I suggested something similar some time ago but it fell on deaf ears. This isn't hard to implement now that you have developed your style tips and stuff. All you need to add to the "publish now" button is a formula returning true if the word count is more than 100 and false if it's less than a hundred. Or you could set your word limit. The formula isn't hard to write, anyone who knows HTML can write it...as a matter of fact anyone who know MS Excel can write it.
This is a prime example of why I am re-suggesting the feature. Though we have the QAP program, these hubs get through the system. Anyone searching HP can find it.
Great suggestion! It's not even in the image category and the images are obviously taken off Google and they are pixelated.
It seems to me that if they pass QAP, they pass QAP. If they pass it in error, QAP needs to be fixed.
We do, after all, allow video and photo hubs which might legitimately have under 100 words.
I must confess, I thought we already had a minimum word count except in the poetry and image sections. I know I used to get a warning if I saved a Hub with too little content. Has that changed?
The warning is still there but apparently people are still ignoring it and publishing. I'm just saying, stop the hub from being published then.
I agree 100%. If you recall, Hubs used to be unpublished for being "substandard" and one of the criteria was insufficient content. I guess I assumed that the warning would automatically trigger a notification to the moderators. Clearly not.
Personally I would make the minimum word count much higher. Some other sites have a lower limit of 300 or 400 words.
I was going to suggest similar figures but I know I would get a lot of negative suggestions...lol I did suggest this some time ago and the thread just died
It's very odd, because I'm sure you remember plenty of discussions in the forums where staff said insufficient text would result in a Hub being unpublished, except in the poetry and photo sections. So I'd have thought it would be a fundamental component of QAP. *Sigh*
I'm just not into hub genocide I think all writings should be allowed leeway upon it's web debut without having to spend 100 hrs on HP to produce 'grades' for privilege to have one's writings seen online. js
Okay, I see your point but just as some writers here have to wait to have their quality hubs featured and some with real potential must edit to re-feature, at least the newbie must show some sort of writing. 100 words is like a FaceBook post, not even basic school essays are that short.
The minimum words, except for poetry, to trigger the below standard warning is 100 words. I am saying use that to hinder trash like the above hub to hit the system. With the standard for quantity placed on content sites, it can't hurt.
Dame scribe, this reply that Cardisa just made was 95 words. Do you think that is an appropriate length for a hub?
I would suggest that if the system in place is QAP, fix QAP so it does not pass rubbish hubs for any reason, not just length.
by Brandon Lobo4 years ago
Lately there have been plenty of hubs that are totally useless to the hubber community. There's a lot that can be done to make the life of the moderators easier.I just used the hopper again and took a note of the major...
by saleheensblog6 years ago
If the minimum words for a hub is set 200 HP will get rid of a thousands of sub-standard contents automatically. No hub should be allowed to publish until it has at least 200 words. If possible 300 words. Poems can be...
by Marisa Wright7 years ago
On another thread, a Hubber suggested that if HubPages had a minimum word count, it would prevent some spammers.I know that a very low word count can get a Hub flagged as substandard, but perhaps it's set too low at the...
by Liz Elias2 weeks ago
Hi--me again.. I was reading that there is a 'nofollow' generated on hubs with scores of 50 or under, so I've un-published all of mine that were down in that range. The result is that my total...
by Ceres Schwarz2 years ago
I was thinking of splitting an article into 2 or even 3 different hubs because it was too long. How many words should our articles have before we can publish them on HubPages? I checked the HubPages FAQ page but the...
by David Ortega7 months ago
I have a sense that the mobile community is growing to the point where I think Hub articles over 1000 words are likely too much for those reading from a phone. I am of the mindset that I need to write shorter...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.