Union Business Agent Responds To a Job Steward Claim

Union Business Agent Responds To a Job Steward Claim regarding being discharged.

In the construction industry on union project jobs ,a job steward is appointed by the local area trade union business agent( BA).The union steward job is to uphold union work rules and protect the rights of the worker on the jobsite. Management chooses a superintendent or a foreman to supervise the workers, protect the rights of an employer and complete the construction of the project. Trade union agreements between the employer and the union includes a provision that a union steward performing union related business activities can not be discharged.

This story is an example that a union steward is not exempt from dismissal if the employee doesn’t perform the work as directed by the employer’s supervisory staff.

The incident occurred during the construction of a project in Chicago, Illinois back in the 1960’s. The Holy Name Cathedral new school and Sisters Convent was build on the corner of Chicago ave and Wabash ave for the Catholic Archdiocese of Chicago by general contractor Meyer and Gebhardt of Chicago .

The BA appointed a steward who previously was a masonry foreman for the general contractor ( GC).Although labor relations with the GC were not an issue with the job steward , an incident did occur that caused the company to discharge the union steward. The reason for *dismissal was his refusal to act as instructed by the contractor’s foreman.

The following day, early in the morning the *discharged worker was seen on the site, apparently waiting for the union business agent to arrive at the site. Upon the arrival of the BA and a discussion with the masonry foreman, a meeting was held in the GC’s field office.

Since other masons had not yet started to work, they attended the meeting of the discharged steward, BA and masonry foreman. The BA reminded the foreman that a union job steward was not to be let go until the completion of the masonry work as required in the employer/union agreement. The dismissed steward stood defiantly next to the BA with a smirk on his face smoking a large cigar in his mouth during the conversation. The other masons of the crew were previously told that the masonry foreman would be chastised by the BA for dismissing the job steward. Their attendance was not requested by the foreman although their attendance would later be important to other issues.

Responding to the above discussion, the foreman said ‘’ that all sounds good to me ‘’after hearing the positions taken by the discharged steward and the BA. The mason foreman began to explain the reasons for the action that he took that warranted the dismissal of the union steward. The actions were that the job steward did not perform the work as directed. The instruction was to install the stone façade first before proceeding with the back-up work because of the work area being temporally blocked to furnish materials. The steward decided to do the opposite work as instructed.

In addition on other occasions, the steward disregarded work procedures involving other tradesman in constructing masonry walls ( **e.g. hog in the wall ) and other actions slowing down the work performance. A few of the masonry crew members were complaining that they wanted a 8:00 am start time. It being winter time they were actually getting in at least 5 to 6 hrs.a day. In order to get a 9:00 am start, the labor crews needed to prepare the work areas to conduct winter operations. Many projects shut down when the weather is too cold because of the addition expenses of providing heat and non productive labor hours to do the work. The complaint was irresponsible since the men were averaging 25 to 32 hours a week when many jobsites were shut down because of the weather

After the foreman finished his explanation to the group, the BA thanked him for his side of the story. The BA turned to the dismissed job steward and said ‘’ I am sorry Barney that there is nothing I can do for you , you were dismissed not for doing union work but you were discharged for your personal actions’. Barney looked shocked, his cigar dropped in his month, said nothing and just left the office in a huff. The other masons were silent as to what had just occurred. Thinking back to the encounter and the results, it was time to clear the air because of the presence of the BA.

With the first issue being resolved, the foreman turned to the workers and said ‘’now that the BA is here, does anyone have any issues or complaints of the way the job is managed, if so let’s talk about them ?’’ Not anyone of them HAVING ANYTHING to say, left the office.

The mason foreman wasn’t aware if a new job steward was appointed by the BA since no one came forward to accept the assignment. One must wonder why?

In conclusion of the true story let’s just say that the Union Business Agent Responds and resolves a job steward claim of improper discharge in a manor fair to all parties concerned.

*dismissal and/or discharged A kinder use of the word ‘ being fired’

**e.g. hog in the wall when one corner of a wall has more courses than the other corner side of the same wall.

Hoping that the story was informative and enjoyed by one and all


Your Author

Jon Ewall

http://jon-ewall.hubpages.com/_ph9ejsxunalx/

Jon's website http://chicagoconsultant.com

Your author is a online marketing consultant of products offered on the internet. Jon’s website blog contains a variety of interesting subjects and articles that he has written

Comments 18 comments

Stu From VT 5 years ago

Wow - do we actually have an honest BA here? I'm glad I'm sitting down.


JON EWALL profile image

JON EWALL 5 years ago from usa Author

Stu From VT

In the 60's,70's and 80's the union labor relations were a lot different from what's going on today. Remembering the foreman's words about working. He always said

‘’ give your boss a days work for a days pay '' and '' we all work on my jobs including me, if you don't want to work, take your tools and leave. ''

The man was fair and honest with everybody.


Harvey Stelman profile image

Harvey Stelman 5 years ago from Illinois

Jon, Up and useful, too bad they don't have informative. I'm glad he got fired, but it's hard to believe in Chicago. H


JON EWALL profile image

JON EWALL 5 years ago from usa Author

Harvey Stelman

Powerful stuff you sent, on thurs Obama is making a speech on the middle east.Chicago will be changing now that Daley is gone.Time will tell if it will be better or ????


Harvey Stelman profile image

Harvey Stelman 5 years ago from Illinois

Jon, Changing, we'll see. Obama will once again disrespect Bibi again today. H


JON EWALL profile image

JON EWALL 5 years ago from usa Author

Harvey Stelman

OBAMA was bought by the unions, he has the mentality of revolution and radicalism. Congress needs to speak out against his and only his ideas of what the Israelis/ Palestinian conflict is all about. He is a traitor to the American people and Congress should start to consider IMPEACHMENT because of the many actions that he has undertaken since being elected to the presidency.


Stu From VT 5 years ago

Jon, I think you hit the nail right on the head. Stu


poorconservative1 profile image

poorconservative1 5 years ago

Reading your stuff always makes me understand things a little better. But this union thing still confuses me. I've always been private sector nonunion and have always had to be good at what I do in order to keep my job. And ya know, I wouldn't have it any other way. Just the fact that you need a union behind you in order to keep a job signifies that your probably not very good at what you do.

Thanks

Chuck

Long live the T.E.A. Party

.


Stu From VT 5 years ago

Jon,

Impeaching Oblabber would make my legs tingle (I guess I'd have to live with having something in common with Chris Matthews), but how would you get the Senate to ratify?

Stu


JON EWALL profile image

JON EWALL 5 years ago from usa Author

Stu From VT

The Whitehouse missed the cut off time to get approval from Congress to continue our involvement in Lyba. Obama speaks about democracy in the middle east and then attacks our ally Israel, figure it out. yes sir, he really is a muslin!


Stu From VT 5 years ago

Jon,

You are right. Obummer is a Constitution breaker, a radical Islamic sympathyzer, and a geopolitical moron.

Stu


sheila b. profile image

sheila b. 5 years ago

My Dad was a union man until they went on strike for a couple of months one summer, and when it was all over the union got what it wanted for itself and my Dad got literally a few pennies an hour more. He did the math and figured out he'd never earn back what he'd lost during the strike - but the union was happy!


JON EWALL profile image

JON EWALL 5 years ago from usa Author

HUBBERS

In SC TODAY,THE BOEING COMPANY moved into their new building today and apparently with a right to work labor force. The government is suing Boeing because of not hiring a union work force. The Labor Relations Board is now run by union past employees.


Stu From VT 5 years ago

Hi Jon,

Thanks for the update. It looks like yet another Obama crusade against common sense is about to begin. He won't be happy until we all have nothing.

Stu


JON EWALL profile image

JON EWALL 5 years ago from usa Author

hubbers

''Are UNIONS THE ANSWER to the problems we face in our country today?'' check out this link

StosselUpdates John Stossel Updates

Unions (Fox News Special, Sunday 8pm ET) http://fxn.ws/j7X1Pr


JON EWALL profile image

JON EWALL 4 years ago from usa Author

hubbers

5/30/12 Here's an update on labor ideas.

Improving Life for Workers

why government and unions don't improve working conditions

http://www.foxbusiness.com/on-air/stossel/blog/201...


JON EWALL profile image

JON EWALL 4 years ago from usa Author

hubbers

The Supreme Court just hande it to the union. check this link.

Supreme Court deals blow to SEIU

http://www.glennbeck.com/2012/06/21/supreme-court-...


francine fennell 2 years ago

i have been in that union over 30 years i will be retirement in 015 i wont to move out of phila so i am looking for a job as a business Agent right now i am a chief steward have been for 26 years i all so a coordinator for the union and sodexo food services so next Dec 31 will be my lest day here at temple university i wont to go to NC or SC or NH or atlanta i hopeing some one will gave me a job at one of this places went the time come .i am good in what i do ask my union philadelphia Joint BOARD

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working