In a recent HubPages weekly email, it was discussing the fact that many use photos and do not provide a source. I was thinking that this may easily be addressed by HP by requiring a source in the source field inside the photo capsule, whether it is "self" or the Freedigitalphotos, wikimedia commons or whatever. If the source is required to even post a photo or image, then that would solve the issue of at least the source being known. Just a thought. Is that something that would be too hard to implement for HP?
I agree with you, Faith. If the source field was required rather than optional, it would prevent use of any unauthorized images. I am thinking of getting a good camera or making my own drawings, since it seems more and more difficult to find images that are free to use.
Yes, Phyllis, I was just thinking the same thing about drawings. I have just been using my cell phone for pictures as I always have it with me. One can find good photos on wikimedia commons but sometimes there are none to fit with ones topic. There are some good choices on freedigitalphotos too. I do think that if that field is required to be filled out before one can upload a photo or image then maybe it willl cut down on those who just pop in images that may not be legal.
I am glad you brought this subject up, Faith. I was thinking about starting a forum on it because of all the issues with images. Time to get out my art pencils and drawing tablet.
Photos on public domain many times have no source, hence "public domain." There's one flaw in your argument to think about. I use graphics a lot that are secured from public domain. Some of the whining is being done because some cry babies here don't like the content. That's too bad and so sad. Their choice is not to use their mouse to go there.
The Frog Prince
Hi Frog, Yes, and that is all we have to put in the source then is PD or Public Domain.
That is an unnecessary step. Much ado about nothing in my opinion. A picture is a picture and is used to speak a thousand words. If that is all anyone has to complain about the world is good!
HubPages does not require an attribution for a public domain image and the staff has stated that many times on the Forum. Here is one post from Paul Deeds:
Maybe it is required for the apprentice program or HOTD, but it is not required on HubPages. Not only that, but your audience will consider it amateur to put 'public domain' as a photo source and search engines won't understand either, unless your Hub has something to do with public domain.
Thanks Writer Fox, yes, that is true and all we have to put is Public Domain. I have seen a lot of images and photos that have been released to Public Domain, but some still say as long as properly attributed, so that would be the only time one would need to worry about the attribution for sure.
You shouldn't list a source at all for a public domain photo. Putting "Public Domain" in the source box is confusing for search engines and visitors to your Hubs.
Jan, I see you use public domain a lot and properly attribute which is the way to go as one sure would not want HP to take off points from one's score for not doing so!
Having a 'source' box as used on HubPages is not the standard protocol Internet publishers follow and it is not what users are used to seeing online. In fact, it's distracting for the user experience unless there is something profound to say about the source of a photo (like 'this was shot by an undercover policeman').
Many Hubbers make the mistake of duplicating the same source text hundreds of times across their Hubs (like 'this photo was taken by John Doe and is his personal photo and blah, blah, blah).
It's bad enough that the caption has to double as the Alt text (a horrible situation), but we certainly don't need to require everyone to spam their Hubs by filling out that source box for every photo.
I have many photo collection Hubs with up to 200 photos and I have no intention of revealing my sources, let alone with followed links irrelevant to my content.
If you have to credit a photo source, use a text capsule and NoFollow the link.
+1, also I believe it is hideously distracting for the reader. Why not make source credits for photos a <h6> or something really out of the way in a lighter grey that could be nofollow and clicked on if needed? I find the current ones really look horrible on the hubs and detract from the user experience as it looks like I am showing off my own name 1000 times.
Using an H tag (Heading Tag) would put more emphasis on the irrelevant text, not less! I don't think that's really what you want to do.
Hi Suzanne, yes, the font size could be smaller and less distracting for sure.
Hi Writer Fox, That is what I am saying that HP is saying that hubbers are just posting an image or photo without indicating the source in the photo capsule. There is already a place to indicate the source, they just do not do it. If it is there own photo, all one has to put is "Self" and if the photo or image is from Wikimedia commons, which is legal, one needs to make sure to give it proper attribution, i.e., CC-BY-SA.2.0, etc. One can be sued by the owner of the photo or image if not properly attributed and there is already a place to do that. If it is required, HP could make that little space a required field before an image can be uploaded. Here in a forum, I have uploaded my own photo, and just as is on questions when uploading a photo or image, there is not source field as there is in a hub.
Hi Faith this is an excellent topic. Since I am NOT high tech, and I am still experimenting on how to post photos on HP, I have cautiously just used my own photos so as not to get myself in trouble. By the way i love your background on your main page, you are so awesome and gifted with phenomenal creations....as well as with your hubs. blessings, Sparklea
ps; i have a doctor appointment, will return to answer your emails.
Hi Dear Sparklea, yes, using one's own photos is the way to go for sure!!! All one has to do is put "Self" in the source field. Then no one can say one word about your photos. Oh, as far as backgrounds, there are tons of free backgrounds to download online too! You are so kind dear friend and an amazing writer no doubt one bit! I hope and pray all goes well at the doctor appointment. Blessings, Faith Reaper
Not all photos require attribution to be used. If your photo source requires attribution or a link, then you have to give them that or don't use that photo.
Correct, Writer Fox, if there is no requirement for attribution, then it is not needed, but the source still needs to be used in the required field. So many photographers have their photos stolen, as we do our hubs at times, and I am sure they would appreciate the attribution and source pointing readers back to them. If one really wants to use another one's photos, one can just contact that person and if okay, all one has to do is put "Used with permission" in the source field in the photo capsule and site the website, then you are good to go without any legal ramifications with which to be concerned.
Your operative words were "internet protocol." The Hub needs to pay closer attention to that as I have pointed out to them more than a few times.
This could be a solution. Usually, when I post my own pictures (most of the time), I don't write the source but when I use other pictures, I always write the source and I make sure I have the right to use them. It's so important to acknowledge the work of others.
Have a fantastic weekend, Faith :-)
Hi Joelle (kidscrafts), Oh, yes, using your own photos is best always, and when you do so, just put "Self" or "Personal" and that will get it done. You are wise, as it is so important to legally use the work of others. Have a great weekend dear one, Faith Reaper : )
Yes, Faith, thought I was doing it right, made all sorts of changes after the other forum confusion about attribution. Now, based on what Writer Fox shares, I'm SMH. I will leave it alone for now. Gotta go, have a good day.
Yes, I would leave it and I do the same as you do. Have a good day!
That is one reason why I use Wikimedia Commons 99% - all of the info is right there. What about if the source box said something such as, "highly recommended, though optional".
Once HubPages changed the way we post pictures I discovered that a lot of pictures I took from the web just didn't match the standards. I was always getting notices like pixelated and things like that. So now I basically use my own images but not always can I get them to match what I write about. The source idea is good if only there was a way we could resize the pics as well.
Yes, I love your great personal photos. The free digital photos site which I have recently started using is easy and has tons of photos with the source right there as does wikimedia commons. Our own photos are best and then all one has to put in the source is "self".
by DrMark19613 months ago
In looking over my edited hubs, I find many inconsistencies. Some hubs will be changed so that all large photos are seen (for mobile viewers?), others will be changed into thumbnails, others not changed at all. Some...
by Tranquilheart3 years ago
I went into one of my older hubs to add a photo and got this message:"It looks like some images in this capsule appear to be reduced in size. Note that saving any changes made to this capsule will update the size...
by LeonJane6 years ago
Hi all, I searched for this topic before posting and haven't found anything similar.I am having problems with the photo capsule. When I insert a photo capsule and then open it for editing somehow my screen jumps to the...
by Mary Hyatt20 months ago
I see Hubs where beautiful photos are used and are from Pinterest. The photos are usually credited as being from Pins. Are we allowed to use those photos??
by Jean Bakula3 months ago
Has anyone at Hubpages ever received a bill for using an Artist's work or a Photographer's Photo on a a hub? And if so, how much? I'm curious, because I've written to artists about twenty five times during my time...
by Catherine Giordano21 months ago
Does HP need to see the link in order to know that the picture was legally obtained?They insist on it in boot camp, but what about afterwards?I know Pixabay and some other free-image sites don't require attribution. I...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.