eBay is changing its affiliate scheme in October and there is one HUGE change which has been sneaked in.
Their cookie is now a 24-hour cookie, same as Amazon. For Hubbers, that makes eBay effectively worthless and I strongly recommend you remove your eBay capsules! Amazon will now be a better earner for almost everyone.
As you know, eBay doesn't pay per sale, it uses a complicated pay-per-click system that usually pays far less than you could earn for a similar product on Amazon. But eBay currently has a long cookie - so the customer doesn't have to buy right there and then, they can think about it, browse around, dither, and you can still make your commission. So although you're earning less per sale, you have more chance of making sales.
As from October, that won't be the case. eBay and Amazon will both have 24 hour cookies, and since Amazon pays a lot better, ditching eBay becomes a no-brainer.
Sadly that's not going to help me on my websites, which rely on eBay - because my sites serve a worldwide audience and offer products on all the eBay sites depending where the customer lives. There isn't an Amazon in every country. I'm not a happy bunny.
Thank you very much for posting this. But I don't like it one bit!
Marisa, thank you for posting this. Sorry to hear this will affect you. It's something we should all know about.
The voice portion of the "fat belly " ad at the bottom of this forum comes on by itself. and stays on. I wonder if readers have to put up with voice ads while they are trying to read our hubs. What a turn off!
What else can HP do to us?
report ads that do that to HP staff, that is not allowed on here.
Gahh, a bit new here and am confused by all this. So does it mean that once 24 hours is up ebay will change the products I chose in their adds? Does that mean that we don't get paid the same amount as the products that I chose?
What else does this mean? Besides the fact Amazon pay more percentage way, what other benefits are there with going to Amazon?
Many thanks to someone whom is now trying to do a bit of Hubpages study!
What you predict may come to pass, but I believe that eBay wants to have a program that is competitive. With their black box payout scheme, it's certainly within their power to adjust the formula to result in similar total payouts even with a shorter cookie. I'd wait and see what happens in October before making huge changes to your Hubs.
Historically, on HubPages Amazon and eBay have performed similarly on a per click basis for most of the year, but Amazon usually does better during the holiday season (when people tend to put in huge multi-product amazon orders).
I'm not predicting, Paul. It's in the notification to eBay affiliates:
"For a “Buy It Now” item, you will be compensated if a user makes a purchase within 24 hours. For “Bid” items where a bid is placed within 24 hours of the initial click, you are credited for winning auctions for up to 10 days, which is the maximum length that an auction can last."
As you know, most people don't bid on an auction immediately - they will watch the item until closer to the end of the auction, THEN start bidding. So we'll likely to get little or no commission on auction items.
This makes it even more important that HubPages looks into enabling "Buy It Now" items only.
You stated some facts about the cookies which I don't dispute, but your conclusion that eBay would become less competitive with Amazon as a result seems to be based on the assumption that eBay would pay more or less the same amount per sale that you generate (and as a result of the cookie change, you'd generate fewer sales). Under quality click pricing it wasn't transparent how the payouts were determined. It appears that yesterday they posted a FAQ on how the commission will be calculated in the new system.
I don't know what the net effect of the cookie and commission changes together will be on earnings. But I do know that EPN knows they are competing with Amazon and others for affiliates, and if they want to affiliates to market eBay for them they have to have a competitive product. So, I'd be surprised if the average payout per click changes too much.
Anyway, I stand by my "wait and see" advice. If in 2 weeks it's clear to you that eBay is less effective, then by all means switch your capsules to Amazon.
My point is, it has nothing to do with the level of commission. It has to do with the cookie being valid ONLY for the first 24 hours.
Before, if the customer "watched" the auction, then went back and bid a few days later, you still got your commission. Now, you won't.
In your original post you said "that makes eBay effectively worthless and I strongly recommend you remove your eBay capsules".
Well so far I would say the Marisa is on the money.
Normally see something from ebay about every other day! Not 1cent from ebay this month so far
Looks like another strategy plan on the way
There are some issues with the ePN campaign level reports that we are still waiting for eBay to fix, so none of the October earnings are certified yet. However, if the aggregate daily earnings are correct (and I believe they are), total ePN earnings across HubPages are actually up 40% since the change. Because they now pay for actual sales, you may see 0's for a while and then get say $6 all one day. Anyway, I suggest that you give it some more time.
By the way, eBay annouced here that while some partners may make less and some more under the new scheme, that total partner earnings are unchanged.
Thanks Paul would you say that leaving it sit till the end of October before going to a Plan B would give us a good indication of where ebay is heading ?
If you are basing your decision on your personal earnings, it would really depend on how many clicks you are getting. The fewer you get, the longer it would take to get accurate idea of what your real earnings rate is. A typical conversion rate on clicks would be in the range of say 2-7%. I think you'd probably want to send ePN *at least* a few hundred clicks before drawing any conclusions. And that advice is separate from waiting for their changes to be stable and their reporting bug free. I'm hoping that will be the case by sometime next week (but it's out of my hands).
That said, based on our data Amazon does pay 20-30% more per click. So if your volume is sufficient (since they have volume based tiers), and the same or comparable product is available on Amazon, and the Amazon Associates program is available where you live and the form of payment they provide is acceptable, then I'd probably go with Amazon. Those things aren't always true, so that's one reason why we provide both options.
Paul living in Australia I can only get paid via Gift Certificate from Amazon. Having said that I have also earned far more from Amazon than I have from Ebay. Needless to say I buy a lot from Amazon
Thanks for your informed advise
You can choose to get paid by cheque, you know. Set the limit higher (say, get them to hold the money until you get to $250). Your Australian bank will charge you $10 to bank it because it's an American dollar cheque, but that's still better than buying stuff you don't need from Amazon.
Since Amazon and eBay now have exactly the same cookie, and Amazon doesn't have auctions, Amazon is (IMO) a much better choice.
Marisa thanks I must have missed the bit about getting paid by cheque, I will have to look into it further as it looks like ebay has now died, on me anyway!
Up till now I have been buying stuff on Amazon that we have been trying to source here in Australia. It's odd that I can buy stuff on Amazon and have it shipped to Australia cheaper and quicker than sourcing it on line from Australia.
Thanks for the tip about the cheque
I've never had much luck finding stuff I want on Amazon so the cheque option was a no-brainer for me. Although I can find stuff cheaper on Amazon than here, often I can find the same product even cheaper on another US or UK site. For books, for instance, Book Depository can't be beat.
Just to see if I understand correctly; Ebay will still pay for clicks?
Luis, my understanding is that they will not anymore.
They pay for actual sales now.
Paul has a bit more details above.
Thanks for the info Marisa and sorry to hear that it will mess up your sites. I tend to use Amazon more, in fact I forget about ebay pretty much, good thing if this is happening.
That stinks. I've wanted to do Amazon, but unfortunately I live in a state where the Amazon affiliate program is not available
I concluded months ago that Ebay, compared to Amazon's commission based model, pays us pennies where I get dollars from Amazon on a big ticket purchases. Amazon approved associates can get up to 8% commission ... although my average has been 6%. I have been deleting Ebay ad links from my articles.
I've found that based on my subject, either Amazon or eBay has more appropriate products, so I'll wind up keeping whichever has the more relevant product.
galleryofgrace--I've noticed that ad comes on as well sometimes. I usually keep my sound on mute but if I accidentally have it on, I'll hear it.
Yep, my state doesn't allow Amazon affiliates either, so it's a moot point for me, as with others.
Thanks for the heads-up Marisa. I wasn't aware of this, but I did start shifting from eBay to Amazon capsules a while back. Am glad I did
I've never done well with Amazon, but have with eBay. This must depend on the individual hubs. With Christmas just months away now, I'm disappointed eBay is doing this. I've always done well at Christmas with eBay.
This pretty much reflects my thoughts. I will be raptly watching my eBay earnings stats. If no significant change, I'll continue to muddle along. If I suddenly start seeing strings of zeros, out comes the chainsaw; one less ad for Google to get perturbed about.
Well, I've got zeros 6 days in a row. Sharpening the chainsaw.
Is it just a fluke then that I earned a lot more than usual on Oct 1st from eBay? like way more than usual... I'm waiting for stats for the past few days to update. I think I'll stick it out for awhile before removing capsules since I can't use Amazon in my state... sigh.
Your hub topics are probably more conducive to eBay sales than mine. If the cookie thing doesn't do you in, I'd certainly keep them.
You may be doing a good job, Christin. The new eBay system will work if you can write Hubs which drive a reader to buy the eBay product RIGHT NOW THIS MINUTE - and if they do, then the commission will be higher.
I've looked at my lifetime eBay sales. Nothing to write home about. I've deleted two eBay capsules so far. Expecting to do more. Only keeping the big-ticket items, cause you never know...
by Keith Schroeder2 weeks ago
Amazon changed their affiliate program yesterday by cutting the payout for most affiliates by half or more. Has HubPages addressed how these changes will affect content providers here?
by Paul Edmondson3 years ago
We are going to increase Amazon earnings for most of you! Amazon is becoming part of the HP Earnings program. In early November folks will have the opportunity to switch to get paid their Amazon earnings...
by Paul Deeds5 years ago
We just released a small update to the site. Among a slew of bug fixes and small updates, there are two notable changes.The first is that you can follow the comments on a hub, and receive email notifications when...
by path-finder3 years ago
Hi all. I have set up Amazon Affiliate program on hubpages and featured Amazon products on a number of my hubs. Looking at it after a while, the link-type report in the Amazon account shows that no one has clicked on...
by David Zermeño3 years ago
I really don't know what to do...keep using Amazon capsules or change to Ebay due to the easier report in HubPages. Help would be good in this case.
by Rajinder Soni7 years ago
I just received an email today from ebay stating that they are starting quality click pricing for new users from 1st of Septembers and for old users like me and you from 1st of October.Now we will earn some money when...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.