I am writing a new hub, with an educational intent, and I would like to include, in its entirety, a very brief poem by Dorothy Parker.
The latest copyright date by her is 1956. (She died in 1967.)
The current copyright is Penguin Books, 2006.
Can this poem be used in my article under the educational rule, or should I write to Penguin Books for permission?
It's still under copyright, and including a poem in a commercial article, even with educational intent, does not fall under Fair Use. (Remember, you are getting paid as a writer, not as a teacher.) You should write to Penguin for permission.
Ok--I kind of figured as much, so I've already sent for the permission. However, I thought the 'commercial' use meant actually using the segment/page/quote or what have you, as a stand-alone way to make money.
The fact that it's to be buried in an article with no commercial intent (I'm not trying to sell anything--it's a purely educational article), and the ads (so often unrelated to the content!) are what pay me, it seemed as if it should skate by.
Sigh...things are so damned complicated all the time. Hopefully, they will grant permission, and I can use the actual poem instead of just linking to it. I don't like links that take the reader off my pages!
The fact that you're posting the poem in its entirety falls under the plagiarism rules unless permission is obtained. You'll have to site the source and give attribution to the proper entity, along with a statement that you have permission to post it. Regardless of what other text is in the post, it (the poem) is being used for commercial purposes since you get paid for each page view.
Going forward, assume that everything you write on HubPages is for commercial intent. If you get paid, by whatever means, it's commercial.
I think it's pretty clear. If you are writing an article for commercial purposes, anything you use within the article must be legal to use for commercial purposes. That includes poems and photos.
Even with permission you are going to have a lot of issues with this Hub due to the content duplication. Personally, I feel this is not a good content fit for this site.
GAH! What a royal PITA!! I guess I'll just end up putting only a link, then, even if I do get permission.... but that is so unsatisfactory....
If it's short enough, maybe you could add it as an image.
+1, as long as you are granted permission from the copyright holder.
Ah--that might work; good idea--that gets past the 'duplicate content' filter!
(And yes, it is very short!)
I await the permission, so that hub is on hold.
Well, I have heard back from Penguin Group, and it is not looking good. Instead of giving me either outright permission, or a straight denial, they have sent a letter requesting additional information.
The very nature of the questions leads me to believe it will end up a denial, anyway, as they have asked question neither I nor anyone else would be able to answer! Here is their list of "requested information":
--Indicate the total number of anticipated users (WTH??!! No one here has a crystal ball!)
--Is this a for profit or non profit site? (Yeah..I guess it is 'for profit.')
--Do you wish to allow the end-user to print or otherwise reproduce multiple copies of this material? (Really?? It's online! I have no control over that!)
--Is site subscriber-access, password-protected? (DUH--no)
--What is the date (mm/dd/yyyy) of your initial release: (Hell if I know--that depends on YOUR reply!)
So, I guess that's that! If it looked more promising, I'd go forward, but this looks more like they are looking for reasons to deny, or charge me a fee I couldn't afford anyway, so eff it--I'll just put a link.
I'm not going to play games and jump through 10K hoops just to get turned down. I've sent a politely worded e-mail to that effect.
I have better things to do with what little energy I have right now.
The U.S. has clear ways of using copyrighted material. If you follow those rules, you are fine...outside of HUB. If HUB determines it's too much duplicate material, they may close it down, even if you follow the rules. I don't agree with most duplicate content hysteria, as google and the web are chock full of duplicate material. Every big site from yahoo to amazon, New York TImes, etc. uses duplicate, copied material...no big deal.
I choose to stick with hub, so I choose to follow their rules, guidelines, and decisions. Make no mistake about that.
I think most people would be amazed at how much and how you can readily use copyrighted material. Commentary, news, satire, etc. all following the many, diverse rules on copyrighted material.
Off topic, but more than half the world could care less about US laws.
That is so very true, and I agree about the "duplicate content hysteria." As you say, the WWW is chock full of it. Even on Google, so, IMO, HP has a hard time defending their position as being based on what Google wants/likes.
It is also true that many other countries routinely copy all manner of written content without regard to copyright laws; they are unaffected and cannot be prosecuted by our laws, so they simply don't care.
As for my predicament, as you can see from my update, they wanted answers to questions for which there are no reasonable answers! It's a dodge around a direct 'no.'
That's okay: the material is already out there at various sites online, and I'll simply link to it! A virtual nose-thumbing, if you will. And, realistically, once you publish something publicly online, you really do lose control over it, so all of this uproar is a lot of tilting at windmills.
The internet is indeed "full of" duplicate content. And Google penalizes it by heavily reducing the ranking of all but one copy (their best guess as to which is the original) when they detect it.
Thus letting people posy duplicate content without any limitations would negatively effect Hubpages by loading it with a lot of low value material.
I'm in no way suggesting that posting duplicate content is a good idea; I'm merely pointing out that people all over the world do it anyway, and that once you post something online, you have really lost any control over what happens next. People are going to do what they are going to do, and other countries do not care about and are not bound by our laws.
by al derecho7 months ago
I know hubpages prohibits writers from having duplicate content. My problem is understanding what that exactly means. I heard from many that it means writers can't publish content here that already exists elsewhere, but...
by Catherine Giordano16 months ago
Yesterday someone contacted me saying she wanted to reprint my hub "Does Religion do More Harm than Good" in her ezine. This is the link: http://churchandstate.org.uk/I was so flattered that I...
by kerryg5 years ago
I used to have an eHow account, but when they closed the Writer's Compensation Program back in May/June, I removed my articles from the site and deleted my account.A couple days ago, I republished one of the articles...
by cupid516 years ago
Can I post an article to ezinearticles which I have already published in hubpages?
by Nicole Pellegrini2 years ago
I just got hit by a duplicate content unpublishing of one of my articles. For the record, it is my own work which I had originally published on another platform and wanted to relocate here. After deleting the article...
by Marisa Wright7 years ago
I was reading a Hub on Hubpages, and was concerned to read the advice that the content we use in our Hubs should be unique, not something we've posted elsewhere on the net.I started out on Helium and have nearly 200...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.