On a number of hubs, I have comments from hubbers who no longer have a profile here. When I click on their names, a page comes up saying "Sorry that user no longer exists".
I suppose these links aren't "dead" but they are very poor links to have on a hub. Might search engines penalize this? Or are they set as "nofollow" by hubpages?
I have never considered that point before. The Hubber link is an outbound link. I would think regarding the bots crawling the whole and complete hub it will examine that link, however it will I presume look at if there is or not any HTTP errors. How that within the complexity of the algorithm is beyond me.
I did a little research when reading the OP. I discovered an interesting article, even though it is kinda' beyond me how to interpret it. It is about inbound and outbound links.
At that site itself are additional internal links at the left pointing to topics for understanding Page Ranking. Even though I do not see a publication date, those principals IMHO will apply to today's algorithms and seems relevant. Here is the link to that article:
Reading through it I can grasp what is occurring enough to see the values of inbound and outbound links regarding a page ranking. At least with the math they share those to be determinate values rather than obscure.
Unsure if that answers your query, but of least myself I gained from the OP. Maybe you and others will too. I dun'no . . .
Thanks for the interesting response tsmog. That's a good resource.
Sharing a bit at the personal level Thomas after reading the entirety of those articles I get it now. Maybe I am left brained when it comes to understanding things . . . I dun'no :-) I easily understand the Big Picture now that I understand the details more thoroughly. I realize the 'values' of links to and within my articles.
Particularly the the value of inbound links by authoritative sites contrast any site regarding page ranking. Even though that inbound link may not necessarily determine traffic, it affects ranking. I have a better understanding how the Google Algorithm may be altered for an impact with PageRanking especially the dampening factor.
Interesting enough I always thought the name PageRank was related to the actual Webpage. My eyes opened once I learned it is from the algorithm formulated by Lawrence Page and Sergey Brin.
commenter profiles are not clickable unless you are logged in, thus the majority of your readers will not know if the profile exists or not. bots crawl the site as a non-logged in reader.
It would seem to me that HP would automatically delete comments from people who have left the site, but if not, they should. It would be a lot of work for a writer here to sort through every comment to see if its writer was still on the site.
I also feel this way about followers. People who followed us but have left should not have their follows on our lists. This is another thing HP should do automatically.
These things keep the site "clean", save money for the team and avoid confusion for people.
Glad you brought this one up.
I completely disagree, what does a commenter's account status have to do with the quality of his comment?
Outside readers can leave comments as non-logged in users (if the hub author is savvy enough to configure his hub settings to allow it), should those also be eliminated? There's essentially no difference between a comment left by a user whose account was deleted and a comment left by a reader who is not a member.
Hub authors can delete comments based on whatever criteria they want, so if a particular person does not want comments showing from profiles that have been deleted or banned, that's his prerogative. But HP should not mass delete them from everyone's hubs. I have received plenty of useful comments from former members who, for whatever reason, no longer have an account.
Yes but how would HP know if a person has left the site for good? For example, I left for two years and returned.
by Hokey6 years ago
Maybe its just me but I realize the work people put into their writing so I comment. Even if its just a thanks for sharing. How about you?
by GwennyOh4 years ago
I commented on a question today, and when I went to clarify what I had originally said, I was limited to 200 words. I had said I would come back and continue the thought because I was under the impression I...
by juana b good9 years ago
There is one guy who is on my fan club who has some content on his pages that I am not comfortable with. How can I get him off?
by AgeOfAquarius7 years ago
I was just wondering if you could delete comments. Still a newbie!
by Virginia Kearney21 months ago
I just emailed a comment to HubPages staff but thought I'd also ask the forum group. I have a lot of errors in the comments posted on my Hubs because I write Hubs read by students and by people who are not native...
by Crazdwriter7 years ago
Okay Isn't it up to ME to delete comments or not on my hubs? I mean it is my hub and if I want to delete a comment for my reasons isn't that up to me?I recieved a comment that I deleted then she had the nerve to go back...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.