jump to last post 1-7 of 7 discussions (23 posts)

Is it getting harder to pass HubPages QAP?

  1. colorfulone profile image89
    colorfuloneposted 18 months ago

    I am being challenged. I have been having a problem getting a new hub to be featured. It has gone through QAP three times already.

    It is a new day, and I am feeling up to the challenge once again.
    Rested and refreshed after a good nights sleep, with a hopeful heart.
    So! Now, the hub will be going through QAP for a fourth time. tongue

    I know I will get the hub to be featured if I persist.
    But, are other Hubbers having the same difficulty? 


    1. relache profile image86
      relacheposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      What is the intent or focus of the Hub that's been so challenging?

      1. colorfulone profile image89
        colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

        The focus of the hub is to show beautiful photos, with background information of the subjects, and to present products on the same theme.

        1. relache profile image86
          relacheposted 18 months ago in reply to this

          Your products are most likely the problem.  You have created a sales Hub, something just to sell stuff.  Those types of Hubs tend to no longer be approved.

          1. colorfulone profile image89
            colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

            No, it isn't just another sales hub, and it is not spammy.
            The hub got approved yesterday to be featured.
            All I did was move the products down further on the hub.
            So! It was the layout that was getting the hub defeatured.
            I thought the four products were the problem...but,
            as it turns out, they were not.
            The hub layout was the problem.

            (If that didn't work, I was going to remove products one by one.)

  2. Lady Lorelei profile image79
    Lady Loreleiposted 18 months ago

    I have not tried to publish a new article for awhile. A couple months ago I tried to bring in a series of 3 articles and they were refused so I moved them to another publishing platform and have not tried to publish new articles here since. Maybe one day I will try again to bring in a new article but for the moment figure I am best to concentrate my efforts elsewhere and just work at updating the articles that I currently have here at Hubpages.

    1. colorfulone profile image89
      colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      I did need to work on one older hub that became defeatured for quality after I edited it. (I knew that might happen sometime.)  But, I was able to get it featured again without much of a challenge. This new hub, however, is a different story.

    2. sockii profile image88
      sockiiposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      Pretty much the same here. A couple weeks ago I spent hours putting together what would have been a new hub on my months of experience making extruded pasta at home with one specific pasta machine...it was the only product featured in the hub, full of my personal photos, advice on cleaning machine components and drying the pasta and with well over 1,000 words...tried multiple times to edit it and it just would not go through QAP as it was considered "spammy". For being a review of one specific piece of specialty kitchenware.

      I gave up, deleted it and published it on Wizzley instead (where it looks better anyway...)

    3. colorfulone profile image89
      colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      Lorelei and sockii, here is a hub that Robin published.
      http://robin.hubpages.com/hub/Gift-Idea … Grade-Girl
      "45 Gift Ideas for a Third Grade Girl: 8 and 9 Year Olds"

      It has 6 Amazon capsules and 2 Amazon affiliate links, and a link to Bilk (not sure if it is an affiliate link or not).

      * I think it is a great example of a product sales page.
      * It benefited me to see how she did it.

      1. sockii profile image88
        sockiiposted 18 months ago in reply to this

        I'd be more interested in hearing how it has actually converted to any sales than learning how to pass the QAP. All I can say is sales modules here at HP convert dismally compared to how they used to on Squidoo, so what point is there in creating product-oriented pages here anyway? I'm just moving such content elsewhere as I have the time.

        HP doesn't seem to care that AdBlock programs block the Amazon capsules here, so a large portion of people viewing our hubs can't even see the products listed in the first place.

        Honestly HP seems to anti-affiliate links and products in general, I wonder why they don't just get rid of the Amazon and eBay capsules completely at this point.

        1. wilderness profile image97
          wildernessposted 18 months ago in reply to this

          I hope they don't (get rid of Amazon/eBay capsules).  As but a minor player in the field of sales, they are still worth $50-$100 per month for me.

          1. janshares profile image87
            jansharesposted 18 months ago in reply to this

            Wow. God bless you, wilderness. That's no minor feat. smile You are the ad sales King.

          2. colorfulone profile image89
            colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

            Wilderness, we crown you the "Sales King" of HubPages.

  3. calculus-geometry profile image86
    calculus-geometryposted 18 months ago

    It's harder to include products.  I saw the hub you most recently published which isn't featured, I assume it's the one you were referring to.  The Amazon products stuck out to me as coming out of left field a bit.

    1. colorfulone profile image89
      colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      I don't know why the hub is not being featured for quality. Maybe the products are overly promotional on the hub? if they seem to be "coming out of left field a bit"?

      I certainly respect your opinion.

      1. calculus-geometry profile image86
        calculus-geometryposted 18 months ago in reply to this

        I'm not saying they're not related, more like their placement seemed a little jarring to me.  I was skimming along enjoying your pictures and descriptions of the history, and then the flow was interrupted by a similar thing I could buy on Amazon.  When I found the hub and clicked on it, based on the title I was expecting an informational hub about a sight-seeing destination, so the products felt out of place to me, especially popping up between your beautiful photos.

        1. colorfulone profile image89
          colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

          I moved the products down. If this layout does not get it featured, I will remove the related products one by one to see if that does the trick. It may stand best as an informational hub.

          Thank you @calculus-geometry.

        2. colorfulone profile image89
          colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

          Your advice worked like a charm, @calculus-geometry.
          All I did was move the product capsules down.

  4. RanaKm profile image53
    RanaKmposted 18 months ago

    YES!! OMG! I think I can't handle this anymore! I'm really close to quitting this whole shitty site! All what the moderators do is sit on their asses and unfeature the hubs which they don't like.
    If they unfeature your hub again, what will you do? Will you resubmit it again and again? This site is really changing into the worse day after day... They have been putting so many useless rules and restrictions ever since the new year has started!
    I've edited like 50 hubs and deleted about 50 too because of getting so many hubs unfeatured. Although, these hubs were previously featured and getting so many search traffic but fuck this.
    I'm really gonna be quitting soon ( If not today )...And fuck this 25$ which I have made for these entire 10 months on here!
    Sorry for being rude and cursing but I'm so angry with this stupid QaPPPAjasdhsbhbfhbf

  5. CelebrateUSA profile image89
    CelebrateUSAposted 18 months ago

    I have experienced that problem too! Stick with it! It is for the good - don't hit me I know the frustration first hand.
    I also had hub unpublished - they had over 10,000 views and then they were unpublished. But you know what, they should not have been published in the first place, HP's review was spot on.
    Stick with it - it helps all us as it raises the quality score to the search engine. We are a team and that quality does need to be raised in order to compete and succeed.
    Best of luck to you.

  6. lisavanvorst profile image81
    lisavanvorstposted 18 months ago

    It was hard when I firs started writing on hubpages. Now I find it easier to pass the QAP. I believe your first few hubs are really scrutinized by the editors. After about 10 it seems to get better, so hang in there if you are still waiting for your hubs to be published.

    1. colorfulone profile image89
      colorfuloneposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      Thank you, Lisa.
      My hub passed QAP 26 hours ago. If you had read the thread you would have seen that mentioned. However, I really do appreciate your comforting words and encouragement.
      That's sweet!

  7. TheHealthGuy LM profile image80
    TheHealthGuy LMposted 18 months ago

    Y'all are really pumping me up! I wasn't to excited about doing new hubs simply because the hubs I have were transferred from Squidoo and when I first joined Squidoo, Squidoo was a cool place. You could write about anything, use your lenses (Squidoo term) to drive traffic to affiliate pages or better to optin pages and not only make money via Squidoo but also from the traffic that was driven to my optin pages, all via free traffic. The links from squidoo helped boost ranking to my sites and things were good. Then ...

    Squidoo became popular and forgot who made them popular, affiliates. They installed a spam bot and soon marketers lenses were all "spam" lenses, locked, then deleted. I lost about 40 lenses. Squidoo and I went round and round. But when the "arrogance" set in they simply became stupid and eventually sold the platform or lenses to hubpages. Now ...

    Hubpages hit me as just another Squidoo with less bells and whistles. Hubs aren't near as easy to create nor can they be made to look as appealing as were Squidoo lenses but so far nobody at hubpages has hasseled me; yet I am reluctant to invest time creating new hubs because I think it is simply Squidoo in a different skin and ...

    Since I have my own domain properties I just don't see the reason to invest what could become wasted time. What it all boils down to is this, free stuff is great, sometimes, but, when someone else owns the property they can do whatever they like and once they decide you are worthless your work and effort is wasted.

    I have just sat and watched. I wanted to see what they did with my current hubs and so far, like I said, they haven't harmed them or hasseled me but who knows what would happen if I decided to invest more time? It sounds, from this thread and others, that it would be smarter to simply build more of my own properties.

    I think it is unfortunate that something with such potential for both parties (hub writers and hubpages) may not be what it could be for both parties.