I took pics with my camera of images on my tv screen. Is it legal to use them? Edited? Specifically, is it illegal to use them in monetized hubs?
I don't know the case. But I think if they're not copyrighted, then you could use them freely. Just beware, the pictures you took can be copyrighted without you knowing it.
No, all television programs including advertising is copyrighted. Be careful you don't infringe on product trademark too.
You may get away with using a general scene or shot from TV that can be duplicated like: traffic in NY, a famous building, an aerial shot of central park, etc but definitely not an actor. However, I have seen some clips used in multiple instances on youtube.
The pics were taken of the inauguration while watching C-span. I cropped out all screen text and used photo gallery to edit/re-color. So I guess I can only use them to make my own personal photo collage of the event. Thanks guys for your help.
I always thought that if you properly reference the material it would be okay but I am not sure.
So C-span would probably deny the request to use them.
I believe shots of a TV show would fall under fair use laws, in which case you'd be fine to use them. Fair use extends entirely to copyrighted works like television shows. Wikis for just about every show on television employ the fair use excuse all the time and can happily post as many screencaps as they like. Just don't go overboard posting pictures on any hubs you might create and you'll be fine.
If you want more info on fair use, check out this article. The author is the first to admit that you should look to a tried-and-true lawyer for a definite answer, but it's still a good starting point - and should make you feel better about posting screencaps. http://lifehacker.com/193343/ask-the-la … s-fair-use
I do not see how it would fall under fair use. And what websites are doing is assuming the networks won't bother suing them. Which is most likely correct but does not make it legal. And in this case where you are transferring the liability to Hubpages who probably do not want to take that risk.
I don't see how it wouldn't fall under fair use. Fair use is intended as an exception to standard copyright laws wherein authors using a small portion of a copyrighted work - like a screen capture - don't have to seek permission beforehand. The article I posted earlier cites a case where a company won a court case against Sony under fair use laws after having used screen captures of a PlayStation video game in their advertising without permission. Here are some more details. http://www.theregister.co.uk/1999/04/12 … eats_sony/
If you're unsure, apply your potential usage of a screen capture against the four factors governing fair use. If it passes muster, I don't see why using a screen capture in a hub would ever get you in trouble. http://fairuse.stanford.edu/Copyright_a … 9/9-b.html
The work could easily be defined as the frame, not the broadcast. Also the use itself needs to meet certain criteria. Fair use is ultimately determined in the courts. It is not explicitly defined other than by precedent (video games have a fair-use-friendly precedent, news broadcasts do not).
There is a good discussion here: http://lifehacker.com/193343/ask-the-la … s-fair-use -- but I would err on the side of caution when writing for the third party website.
Uh... yeah, I already posted that link. As for the courts determining whether something is fair use or not, you could argue that for almost any law. If we had to wait for the courts on absolutely every decision with even moderately questionable legality, society would grind to a halt.
Ultimately, if you feel nervous about infringing on copyright laws, then don't use any screencaps. The question is never raised if you never post anything. But I'd say the chances of getting in trouble over any are about a billion to one, and I plan to continue using screen captures of video games in my own hubs. Heck, ages ago I used several screencaps in a hub and the company that made the game tweeted my article to all of their followers. (Wasn't a small company, either. They make the Grand Theft Auto series.)
I would be more worried about doing what Hubpages finds acceptable, in this setting. So OP could send an email query.
And a lot of the law is much more specific, and you are in compliance or not. Fair use is a PITA for someone who works in education. No-one agrees about what is in and out unless there is a closely relevant precedent.
Excellent discussion fellow hubbers. Both sides of the argument make sense to me. However, I'm beginning to think that since the same feed of the inauguration was used on most channels, it would be difficult to determine which network has the copyrights. That seems to be a criteria good enough to support fair use, you think? I do agree, though that I wouldn't want to intentionally post images that violated HP rules. But jeeez, the pics of the President and First Lady, who are public servants, are splattered all over the place from yesterday's event. It would seem that their images, unless taken by a professional photographer, are fair game for all to use. Thanks for the additional info, I will read the links.
How about contacting whitehouse.gov? You may be able to get permission to use their pictures; .gov sites are typically in the public domain, because they're paid for by public money.
by Ronald E. Franklin7 months ago
I'm planning a hub about one particular actor in one particular scene of a movie. Without a visual representation of the actor in the scene the article would be meaningless, but no free or non-copyrighted photos appear...
by NotPC2 years ago
HubPages is very firm in their rule to only use photos for which you have permission to use. Hypothetically, what happens if you break this rule? I've seen many people using images that are clearly not theirs to use and...
by LetterWriter6 years ago
I want to write a HUB and it will discuss about a dozen online images. I want the reader to be able to see the images as I include them with my writing in my HUB article. I could try to get approval for all of them, but...
by Brittany Kennedy5 years ago
A couple of weeks ago, I realized that I had not read the ToS about image use correctly and had to go back to all of my hubs and make sure the images were cited properly and were available through the creative...
by Rose West7 years ago
Has anyone ever run into copyright issues using images from photobucket? I like the selection at photobucket, but it seems like people post a lot of photos they probably do not own. I like using photobucket, but there's...
by Sharilee Swaity6 years ago
Hi guys! I asked this question on answers but haven't received an answer, so I thought I would try on here. I know that you are only allowed to use two images from each source, but I am hoping Flickr might be an...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.