Just interested in how many of you just read a hub and dont leave a comment. For me if i read something I always leave a comment but by looing at my reads I can only assume loads read but dont leave a comment. What makes you leave a comment and what makes you not bother, just curious.
Sometimes...after reading our hubs and maybe our comments....maybe they're just too embarrased ....whaddaya think?? But I really appreciate comments...means I've connected with the reader....good, bad , but hopefully not indifferent. I even appreciate disagreeing comments.
I have to agree, even the bad is good. So far I haven't had any bad, but I am sure they will come.
For me, It is a matter of having something to say. If I don't have a comment that is worthy of print, I'll save my say for a later day.
Ya agreed ..the advantage of living comment is more people can be your fans while reading those same hubs..
I always use to drop comment when I read whole info...without reading I had never done comment..wrong comment...
So read before u drop comment..
Maybe about 50% of the time I don't leave a comment, it depends. Sometimes I really enjoyed the hub but I have nothing to say, so I don't leave any comments.
So if we have no comment from you we can assume you haven't read it BadCompany? And here I thought it was a mutual fan club...(another wink)
Seriously though, I do my best to read and leave comments for hubs my fans have written if the subject at all interests me. That may get tougher the longer I'm on here but I do believe its important to not only create relationships with those who've taken the time to read and comment and especially to become fans. Eventually if a newbie likes my work, it takes little effort to help someone else improve or show returned support and encouragement.
I haven't ever put a thumbs down - I'll leave decreasing scores to outsiders who aren't part of our community and who don't understand that a lowered score guarantees less traffic. And, as I cruise around and read, I'll leave comments for the ones that inspire me or that I feel someone has done a great job on. Only a couple times have I made a comment on 2-3 paragraphs written that added no value to anyone as far as I could tell.
Great topic - I've written a few explicitly to invite comments on a subject I'd like to discuss and...next to none but plenty of readership (?)
I like that idea--to bring up something I saw in a thread a while back-- If you don't like one of my hubs for wahtever reason--think the writing was bad, title didn't work, whatever--I'd rather you leave me a snarky comment than a thumbs down. I'd prefer to know the reason you disliked it so much. Believe me I will appreciate and possibly reciprocate any sarcasm and take any suggestion anyone has to offer. So, repeating what so many others have said--even bad comments are good. And thumbs up are great but comments can be very helpful in improving hubs and writing technique.
Very true Janetta - I agree. All constructive criticism or comments with a differing opinion are better than simply voting "yuck - I don't like it" which is what a thumbs down seems to mean. Could be someone doesn't like it simply because they don't agree with your opinion, or even if they think your hub sucks - why not have the courage and consideration to state why and help the person write a better one next time.
Only feedback will let a person know why or that they'd prefer to have Hubpages enhanced for us all in a different way. As authors, I'm sure we can form 'polite' words to persuade better content or care and improve this venue for all concerned rather than just copping out with a thumbs down.
Personally, I think that HubPages should just get rid of the thumbs-down. Frequently, it is used because the reader does not agree with the writer's view, and has nothing to do with quality of content. Sometimes, people also use it in retaliation to some disagreement in the Forums.
At the very least, only allow thumbs-down after the reader has left a comment.
Quality of content, length of content, too many comments already, or time restraints. Good question!
I always leave a comment when I like the hub, and I don't care if it has been said already - it wasn't me. But I don't leave one just for the sake of
I wonder too. I am ashamed that I sometimes fail to leave a word of encouragement or praise because I don't think I have time to write something worthy. I promise to change my ways from this day forward. Thanks for the elbow in my ribs.
Sometimes my fingers get tired of rubbing the keys, but normally I always comment.
There are quite a few possible reasons, power failure for example!
Good point BC. I think comments are like the acknowledgements we give when we can see each other- like catching someone's eye in agreement, a smile. Sometimes though I just don't know what to say. But when I do comment I like to say whatever strikes me first about the hub or the writer and as much as possible I try to be truthful not just comment for the sake of it.
But hey, the comments are just as entertaining if not more than the hub itself. And I've fanned people because of great, witty, sweet or insightful comments for example. So I'm with you BC - keep those comments coming!
That all depends. Sometimes I am in a rush, and just don't have time, other times, I don't really know what to say. Sometimes, it's just a matter of needing some time to think before I leave a comment.
And also sometimes their are so much comments so i just move from that page.
I only leave comments when I have something worthwhile to say. If I enjoyed the hub I always, hit the ranking button up, so the writer gets a boost, even if I didn' leave a comment.
Gosh..Nellie..never did know about the ranking button.Just checked it out.Thanks for the useful info!
Yeah, ditto the above. Also, if I don't like a hub, I rarely leave a comment unless the writer somehow invited criticism of their work (some people do directly ask).
Fewer than 1% of readers comment on my hubs.
If I do not know what to say sometimes I just do not comment.
Even a one word comment like "Interesting"....or "huh?" is appreciated. Helps guide us along the path of what our readers are thinking.
Well said! Half my job is to lay down a foundation and frame the house. You tell me what you like about my design, and then I'm able to bend and mold it around what you like. Together we furnish the house.
I always try to comment. It makes me giddy when others do, so...I want them to know that I'm not just enjoying what they've done, I want them to keep doing.
I always try to leave comments. I don't always do it, but I try to.
okay, you guys are making me feel guilty. I'll try to leave comments more often.
I always enjoy the simplicity of the subject. Posting a reply could be as simple as, great subject or to much to think about.I always enjoy reading the comments that are posted. Thanks for reminding me to post.
I always try and leave a comment as I guess the writer spent time writing it and it only takes me a minute to leave a comment. Thing is we rely on hubpages and if hub is to grow then newbies need a comment. That is why the lovely AEvans is so popular, she takes that time and I think we should all perhaps make an effort to comment. Hubpages can be the biggest community on the net because the people are here, just try and leave a lil comment. Not trying to tell you what to do or be some smartass but i just think it wud enhance the site, people like writing but they also like a response. Look at the top writers like Chris A, that guy takes time for everyone, as does AE so you work it out !
I thank badcompany99 for asking such a great question.
Nah that guy's a smartass...and a bad writer to boot...don't any of you go and read his stuff *wink*
A true gentleman he is even thanks his Cabin girl in so many ways.
RBlue is so right, I really am such a shallow twat and my writing is bad, but hey my old gran once said honesty is the best policy so if you admit yer writing is crap then who knows crap may become the in thing. But isnt Jordan crap, isnt Beckham crap, isnt half the shit on the Movies crap, yeah it is. so why worry about yer writing you dick !
was just thinking they might enjoying a hub on Intercourse BC...and was trying reveersed sycology on them ...did it work?
hhahaha oh and fantastic sense of humor too I see
Comments ,I usually leave one ,if I dont its because I get caught up reading others that I surf off on out and forget too.
I will improve this cause yes I love it when others comment on mine
Why I thank you, nice eyes you have there btw, very nice indeedy !
You all see why I can't turn my back for a minute here...this Casanova BC is trying to edge his way in with all the women.
Yup. And the one is Lindsay Lohan. No, really. She was trained by Sean Connery...oh wait, that was a spoof on Robot Chicken.
Yeah ands shes a Lesbian, what a waste !
I don't think so. She's dating a guy again, so I hear from the chatter of the teen girls that come into my work.
So, hey, if you can find and kill'em...you've a chance with a strung out crazed red head early twenty something (if even that?) that is just another ear of corn produced by the Mickey Mouse Club.
Only One sounds so.....uhhhhh.....limiting......sure you won't reconsider????
R. Blue - I think you should let the wimmin on here decide ...
Time for a poll methinks.
Come on boys, step up. And show us what you've got
wait Im still on the lesbian bit!
oh well whatever rocks ya boat I spose
oooaaa nice eyes ( bats her eyelids)
we can even trade mascara tips huh lol
Badcompany99: Many of us enjoy your writing and we do not need testosterone running rampant. Keep on writing.
R.Blue you are naughty and need to behave.
Comments are always great to get and much appreciated. 9 times out of ten I try to leave a comment. Sometimes it's just a word or two, sometimes it's a paragraph, depends how I feel about the hub. The only time I don't comment is if the hub was just not that great/I didn't like it. I'd rather say something nice or nothing at all. Thankfully those hubs are few and far between as we have so many talented writers around here
I may "vote" up or down, but I don't always leave comments if I don't feel I have something to add. Some Hubs naturally "inspire" some comment, one way or another. Others are fine Hubs but may be about something on which I, personally, don't have much to offer. Some are strikingly well done, and I always try to find a way to "good Hub" (in words other than "good Hub"). Sometimes there may be something that I think is "debatable", and I may add a comment that make get a little debate going. I don't vote "down" very often, but if I do I don't usually leave a comment (which may not be great, because maybe it's better to give the author some honest feedback - but if I just think a Hub is a poorly prepared one, I think a thumbs down ought to do it, and am in not a fan of "insulting" people who may have tried to create a good one). With the well done Hubs I do lean toward trying to think up a comment, even I wasn't "naturally inspired". Usually, there is something that strikes me about any Hub that has some substance to it. If I see something in this thread that makes me aware I'm using a bad approach I'll change.
refer to Generique medias analogy of building a house.....what you mean you don't want the toilet in the middle of the kitchen...wish you had told me.
I wrote a hub about this topic. It's called "Comments are Welcomed." It gives you a perspective about what comments mean to writers like myself.
Thank you for allowing me to shamelessly post my hub's name.
Hmmm, thanks badcompany99 for making me feel bad
Over the last few weeks I have been reading many hubs but never added any comments. Thanks for highlighting this vital aspect of hub community which I have so far been ignoring. Also the replies to your question has also brought to my attention the thumbs up/down vote system which I somehow missed as well.
In future, I will be more conscious of adding comments to hubs I like.
Its not making anyone feel bad, I am new here but I love the place but it has the ability to become so much bigger if we take time out to leave a comment, people post on here, no reply then just go. Think of the great community on here trebled, be nice, doncha think ?
Lisa I so agree with you but a newbie just joining would like a comment even if its telling them what they did wrong. I have only been on here a month but I have noticed loads of newbies leaving. Ok some may so what well we need newbies, some really great members have joined in the last month or so but without comments newbies will bugger off. Long term members may not care but they will long term if the hub membership drops. Lisa even a negative comment means a lot, it shows the hubber didnt write just to be ignored.
Ok, now everyone who has read without commenting, lets all go back to every previously read hub and leave a nice comment for the writer. Come now, everyone, let's go! Surely we won't overload the hubtivity...lol
BC and I welcome the overload...speaking for BC...both of him
I love a cynic and obviously you didnt read a word I said !
Geezz...I feel bad now too,lol ...I will leave a thumbs up behind especially when everybody else has left comments that reflect what I think too. Sorry to BC99 and Hubbers.
Comments rock and silence - sucks. Personally, I say something, because I dunno, I think feedback is great, in all its forms. I also rate hubs I enjoyed reading.
I even got my first shitty comment today. I still welcomed it, simply because he took the time to write it. Maybe wasting time telling me I was shit made him miss something else far more important.
I like that idea
I am only a itsy bitsy tiny part of the world of HP as we all are but our working together does make us partners still, the problem I have found is that I am not aware there are *newbies* other than when they ask for critiques then we all run over n leave our comments and suggestions and fanship we really need some sort of something for newbie announcements, lol ... O..n you and we reap what you and we, sow that's a lot of comments I got go do
I read hubs a lot but most times just don't find it necessary to comment.
I get frustrated when my comments get flooded out or ignored, so I'm less inclined to comment on a hub if I know I'm not going to get a response. And yes, badco, you're guilty!
I'm trying hard lately to read and comment more though!
*POKE* Consider this a notice of being noticed.
Yes I am also guilty my friend, but I will make more of an effort !
It isn't a huge thing. It's the "knowing you're going to get flooded." I've done it too, and I don't always reply to comments when I don't understand them or when I can't add anything of value (a lot recently!).
G|M, heading over to your hubs now... Finally! I got to writing yesterday (go figure!).
I've had times when I've been "guilty" of not responding to comments, but the only reason I do that is because I think the person has said something that, sometimes, deserves to be the "last word". I don't want always look like I have to be having that last word; and sometimes I'm torn between the basic, "thank you" and just letting their comment be that "last word" (at least at is relates to their communicating with me, and not necessarily on the whole Hub and comments). In other words, sometimes I think I'm being particularly respectful NOT to throw in my addition "two cents" (particularly if I'm been throwing in those pennies through a lot of earlier commenting).
See!!! BadCo is a Bad Bad Bad man and owes Everyday Miracles an apology. Bad Bad Bad Man
Kari did a brilliant hub on this recently:
"Why I Don't Always Comment, Even When I Loved Your Hub"
http://hubpages.com/hub/Why-I-Dont-Alwa … d-Your-Hub
I comment when I have something worthwhile to add to the hub, but occasionally time is short, especially on long hubs or when there are lots of comments to read before commenting. Often I'll give a Thumbs Up anyway; however, the writer of the hub doesn't know it. I don't like just saying "good hub" without any further comment because it almost looks like spam. It would be nice, I think, to have something like the Thumbs Up so the writer could see that the reader liked the hub even though there was no comment offered.
After reading through all of this, I feel bad for not always leaving a comment. I promise, from this point on, to always leave a comment on every hub I read. Good or bad, I will leave a comment.
I make sure to leave a comment for every Hub I read. I sometimes also follow the comment I make to see if the author has posted a reply comment and if need be I reply back.
I do the same packer till sleep draws me away....any of you think I may be addicted???
I don't even return comment on my own hubs! I think once you've established a true relationship and respect with many writers you don't have to leave a comment, a thumbs up will do if you feel especially strong about it, but typically the best writers are confident and don't feel hurt about missing comments from fellow veteran hubbers(at least I hope they are!)
Interesting perspective Goldentoad. If not about building relationships, or connecting with those who enjoy your work and what you have to say, I'd love to know why you write.
If I really enjoyed reading the hub, I will definitely leave a comment. However, if I didn't enjoy what I was reading, I just don't bother.
I try to leave some kind of comment, even just out of respect for the writer. However, yesterday, I read three hubs and did not have time to leave a comment. If I really did not like the hub, I will not leave any comment. Not liking a hub maybe just my personal opinion and I would not want someone not writing just because I did not like it. I would rather not leave a comment and have the writer continue writing. However, I have only read one hub that I did not like... I generally think all hubbers try really hard and come up with some great ideas and/or information. Thank you to all you wonderful hubbers.
Some really good replies in there, cheers for posting a reply.
I *want* CC on my poetry and fiction.
And if you're intending to leave some, maybe try reading my hub about CC before doing it, just because like any artist, I *can* be sensitive!
I always try to think of a comment, but when I cant "Nice Hub" seems too cliche. I feel guilty not leaving one. Perhaps if I am brain dead at the time I will just leave a
I always leave a comment. In a way, it is like raising a leg and leaving a social marker behind I think it benefits everyone, even the grass.
I can identify with a lot of the comments made here.
Yes, I do love to have comments from others on my own hubs-- and I do try to "do unto others" frequently whenever I can.
I especially like to leave n encouraging comment for a new contributor who hasn't had much feedback.
Sometimes it is a matter of time.
Sometimes I can only think of the dreaded "good hub".
Sometimes it is a matter of there already being a lot of comments which expressed my thoughts so much better than I ever could.
Sometimes, the hub is so good (and already has a lot of positive comments) that I feel the writing, the quality, the thinking, the organization and the execution has gone totally over my head.
I do try to remember the 'up' button.
(I will try to do better, too.)
I think what makes HP such a lively and interactive place is the comments facility. I do try to leave a comment on every hub I read, even if it is sometimes quite embarrassingly inane...the comment, not the hub!
FP, I especially love reading your insane comments. Muhahahaha
Same here. I have 2-3 hubs that account for most of my comments
No way! As far as cats go, you are extremely non-inane
I try to comment as often as I can, but sometimes I am just at a loss for words. I like to write something witty and unique, but if my mind is blank, I can't do that. I hate just writing, "nice hub" since it is so impersonal to the hub content. I am trying to comment more, though!
Comments by Janet21 coming soon to a Hub near you! LOL!
My only source of any views has been majorly hubpages. Whenver i posted a hub many view but never comment on it. I have noticed that the older hubbers recieve comments instantly the moment they post it. They sure have a strong fan base and have been wonderful writers. Things will change in course of time, i wish they left a line as like badco says it does take time to write and assemble a complete hub. Thanx badco for raising this issue, a very common problem shared by many of us.
I think that reply just about covers how a newbie can land on hubpages then leave just as quickly. Personally I try to read newbies that write something I share an interest in and comment. The comment only takes me a minute but means loads to them.
Thats the difference if there was no support system there would not be a community and we would not be sticking around. I will surely keep the good people in mind who helped me in the thick times of making the first days here memorable.
p.s:You rock in the profile pic, lol it does not change a thing about the pirate image you adorn lol. Would never have another captain in hubpages ever other than you.
I myself love testosterone running rampant, and i love naughty comments ; )
The only people who leave comments on my hubs are ones leaving links to their hubs.
I must not be a good writer.
I try to leave a comment every time I read a hub. I think we can all use feedback on our writing. This may be tough during this challenge period but I will comment as much as I can.
by damian00003 years ago
I don't seem to be able to leave comments on anybody's hubs this evening...Is anybody else having the same problem?
by HubPages4 years ago
Earlier this week we announced that it would soon be possible to leave comments on Answers. Great news- the feature is now live!We hope you like it
by marisuewrites8 years ago
suddenly, I can't leave any comments. I 've erased cookies on my computer, but no matter what hub i'm on...I can't leave a comment? suggestions?
by dellea3 months ago
PROBLEM: Whenever I write a hub on a controversial subject, a number of people create new, fake hub accounts solely for the purpose of posting negative comments and feedback on my hubs and/or threatening me anonymously....
by lyricsingray7 years ago
How do you do it? I am now averaging 100 Hub published notices a day. I want to leave comments as Hubbers do for me.Picking a certain amount or choosing a few per day is not a solution for me. Most of...
by Wendy Iturrizaga9 years ago
Is it ok to put links to your hubs when you leave a comment on someone else's? I've notice that some people made comments on my pages and along with the comment they left a link to their own page.
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.