HubPages Subdomain and Google Panda—the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

The New HubPages Subdomain

HubPages got hit hard with Google Panda, the dreaded search engine's newest algorithm update that drastically changes the world of SEO or Search Engine Optimization as we know it. Google has been very vague and secretive about the launch of the update and at the same time HubPages has been in a stage of denial on how bad it really is. They conducted tests to address Panda and have decided they will now give users a specific subdomain instead of the old one. As my title suggests, this change entails good, bad, and ugly news for bloggers like me.

I saw an article online talking about some sort of survival guide for SEO bloggers, as if the Panda is wiping us all out already and there's no war anymore to be fought. We must keep in mind that Google is expected to earn over 9 billion dollars this year because of Google AdSense alone.

You know that scene in Lord of War where Yuri Orlov gets caught by the government only later on to be set free by the higher ups? This is because without him selling weapons to the enemy, there will be no war, thus making him a necessity sort of. I think the same goes for Google: as much as they want to improve their search engine and fill the internet with quality content, they will always have a love-hate relationship with spam and spammers alike.

Don't get me wrong, I'm sure they want their ads to be placed where it is relevant and they want to improve the quality of content but at the same time they won't get rid of it. For instance, we see now that they forced HubPages into playing with their game with their own rules. I have nothing against it, really. It is all voluntary exchange; no coercion (I advocate the philosophy of liberty). And Google has brilliant mathematicians and programmers working on this, I'm sure. But then as you read this article, you'll see why I'm so wary of the whole switch to having a subdomain compared to having just one powerful "www" subdomain.

SEO bloggers remind me of the Lord of War, Google can't really get rid of us, because without us there is no war and without the war there is no Google
SEO bloggers remind me of the Lord of War, Google can't really get rid of us, because without us there is no war and without the war there is no Google | Source
Google Webmaster Tools
Google Webmaster Tools

The Good

By having your own subdomain, your profile page and hubs become more personal in the sense that you can monitor your own specific traffic and other stats. For instance, you can use online blogging tools like Yahoo Site Explorer or Google Webmaster Tools to assess your traffic, traffic sources, inlinks or backlinks, indexed pages, and relevant keywords that point to your articles and pages. This is a brilliant thing and something I've always wanted to be able to do.

But there's a upside and downside to this switch to a more individualistic concept. This is very bad for those who have little content or little knowledge in SEO or Search Engine Optimization. The idea is that users are forced to work on building up the content and rank power of their hubs without help from others. Take backlinks, for example. Before, everyone ultimately shared the rank power and authority level of HubPages in the search engines but now everyone is on their own.

So the one good thing that is brought about by this change would be that it is forcing users to work ten times harder, provide better quality articles, and avoid blackhat spamming SEO techniques. So ultimately, we become better writers, I guess. But when it comes to traffic and earnings I'm not so sure. All in all, this is very experimental with HubPages saying that "there are risks" but are very vague and restricted when it comes to what the full effects really are. But hey, I'm sure they have an army of SEO experts and programmers who worked on these tests and in the end only time will show us what the real effect of the changes will be.

Blogger vs HubPages
Blogger vs HubPages

The Bad

In my Blogger vs HubPages article, I've expressed that HubPages is way more powerful than Blogger, in my own experience, in spite of the conventional notion that Blogger has a more powerful PageRank score. This is, of course, very related to the concept of having a subdomain. I noticed that Blogger ranks well in niche blogs, those that have one specific topic and keywords are inter-related and somewhat repetitive (I even noticed that those who resort to keyword stuffing still get good rankings). So those who have HubPages who write on several topics (like me) can be really affected by the whole subdomain thing. I don't know what HubPages mean exactly when they say that their tests had positive results. This is what I mean by them being so vague.

I have addressed that I don't mind the whole 60/40 cut of ad space or earnings. I've always had the impression that their powerful www subdomain is exactly what I was paying for or sharing my content for. There is no zero-sum, I know. I get backlinks, free space to write content and place my ads, but then in the end without the previous ranking power of before the whole subdomain switch, I might end up not writing here anymore. Maybe this is also why I've been writing more often on my Blogger blogs instead. But as I have said, only time will reveal what will really happen. If anything, I have no right to complain.

HubPages reply to my Twitter query regarding the subdomain
HubPages reply to my Twitter query regarding the subdomain

The Ugly

It was my first year anniversary of writing on HubPages, but with my skills I was able to get way over 300,000 views already even when this Hub you are reading now is only my 100th post ever. So it is important to consider that I haven't been writing here for so long and I haven't even been writing a lot. So I have very little content and little online authority as well. But in spite of all of that, as I have said, I have gotten a lot of views and of course views for HubPages as well (60/40 cut). But then this whole subdomain switch thing targets people like me, those who have little content even when I have used my SEO knowledge in making sure I drive a significant amount of traffic to HubPages. In attempts to provide better ranking to those who drive traffic to HubPages, the subdomain might actually backfire by hurting small-time yet significant authors like me.

The whole Google Panda issue and switch to the subdomain has me very very worried about the rankings and traffic of my hubs but as you can see on their reply to my Twitter above, they say that in the long run this will be good for my traffic. I think what they mean by this is that in the long run I'll be forced to work harder on my own. My biggest concern here is, if I'm going to work much harder anyways then what's the point of the 60/40 cut? Why don't I just post the quality articles on my own blog.

Well, as I have been saying, only time will tell what happens. So be sure to go visit my HubPages subdomain real soon or follow me on Twitter to get updated on my latest hubs or blog posts.

More by this Author


Comments 7 comments

PWalker281 5 years ago

My understanding of why HubPages got such a hard "Panda Slap" (i.e., they lost a lot of their, as you put it, "rank power and authority") was because the lower quality content pulled down the site as a whole. The switch to subdomains is supposed to remedy that by disassociating the poor quality writers and spammers from those who publish high-quality content, which in the end, HubPages hopes will help these writers rank higher and hopefully pull the site as a whole back up to its former position.

Google posted an article on its Webmaster Central blog which lists a series of questions its programmers ask as they create the algorithms that assess site quality. Here's a link:

http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2011/05...

And here's an article recently published in the Wall Street Journal about the genesis of HubPages switch to subdomains:

http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2011/07/13/site-claims...

I think if you publish original, high-quality content (and this hub is a good example of that) and do a little on-page SEO and backlinking, your hubs should do well, despite the fact that they're on a variety of topics. Rated up and interesting.


cinder03vp profile image

cinder03vp 5 years ago

What an excellent analysis on the whole situation. My sites have been hugely affected by the algorythm change. I don't know whether or not they will ever recover. I'll just have to keep trekking and see what happens.


stunnercold profile image

stunnercold 5 years ago from Dubai

Google will keep changing strategy as far as i know. Keep writing quality content and things will eventually get better.


Harry Santos profile image

Harry Santos 5 years ago from Metro Manila, Philippines Author

Thanks for the helpful and informative replies! Especially the first one that had really helpful links! I surely learned a lot by going through those links!

I think the problem is, I've seen a lot of articles that are very high quality and relevant and yet doesn't get rankings at all. I'm scared of that chance of having quality content and still not get ranking or traffic.


PWalker281 5 years ago

Glad you found the links helpful, Harry. Yes, it's true, high-quality content may very well not turn up on the first page of Google SERPS or get a lot of traffic. If the writer hasn't done any keyword research and optimized the content or if it's a subject the writer wants to write about, but not many people are interested in it, or if the writer hasn't done any backlinking, then the articles may not get much traffic. It's a combination of factors - good content plus on and off-page SEO (and probably more) -- that help drive traffic to web content.


Harry Santos profile image

Harry Santos 5 years ago from Metro Manila, Philippines Author

Now I know why you got an accolade of Level VI commenter here on HubPages. You really give a lot of helpful and insightful comments. Thanks for helping out and clarifying some of my concerns. :)


PWalker281 5 years ago

You're quite welcome, Harry. I was a trainer in another life - old habits die hard :-)

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working