I just published a hub about the Amityville Horror. I was forced to categorize it under "Halloween" because it is a "haunting" story. I would like to see a category for haunted houses somewhere *else* so that the content is recognized as ever green and categorized as such. Thanks!
I second that, EM. I just did a hub about an indie film company that made a cult-fave horror flick, and had to put it in "Entertainment - Movies" when a main category "Horror" or "Hauntings" would be much more appropriate.
Looking at the Categories list as a whole, many of the sub-categories would be better as the lead/main.
Maybe a "paranormal" or category with hauntings, spirits, ufos dreams, visions?
Yes, Rochelle. Paranormal and everything under it.
I wound up putting it in crime since it was mainly about Ronnie Defeo anyway.
So will the right people see this? the "Team" who can do something to add it?
I imagine they will, though Paul made an announcement after I posted this lol
There is already a paranormal category under Religion & Beliefs, with subcategories for ghosts, UFOs, etcetera. In the future, please use the search functionality if you are having difficulty finding what you are looking for.
I beg to differ, Fawntia, but Paranormal as a sub-cat under "Religion & Beliefs" is quite a stretch. Just my two cents.
FYI, I do use the search functionality.
So do I, and so did I when looking to place the hub. That's the only way I can find what I'm going for with so many categories. I was deposited right into "Halloween" because I'm not dealing with ghosts, but a reported haunting.
I also agree with JamaGenee that Religion and Beliefs really isn't the right place for it. It wound up in the right place (crime) but regardless, I think this issue should be revisited by the staff.
Wow - The Amytiville Horror takes me back! Certainly nothing whatsoever to do with religion as it is full of more holes than a tennis net but it was a great film.
I will be honest in that I haven't seen the Hub yet (though will check in a minute) but isn't there a section for films (movies) on HP?
When I published my hub Living in haunted house, http://hubpages.com/_4s51btzfmykm/hub/L … nted-Homes I didn't know what kind of topic to mark it under?! Maybe just an ordinary hubber topic?
EXACTLY MY POINT!
I'm sorry for the caps but I feel as though people are missing the point I'm trying to make.
The hub wasn't about the movie -- not at all. It was about the history of the house, the Defeo murders and the Lutz "conspiracy" if you will. But the house is "known" as a haunted house, not known for the crimes that took place there. I wound up putting it in crime, but it's going to look out of place there.
The story has NOTHING to do with ghosts so Fawntia's suggestion doesn't hold water. I wanted to put the hub in a category where it would be useful and recognized, but that was impossible for me to do, since the necessary category (hauntings/haunted houses) doesn't exist.
And once again, I need to state clearly that I *did* a search for Haunted Houses, because that's where the hub belonged!
I apologize if I have upset anyone. When I suggested that "you" should use the search function, I didn't mean anyone in particular. Many people were suggesting that we create a paranormal category, which already exists. So I came to the conclusion that no one had searched for "paranormal" or "ghosts" since no one seemed aware of the existence of those categories (which are easily found via search).
Whether or not paranormal belongs under Religion & Beliefs is a separate issue. Ghosts, UFOs, and all of those things are not established facts, but things that some people believe in and some people do not. So it seems perfectly reasonable to me for those things to be under Religion & Beliefs. But if anyone disagrees, please feel free to explain your reasons why.
As for Everyday Miracles' hub in particular, the issue seems to be that her hub does not fit perfectly into an existing category. That is bound to happen sometimes, particularly for hubs that cross the boundaries of multiple disciplines. It sounds like her hub is about the history of crime in a haunted house, so it sort of belongs under "history," sort of under "crime," and sort of under "ghosts." (You can argue the ghosts thing if you want, but every other haunted house story fits well enough under "ghosts" since haunted means, by definition, "inhabited by ghosts.") In cases like these, you really just have to pick the category that fits the best and live with imperfection. If it would solve the problem, then I am open to creating a "haunted house" category, but I would probably just change the name of the existing "ghosts" category so that it specifically mentions haunted houses.
Fawntia, I'm going out on a limb here, but how do you define a house that is (purported to be) infested by demons? I've always defined that as "haunted" but there are no ghosts involved.
At this point I'm satisfied with the hub being under "crime" though I'm not sure it will get the best traffic there (and therefore benefit both HP and me).
In fact, our ghost category is currently called "ghosts and demons" so for the purposes of our categories it doesn't matter if "haunted" also includes demons.
I do see a potential problem here that I think the staff (in general) might need to look at. I have become incredibly bored of digging through categories and sub-categories to find the right one, so of course I'm using the search feature. A search for "haunting" brought up the Haunted Houses in the Halloween sub-category. It was never going to lead me towards ghosts. And I was too exhausted from the writing to think of demons, darnit!
Yes, search definitely has its limitations. For many of our categories, we do not have detailed descriptions of what the categories contain. I spent a couple of days writing descriptions for the main categories and most of the second level categories (which was deadly boring), but for third level categories and beyond, we do not have a lot keywords for search to latch onto. I agree that this is a problem. As we add more descriptions over time, search should improve, but unfortunately we don't have a lot of extra time to do this.
For now, the best I can suggest is that you try searching for many phrases related to the topic you are searching for. So, if "haunted" doesn't work, try "ghosts," "paranormal," or any other related words you can think of that might lead you to the right thing. I often have to do this even when using Google to find what I am looking for.
I realize that this can be annoying and time consuming. We have done our best to make it as easy as we can with the resources that we have, but there is admittedly room for improvement. In general, I wouldn't worry about it too much. A few imperfect hub categorizations are not going to make a difference to your success on HubPages. If you are particularly concerned about traffic to your hubs, I would worry more about writing text and adding tags that are appealing to Google. (The hubs with the most traffic generally get it directly from search engines.)
Okay, I finally get your point, demons are not ghosts of people who previously lived - but come from some other source in the universe.
I don't have a problem with haunting as a category to put it in. To me being haunted, just means by something other than what we typically see every day. Could be ghosts, could be other stuff.
But I do appreciate you angst.
Okay, so I do then have a question: If I had left the hub in the Halloween category, would the search engines have treated it as a seasonal hub?
I wound up doing what you suggested, which is how I got to "crime." I think that's the best place for it, anyway, and I hope to improve the hub in the future. I just, darnit, have to get my hands on some books for research since the internet isn't offering me much on the Defeo case.
It's true, who knows how Google and other SEs really work? LOL
by Katherine Tyrrell2 years ago
I've noticed that there are some missing categories on HubPages. I'm hoping this is something that can be addressed so as to enable hubs which have transferred to cluster in a more appropriate wayCan I suggest we try...
by logic,commonsense6 years ago
Watching HGTV's first time homebuyer, there was a dude on there that had to have the house he was planning on buying, exorcised of spirits before he'd finalize the contract. He was a teacher and a coach! You...
by Katherine Tyrrell2 years ago
Is it possible to run this as a thread for suggestions for categories missing from the existing category listFor example - any chance of an "Art Business & Marketing" category under Arts and Design?
by Tessa Schlesinger7 months ago
I often battle with which categories to put hubs in. Sometimes a category just doesn't exist.What category would you put this hub in?http://hubpages.com/politics/Estonia-Fr … enty-years
by Paul Deeds8 years ago
We made an update to the site a few minutes ago. The big changes with this release are the addition the hub categorization tool, and some enhancements to the main search box as well as request and forum...
by momster4 years ago
I was asking a question about winter. What category would you put that under? Maybe there could be a Seasons Category or maybe Misc. Category for questions that are not specified under the other categories.
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.