My hub below used to be always featured and suddenly after I made enhancement to it and made more explanative and informative to readers, the hub started getting unpublished due to spamy elements which I am unable to locate.
http://hubpages.com/education/Discovery … ssory-Note
Can you be of help please?
Try removing all the reference links. Then add them back in at the rate of one each day. One of them may be the problem.
I'm sure you're aware that the rules have changed, so your writing must change with it. Here is what I think you are doing wrong:
Your title is way too long and is not searchable
Your photos are not all properly accredited
You have huge blocks of writing that should be divided into capsules
You have links to all of your references...far too many links. Get rid of the links completely and just name the references.
You have one photo that is not written in English. This is a site for English speakers, thus, that photo is not acceptable.
Your information is interesting, but you need to do a better job of formatting it as per HP's guidelines.
Thanks for your advice. Kindly be assured that I followed your advice but seems something is going wrong somehow.
As to the title, the same is as follows:
"The Umayyad Standing Caliph Gold Coin, Damascus (71- 72 A.H/691-692 A.D.); The Earliest Promissory Note in History"
Would you please rephrase it in a away that is in compliance with HupPages?
Your opening few paragraphs contain how many links to wikipedia???
You need to get rid of the rating capsule. It is only meant for recipes.
The Wikipedia links would be a problem as you are sending people to another website that has information your article could contain. Also, Wikipedia can be edited by anybody so the information contained on these pages may not be 100% reliable. If you must use links, use a more reliable source.
I am pretty sure I know what the problem is. It is the links. You are using them incorrectly, and that means some of your links are " not sufficiently relevant" according to HubPages' criteria.
1. You must not create a link simply to provide the definition of a word. If you think your reader doesn't know what a "promissory note" or "gharar" mean, give them the definition yourself. If you are linking to a whole web page just so they can read one or two sentences which explain a meaning, then that will be judged "not sufficiently relevant".
2. Same for people - if you are going to mention a person, do not link to a biography of that person unless a knowledge of their life is essential to the topic you're writing about. If their life story isn't essential to the topic, then HubPages will judge that link "not sufficiently relevant".
3. Same for places - the history of Damascus isn't essential to the topic. If some of the city's history is relevant then you should either find a web page that covers that specific period, or give an overview of it in the Hub itself. General information about the city will be judged "not sufficiently relevant".
Recently, the rules about the Ratings capsule were changed. Previously you could use it in any Hub, now you can use it in recipes ONLY. So it needs to be removed.
Finally, your grammar and sentence structure are poor in some places. HubPages demands a very high standard of fluent English so that needs some work.
I thank you Marisa for your so informative reply and that you are pretty sure of what the problem is.
1- I did remove all anchored links,
2- Same for people, despite the fact that the Article has no reference to an unknown personality but I did remove any suspicious link that may cause a misunderstanding.
3- As to places, despite the importance thereof, I removed any external link to the same,
4- As to Rating Capsule , I removed the same.
5 - As to the grammatical mistakes or/and poor not understandable language if any, please provide an example to the same so I take the right action accordingly?
Finally, I followed all your advice stated in your message above but still getting the article unpublished due to the so-called "Spammy Elements".
I thank you for any further advice in advance.
Thanks again for your time.
Seems there is something somehow going wrong here which may be due to robotic reviews rather than human!
I hope an official reply from Hubpages be of help soon.
by VivBounty6 weeks ago
Can someone please help me? I've seen some really sub quality hubs out here. I write well and yet my hubs are being unpublished and continuously picked on for sub quality. I'm offended. You're making it not fun to be a...
by michifus4 years ago
I have noticed that all of my hubs that contain affiliate links have now been marked as being in violation of the terms and conditions of hubpages.Hubpages must have forgotten to mention that affiliate links are now...
by RanaKm21 months ago
So, I've had a hub unpublished due to HP claiming that it's overly promotional.The hub only has 2 outbound links ( which is the number of links we're allowed to put for the other external sites ) this is the only thing...
by Bill Ames3 years ago
I've written my first hub. Maybe I don't understand the purpose. I have a topic and I would think the best way to engage readership is with quality content and quality links on the subject.My website is a...
by AnnaMKB6 months ago
First off, my hubs are transferred from Squidoo, and I am aware of various issues there. I'd already checked and edited hubs after the transition, so this is all post transfer.What I don't understand is why some...
by Liam Hallam20 months ago
After 6 months on the site i've started the really wonder how many backlinks is a reasonable number to any hub, and really to a hub becoming successful? Or is it simply a lottery.What kind of figures do other hubbers...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.