R.I.P. XLH: How Could Harley Kill Off The Traditional Sportster?
Some of the nicest memories I have are of riding my black Harley Davidson Sportster XLH along leafy winding backroads in Mississippi, blazing two lane blacktops in Arizona and cool sparkling lakeshores in Ontario. Although I have owned nearly 40 motorcycles, that wonderful XLH always makes my top three list of motorcycles that I would give anything to own again, even if just to keep in my living room and lovingly wax all day.
That is why the news that the 2009 Harley Davidson lineup was to be bereft of this historic model has caused a pall to fall over Stately Hal Mansion and placed me in a state of mourning. Harley Davidson without an XLH is like Batman without Robin, Peanut Butter without Jelly, or Hot Dogs without Mustard!
The Sportster H model was introduced in 1956 as an offshoot of the K model which was designed in 1951. The Sporty was an overhead valve engine, distinguishing it from the original K's side valve configuration, and it was one of the first motorcycles to integrate the transmission within the crankcase. In 1961, the Sportster was restyled with a smaller fuel tank to allow for easier access to welds. As it turned out, the "peanut tank" swiftly became the icon that would distinguish all true Sportsters for nearly half a century. (Let's not even mention that delectable chrome headlight brow!) For the classic XLH model to be axed is an offense against motorcyclinghood!
Granted, the 2009 model lineup includes the XLH 883 Low which would likely have been my choice if I had been in the market for a new Sporty. The standard XLH was a bit of a tippytoe reach for my short inseam, and the flattish bars that had been fitted onto it the past couple of years were so utterly un-Sporterish they might as well have come off a Ducati. But Harley missed a very significant market opportunity in placing a 2009 XLH 883 on their model line up at a Suggested Retail Price of $5,999. Harley Davidson may be in the process of pricing itself right out of the market with bikes such as the utterly uninspiring V-Rod Muscle with its insipid cookie cutter styling and nearly $18,000 retail price. You really have to wonder what the boy wonders of Milwaukee and York were thinking: "Let's place a 1250cc bike on the market at $4,000 more than a Kawasaki Vulcan 2000!" Er... then you might wonder why they're still going to be collecting dust in the Harley dealerships at the end of the year.
Harley Davidsons are just too damn expensive. An FLHTCUSE3 Screamin' Eagle Ultra Classic Electra Glide 105th Anniversary for $35,490? Almost $6,000 more than a Tri Glide? Is Harley charging for a motorcycle or for the length of the name? When I shell out more for a motorcycle than for a Mercedes C Class, Jaguar X Type, or Land Rover LR2 is the day you can all cart me off to the insane asylum. Sure, the price means nothing to the silver haired enthusiast who has just sold 1% of his Google stock holdings that he bought at $180 and sold at $490 and has enough to buy a Tri Glide and enough left over for a Corvette. However, when the median price of a Harley Davidson is quickly approaching $20,000, Willie G. and friends have to realize that a lot less money will buy a lot more bike from the competition. It's not 1970 any longer when the Japanese were only filling in the low end commuter market. If I was going to buy a big cruising V-twin right now, the Kawi 2000 would get my check! I recently saw a brand new 2007 model on sale for $9,999! I could have two for the price of one Harley Davidson Rocker C!
You dropped the ball, guys. Bring back the basic XLH at under $6,000 for 2010 with buckhorn bars, a cobra seat and a little more rake and extension on the front end, and I'll be in the dealership with a check in my teeth!
Check out Hal's latest Hubs:
Also don't miss Hal's many other Motorcycling Hubs!
- An $85,000 Diesel Cruiser. But It Gets Great MPG!
- Could MPG Alone Get You On A 250 Cruiser?
- Nothing Exceeds Like Excess: Boss Hoss
- Same Bike, Different Name: Suzi Boulevard Vs. Kawi Vulcan
- The Biggest & Meanest: 2007 Kawasaki 2000 Vulcan
- The Wacky World Of Mini-Choppers
- Which Cruiser Engine Layout: A V-Twin Or Straight 3?
- 2007 Factory Choppers Buyer's Guide
- 2009 Yamaha V-Max VMX17: The wrong bike at the wrong time
- All the Fuel-Saving Devices that do nothing but rip you off
- American Vs. Metric Cruisers
- CanAm Spyder: 3-Wheel Cruiser Or Roadgoing Snowmobile?
- Finally! 2009 Official EPA Harley & Yamaha MPG Figures
- Hal's Master Motorcycle & Scooter MPG Reference Hub
- Harley Davidson's Outrageous Pricing Ripoffs
- Honda Fury vs. Yamaha Raider: Perfection Meets Grotesquerie
- How You Can Ride Captain America's Panhead
- Hypermile your motorcycle up to 179 MPG: No snake oil, no scams!
- Is it time to retire superbikes?
- Motorcycle Ergonomics: Getting That Kink Out
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: BMW
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Ducati
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Harley-Davidson Big Twins
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Harley-Davidson Sportsters & Below 1201 cc
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Honda Boxers & Sixes
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Honda Off Road
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Honda Street Singles
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Honda Transverse Fours
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Honda V-Fours & CBRs
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Honda V-Twins
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Honda Vertical Twins
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Kawasaki Ninjas
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Kawasaki Singles
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Kawasaki Vertical Twins, Fours & Sixes
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Kawasaki Vulcans
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Suzuki Singles & Vertical Twins
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Suzuki Sports & Fours
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Suzuki V-Twins
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Triumph
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Yamaha Sports & Fours
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Yamaha V-Twins
- Motorcycle MPG Guide: Yamaha Vertical Singles, Twins & Triples
- Motorcycle nostalgia items I would gladly pay $$$ for!
- MPG Guide: The Fuel Economy Of 700 Top Selling Motorcycles
- MPG Guide: The Fuel Economy Of 250 Top Selling Scooters
- Pugang 125: The motorcycle built by starving slave laborers
- Revolutionary Harley Trike Has 2 Front Wheels That Lean
- Riding Your Bike For Maximum MPG
- R.I.P. XLH: How Could Harley Kill Off The Traditional Sportster?
- Sportster Iron 883: The Bike That Won't Save Harley
- Styling: Why Harleys Look Right & BMW Sedans Look Wrong
- Suzuki 350 runs on water. Pigs fly. Film at 11.
- Suzuki-ENV Hydrogen Fuel Cell Motorcycle?
- Suzuki's 2008 1300 And 1800 Deformed Emetogenic Mutants
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Sportsbikes
- The 25 Wackiest Motorcycles Of All Time
- The Current State Of Solar Powered Motorcycles
- The new 123 MPG Champ: Yamaha Zuma!
- There's no zen in the art of motorcycle maintenance
- Top 10 Japanese Street-Legal Bikes Of All Time
- Top 10 Ugliest Motorcycles Of All Time
- Top 10 Tips For New Motorcycle Riders
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Bizarrobikes
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Current Cruisers
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Golden Age Bikes
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Hypermotards
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Naked Bikes
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Older Cruisers
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Supermotards
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Tourers
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles - 10 Vintage Bikes
- Top 100 Ugliest Motorcycles In History - The Ultimate List!
- Top 50 Best MPG Motorcycles
- Tri Glide Trike Leads Harley Davidson's 2009 Lineup
- Why Motorcycle Manufacturers Missed Out On MPG Mania
- Why the VMX17, Hayabusa And Similar Bikes Should Be Off The Streets
More by this Author
A reliable, fun, street legal brand new 100cc Honda that gets 100 mpg and costs under $1,000? If Honda was smart enough to bring it from India to North America, they'd sell by the thousands!
This is the definitive guide to the fuel economy of the 250 top-selling motor scooters from 50cc to 800cc expressed in mpg and km/l.
Genovese pasta sauce has been Naples' best kept secret for over 400 years. This incredible onion-beef sauce simmers all day long until it's poured over steaming hot pasta and covered in Parmigiano Reggiano. Irresistible!