jump to last post 1-23 of 23 discussions (42 posts)

Check your earnings vs. the other Pay To Write sites

  1. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    I'd appreciate the feedback from anyone who has written on other Pay To Write sites on this statistical survey I've just published:

    <snippy snippy- for shame!>

    It was not possible to be totally accurate on a couple of the figures, such as the total number of articles published on triond.com and methodshop.com, so I'd appreciate any input to help achieve greater accuracy. I found it rather surprising that on about half the sites, the average monthly payment is less than one penny for every 33 words written! That's chain gang writing wages! smile

    Ok, anyone who wishes to smack me across my little kitten face for a shameless Hub plug may now feel free to do so. smile

  2. Misha profile image75
    Mishaposted 7 years ago

    BTW, I came to your hub before this terrible violation of rules by you tongue

    1. soni2006 profile image48
      soni2006posted 7 years ago in reply to this

      yes I agree:cool:

  3. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    Ouch, Misha. That was a very hard slap! Don't you ever show any kindness and consideration to poor, helpless kittens? smile

    Ya... I know... my 5th forum post and already I'm tearing up the rulebook. What can I tell ya. It might sound hollow to tell you that I haven't done this before for any of my thousand Hubs, but I really wanted to get input from Hubbers who have written elsewhere so I won't say that.

    Oops... I just did. smile

    1. Anti-Valentine profile image94
      Anti-Valentineposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      His name is Hal Licino.

      Commendations during his career:

      on Hubpages for 2 years,
      996 hubs,
      495 fans...

      and 5 posts in the forums.


  4. Lisa HW profile image83
    Lisa HWposted 7 years ago

    In fairness to some of those other sites, though, there is the point that a person can let, say, 500 articles sit from month to month, without writing anything new; and pick up, say, a minimum of $1 or so a day (more if the material is in a higher earning category).  On a per-word basis, of course, the pay is still awful (because those 500 articles had to be written).  On Helium, however, they can be re-published from the writer's other sites if the writer wants (which means not coming up with the words specifically for Helium).  That aside, a collection of x amount of articles (ideally in high-paying channels) can earn a person anything from as low as $40 a month on up.  Some people are getting a few hundred dollars every month for articles that are sitting there.

    Helium now pays an upfront payment for any article.  A five-star writer can collect 2.50 for that.  There are a few other little bonuses, and there's also the chance articles will be purchased as "stock purchases".  Associated Content pays the upfront and the revenue share, and offers assignments to people accepted as "custom content producers".  The per-word or per-hour rate is, no doubt, dismally low; but people can pick up a few hundred dollars if they have the time/inclination/need.

    Having said all that, the right article (searchable, useful, popular) on here can earn several, several, times all of the above.  For those articles that aren't "just the right kind" it's not as promising.

    Just yesterday I ran into Text Broker, so I thought I'd sign up.  That one lets people select "orders" for articles, write, and be paid.  I was shocked to see that the per-article pay is around 3.50 (at least until a person proves himself, in which case the rate goes well up).  That's kind of a worst-case situation, though, because they're super-low-paying "assignments", and the writer would be pounding out 500 unique words for his $3, $8 or even $25.  I do think there's something to be said for putting in the initial time, letting the stuff sit, and picking up a few hundred dollars for no work each month.  Then you have the time to do other things, after making that initial time investment.  $50 from one site, and a few hundred from another one or two, and even the occasional extra $10, all add up.  Having said all that, I reiterate what I said on your Hub, Hal, that HubPages does seem, to me, to offer the best earning potential.

    1. karpouzian profile image61
      karpouzianposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      This needs to be a Hub.

  5. Misha profile image75
    Mishaposted 7 years ago

    LOL Hal, I think the jury will consider your contribution to the site and might even let you free wink

  6. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    Lisa HW: In some of my Hubs such as:

    <snipped - oh, Hal, how could you? wink >

    I outline how I don't really make much of anything off of anything in the online ad universe, with the possible exception of AdSense, and even then, I have yet to reach a $200 month. Fortunately I don't rely on ad income on my Hubs, and I'm very grateful for that. However, you're completely correct on the staying power of articles, whether on Helium or HubPages. Some Hubs that I wrote 2 years ago are still scoring more than 100 page views each and every single day, day in and day out. So it's kind of an annuity! smile

    $2.50 upfront for an article (given that it's 500 words) is still half a cent a word, and that's still mighty low. So is TextBroker's starting wage of 0.7 cents per word. You have to type your fingers to the bone at those rates to not even match burger-slinging wages.

    All told, and all analyzed, I concur that HubPages seems to be the best deal on the Net! smile

    Misha: I think that if the jury truly looks into my writing, especially some of the more controversial Hubs, they'll execute me at dawn! smile

  7. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago


    I've been snipped!

    This was nothing short of a HubVasectomy against my will! And no anaesthetic!


    I'm gonna take this to Madam Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg! She stood up for what was right in halting the Chrysler Communist Deal and she will stand up for me as well!

    I demand an HubEpididymovasostomy!


  8. bgpappa profile image82
    bgpappaposted 7 years ago

    Helium requires 400 words per article, not that it makes the per word ratio any better.

    Helium is better for short term payments.  Upfront payments, kill fees, empty title bonuses.

    But Hubpages is better for long term revenue as well as producing a better product.  Use of pictures, videos, links, etc makes for better overall product.

    1. lisafwg01 profile image60
      lisafwg01posted 7 years ago in reply to this

      A word of caution for anyone thinking about using Helium: Once you put up an article on Helium you lose ALL control of it. You cannot edit it yourself, you cannot delete it and even if you leave Helium you cannot remove your work from their site!

      1. Lisa HW profile image83
        Lisa HWposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        Another word of caution:  Once you have - like - 500 articles up, thinking you don't care about doing anything else with them and are only using them as a source of passive income; surprise, surprise.  The rules change, and you have to keep going back to keep a minimum number of rating stars in order to have all those articles keep earning.  In other words, there's no just forgetting the articles and letting them do whatever they do.  In other words, it isn't really "passive" income.  (The thing about not being able to delete anything is not something to take lightly either.)

        1. Anti-Valentine profile image94
          Anti-Valentineposted 7 years ago in reply to this

          I've heard of a lot of these before. So, basically, shall we say Helium sucks? All in favour?

          1. Marisa Wright profile image93
            Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago in reply to this

            Yes, I wrote a Hub about it, but I'm not game to post a link here!

          2. lrohner profile image84
            lrohnerposted 7 years ago in reply to this

            I second that! I left Helium a long time ago, and then hired one of their editors, and I can tell you quite honestly the only way you're going to be successful there is if a 3rd party hires you.

            I have no idea why anyone would write (if I read this correctly) a 400 word article for $2.50 when there are higher paying sites out there that pay upfront, and via PayPal, and weekly.

            You have to pretty much give blood to be approved, but they are worthwhile.

  9. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    Anti-Valentine, my good friend Misha has been pushing me to get onto the Forums and as soon as I took the plunge I had to violate the sacred entrails.... wouldn't ya know it? smile OK, so I'm antisocial... the rumors that I'm a hermit are completely true. And I'm crabby too! Maybe I should change my avatar from a cat to a hermit crab. smile

    bgpappa, yes, I can see by checking out Helium that they have reasonable short term payments, but the bottom line is still that it's just not worth it for anyone who has to confront the cost of living in a developed nation to be able to write on Helium. If a writer happens to live in a Third World country where $10 a day is a good wage, then by all means go for it. Unfortunately $10 won't even buy me a pizza here. sad

    1. Anti-Valentine profile image94
      Anti-Valentineposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I'm also antisocial or asocial. Check the name: Anti-Valentine.

      I like these forums more than others though.

    2. Maddie Ruud profile image81
      Maddie Ruudposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Violate the sacred entrails?  Yipes!  I didn't know you were into sexual assault/beastiality/necrophilia, Hal.  That's a wicked combination.

  10. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    Anti-Valentine, welcome to the antisocial group. Maybe we should establish the HubHermits group! We could have meetings and never attend them! smile

    Maddie Ruud, some may call me a Mithraic Pontiff, some may just call me a filthy pervert, but when you're as old and fat and ugly as I am, you gotta get it wherever you can. smile

    lisafwg01, hmm... I wasn't aware that you couldn't delete your own work from Helium. That seems awfully Draconian. Just another reason to stay away.

    1. Maddie Ruud profile image81
      Maddie Ruudposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I hear you get brain damage from inhaling too much of that stuff.  Jus' sayin'...

      1. curiozities profile image61
        curiozitiesposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        (inhales some helium and responds in a munchkin-like voice) Hey, that's not true, I have no dain brammage at all!

    2. Anti-Valentine profile image94
      Anti-Valentineposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Excellent suggestion! I'll not agree to not attend right away. Or something like that...

      1. caspar profile image83
        casparposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        Can I be invited to your non-meeting? I'm a bit of a hermit too and I'd love not to come.

  11. Kidgas profile image80
    Kidgasposted 7 years ago

    Thanks for that info about Helium.  I just went over and looked at their site.  I'll stay here for now.

  12. Pete Maida profile image60
    Pete Maidaposted 7 years ago

    I may get slapped for this but I write here because I enjoy it but I believe performance payment works better.  At least you can see a clear road to where you can make a buck or two without writing commercials for some product or vacation spot.

  13. Lissie profile image87
    Lissieposted 7 years ago

    Textbrokers is not the same as the other sites Hal mentioned -its purely a writer for hire service - the articles are for buyers who use them as their own - there are no residues. Its more akin to constant content <snip one, I gotta snip 'em all> which pays a lot better but is probably harder to break into for regular work.

    Worth noting that textbrokers and associated (at least) only allow US authors too

  14. Lisa HW profile image83
    Lisa HWposted 7 years ago

    Thanks for pointing that out to others who may not already know that, Lissie.  I should have been clearer.  The only reason I included them in with the others was within the context of writers weighing the different, most common, payment set-ups for their work and comparing.   Maybe I should have included that, but, to me, a lot of the sites have different "payment set-ups" anyway.  Members of some are paid by the site, itself, rather than Google (as on HubPages).   A lot of them have their differences between them.  I just threw in Text Broker as yet another one.

  15. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    Maddie Ruud: Whenever I've inhaled Helium it doesn't do anything because I already talk like a duck.

    Pete Maida: Believe me, no one will slap you for enjoying HubPages, as that is by far its greatest attribute! HubPages is FUN! smile

    Lissie: Yes, I've checked out textbrokers and it is a write for hire service, which translates into there being a much smaller throughput of articles, regardless of what they print. You can also add demandstudios to textbrokers and associated in the list of sites that will not deal with writers outside the USA.

    curiozities: I didn't need Helium to get brain damage. I was born like this. As a matter of fact, when I was born, the doctor took one look at me and slapped my mother. smile

    Lisa HW: The more I learn about Helium from you and other writers, the more I get the feeling that it is one heckuva crummy site for anyone to work on. Why would anyone want to subject themselves to that level of arbitrary restriction when they can come over here and have a great time? smile

  16. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    Anti-Valentine, by the power vested in me by me, I hereby name you Vice-President of the Official HubHermits Group, dedicated to upholding the rights and privileges of the elite membership of HubHermits to live in solitude; go for entire weeks without speaking to anyone; peek out of our darkened windows to deride the groups of people walking by; and in every possible manner truly embodying our motto "LEAVE US THE #$%& ALONE!" smile

    1. Anti-Valentine profile image94
      Anti-Valentineposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I'm honoured, and I will certainly enjoy the bit about deriding people. I do it all the time.

  17. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    Anti-Valentine, the honor is all mine, and I look forward to not joining you as we engage in public derision sessions.

    And yes, from all the information I've been able to gather to date, the conclusion has to be that Helium sucks.


    caspar, consider yourself invited to our non-meetings and I'm sure I speak for the entire membership in stating that we look forward to not seeing you there. smile

  18. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    I would also like to formally announce, consistent with the prevailing policy of non-doing, that I have just published a Hub dealing with my anniversary of 1,000 Hubs but I cannot state that on this forum as it would run counter to the policy of non-statement. Therefore, disregard any mention of said Hub. smile

  19. Misha profile image75
    Mishaposted 7 years ago

    Wow! 1000 hubs! I can only recall boppster with similar quantities, but quality was a bit different big_smile

  20. Hal Licino profile image65
    Hal Licinoposted 7 years ago

    Misha: Hey... wot are u sayin'? boppster's better than me, huh? That does it! Tell him/her/it that I challenge him/her/it to a duel! USB keyboards at 30 paces. I will avenge my honor! smile

    Marisa Wright: In adherence to forum standards, I'd like to thank you for your non-announcement of your non-Hub. I assure you I will not go check it out and then I promise I will immediately erase what I didn't read anyway from my memory. smile

  21. 0
    Ghost32posted 7 years ago

    Hal, I've never seen anybody give so much blood and then get right up off the donation table and walk without so much as a cookie or a glass of orange juice.  You are one durable dude.

    Must come with the Hermit lifestyle.

    I'd ask to join the antisocial Hermitage group but it would feel too much like I might have to get along with somebody.  Don't think I could handle that.

    One of the things (among many) I deeply appreciate about HP is the ability to come and go at will without losing my manhood.  From April of 2008 to early May of 2009 I was hardly ever here, yet my Hubs kept earning their pennies and when I came back active nobody even noticed I'd been gone.

    Ezine Articles,  on the other hand, deleted my (admittedly lone) article and stole back my Expert Author logo during the same interim.  So, Ezine, this (blows raspberry) is for you!

  22. Pete Maida profile image60
    Pete Maidaposted 7 years ago

    It is simple I make money other places; I don't make money here.  I enjoy HubPages for the people here but I don't expect to make any money here.  I will admit up front that the main  problem is level of effort on my part.

  23. Eaglekiwi profile image73
    Eaglekiwiposted 7 years ago

    You guys are so funny lol humour appreciated ,but hugely distracting ,lol...
    My middle name must be procrastination ,and I am  kinda hoping to learn of other writing sites too.

    No-one mentioned Squidoo, are they similar to HB? in terms of revenue etc

    1. Marisa Wright profile image93
      Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Squidoo works in a similar way to HubPages. Most people I know seem to do better here than Squidoo, but then most people I know are Hubbers smile

      HubPages is my only writing site now. People have told me I shouldn't put all my eggs in one basket - but the thing is, if you spread your writing over multiple sites, then it takes longer to get to payout from each one. 

      Check out Hal's Hub on revenue-sharing sites and you'll see that you're probably in the best place right here.  Instead of joining more writing sites, why not try selling your articles on Constant Content or some of the freelance sites?

      1. relache profile image87
        relacheposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        My accounts beg to differ with you.  Having multiple sites where I've got AdSense, Amazon and eBay makes me hit those thresholds a lot easier than with just one site.

        1. Marisa Wright profile image93
          Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago in reply to this

          Sorry Relache, didn't express myself well. I was referring to sites which have different revenue sources - so for instance if you have Adsense, Amazon and eBay on HubPages but then sign up for another site which pays you a share of their earnings through Paypal, and another site which pays through CJ.

          I agree that if you select sites that all use the same advertisers, it's not a problem.

      2. Eaglekiwi profile image73
        Eaglekiwiposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        Ok thanks ,I will check them out sometime.