jump to last post 1-7 of 7 discussions (16 posts)

copyright infringement icon on my Account & individual hubs

  1. premsingh profile image60
    premsinghposted 7 years ago

    If any content of the hub is being copied by someone and used elsewhere, its not the fault of hubber. This is nice that HP is motivating hubbers to file DMCA to the concerned site and take appropriate action,who is going to waste time to fight with the copyright violators. HP has witnessed disabling of several top hubbers account as an act of revenge. Please don't highlight copyright violation information on individual hubs and on "My Account Page". HP didn't help hubbers even for reinstating their adsense account by recommending to google that these are good hubbers and they can't be expected for violating policies.  I thinks its sufficient to inform the hubbers once that their content of their hubs has been copied elsewhere. When HP is having all the information and can verify date of publication of a hub on HP and date of publication on other site, why threatening hubbers/obliging them that their hub or hubber score is not being penalized, create a sense of unnecessary guilt in hubber's mind. In few cases , HP's stand can be justified also. Best example of this may be when hubbers are themselves placing their content on other sites but such cases are negligible.

    1. Marisa Wright profile image91
      Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I've only had to file three DMCA's and they all worked.  Premsingh, have you actually tried filing a DMCA - it only takes a few minutes.

      I read your profile and your Hub about copyright violation and it sounds like you're trying to deal with it by complaining to advertisers.  Why not file a DMCA?

      If it's on a site like HubPages wher members post articles (e.g. Bukisa, Weebly etc) you can file the DMCA with the site owners, and they'll usually remove it.  If that doesn't work and the site uses Adsense, you can report them to Adsense.

  2. relache profile image86
    relacheposted 7 years ago

    I don't think you actually understand how the copyright alert works.

    When you see a copyright icon on your Hub, YOU are not being penalized and neither are your Hubs.

    As far as who fights with copyright violators, I'm one of them and I'm very grateful that HubPages makes it so easy for me to contact people and ask them to not steal my writing and get it taken down from other web sites.

    Hub authors CAN place their content on other sites, it's just that in the long run, that might hurt the standing of your Hubs in the Google rankings.  And they have to be willing to then ignore the little red copyright icons on their dashboard.

    Now if you take work you've had elsewhere FIRST and then copy it to HubPages, you're taking your chances.  Whereas HubPages will merely dock your HubScores, there are a good number of members in this community who are just waiting to attack and vilify people in the forums if they are perceived of as stealing content.

  3. Whitney05 profile image67
    Whitney05posted 7 years ago

    It's not HubPages job to track down people who copy from HubPages. The people who write on this website own their material, so it is the person's responsibility to track down and speak with those other people who stole the content.

    I for one have contacting numerous people. Some get nasty attitudes, others realize their mistake, and some never respond back. I have a nice list that I'll be sending to Google DMCA soon for those who never replied back and those who don't have a contact button or contact info anywhere on the site.

    Forums are a big problem for me. Where people copy my hubs onto other forums... Those are harder to get removed, I've found.

    Anyway... It's not HubPages responsibility. They've done a big favor by alerting us that our content has been stolen. Most placed don't even do that.

    It's also not HubPages fault that some people have had their Adsense accounts closed. They can only do so much, and in my opinion the HP team does a lot more than most websites do.

  4. darkside profile image84
    darksideposted 7 years ago

    premsingh seems to be making two conflicting points in the same post. I don't understand where they're coming from.

    1. relache profile image86
      relacheposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      3 out of 4 Hub users agree....

  5. premsingh profile image60
    premsinghposted 7 years ago

    thanks relache for nice explanation of working of copyright alert. You really deserve appreciation for fighting against violators. I also did it once and still doing but I've to pay heavily once for it. Darkside, hope you understand my position why do my statements seems conflicting (I know it very well that HP is doing to help hubbers protect their content but this is a burden also to part time hubbers like me).
    whitney05, I am not asking HP to take responsibility of guarding the content of hubs. I'm just requesting them to use the copyright alert in a mild way. Message should not create a guilt in the hubber's mind.
    Merisa I agree with you. I also filed DMCA to few sites. One of the sites have three different blogs (with same or different titles)copied from my single hub. It has already removed two and one still live.

    1. darkside profile image84
      darksideposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      It was the wording of your post. It sounds like you're unhappy with HubPages HQ on one hand, but praising them on the other.

      There's no guilt on my part when I see one. If you know what it's about, there shouldn't be a problem. It'll only create more confusion to be too wordy...

      "© Don't take offense to this, someone else has violated your copyright. Or maybe they haven't. Maybe you have posted the information elsewhere. Which is fine. We're not going to get mad at you, we just wanted you to know just in case someone has done the wrong thing and you want to protect your interests. Have a nice day"

      ...and it'd look unprofessional if they threw in a smiley face...

      © smile

    2. Whitney05 profile image67
      Whitney05posted 7 years ago in reply to this

      You just sounded like it was hubpages fault and like you were blaming them. It's just your own responsibility to deal with it.

      The sign is just to let you know that someone may have copied your stuff. Doesn't mean you did anything wrong.

    3. relache profile image86
      relacheposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      What are you talking about?  Why would anyone get "guilty" after getting an alert that someone else took their writing? 

      I don't know what you are trying to say, but to me, it's not coming through in an coherent/understandable manner.

    4. Marisa Wright profile image91
      Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      If the copyright symbol creates guilt in your mind, that's your own doing.  You are choosing to feel guilty about it - HubPages is merely telling you that a duplicate exists.  There is a simple solution to your problem - stop misinterpreting the symbol!

  6. premsingh profile image60
    premsinghposted 7 years ago

    Thanks to all for explaining the essence of copyright sign display on the hubs. Everyone said the copyright sign is just an alert. After noticing this alert I filed DMCA with a site that hosted three blogs identical to my hub. I am sure if these blogs were not copied from my hub, the site would have never removed all three blogs after receiving DMCA notice. However, copyright sign is still displayed on my hub. I know HP will remove it when it verifies it next time (It may take few weeks). My hubber score (I'm not worried about as I can not keep it 100 always for other engagements) has come down to 85 from 94 after appearance of copyright sign or/after starting this thread.

    1. sunforged profile image68
      sunforgedposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      It will jump back up!..as if it matters

      1. premsingh profile image60
        premsinghposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        Thanks sunforged, I came to know from other thread that hubber score of majority of huubers has gone down due to a bug in the new release (program upgrade) of HP.

  7. Bard of Ely profile image87
    Bard of Elyposted 7 years ago

    I get annoyed by people who copy and paste my hubs onto blogs and forums and often I find it impossible to get them removed even if I join the forum and post a complaint in a thread. It annoys me most when my name is left out and no link back to where the text came from and I have had that done. I personally cannot find the time to be chasing people who do this and do not answer my complaints and I have come to accept that it is just an annoying problem we have to put up with!

    I think it is good of Hubpages to let us know when this happens though!

    1. Marisa Wright profile image91
      Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Bard, the solution is not to post a complaint on the thread - hit them with a DMCA notice.  It's usually quite simple - make one up from HubPages' instructions so you just have to fill in the blanks! 

      If the blog is on a blogging platform like Blogger or Wordpress.com, or an article writing site like HubPages or Bukisa, it's really easy because you just send the notice straight to the site, not to the author.  They'll make the author remove the dup content and may even remove the whole blog.

      This article also gives some tips: