, frequenting trainers and this whole ordeal is what ultimately enticed me to become a professional certified dog trainer and help others in similar situations.

The Effects of Stress on Dogs: Individual Reactions

How a dog responds to stress varies on several factors. I often asked myself, why is my male more likely to aggress when stressed, while my female was more laid back, and appeared to have less problems? The predisposition to respond to stress in a certain way may be genetic. Just as in people, some dogs may be more likely to take out their stress on others, while some may instead take it on themselves. Also, just as in people, stress can be subjective: what one dog may see as stressful, another dog may take as normal or non-stressful.

Commonly, dogs tend to get stressed when there are subtle or more significant changes to their routines. Expect to see stress in the following scenarios:

  • Upon being relinquished to a shelter.
  • Upon being adopted out to a new home.
  • Upon moving.
  • Upon having new guests
  • Upon having a new baby
  • Upon adding a new dog
  • Upon undergoing surgery or medical treatment
  • Upon traveling
  • Upon being left at a kennel
  • Upon being left alone.

The Effects of Stress on Dogs: What Studies Say

When dogs go through intense, prolonged emotional stress, their body will still be bombarded by stress hormones such as adrenaline and cortisol even after the stressful event has passed. When stress is intense and prolonged like that, dogs often display exaggerated behavior, and are therefore, more likely to aggress because stress lowers emotional and impulse thresholds. This means dogs can be more likely to overreact and react with less and less provocation and impulsively.

For instance, in a study conducted by Michael B Hennessy, ,Harry N Davis,Michael T Williams et al, cortisol levels of dogs in a county animal shelter were examined. According to the study, quoted: " Groups of dogs confined in the shelter for their 1st, 2nd, or 3rd day had higher cortisol levels than did a group maintained in the shelter for more than 9 days. Dogs in the shelter for an intermediate period (Day 4–9) had intermediate levels of cortisol. "

Stress as it turns out, has also several health effects in dogs, weakening the immune system and predisposing dogs to disease. And don't believe post-traumatic stress only applies to veterans and Army personnel! Military dogs were found to suffer from post-traumatic stress as well! Prolonged stress was also observed in dogs that were subjected to the 2011 Japan earthquake and subsequent nuclear disaster at Fukushima. These dogs were found to have "five to 10 times the cortisol levels of dogs not touched by disaster, a gap that narrowed but did not close even after 10 weeks of loving care in the rehabilitation program."

Interestingly, the effects of stress on dogs can start even before they are born! Studies on rats show that when pregnant rats are subjected to stress, the offspring are more likely to show fearful behaviors and decreased learning. In dogs, it's important to provide pregnant dogs with a relaxing environment, especially during the third trimester.

Alexadry © all rights reserved, do not copy!

Dog Suffering from Post Traumatic Stress

More by this Author

Comments 13 comments

Larry Fields profile image

Larry Fields 3 years ago from Northern California

Hi alexadry. Great hub as usual. I didn't know that dogs could suffer PTSD, but I'm not surprised. That would explain a thing or three.

That said, I'm not sure what a person should do to help a PTSD dog. I remember from your earlier hub (about canine phobias?) that you can expose your dog to his triggers, but starting at very low doses, and gradually increase from there. Then immediately after he takes it in stride, reward him with a high-value treat. Is it the same thing with canine PTSD?

Voted up and interesting.

geetbhim profile image

geetbhim 3 years ago from Ludhiana India

I must say that the one who own pet should go through your hub, as usual this hub too is useful and understanding a canine behavior why do they act strangely. voted up! and sharing.

alexadry profile image

alexadry 3 years ago from USA Author

Hi Larry, thanks for stopping by! The video I posted shows the rehabilitation process of a dog suffering from PTSD. As you can see, they were engaging in confidence building exercises, exposure to people giving treats and loads of praise. I am sure it's quite a challenge to recuperate these dogs and that it takes loads of time.

Nettlemere profile image

Nettlemere 3 years ago from Burnley, Lancashire, UK

Interesting to read about your experience of a dog suffering from stress. I've certainly seen it in dogs kenneled in rescue kennels - most manage fine, but a few really go to pieces.

wetnosedogs profile image

wetnosedogs 3 years ago from Alabama

I can imagine it hurt so much to see your dog react so differently than normal.

Interesting video. I am glad to hear that dog was recovered as well as yours. They certainly are worth the extra work and love needed at the time.

GiblinGirl profile image

GiblinGirl 3 years ago from New Jersey

Very interesting. Who knew stress could have such prolonged effects on dogs. I also checked out your hub on calming signs - I think I can see some of them in my own dog - very enlightening.

alexadry profile image

alexadry 3 years ago from USA Author

Nettlemere, thanks for stopping by. I worked for a kennel and saw some poor dogs getting diarrhea and being unable to eat and shaking those first few days of boarding. They looked very stressed.

alexadry profile image

alexadry 3 years ago from USA Author

Wetnosedogs, my male is again his old happy-go-lucky self fortunately, greets people happily but he taught me so much!

alexadry profile image

alexadry 3 years ago from USA Author

Thanks for stopping by Giblingirl! As studies unroll, dogs seem to share more traits with humans than imagined.

midget38 profile image

midget38 3 years ago from Singapore

A very informative hub!! Stress does have a prolonged effect on dogs....if left alone for too long, they show it in eliminating, barking, glad yours managed to get over it quickly! Thanks for sharing!

alexadry profile image

alexadry 3 years ago from USA Author

Many dogs suffer from separation anxiety, something my clients call me often for! thanks for stopping by!

Lipnancy profile image

Lipnancy 3 years ago from Hamburg, New York

The poor thing. Those situations stress me out also.

alexadry profile image

alexadry 3 years ago from USA Author

Dogs are more similar to use as thought!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article