jump to last post 1-10 of 10 discussions (20 posts)

Someone possibly stole a hub idea I've already published.

  1. Laura Rash profile image80
    Laura Rashposted 18 months ago

    I published a hub years ago (3/8/2012), and recently discovered that there is a VERY similar hub that was published as well.  How do I find out when the other hub was originally published?  It's been edited so I can't see the original publishing date... Any help is GREATLY appreciated as I do not want to find out that mine was published AFTER the other one.

    1. myshortstories profile image59
      myshortstoriesposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      What was the hub about?

      1. Laura Rash profile image80
        Laura Rashposted 18 months ago in reply to this

        cooler corn

        1. myshortstories profile image59
          myshortstoriesposted 18 months ago in reply to this

          The recipies for cooking the same dish are very identical.Maybe it just happened by chance that your hub is very similar to the other person

          1. Laura Rash profile image80
            Laura Rashposted 18 months ago in reply to this

            If it were just the basic steps, then I would agree - however even some of the language (article wording) in the hub are EXACTLY like mine...

  2. Laura Rash profile image80
    Laura Rashposted 18 months ago

    Any idea how to find out the original publishing date of someone else's hub to compare dates?

  3. Joan King profile image77
    Joan Kingposted 18 months ago

    Could you just not ask HP to moderate and decide if it is copied?

  4. DanielMarcosi profile image82
    DanielMarcosiposted 18 months ago

    In my experience, hubpages has been very diligent in determining if new hubs are plagiarizing other hubs. If they don't catch it immediately, then they will probably catch it soon. If not, you can always write to HP and point it out to them.

  5. DrMark1961 profile image91
    DrMark1961posted 18 months ago

    You can try reporting that hubber to the team@hubpages.com, but do not hold your breath. I have had my most popular hub copied several times, and one of them full of great stolen images from other websites, and if your hub is better it is still going to outperform the new one.
    If it is not doing that great, it was probably not doing that well before it was stolen. My suggestion? Write some more. As you have pointed out yourself, quantity is queen.

  6. Barbara Kay profile image86
    Barbara Kayposted 18 months ago

    Laura, If you use the search bar here at Hubpages, both hubs will come up for cooler corn. The other one says it was updated August 12, 2012. The odds are that the other one was written before yours. Since your hub is coming up first, I wouldn't worry about the other one. That one doesn't seem to be indexed by Google either and yours is.

  7. ThelmaC profile image92
    ThelmaCposted 18 months ago

    The other hubber has been on HubPages 6 years, has over 1500 followers, has written almost 700 hubs and has a hubber score of 99.  Doesn't sound like your typical person that steals hubs from others.  I wouldn't worry about it.

  8. makingamark profile image71
    makingamarkposted 18 months ago

    You do realise there is no copyright on an idea?

    Plus if you look on Google there's any amount of people who have had exactly the same "idea".

    1. myshortstories profile image59
      myshortstoriesposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      You do realise cooking books are copyright protected?

      1. theraggededge profile image95
        theraggededgeposted 18 months ago in reply to this

        What's that got to do with anything?

      2. Ramkitten2000 profile image94
        Ramkitten2000posted 18 months ago in reply to this

        However, recipe ingredients are not copyright protected.

        1. Marketing Merit profile image86
          Marketing Meritposted 18 months ago in reply to this

          Beat me to it! That's quite correct.

        2. myshortstories profile image59
          myshortstoriesposted 18 months ago in reply to this

          Its the way you make the recipe.I am pretty sure her recipe didn't only include the ingredients.Like Laura said "If it were just the basic steps, then I would agree - however even some of the language (article wording) in the hub are EXACTLY like mine..."

  9. Barbara Kay profile image86
    Barbara Kayposted 18 months ago

    I design crochet patterns. Someone else quite often will have designed the same thing I did at the same time and I always think I have unique idea. The amazing part is how minds can work so much the same. That is what happened here in all probability. Just leave it be.

  10. makingamark profile image71
    makingamarkposted 18 months ago

    There's two issues here

    The first is whether or not the two hubs are similar. I've taken a look and frankly IMO there is absolutely no case to answer. They are no more similar than any writing might be which describes a particular approach to cooking something which is also described by other people elsewhere on the internet. Neither author originated the idea and both are reciting an approach they were told about - end of story. It's not original and it's not unique.

    The second issue is the matter of identifying other people as infringing your copyright.

    It's a really bad idea to discuss this in public unless:
    1) you have a really good understanding of copyright and how it works
    2) you are absolutely certain this has happened.
    3) consequently you are definitely prepared to issue a "cease and desist" notice and report the matter to Google to ensure the content is taken down (i.e. submit a form to Google citing the copyright infringement (see https://support.google.com/legal/answer/1120734#counter) and make all the necessary legal declarations that they require of you - and then sign the form as a legal document)

    That's because it's libellous to suggest somebody has done something when that's not the case.

    It's also possible that the individual in question might see this as a personal attack - and that's not allowed in the forum.

    If you're not sure about a possible copyright by all means ask people for their advice - but just do not do this in public if you're discussing details which identify the other person.

    In general if you see something that bothers you in terms of copyright it's a much better idea to discuss it offline (or not in public) with a knowledgeable friend and that way you stay on the right side of the libel laws.

    BTW - Laura's original query was fine - because it asked for a technical answer to a technical question - which would assist Laura. The problem arose when it became possible to identify who the other author is (and that happened as soon as the topic of the hub was identified)

    My recommendation would be to delete from this thread anything which identifies another individual.  Then do as Barbara says and just 'leave it be'.

    1. Laura Rash profile image80
      Laura Rashposted 18 months ago in reply to this

      As far as I know there is no way for me to remove a discussion or comment from a forum discussion... Is there?

 
working