American Gothic

Art critic Robert Hughes once remarked of this arresting image, painted in 1930 by Grant Wood :"Along with the Mona Lisa and Whistler's Mother ... it's one of the three paintings that every American knows."

As a non-American, I first came across American Gothic flipping through an art textbook back in high school and was immediately struck by it. An image from a different time, different culture, different country, there was a strangeness about it that fascinated me. Yet beyond that, and despite the unfamiliarity, something about the painting resonated so deep within my psyche I couldn't take my eyes off the page. It struck a chord. Why was that...?

Intiitially I knew nothing about the the painting, apart from what I saw before before me and the artist's name. It was a static, frozen image of a man and woman yet the more one looked, the more things revealed themselves..there was more going on beneath the surface than initially suggested.

Who were the people in the painting and what relationship did they have to each other? Was the woman a wife, a sister..a daughter perhaps? Clearly this was a rural couple, as evidenced by the farmhouse and the pitchfork, at once menacing and emblematic of labour and farm life.

The patriarch looks out directly at the viewer with dark, intense eyes and a stern, uncompromising expression, while the woman, who appears younger, looks across somewhere to the side. Her eyes are softer and blue and her expression is distant and unconnected and the tenseness of her brows knitted together suggests stress or anxiety. While her appearance is neat and orderly --the sombre black and white dress covered by a practical apron--there is a small suggestion of dishevelment in the lock of stray hair dangling from her otherwise perfect hairstyle. A decorative cameo at the woman's neck is the only hint of feminine treasure and that this woman may have dreams and desires beyond the hard pragmatism the image conjurs.

These two figures dominate the scene, positioned as they are to take up three-quarters of the painting, but beyond them is the farmhouse, white and clean, a verandah to the left with homey potted plants and a red barn off to the side. Behind the house a lush landcape is suggested. Most interesting of all, apart from the figures themselves, is the upstairs window, placed between the man and woman. Possibly a bedroom, a white lace curtain obscures the mysteries within and the viewer's eye is inexorably drawn to this area.

Although everyone will attach their own meaning to the work, this writer fancies the painting represents repression, with desire and longing residing in the darkly hidden room behind the upstairs window. Repression is reflected in the tightly shut mouths of the two figures, the furrowed brow of the woman, the male hand clasped firmly around the pitchfork and even in the darkness of the clothes against the light background. The farmer, whose blue overalls, black jacket and wire-rimmed spectacles give him a half preacher/half labourer look, stands in front of the woman, as if to constrain and dominate her and his direct look seems to dare the viewer to challenge his position.

Perhaps this repressive element is the chord it struck with me when I first came across the painting. I felt something bump against my brain...a recognition. Of course a painting need not be analysed to be appreciated..it just has to be 'felt' emotionally but it's interesting to attempt it.

Grant Wood

The woman in the painting is in fact meant to represent the spinster daughter of the farmer and rather prosaically, Wood's models for the painting were his own dentist and his sister.

Grant Wood, who died in 1942, was an obscure American artist, trained in Europe, who wanted to paint a Gothic revival style house along with the kind of people who might live there : “I saw a trim white cottage, with a trim white porch – a cottage built on severe Gothic lines. This gave me an idea. That idea was to find two people who by their severely straight-laced characters would fit into such a home."

The painting won him a bronze medal and $300 in the 1930 Exhibition of American Paintings and Sculpture held at the Art Institute of Chicago.

The real American Gothic house...still standing in Eldon, Iowa
The real American Gothic house...still standing in Eldon, Iowa

Though the models are real, the characters are figments of the artist's imagination and whatever Grant intended, (if he intended anything specific) has been variously interpreted as a satire of Mid-Western puritanism, a representation of the Protestant hard-work ethic, a statement on backwoods incest and even, as Robert Hughes suggested "early camp". Many have seen the woman not just as repressed and dominated but cold and dissapproving. It seems American Gothic rings bells all over the place...sending out different tunes to different viewers. Maybe that's what makes it so special. For a painting to be so endlessly parodied and so far embedded into popular culture, it must at some deep-rooted level connect with a large number of people.

Washington Post Staff Writer , Micheal O'Sullivan, who thinks the painting 'hilarious', gives an interesting take on Woods in a 2006 article, Grant Woods Studio: Birthplace of American Gothic. As well as being an artist, Woods was also a carpenter, designer, stain-glass, jewellery and wrought-iron hardware maker. O'Sullivan posits:

The flavor of "American Gothic" is more truthful, in a sense, to the artistic qualities Wood came to admire and champion -- clear-eyed, solid, precise craftsmanship -- but the painting was not without a certain jaundiced detachment that kept the artist from ever wholly embracing the rustics he depicted. This humorous distance (and it's still a rather hilarious picture) is what Hughes meant by camp.

So is the painting a coldly aesthetic construction rather than an 'embraced' depiction? There is a detachment in the painting, that in fact, heightens the impact of the scene but I think it is also true that the many subtleties and nuances...the humanness, saves it from being viewed merely as a crafted design piece or an amusing slice of camp..

Solemncholy

In the 1930s the painting did not inspire universal admiration -many thought it was too 'grim and serious', especially at a time when Depression-era America was grim and serious enough. To add to this, some Iowa folk thought they were being made fun of:

Mrs Inez Keck of Washta said they looked “inordinately solemncholy” and might have been to a funeral. Mrs Earl Robinson, from the Iowa town of Collins, declared that being true to life wasn’t good enough and that next time around the painter should “choose something wholesome to look at and not such oddities. I advise him to hang this portrait in one of our fine Iowa cheese factories. That woman’s face would sour milk".

From an article by Roger Sandall in Arts and Letters


American Gothic remains one of my favourite paintings. There are so many different interpretations of the one scene to be had and I suspect it's this very ambiguity that gives the picture its strength, in spite of its ubiquity and the fact that it's been parodied to the hilt and back again. In fact it's been parodied so often that that aspect doesn't really work any more. It'd be a pretty tired and unimaginative satirist who would still use this painting to lampoon any sacred cows.

When I first saw it as an Australian teenager I understood little of the Mid Western cultural references and I thought it was much older than it is...it seemed so removed from my suburban context. It didn't really matter that in my ignorance I'd bypassed the essential "Americanness" of it ...as a painting of a man and a woman there was enough to fascinate and interest the viewer. No matter how hackneyed an image it has become, I feel sure it will continue to intrigue.


More by this Author

  • Gilbert and George
    11

    Provocative, eccentric, sensational, attention-seeking, perverse, disturbing, confronting...these are just some of the adjectives fascinating British-based collaborative artists Gibert Proesch and George Passmore...

  • Hyperrealism
    27

    An art dealer first used the term Hyperréalisme (meaning Photorealism) back in the early 1970's to describe a genre of painting and sculpture that mimicked the exactness of high resolution photography....

  • A Day in the Life of a 1950s Housewife
    115

    Post-feminist revolution, 1950's housewives carry a certain amount of hip kudos. Now that we have equality (or a facsimile thereof) we don't have to be on the defensive anymore. We can wear a stiff, full skirt, vintage...


Comments 19 comments

Micky Dee profile image

Micky Dee 6 years ago

I thought all your buttons were awesome as I looked at that classic painting!


David Stone profile image

David Stone 6 years ago from New York City

Good work, Jane.


De Greek profile image

De Greek 6 years ago from UK

Might the answer be here?:

http://hubpages.com/food/Garlic-Longfellow-Humour-...

It might be a classic example of this case :-))


De Greek profile image

De Greek 6 years ago from UK

On second thought, I shall copy the story here to save you teh trouble. If it is too long, please feel free to erease it:

.

.

At the NationalArtGallery in Dublin, a husband and wife were staring at a portrait that had them completely confused

The painting depicted three black men totally naked sitting on a park bench.

Two of the figures had black willies, but the one in the middle had a pink willie.

The curator of the gallery realized that they were having trouble interpreting the painting and offered his assessment.

He went on for over half an hour explaining how it depicted the sexual emasculation of African-Americans in a predominately white, patriarchal society “In fact,” he pointed out, “some serious critics believe that the pink willie also reflects the cultural and sociological oppression experienced by gay men in contemporary society.”

After the curator left, an Irishman, approached the couple and said, “Would you like to know what the painting is really about?”

“Now why would you claim to be more of an expert than the curator at the gallery?” asked the couple

“Because I’m the guy who painted it,” he replied.” In fact, there are no African-Americans depicted at all. They’re just three Irish coal-miners. The guy in the middle went home for lunch.”

.

.


drbj profile image

drbj 6 years ago from south Florida

Jane - this is a brilliant hub - I devoured it with relish. And Dimi - you're a naughty boy. Funny, but naughty!


Jane Bovary profile image

Jane Bovary 6 years ago from The Fatal Shore Author

Hey Micky...thanks!

David, thanks to you too. I appreciate the comments guys.


Jane Bovary profile image

Jane Bovary 6 years ago from The Fatal Shore Author

De Greek..haha..that was not only really funny -it was an apt statement on the posturings of art critics. As if I would delete a comment that enhanced my hub so much? Although I did think I saw the guy with pitchfork raise his eyebrow....must have been my imagination.


Jane Bovary profile image

Jane Bovary 6 years ago from The Fatal Shore Author

Hi drbj..he is naughty. Thankyou for the lovely comment.


Rod Marsden profile image

Rod Marsden 6 years ago from Wollongong, NSW, Australia

Good one Jane.

In the movie Rocky Horror Picture Show there is a nice salute to this painting at the wedding scene which is, of course, quickly followed by a funeral scene. And yes the pitch fork is there along with the couple or I should say the Rocky Horror version of the couple. The fact that it is such a recognizable salute says something about the power of the picture to draw you in.


epigramman profile image

epigramman 6 years ago

..fascinating and enlightening story behind the painting of the sexist couple of all time Dame Jane - and it takes someone like you - and only you - to do such a wonderful job with this subject - you truly are a hubgem - new word by the epigramman by the way - hubgem - not to be confused with what goes on at my hubs - which is a hubjam - loloolo

lol lol


Jane Bovary profile image

Jane Bovary 6 years ago from The Fatal Shore Author

Hi Rod,

Yes, it is definitely powerful. I've yet to see the Rocky Horror Picture Show...I just never got around it, though I've seen plenty of cips. Looks hilarious.

Cheers


Jane Bovary profile image

Jane Bovary 6 years ago from The Fatal Shore Author

Ah Epi...I think it's you who is the hub gem. Thanks for reading.


alberich 6 years ago

Dear Jane!

When I read your hubs I conclude that if this life was a bit different I would like to walk with you all day through the lavender fields in Provence and when the night falls we would find a ridiculously good restaurant in some harbor town at the Mediterranean Sea. There I would like to listen to you,drink exceptional delicious wine to the most excellent of French cooking’s.

Well this is NOT some kind of flirt, it is just respect.

In short, you are a very interesting person and I want you to take care of that!

Love!


Jane Bovary profile image

Jane Bovary 6 years ago from The Fatal Shore Author

Well sounds great to me alberich..and thanks, that was just a beautiful thing to say.

As Mark Twain said.."a good compliment can last me a couple of months". This'll keep me going. Much appreciated.


alberich 6 years ago

Well,"You cannot be comfortable without your own approval."(Mark Twain)

:-)


J. Edward Hardin profile image

J. Edward Hardin 5 years ago

This is an excellent hub. I'm inspired to write about one of my favorite paintings right now! Thanks for this one. Goodjob!


Jane Bovary profile image

Jane Bovary 5 years ago from The Fatal Shore Author

Hey J thanks very much. I'm thrilled to have inspired someone to do something..;)


Brutus Orkney profile image

Brutus Orkney 5 years ago from AZ

What a great hub. I've seen this painting a million times, but never really looked at it extensively. While reading your hub, I found myself doing exactly that however....What a great painting, and I'm not completely sure why. Maybe it did in fact capture the true American spirit / emotional state of the time. Either way, thanks for an entertaining few minutes today Jane!


Jane Bovary profile image

Jane Bovary 5 years ago from The Fatal Shore Author

Hi Brutus, thanks for reading and commenting. I think there's soemthing in what you say - about capturing an aspect of American life. Also maybe it strikes a chord because we're all a litlle bit repressed in some way..;)

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working