My name's Earl! I would like to try an experiment on HP, and lend assistance to hubbers who do not speak native English, and would like for someone to proofread and polish up their hubs for them!! If you fall into that category, and would like my assistance, then please respond to this post.
Like I said, this is an experiment, so first come first serve! Also, if this offer is somehow in violation of HP rules and regs, I humbly apologize. I just thought this might be a good way to help out the community, especially those authors who have great content, but suffer unnecessarily due to the limitations that come with speaking English as a second language (on an exclusively "English" site!).
UPDATE: Thanks to LuisEGonzalez and Carb Diva for offering their services as well!
Helping other Hubbers with editing is not against our rules, and it's a very nice thing to do.
Great idea and super nice of you to offer. I would like to join you in your quest, so please email me and I'll do my best to proofread any hubs.
Whoops! Maybe I should have placed this thread in the Improving Your Hubs section? Perhaps the admin powers that be will migrate it for me ...
Thank you for your kind offer. I wish to register myself since I belong to the category you mentioned above. I do not speak native English and my mother tongue is Malayalam. Please evaluate my hubs and give some tips to improve. Now my author score went down to below 80 and it was between 90-95 range till a few months back. Kindly help me to improve. I once again thank your for your great offer.
Sure thing, sunilkunnoth2012! Is there any particular hub that you would like for me to read first?
Thank you. I paste the link of those hubs that I wish to get examined: 1) http://sunilkunnoth2012.hubpages.com/hu … th-Breasts
2)http://sunilkunnoth2012.hubpages.com/hu … luenced-me
Great! I also emailed you a quick edit for your profile blurb, just to get the ball rolling. I will review and edit the two hubs you listed above, so look for my revisions in your email over the next few days. In the meantime, if you have not done so already, I recommend reading HP's EXCELLENT Beginner's Guide to online writing success, cover-to-cover, found here: http://hubpages.com/learningcenter/great-content
That's a lovely idea Earl:)
Unfortunately I will not be joining you because, as they say, "once bitten, twice shy".
About three years ago there was this lovely pleasant girl on the forums who was a ESL writer, whose works really needed help.
She asked for it, and she she got it, from a whole bunch of us.
We'd sent her several corrections before I landed upon a Russian word in one of her hubs that would not translate.
The sentence could not be understood, nor rewritten, until I knew what that word was.
So I Googled it. All of a sudden, it became apparent that not just that hub, but all of her hubs came directly from Russian or eastern European newspaper articles. She's never written a word of them. She'd just used Google translate to plagiarise the works of others in her own language.
While I am sure many ESL writers do genuinely make the attempt at writing fresh content, it has left me with the sinking feeling that many are just using a translate service from articles written in their Mother tongue.
I considered offering the same service.
I didn't know if it was permissible, and had the same fear of offending people with the offer, as well.
I was also not sure how much time I could dedicate to it, either.
Good on you for moving forward with it.
Early - What a wonderful offer! I have seen many posts that are obviously written by one for whom English is a second language. I would be willing to help also.
Thank you, sir. This is the reason why I don't have one yet.
Oh wow, that is a very good point IzzyM, I hadn't even considered that aspect. I know that HP uses some kind of software for plagiarism here, but does it also check foreign languages?
As far as I know, there is no plagiarism software capable of detecting a foreign language translation, especially considering that each translation service will word sentences differently.
In the case I highlighted, she had used Google Translate and copied it word for word. Had she used another translation service I would never have found it.
I have since found others guilty of the same practice. The only 'giveaway' they leave is when there is one or two words in the article that have not translated. This allows Google to detect the language it came from, and gives the searcher a narrower field to search for existing articles.
I don't know how common this practice is, but if you have ever used Google Translate you will know how defective it is (though it has got better over the years).
Hubs written in similarly poor English should be suspect.
This is swell of you.
Can you spare some tim to have a look at my hub at :
http://thirdmillenium.hubpages.com/hub/ … ovies-same
Thank you very much
Sure, thirdmillenium! Although, I am working with sunilkunnoth2012 right now. Once I have finished, I'd be more than happy to help you. Or, perhaps, Carb Diva or LuisEGonzalez — who also volunteered to help, would like to work with you instead?
Both Carb Diva and LuisEGonzalez are as welcome as you are, DEarl
So glad to note that you working on my write ups. Await the pleasure of receiving your kind suggestion and useful tips. I hope I can improve with your suggestion.
Send me the link via email, or if you wish I will take a look at it today.
Your hub is well written and your use of English is good. However it is lacking links, videos, ads and images. These would make your hub more apealing
You are having a laugh!
"And, even if you do not have a hole to put your thing into or something solid and long to put into your hole, you can always widen the scope to include a lot of other avenues to satisfy yourself."
And yes, this hubs refers to the S stuff, that everyone knows not to write about on HP.
So you want photos of what, exactly? Polls? Why not a map, in case anyone is confused?
This sort of stuff is not encouraged by HP because Google doesn't like it, and doesn't want their advertising on it.
It doesn't actually matter how well you write, the subject is taboo.
I am glad a veteran like IzzyM has taken the trouble to read my hub. Though it about S, it is an enlightened (at least to me) look at S and violence juxtaposed as it were. And laugh I did. What links in deed! I am sure thankful for the suggestions of Luis
I did no take into consideration whether the subject was taboo or not. I just looked at it from a technical standpoint and since I am not a moderator I did not dwell on those other aspects. Off course it should be moderated for other elements such as pictures, links and so on and perhaps using substitutes for some words. I found it somewhat enlightening as well as "tongue in cheek funny" written from a "layman's" perspective. The subject, words, pictures, links are not decisions upon which I can offer any "official" advice..........
If the author had asked for opinions,suitability etc. about the subject I would not have needed to be sarcastic in order to say what others have pointed out and keep in mind that the topic is the use of the English language.......
I just looked at it from a technical point of view and since I am not a moderator I did not feel that I should offer advice on suitability, what pictures, what links etc..(no maps ) This is not up to me.
However I did find it enlightening and 'tongue in cheek ' funny. As I remember the topic is use of the English language. Anything else is out of my realm and I did not want to come across in any way as trying to tell others what topics they should cover.
Off course it should be moderated for pictures, suitability and use of some words, but that is between the author and staff.
If opinions would have been sought then I would have offered some along the lines of Izzy's comments but perhaps with less sarcasm.........
Thank you, Luise
I am happy that my hub is good
I wonder what a non-English speaking person imagines when they read: "allow me to lend a hand."
I have on Hubpages for a while but have found it tough to get Hubs approved.
I am dutch so not a native English speaker but on the other hand I don't think my English is really bad. Since Hubpages is open to anyone, worldwide, I think it would be fair to take this in consideration when reviewing a Hub for publication.
I fully agree that all Hubs MUST be high quality, but there is a difference in Hubs with poor grammar and Hubs with just a few errors here and there.
I mean, we can't have all our Hubs proofreaded by someone, can we?
That's just my opinion ....
So far I have 1 approved Hub, but others do not get cleared for publication.
For some Hubs I understand why, but for the Hub below I really have no idea.
http://ronwan.hubpages.com/hub/Make-Mon … -Postcards
I have read it over and over again and feel the grammar is pretty good. The text is broken into multiple text capsules. All parts are illustrated with a related picture and there are Ebay and Amazon capsules.
It has 770 words right now; but I feel there is not much more to say.
So, if anyone likes to proofread it I would be very grateful for any comments that might get this Hubs approved.
Thank you !!
I can't see that hub as it says 'not published', but if the writing quality of your hubs is like the writing quality of your question here, then poor grammar and spelling are not the reason for not getting your hubs approved. Your English is well up to the required standard (although I'm overlooking where you missed out the word BEEN after HAVE in your first sentence - a simple but glaring typo).
Hmm yes, I missed that one
Pity you can't view the Hub using the link.
I have done some copy and paste; hope it is readable in the attached picture.
Do not pay much attention to the right side-bar. Lots of duplicate parts there but that is because of the copy and paste.
Edit: now that I uploaded the picture I see it is not readable ... any other way to show it to you??
Ok, I found out I had to make a Google document of it and publish the link to it; that makes it readable for all of you.
I thought I better make a new discussion for this, so here it is:
Any comment are most welcomed !!
It's now published - but with only one pic. Did you remove the others?
No, i did not !!
You can try the link above for the other topic with a link to a Google document that show the whole Hub.
There are two hubs "Make money Selling Postcards" and "Make Money Selling Vintage Postcards" (which is published). This can be a reason for one of them being rejected on the grounds that it's not unique enough. For the unpublished one, you might need to attribute the images to show that they're legally used and not infringing anyone's copyright.
I see. It looks like he's trying to publish two hubs that are very similar.
I took the pictures from sold Ebay-listings as to show what they can be sold for. That is what the Hub is all about.
Should I add to them that they are taken from Ebay-listings?
Regarding the other Hub, this one is meant to explain about selling both modern and vintage postcards and of different subjects (trains, cats etc.), while the other (published) Hub deals only with vintage postcards, mainly topographic cards.
You think that is not unique enough?
I think they need to be condensed into the same hub.
I think that's your whole problem.
Taking pictures from eBay listings isn't allowed unless they're in the public domain, i.e., their copyright has expired. That won't be the case for the newer ones, so unless you get permission from the copyright owner, (not the eBay seller) or find them elsewhere complete with licence (such as Creative Commons) allowing anyone to use them under certain conditions, you can't use them legally. I don't think 'FAIR USE' can apply here because HubPages is a commercial site - not an educational site, where you'd have a much better chance of claiming FAIR USE of the images.
I think the two hubs' contents are unique enough but the titles are almost identical. That alone could cause someone to hit the disapprove button.
So, when I understand you right there is no way to show readers for what prices postcards sell on sites like Ebay??
What about a title like 'Make Money Selling Vintage And Modern Postcards'?
I don't know of any ways other than those I mentioned. Someone more knowlegeable about FAIR USE might be able to tell whether that's an option or not. But try to find the postcard images from somewhere else with an attached licence (like you see all over Wikipedia). You can still mention the eBay sold prices.
The title - No, it's still almost the same. Only two words are different. Make it very different. In fact, I'm inclined to agree with quiterandom - They should probably be merged into a single hub.
When I clicked the link to the hub (not the google document) it said unpublished.
by mrsbaker023 years ago
I have a hub that was not featured due to problems with quality. How do we know what the quality issue is? I read the rating chart and didn't seem to find anything wrong with the hub in question.
by Janet Giessl4 years ago
Hi,I'm a real newbie here at HubPages. English is only my second language. Therefore, I would like to exchange information with other hubbers that have English as a second language. How are you doing here at HubPages?...
by Murtaza Abbasi2 years ago
I think this is to straight to ask about earning as I am new here also. I have written up to 5 hubs and writing more to reach number 10, I will write some more and apply for adsense if that works. Before I reach to that...
by Edward Belli7 months ago
Hi Hubbers,I'd like some help with passing the Quality Assessment Process. Will you please give feedback on my Hub How to Choose an Aquarium Tank Size for Your Room (must be signed in to view). What can I do to improve?...
by Thomas Swan4 years ago
Is hubpages in danger of being over-run by writers from India who can't write proper English? I went to a hubpages question yesterday, and half the answers were from Indian hubbers who didn't understand the question but...
by Nemanja Boškov5 years ago
I'm very curious to know what the natives think about this.I have been studying English for a long time, and I'll probably be a lifetime learner of the language as I am not a native speaker. On the other hand, I often...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.