jump to last post 1-3 of 3 discussions (8 posts)

backward comments

  1. B. Leekley profile image85
    B. Leekleyposted 4 years ago

    I just looked at the comments to one of my hubs and found that the comments are backwards.  The newest comments are at the top and the oldest comments are at the bottom instead of in the proper order with the oldest comments at the top and the newest comments and newest replies at the bottom.  What do I need to do to correct this and to stop the order from getting messed up again?

    1. Rochelle Frank profile image88
      Rochelle Frankposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      In the edit mode, go to  the hub in question, and to the comments capsule of the hub-- click "edit".
      You will find a check box  in there that says " Display most recent comments first " .
      If it is NOT checked you will see comments from oldest to newest in order.
      Some people like to put most recent up at the top.  I don't. I think they are easier to read in chronological order, but it is the author's choice.

      1. B. Leekley profile image85
        B. Leekleyposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        For me there is no edit mode for hubs, or for hub capsules, that are not mine. I just made my global setting for Comments to always put the most recent hubs last, at the bottom, and then I went to someone's hub that I commented on recently, and the comments are still backward, and I could not find a way to edit them or reverse the sort order.  The oldest comments are at the bottom and the recent comments like mine are at the top. The normal way to read text is from the top of a page or screen down, not from the bottom of a page or screen up. Strangest of all, the author's reply to my comment comes before (that is, above) my comment, which makes no sense.  If an author has chosen to put comments in backward order with newest first, why can't I click a resort button and view them in the correct order? A web page should be user customizable. Or is there a way that I'm not seeing? Anyway, thanks for explaining how I can make the choice in my own hubs.

  2. dwachira profile image84
    dwachiraposted 4 years ago

    Hi
    You can change these settings by going to "My account" >> "Comments"
    On comment settings, you can change comment global settings
    by selecting "Yes" on "Display most recent comments first" option.
    I hope this help. HAPPY NEW YEAR!

    1. dwachira profile image84
      dwachiraposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      If you want to display the oldest comments at the top, select "No" on "Display most recent comments first" option. Alternatively you can select "Configure per Hub" option to set these settings per particular hub.

      1. B. Leekley profile image85
        B. Leekleyposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Thanks for your helpful replies, dwachira.  Now I know how to make sure my own hubs have comments in the right order.  I don't think that I have had a problem with those.  The annoyance comes in other hubbers' hubs. Some have the comments in the correct order and some have the comments in the wrong order, and I don't see a way for me or any viewer (except the author) to fix that.  The system seems to be set up to let page authors impose on page viewers the order in which comments are viewed and read.  Or no?

  3. DzyMsLizzy profile image92
    DzyMsLizzyposted 4 years ago

    I usually have the comments set to display in chronological order, with the oldest first, newest at the bottom.
    But, for some hubs that are older, and have a LOT of comments, I reverse the order, so that anyone who has recently made a comment doesn't have to scroll through the lot of them to find my reply to their comment.
    And 99.99% of the time, I do try to put, at the very least, an acknowledgement of the person's comment.

    1. B. Leekley profile image85
      B. Leekleyposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Thanks for your input DzyMsLizzy and thanks for your thoughtfulness. If I came upon one of your hubs after you had switched the comments to reverse chronological, i would probably write a comment as usual (because the system jumps to the bottom for that purpose) and then when I got a notification that you had replied, I would go back to the hub and scroll to the bottom of the comments, realize that they were in the other order, and scroll to the top to find my comment and your reply. I do a lot of scrolling way down and way back up.One option in the case of a lot of comments would be to both put them in reverse chronological order and change the initial view from All to, say, 20.

 
working