jump to last post 1-2 of 2 discussions (36 posts)

Maximum Length of a Hub

  1. madscientist12 profile image95
    madscientist12posted 2 months ago

    Hello Hubbers! I was wondering if there is a recommended maximum length for a hub? I started writing one, and then realized that I have enough information to write a book. So I decided to break the info into eight parts (translation: eight hubs). I started writing part one, then realized that i needed to split that into two parts, so I am actually working on part two first, and I'll go back and write part one later. Well, this particular hub is long already (1400 words) and I'm only halfway through it. Should I split it up even further, or keep going? How long is too long for a hub? Or should I just take all the information and actually write a book, lol.

    1. madscientist12 profile image95
      madscientist12posted 2 months ago in reply to this

      I also have photos, a poll, and a video as well to help break up the different sections.

      1. Kylyssa profile image94
        Kylyssaposted 2 months ago in reply to this

        As far as I can tell, based on my own hubs, there's no maximum length and, if there is, 1,400 or even 2,800 words comes nowhere close. When my hubs were transferred over from Squidoo, one of them, the first chapters to a serialized novel, was over 40,000 words in length and it didn't even load slowly. I have since split it up and given each chapter its own hub for other reasons, but that's another story.

        People bookmark and come back to information-dense hubs of mine with high word counts and they tend to get shared the most on social media and by online publications of all my hubs. So I'd suggest you write as much as you need to to thoroughly cover your niche topic in-depth. As long as you keep the focus tightly on your stated topic and only on your stated topic, take as many words as it takes.

        1. madscientist12 profile image95
          madscientist12posted 2 months ago in reply to this

          The topic is extremely broad, which is why I decided to break it up into parts (like chapters in a book). I just don't want my articles to be so long that it passes my readers' attention spans.

    2. lions44 profile image94
      lions44posted 2 months ago in reply to this

      I don't think there is a max rule, but I do use my own 5000-6,000 word rule for each hub. My hubs should never be over 6,000 words, regardless of topic.  I had a hub 6500 and once I trimmed it down, it read far better.  I might have a couple hovering at 7,000, which I will keep editing.   As for minimum, 2500-3,000 is my floor.

    3. Sherry Hewins profile image94
      Sherry Hewinsposted 2 months ago in reply to this

      I would break it up into hubs, but make sure each one stands on its own, and give each one a unique title that tells people what it is about.

      1. madscientist12 profile image95
        madscientist12posted 2 months ago in reply to this

        Yes, that is what I was thinking also. It's a lot of information.

    4. promisem profile image94
      promisemposted 2 months ago in reply to this

      I can tell you from a lot of research and experimentation that the number of people who exit an article grows the more they have to scroll.

      So my suggestion is that you follow a common journalism practice of putting your best and most important information toward the top of the article and the least important at the bottom.

    5. jackclee lm profile image80
      jackclee lmposted 2 months ago in reply to this

      My suggestion is to create hubbooks. I have been doing this for awhile. Search on "How to create a hubbook". I call each hub a chapter and I have a Table of Contents hub that links to each chapter. I also provide navigation links to go from one chapter to the next. Each chapter should be around 2000-3000 words. BTW, it is also a good way to track hubs that are related to a topic. HubPages use to have Groups but they have discontinued it. A hubbook can group hubs of one topics in a easy to follow fashion. Good luck.

  2. Marisa Wright profile image94
    Marisa Wrightposted 2 months ago

    My own thoughts would be that if you have so much information on one topic, it would be worth turning it into a stand-alone website.  But assuming you don't want to do that, then the most effective approach would be to split the subject up into 1,500 word segments. 

    I say that because many Hubbers have researched length over the years, and the 1,500 word length seems to be the "sweet spot".  It's long enough to provide solid information but not so long that people's eyes start to glaze over!   Go over that length and people have to scroll too far to find what they're looking for.

    Be aware that there is a problem with writing a series on HubPages - navigation.  If you create your own blog or website, you would still split your topic up into smaller articles, each covering a different aspect of the subject.  Readers will arrive at one of the posts, having found it on Google - if that doesn't quite meet their needs or if they want to read further, then you'll have a menu in the sidebar listing all the categories or sections, so people can easily navigate around the whole site to find what they want.

    Readers can't do that on HubPages.  They'll arrive at one of the Hubs in the series, but if that's not quite what they want, they can't see a list of all the other Hubs in the series.  You're not allowed to add a list in the Hub, either!   What they do see is "Popular Hubs" and "Related Hubs", so they're more likely to click on those than to look for the other Hubs in your series. They won't even think to look at your profile and even if they do, they probably won't know how to search for the series in your list of Hubs.

    If each Hub can stand on its own as well as forming part of the series, that may not matter, but it's something to think about.

    1. madscientist12 profile image95
      madscientist12posted 2 months ago in reply to this

      Thank you so much for this information. You have great ideas!

    2. madscientist12 profile image95
      madscientist12posted 2 months ago in reply to this

      Hmmm, I like the idea of creating a website just for this series. I never thought about that. Thanks for the idea.

      1. Marisa Wright profile image94
        Marisa Wrightposted 2 months ago in reply to this

        Creating your own website isn't as hard as it sounds, but working out how to earn money from it is harder than it is on HubPages.  In the long run you should be able to earn much better from your own site, but if you don't have time to invest in learning how to promote and monetize, you may be better to stick to HubPages where you'll start earning much sooner.

    3. gerimcclym profile image85
      gerimcclymposted 2 months ago in reply to this

      Has HP explicitly said they don't allow a list of links of related hubs we've written? Many top-notch writers on HP have lists of related work of theirs so I was under the impression that it was allowed.

      1. Marisa Wright profile image94
        Marisa Wrightposted 2 months ago in reply to this

        It's something we all used to do, but it's no longer allowed because its regarded as overly promotional.   I notice that such lists are not allowed on the niche sites - and since that's where the main income potential is, you don't want to create a Hub that might not be approved for the niche sites for any reason. 

        You will still see many Hubs with those lists on them, but that's just because they haven't been edited since the new standards came in.

        1. jackclee lm profile image80
          jackclee lmposted 2 months ago in reply to this

          I don't think it is not allowed. I have many hubs with table of contents. They may not be featured but I really don't care. I still prefer to have a hub that lists all my other hubs related to the same topic such as recipes or travel...This way, I have a dozen or so main hubs that tracks over 200 hubs.

          1. Jean Bakula profile image96
            Jean Bakulaposted 2 months ago in reply to this

            I had one series of 8 hubs that were about 3,000 words each. They always were my most popular hubs, and were moved to a niche site. But that was a nightmare, getting them all moved so it would make sense. If you find people interested in your topic, it will do well. Now that the hubs are being moved to niches though, you may get stuck with part on HP and part on a niche site. If you cut them down in size, you are not allowed to link them. So unless the administration puts a picture of one of the related parts next to your first part, nobody will know it's a series. You have to tell your readers, in the summary, or in the first paragraph.

            At election time in the U.S. I always interpret the astrology chart of the Democratic and Republican nominee. The ones from the last election are still getting traffic, after 4 years. I wrote about Hillary Clinton, 5600 words a few months ago..Readers have ASKED me to keep doing this.

            The other day I did the same for Donald Trump, and within hours it was moved to Exemplore. I have asked the administration to move Hillary's, since they are a set, written in the same style. I'm being told that the images on Hillary's were pixellated, although they weren't, when the hub is in edit mode it tells you. So I put a few different images on it and moved a few around, no Amazon capsules are allowed anymore, and am awaiting an answer.

            I was also told in the email that we are no longer allowed to choose a hub every 60 days to be moved to a niche site if it meets the criteria. I responded that we no longer know what the criteria is. Apparently we are not allowed ANY Amazon capsules anymore. Good luck to you.

            1. jackclee lm profile image80
              jackclee lmposted 2 months ago in reply to this

              I am not interested in the niche sites so much. I had a few hubs moved but my traffic did not increase. The main restriction of no links is a definite disadvantage. So far, I didn't see much other advantage of the niche sites. In addition, they don't seem to rank as high on google search page ranking. I much prefer the abilty to link related hubs so the reader can follow.

              1. Marisa Wright profile image94
                Marisa Wrightposted 2 months ago in reply to this

                Links are restricted but they are not banned.  If your links are directly relevant to the main subject of the Hub, they are allowed.

                What HubPages doesn't like now is the Links Capsule being used to list several other Hubs, e.g. at the end of a Hub.  I've had those removed even if the other Hubs are directly relevant.

                As for whether the niche sites are better, it depends which sites your Hubs have been moved to.   Where the niche sites have a coherent mix of subjects, they seem to be doing very well and traffic is up (e.g. PetHelpful).   Where unrelated subjects have been shoehorned into a niche (e.g. Performing Arts in a niche site which is otherwise all about Games), one of two things happens - either Google ignores the section that doesn't fit, or penalises the whole site for including irrelevant material.

                1. jackclee lm profile image80
                  jackclee lmposted 2 months ago in reply to this

                  Thanks for the info. I had no idea the various niche sites are treated differently by google search. It does bring up the question of how effective are these transition to niche sites? I always believe there are more strength in numbers. I still like the old hubpages with all hubs under one roof and prefer they just divide up the topics in a more suitable way. I still have trouble choosing the category of some of my hubs, not sure where they fit...

                  1. Marisa Wright profile image94
                    Marisa Wrightposted 2 months ago in reply to this

                    Jacklee, I suggest you do some study on how Google works, as a Hubber it's a good thing to understand it.

                    Having all Hubs under one roof is exactly what Google hates - it doesn't matter how they split up the topics, Google disapproves of sites that don't specialise in one subject area and wants them gone.

                    Don't take my word for it - HubPages agrees with me, that's why they've given up on trying to make the main site work, and are putting all their efforts into creating the niche sites.  They know that's what they must do to continue to get good Google traffic!

                    Where we disagree is the way that those specialist sites are being created. PetHelpful is an obvious example of a specialist site that makes sense:  it's about pets. But look at HobbyLark:  HubPages says it's about hobbies, but the word "hobby" is too vague:  people do crafts as a hobby, and yet that's not on HobbyLark - but Performing Arts is, even though people don't always do that as a hobby, it's often a paid job.  So my concern is that Google will look at sites like Hobbylark and think the mix of subjects isn't specialist enough.

            2. Marisa Wright profile image94
              Marisa Wrightposted 2 months ago in reply to this

              Did they actually say in the email that no Amazon capsules are allowed?  I have some Amazon capsules in Hubs that have been moved.   I understood the rule was that they had to be very closely related to the subject, that's all. 

              I can still see the option to submit a Hub every 60 days.  When you click the button to submit the Hub, it asks you whether the Hub meets the criteria, one by one.

              1. Jean Bakula profile image96
                Jean Bakulaposted 2 months ago in reply to this

                Marisa,
                I was online with Christy at the Administration, asking if my Trump/Hillary hubs could be together as companion pieces. They moved Trump to Exemplore hours after I posted it, and Hillary is the same, but is still on HP, published about 3 months ago.

                I was told Editorial would decide. But that I had to take off my one Amazon hub. The hub was 5600 words. I was also told my pics were fuzzy, but in edit mode it didn't show any that way, so I know it was just an excuse. I changed a few pics and moved a few, but am awaiting an answer.

                But I was told no Amazon capsules. I asked if we could have a new set of rules. And said that I and probably others have hubs they would publish, but they are being too unclear about the rules. I would take the Amazon capsules off. I use them very sparingly, in spite of my large word counts at times, so if I'm being told that, I think it's the new rule.

                1. Jean Bakula profile image96
                  Jean Bakulaposted 2 months ago in reply to this

                  Oh, forgot, and about the button that supposedly will allow us to submit a new hub every 60 days. They are retiring this, as of now I believe.

                  I had a hub that I chose 56 days ago, and this began when I asked if I could change my mind and submit my Hillary hub in place of that. Christy said they weren't going to let us choose hubs to submit anymore. I asked again that they submit a new set of rules.

                  I'll be very annoyed if they don't move that hub. It takes about 12 hours to cast and interpret an astrology chart, and I have to spend a lot more hours tailoring it to fit with a format that will interest hub readers. I did this last year at US election time, and people have been begging me to do it again, even asking me to do other political figures, but I don't have time.

                  They better update the rules, they are playing us for fools.

                  1. makingamark profile image75
                    makingamarkposted 2 months ago in reply to this

                    Why don't you get your own website and organise your content as you see fit?

                  2. Christy Kirwan profile image
                    89
                    Christy Kirwanposted 2 months ago in reply to this

                    Hi Jean,

                    I'm sorry I was unclear in my email. We are not retiring the button, we are simply no longer considering requests that are NOT submitted using the button (for example, requests to move Hubs made via email or in the Forums-- our Editors simply can not keep up with these types of requests).

      2. madscientist12 profile image95
        madscientist12posted 2 months ago in reply to this

        I dont put lists, but i do put links to my other hubs.

 
working