OK, I thought to make a more comprehensive post, here. Please add your two cents (but try not to duplicate concerns, too often; this helps the folks at HP to go through everything more easily).
* Let the writers decide whether they want to opt in or opt out. Provide a button for that.
* Do not make changes in article copy; send emails to the writer saying that an "error" has been caught and let the writer decide whether it is necessary to deal with the issue. (In my case, most of the changes, were for alternate spellings (which I always check before publishing and often, deem OK). The other problem is that the EditBot changes branding and promotion spelling for particular products.
* Remove the editing icon after the page has been viewed by the writer. Change the color of the icons each time the Bot makes its run.
And what else?
HP should make an error submission form for authors to report genuine editbot mistakes. For example, it apparently autocorrects "try and" to "try to" without seeing the context, which often results in errors. In math hubs, it sometimes doesn't understand when "A" is being used as a variable and in education hubs it sometimes doesn't understand "A" being used as a letter grade.
Marina just posted an update related to EditBot here.
Totally agree with all your suggestions. Also it would be good if there was a way to skip through to each correction to make checking easier.
I really think the editbot shouldn't tag us for someone else's errors, when it comes to comments...
Suspend editbot until the kinks are worked out; re-think if this was the best choice for an auto-check app for HP.
I think its brilliant. How can the program edit every single hub?
Its very educational for all!
It forces those who call themselves writers to get consciences in their writing and editing.
If the EditBot is consistently averaging under 1 error or less per 1,000 words per published hub leave that Author alone - they know what they're doing!
(ie find a rational hurdle mark (eg error rate per 1,000 words) where everybody above MUST be subject to Editbot and everybody below is not or sampled periodically only)
Do not include errors which are not errors - i.e. they are due to a not very intelligent (as yet) EditBot
Apply the EditBot to comments only in the first instance.
After these have been eliminated and the slate cleared then assess the author's error rate per 1,000 words and Editbot should then ignore all those who have an error rate less than a standard which is acceptable for a good writer.
I just want those icons to go away because they're starting to become a nuisance.
by Catherine Giordano23 months ago
I always appreciate it when someone lets me know about a typo or an error of fact in my hubs. I have also given a heads-up to others and they have been appreciative. When I tell someone about an error, I send them a...
by Pamela Lipscomb3 years ago
Why do I keep getting crawl errors, this is the third time?http://archive.org/web/20101126145744/h … dit-Report
by Marina12 months ago
Happy Thursday, everyone! In August we pre-announced a new tool that fixes common spelling and grammatical errors across the site. Today, Editbot, the first iteration of the tool, is live on a small percentage of Hubs...
by JSParker5 years ago
I think HubPages is just a terrific opportunity for writers to write and make connections within the HubPages community. However, I am concerned about the quality of some of the hubs I see. Even if the...
by Kylyssa Shay3 months ago
A hub of mine was recently put through HubPro Basic. That means photos were removed, a bunch of the text was reworded, and one or more links to educational and supportive resources were removed. A few grammar errors...
by Ben Guinter3 years ago
Ever since the 18th of May there has been an increasing jump in 403 errors because of some xml-stats-realatedhubevents.php.... which can't be good for rankings. I know the 403 error means that you're denying...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.