HubPages, Panda, and Duplicate (Stolen) Content

Why I Chose HubPages

I chose to write at HubPages because I had the freedom to write about anything I wanted to write about. I could publish informative articles, how-to articles, current events and political articles, and I could even publish rants (which is what this hub has turned out to be). I could publish all sorts of material without being subject to censorship or an approval process. Once I began publishing on HubPages, my material was being read, and I was earning money, too!

Another reason I chose to write at HubPages was because other writing sites (like Triond and Redgage) rely heavily on social networking for success. I don’t particularly care for relying on other members to read my material in order to receive traffic or to earn money. Any social networking on HubPages (was) for enjoyment, not for need.

Since Panda, I can’t really say this anymore. Although I still have the freedom to write about anything I want to write about, my material is not as visible on an internet search as it once was, and I have experienced a sharp decrease in readership and an even sharper decrease in earnings from Google Adsense.

It also seems that the HubPages’s ad program is based upon page views, and since my page views have plummeted due to Panda, a few dimes a day has not made up for my lost visibility and my lost readership.


HubPages’s Solutions to Panda

HubPages was quick to implement some changes in an effort to try to regain its reputation with Google. I thought that addressing the Amazon capsules and any links that redirects readers to other sites at the beginning of a hub were sensible ideas. Of course, since then, the Amazon affiliates program is no longer available.

I haven’t been very happy about the other changes. These changes, I feel, gear the site more towards a social-networking site—the type of site that I just don’t particularly care for—promoting, what I refer to as, swapping reads.

And while I do enjoy reading material written by other hubbers, and I enjoy having comments made on my hubs, I don’t enjoy having to rely upon members within the site in order for my material to be read (or to make money). Although I feel that HubPages is a community, I never felt that this was forced until recently, and this is a turn-off, at least for me it is.


Duplicate and Stolen Content

In April of this year, I happened to come across several of my hubs that had been stolen, some ranking higher on a Google search than mine. Not only did I find my hubs on other writing sites, but I found my hubs on blogs, too (one a local DUI attorney to boot!). Not only was my content stolen, but my titles were used. Not once did I receive a flag for duplicate content from HubPages, even when the site began cracking down on duplicate content that same month.

(If you have ever found your material stolen, I don’t need to explain the deflated feeling that it causes. I, still, can’t seem to write much of anything worth reading since this happened to me.)

This is very confusing because, from what I understand, sites with duplicate content were hit hard with Google (Panda), and I was also under the impression that duplicate content is something that has always impacted the PageRank of writing sites.

Although HubPages has a process for receiving complaints about material published on its site that may be a copyright infringement, HubPages doesn’t seem to have a process to protect (or even alert) its own members from being victims of copyright infringement. Please correct me if I’m wrong.

If you search HubPages for duplicate content or stolen content, you will come across articles and comments in both forums and hubs that indicate hubbers have experienced their content being stolen from this site. So, this isn’t something new.

I wonder why HubPages has never addressed this problem. I also wonder why HubPages isn’t currently doing something to address this problem since duplicate content is a factor with Panda. One would think that preventing (or alerting) stolen content for its members would be a priority, but, instead, it seems that focusing on social networking and creating more traffic from within the site is priority.

This is selfish.

Disgruntled

Unfortunately, I am one of hundreds (perhaps thousands) of hubbers who relied solely on HubPages instead of utilizing several different writing sites. So, not only am I battling this fear of having my content being stolen (without being alerted and/or protected), but I am also afraid to move some of my content to other sites, fearing I will be accused of stealing content even though the content is, in fact, mine.

The only good part about this experience is that filing a DMCA complaint with Google is quick and easy, and Google’s response time is more than impressive. Google removed my stolen content that was posted on Google Blogger and removed the content from its search engines. However, I had to find the stolen content on my own.

Google’s quick response doesn’t solve my problem of relocating content without fear of being accused of copyright infringement or being accused by a different writing site of stealing content or refusing to publish it, branding it as duplicate. It also doesn’t solve my problem of publishing new content on HubPages without fear of it being stolen so very easily.

Needless to say, this is what has curbed my activity on HubPages.

It has also resulted in a severe bout of writer’s block...


More by this Author


Comments 8 comments

Jillian Barclay profile image

Jillian Barclay 5 years ago from California, USA

There are many who have left Hubpages for the specific reasons that you have mentioned. In addition, if you publish your own work on another site, it is best to delete it from Hubpages, because they will certainly pick THAT up and then inform you that you are guilty of 'duplicate' content, even if you cross-post. You do NOT own your writing, in my experience. Cross-posting increases your Hubpage views, because after people read one article, they tend to go to Hubpages and check out your other writing.

Have had several articles (health-insurance) stolen. In only one case, was Hubpages able to assist me with having one site remove it. The other site that is still using it is in the UK, and they are crooks. Kind of embarrassing to know that your work is being used in an advertisement designed to steal money from people. I guess that in a way, I am happy that they removed my name as the author...


Deni Edwards profile image

Deni Edwards 5 years ago from california Author

Thanks for the comment, Jillian.

Sorry to hear about your stolen hubs. It would be nice if HubPages would address this problem or, at least, be more helpful. After all, it is HubPages's writers who bring traffic to the site. It seems that HubPages's doesn't realize this.


Paula Andrea, MA profile image

Paula Andrea, MA 5 years ago from www.mode of cosmic therapy.com

As a Hubber, I really enjoyed reading your article. However, I'm still not certain I know what Panda is. Glad to know you are on RedGage, too. That's Where I found you.


acaetnna profile image

acaetnna 5 years ago from Guildford

Such a useful and incredible piece of work. Thanks Deni!


Deni Edwards profile image

Deni Edwards 5 years ago from california Author

Thanks for reading and commenting.


MartieCoetser profile image

MartieCoetser 5 years ago from South Africa

Deni, we certainly have new challenges to meet. This hub of yours clearly describes them all.

How does one detect a stolen article? I agree, HubPages should protect us – I, too, wonder why they don’t register stolen hubs immediately – if they can promptly detect quotes we copy, why not also our articles the moment it become a duplication?

Why not send this hub via e-mail to HubPages team? Or post the link on Paul Edmondson’s latest hub/blog.


Deni Edwards profile image

Deni Edwards 5 years ago from california Author

Hello, Martie!

I was actually researching one of my favorite topics and found one of my articles. After I found it, I searched the internet for some of my more popular hubs under my titles. I then began plugging in sentences from my hubs in Google search. This is how I found them. It knocked the wind out of me!

HubPages has to be aware of the problem (I would think), as there are other hubs about this problem and threads in the forum, too.

As always, thank you for reading, Martie. I appreciate your input and suggestions.


DonnaWallace profile image

DonnaWallace 3 years ago from North Carolina

Thank you for this helpful article. I just found one of my HubPages article that is published (and stolen) and on another site. This is very helpful. I appreciate the post!

Submitting comments has been temporarily disabled.

Click to Rate This Article
working