Alignment versus Balance

Alignment or Balance?

 

What is alignment and how can this idea be useful? How is alignment different from balance?

Alignment of organizational elements is the key to organizational effectiveness.

In organizational design, strategy has to be aligned to other organizational design elements – structure, people (skills), work processes, management processes, culture & leadership .

The concept of alignment versus balance is the focus of this article. Alignment is different from balance, and it’s useful and important to know if we want to achieve balance or alignment. Example of work life balance – in corporations, do we want to achieve WL balance of WL alignment. Do we want to work towards alignment or balance?

If we work towards balance, it implies trade-offs, giving up something in return for something else. If we give up more office time, we gain more personal or family time because we can’t add more time. What message would companies give their employees if they ask them to practice WLB? They will say WLB is different for each of us, and have to find the right level of balance for each. Everyone has different needs and circumstances. But what does it mean for senior executives who have much more on their plate? How do they balance? Anecdotally, we hear that the personal or family life takes a back seat, or it is important to have a very supportive family.

Here, we can bring in the concept of alignment – align the interest of the company with the family. The needs and interests may not always be the same but the company can try to accommodate to align the interests as much as possible. This can be flexible depending on needs of the executive. For example, the company can subsidize cost of travel so that spouse can travel with executive if so desired, since the executive spends the extra time traveling. What if time with family is what is desired? How can the needs be reconciled? Giving time off for the executive to plan around it is one way to do it.

What if companies ask employees to practice WL alignment? What does that mean? Align employees’ work with their personal lives? Unfortunately, companies may hesitate doing this because they do not want to open themselves up to being challenged if they are doing enough. However, I think this is not a big barrier - as long as employers state that ownership rests with the employee and the employer will support as much as possible. The employer can also proactively come up with policies and programs to make it happen.

Alignment does not bring with it the concept of trade-off. Implementing work life alignment means employees and employers finding ways to better align their interests. This is a win-win approach. What is good for the employee is also good for the company.

Can better balance be achieved without finding alignment? Yes, by trade-offs; less of one for more of another, but this is not what employees want. It’s a win-lose approach. Company win, employee loses. So, I would suggest that in order to address challenges between work and life, frame it also in terms of work life alignment. Work life alignment prompts thinking in a different way - it helps people to think synergistically and to seek a win-win approach. Sometimes, we call it integration, and in some places for example in Singapore, the Employer Alliance calls it work-life integration.

Work life balance or Work life Alignment?

  • Work life Balance
  • Work life Alignment
See results without voting

More by this Author


Comments 2 comments

deeraj 7 years ago

The above article is really nice. But while i was reading this i thought whether the companies would really want to think so much about the employees (i mean yes, theoritically people would talk about it discuss it, but it remains as a last priority on the list), specially about middle level mgmt and a level below? And in majority of cases we usually tend to run by the thought of making more and more profit, which runs a vicious circle of working harder and working late hours in office; this leaves people with very little choice - they have to sacrifice family life to attain status and success in the organisation.

Please correct me if i have misinterpreted the article, I would really want to know what can I as an individual do to maintain the balance between work and family life, and not let work take a toll on the family life.


Truexpression 7 years ago

Hi Deeraj, Thanks for your comments. I do observe and it's fairly obvious to everyone that the higher a person goes up the corporate ladder, the greater the responsibilities and hence greater pressure from others on the person's time.

So, it's a sacrifice on one hand for the individual to have less "quantity" time for the family if he also pursues greater career challenges.

One way to address this dilemma is the individual spending time to figure out for him/herself what he truly wants in life, his values in the long term - material success yes, but to what extent and if he starts to feel beocming too unbalanced at the expense of family, then he/she needs to make a decision to slow down or negotiate with the employer for other arrangements.

The other way that I have touched on in the article is the organization who believes in helping its people in their work life find ways and policies to help employees align their personal needs with the company's needs(ie work that say involve a lot of travel away from family). If the company is progressive, mgt would look at work life balance as a talent retention tool or an important employee value proposition for potential recruits. This I think still remains a big challenge.

Personally I feel it falls back on the individual, what he wants, how he sees his priorities in life holistically and make the call. It is of course also possible to find a company that believes in supporting work life balance (look at their policies and ask those working in that company)

Well that's my 2 cents worth. All the best Deeraj.

Chris

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working