Dog People and Cat People Personality Types

Pet Preference and Personality

Are the pets we prefer a reflection of our personality?
Are the pets we prefer a reflection of our personality? | Source

Dog People and Cat People

Do dog people really have different personalities than cat people?

Some people call themselves dog people or cat people. What makes a person have a preference over one species of a pet over another?

When you talk to people about pets, they most probably will reveal that they are either a dog lover or a cat lover. Sometimes people’s preference is very strong. Some people are not just cat or dog lovers, some people are haters of one or the other species.

It is believed that people who are dog lovers or cat lovers of those who hate the species, may fit into a particular personality type.

Dogs and cats do have distinct behavioral characteristics and these behaviors may reflect the way a person can interact with their pets.

Personality Traits and Pet Preferences

In the wild, non domesticated cats are solitary hunters and are active at night. Wild canines are social animals that travel together in groups. Dogs work together during daylight, from dawn to dusk. All dogs evolved from the wolf. Wolves are also pack animals. Dogs do not do well on their own. When they don’t have a pack, they look somewhat lost. Domesticated dogs retained these qualities and when they are adopted by a human family, the dog looks at the people they live with as part of their pack. A dog wants to be part of the activities of their family, sometimes even intruding on the things they are doing in order to be part of what everyone is doing and when they want to play or they feel bored.

Cats may or may not be part of the family activities, and if they are, their interest is limited.

There Are Dog People

Dog people have a different connection with their pets than cat people.
Dog people have a different connection with their pets than cat people. | Source

Differences Between Dog People and Cat People

In a poll done by Associated Press - Petside.com, there are more dog lovers than cat lovers. the majority of the people in their study had a strong preference for liking dogs. Only 4% said they disliked dogs, and 25% said they disliked cats. Married men were the most likely to dislike cats.

In another study done by psychologist Sam Gosling, at the University of Texas in Austin, over 4500 participants were asked in a web based study if they considered themselves dog lovers or cat lovers, neither or both. The people were also given a personality assessment test that would classify their personality into the Big Five personality traits. His research results showed that there are major personality differences between dog people and cat people.

According to the study, dog people showed that they were slightly more extroverted by 15%, slightly more agreeable by 13% than cat people, and 11% more conscientious than cat people. Both agreeableness and extroversion are associated with sociability. Conscientiousness has to do with self discipline, completing tasks, and achieving. Conscientious people often schedule things, rather than being spontaneous.

The study also showed that cat people were slightly more open than dog people, by about 11%, and slightly more neurotic, by 12%, than dog people. Being open has to do with wanting exposure and appreciation for adventure, creativity, art, curiosity, emotions, and gaining a variety of experience. People who rank higher on the openness range are more likely to have less conventional beliefs, be somewhat less traditional thinking.

and There Are Cat People

Are there differences in the personalities of people who prefer cats to dogs?
Are there differences in the personalities of people who prefer cats to dogs? | Source

Big Five Personality Traits and Pet People

In a book called, "Why We Love The Dogs We Do." a study was done involving over 6,000 participants from age 16 to 94. 3,362 dog owners only, 1,223 cat owners only, and 1.564 who were not pet owners. People who own dogs and cats are more similar to people who only own dogs. According to the results of the study, people who owned both dogs and cats, were more like dog people.

The study revealed that about ⅓ of the cat owners were more likely to live alone and two times a likely to live in an apartment. Dog owners were more likely to be married, to live in a house, and had children living at home.

Single women were more likely to have a cat. For those people that grew up with a cat, 47% were more likely to have a cat as an adult. Only 11% of people who grew up with a dog, had a cat as an adult.

Lifestyle and Pet Ownership

This study also found that people who owned cats were more introverted, less warm, and less agreeable than dog owners. In addition, this study found cat people were less dominant type personalities. People who are more dominant tend to be more assertive, more self confident, and stand out in social gatherings. In another part of the study, it appeared that cat owners were more trusting. Trusting people are categorized as being more obliging, modest, and straightforward. The opposite would be people who are more suspicious and manipulative.

This study also asked cat people if someone gave them a puppy, and they had the space for it, and there were no objections from others, would they keep the puppy. The same question about a kitten, was asked of people who only owned dogs. Over ⅔ of the cat owners, 68% said they would not keep the puppy. Among the dog owners, 70% said they would keep the kitten.

In these studies, it is important to consider that ownership of a particular pet may reflect more of their lifestyle, than their pet preferences.

It is not really known why there are differences between dog and cat people. One theory is that the dog or the cat reflect closely to the compatible personality traits of their owners.

Dogs are very affectionate, sociable, and warm, which correlate to the extraversion and agreeableness of the Big Five Personality Traits. Dogs require more care and this may appeal more naturally to the conscientious trait too. Cats require less attention, and the owners can be more laid back because of this.

Because cats have a more independent streak, this may correlate to the more non conformist thinking of cat people. It is not as clear why cat people score higher on the neurotic scale of the Big Five Personality Dimensions. Some think that cats may have a more calming effect on people and this may appeal more to people who feel more neurotic.

When the study further looked at the gender differences, it showed that men who owned cats were more neurotic than male dog owners. There seemed to be less difference between dog and cat people who were female.


Read More

If you would like to read more about the personality of people and there pets you can click here

if you would like to read about how dogs can understand humans so well click here.

If you would like to read about behavior disorders in dogs and cats click here

If you would like to read more about personalities, please go to my website:

www.aboutpersonalities.com


People and Personality Types

Do you think personaity types match the pets people choose?

See results without voting

What is Your Personality Type

Are You ...

See results without voting

More by this Author


Comments 16 comments

mylindaelliott profile image

mylindaelliott 3 years ago from Louisiana

I always wondered at the differences between cat people and dog people. Good article.


toknowinfo profile image

toknowinfo 3 years ago Author

Hi Mylinda, I am glad you enjoyed this hub.


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 3 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids

We are dog people but for my wife it was an acquired taste. My son and his wife have a cat and not a dog. However, his wife came from a family that raised dogs and she is quite knowledgeable about dogs. My daughter and her husband have two dogs and a cat. It is hard to find a pattern here.up votes and sharing.


toknowinfo profile image

toknowinfo 3 years ago Author

Hi,

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Part of the pattern might be lifestyle. Maybe your son and daughter are not ready for a dog yet. I waited to have dogs until I had kids and a bigger house, yet we had a cat before we started our family.


rebeccamealey profile image

rebeccamealey 3 years ago from Northeastern Georgia, USA

Cool, but what about Cat and Dog people equally?


toknowinfo profile image

toknowinfo 3 years ago Author

Hi Rebecca, People who are equal cat and dog people are supposedly more like dog people, according to the studies that were done.


mecheshier profile image

mecheshier 3 years ago

Wonderful article.. Thank you for such great research and writing. Love the topic! Voted up for interesting and useful. :-)


Suhail and my dog profile image

Suhail and my dog 3 years ago from Mississauga, ON

I liked reference to research work. Very informative!


toknowinfo profile image

toknowinfo 3 years ago Author

H Mech, Thank you for you kind comments and for stopping by to read my hub.


toknowinfo profile image

toknowinfo 3 years ago Author

Hi Suhail, I am glad you enjoyed my hub.


kidscrafts profile image

kidscrafts 3 years ago from Ottawa, Canada

Interesting article, Toknowinfo!

I am a cat person and we are cat people on my mother's side since generations.... and my children continue the tradition.

As a kid, we had one dog and a cat at one point but because my father was not often at home, when we moved from Africa to Belgium, my parents decided that they didn't want another dog.

It's interesting what the study says. I suppose that it's always possible to find generalisations when you can poll enough people.

Thanks for sharing all those facts and statistics! Very interesting!


kashmir56 profile image

kashmir56 3 years ago from Massachusetts

Hello my friend well written and researched article that was very interesting and informative . Well done !

Vote up and more !!! Sharing !


psychicdog.net profile image

psychicdog.net 3 years ago

Hello TKI - I always wondered about this in the recesses of my mind it has been there a long time but you actually put it out there! Well done. I put this up on FB - lol from (just another one) of your admirers.


peachpurple profile image

peachpurple 3 years ago from Home Sweet Home

interesting article. Dog people and cat people, i believe it depends on the owner personality. Some love cats and hate dogs or vice versa and some just aren't animal lover. Voted up


TriciaMool profile image

TriciaMool 3 years ago from Nothern California

good article!


toknowinfo profile image

toknowinfo 3 years ago Author

Hi Tricia, Thanks for stopping by and commenting.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working