Best Diesel Car in India – Maruti Swift Diesel versus Skoda Fabia
Lets see what people say
So which do you think is the best diesel car in 5.5 to 6.5 lakhs INR?See results without voting
Diesel Cars – Maruti Swift and Skoda Fabia Comparison
In terms of technical specifications, Maruti Swift Diesel is a four cylinder car whereas Skoda Fabia is a three cylinder car but both are equivalent in terms of power and performance. Rather, Fabia is approximately 1 lakh or more costlier than Swift.
Of course Skoda Fabia's built quality and the brand name itself market it. In addition to that, high-end multi jet engine with all the qualities makes Fabia the superstar, but I am not quite sure of one thing that whether Indian market will accept 6.5 to 7 lakhs hatch of Fabia? One more thing, we need to consider here is the brand image. Maruti has got a good reach across India. Though Fabia is technically better than Swift, it cannot beat Swift in sales.
The Swift Diesel is already a hit and has gone a long way. Both cars have got good engineering speculations. Though I believe that Fabia will be costlier to purchase and maintain. Considering these two factors, Swift is outperforming Fabia in sales chart. The Fabia has a less powerful engine than Swift and the version available abroad has lower performance than our Swift here. Hence, I guess Swift will leave no space for the Skoda to sell in Indian market. I really doubt that Skoda will come out as a superstar mainly because first the engines of Fabia will cost more and second Skoda will not be able to cash on excise duty cut which applies to petrol car less than 1200 cc and diesel cars less than 1500 cc, besides that is the whole reason why Maruti launched sub 1500 cc diesel engine, though they initially planned 1600 cc engine for it.
Now the big question comes that how Fabia is compared with Swift. The Swift looks better and the main question is the price. The basic version of the Fabia costs around 7,50,000 on road as compared to 580,000 for the VDI + ABS for Swift.
The top end in the Fabia diesel goes above 9 lakhs and surprisingly Skoda has only one variant in Petrol, i.e., the top end which costs around 8 lakhs.
In any event, with 7.55 lakhs as the starting price, Fabia is going to find it hard to eat much into the Swift's sales.
Besides that, Fabia Diesel is a serious competition to Swift. Yes, price is an advantage for Swift and maintenance too. It seems the price of the Skoda Fabia is a big letdown, as it starts from 7,50,000 lakhs.
There are four variants of Fabia. The cheapest variant is Fabia Active, after that comes Fabia Classic, Fabia Ambiente, and Fabia Elegance. Fabia Active does not have power windows. Skoda realized that people have problems with the pricing when compared to Swift, so they came up with a cheaper one, i.e., Active.
And between, petrol cars will obviously be cheaper than diesel cars. That is how it works. With diesel, you get better fuel efficiency but a rougher ride and petrol is smoother. Those who go for diesel pay more initially but it is cheaper in the long run.
The prices are way too high for Fabia. I think Skoda got the pricing for Fabia wrong. One cannot sell a hatchback for 8 lakhs here in India. I think they are competing with Honda City, Hyundai Verna, and Maruti SX4 in terms of price.
Swift Diesel is more powerful and better.
1. 1.3L DOHC DdiS-Diesel. 2. Displacement is 1248cc. 3. Power is 75 PS at 4000 rpm. 4. Torque is 190 Nm at 2000 rpm. 5. Valve Mechanism is DOHC. 6. Bore is 69.6 mm. 7. Stroke is 82 mm. 8. Compression Ratio is 17.6:1. 9. Number of cylinders = four cylinders. 10. Cylinder Configuration is Inline. 11. Valves per cylinder = four valves.
Besides this, we are not just sitting on the engine without wheels and driving it, we are driving the whole car. There are many other things to it, also considering performance after some time, when the engine is not new. My neighbor who is a chartered accountant has both, Swift Diesel for himself and Fabia for his wife. They know very well how capable each one is.
So build, quality, safety, comfort, ease of use, good space planning, better tires, more planted feel, etc. are not as important as PRICE for most of the people in India. It is just important for a few people. Maybe it is only for high upper class people.
One more thing to add is that a Swift could be serviced with a number of Maruti Service Centers in India. In case of Skoda, try to get in touch with their service other than the urban locales and you will feel the difference. Here comes Maruti's biggest advantage which is their service network and cost of spares in the long run. The Skoda's service centers are less in India when compared to Maruti.
Yes Swift's engine is the best and Fabia is also not bad, as it comes with a pump duse technology. Do not see the bhp and torque, it is only a number game. At the end of the day if you are comfortable and the car you travel fetched you a good brand image that is all. So I think the best diesel car when compared with pricing, service centers, and everything else, Maruti Swift is better and ROCKS long time..............
Skoda Fabia RS vs Suzuki Swift Sport vs Suzuki GTI
More hubs on Indian cars by me
- A nice Fiat Linea with smooth engine in 7 lakhs INR
Hey friend. I am also looking to buy a new car in the same budget and I had some questions a few days back about some different types of car models and makes. So I visited the showrooms of Hyundai, Ford, and...
- New Maruti Alto vs Chevrolet Spark - Below 4 lakhs INR Cars
Ownership I own a November 2003 model Maruti Alto and my cousin brother has a Chevrolet Spark. Alto's advantage is fuel economy and ownership experience. As I am an Alto owner, please do not think that I...
- Maruti Swift versus Hyundai I-20 –5 lacks segment cars
Hi friends, You people might have heard a lot of hoo-haa going on in the motoring press about Hyundai I‑20 these days. Recently, I had the opportunity to drive one for an extended session. LOOKS...
- Is Maruti Ritz a serious blow to Hyundai i10?
I test drive Maruti Ritz in a Maruti showroom in Delhi yesterday and here is my review on that. Ritz versus i10 Maruti Ritz is a very cool and nice car but, I do not feel that Maruti Ritz has given a...
- Car Cleaning Tips - How to clean your car and save money?
Hi car lovers, I drive my car 80 to 90 kilometers per day and clean it daily with a feather stick daily and with shampoo and wax polish on a twice-weekly basis. Here are some tips on how to clean your...
- How to get a dent repaired on my new car in Delhi?
Original hub request: How to repair a dent just above the wheel on my Maruti Swift car? How I can talk to my car insurance company so that they replace it? The Maruti Service Center in Delhi did a good job...
- Is it time to say goodbye to Maruti 800 after Nanos launch?
Maruti Suzuki says goodbye to Maruti 800 after Nano's launch. What would be the possible reasons for that and what do you think will be the effect of that? Do you agree that it is production life cycle and...
- How to check and increase mileage of your car?
As you know, mileage is a prominent aspect when using any automobile, so you must know how to check your car for mileage and how to increase it, as increasing the mileage will save you money. 1. Get a full...
- Confused - Fabia or Fusion or Swift or Getz...? - Team-BHP
hi all, I registered in this forum explicitly to get answer to this question... (to know about me please refer here ). coming to the point: I own a black 2003 Indica DLS that I am ready to sell and
- A Journey Called Life: Skoda Fabia or Swift?
A Journey called Life: Anthony Tongbram's Weblog on Business Environment, Technology, Internet, Gadget, Investments, Finance, Venture capital, Start-ups and Society et al
More by this Author
Seven Indian bikes in the 50k to 70k range. This list is old but is still useful for many.
Recently, a friend of mine asked me that I have been driving Maruti Alto Lxi since last four years now and I want to sell my old car. I would like buy a new car in the budget of 3.5 lacs and my father is really...
Common questions about gear application on the Royal Enfield 350cc Standard Bike.