I posted a few weeks ago about my highest traffic hub that was ranked #1 in Google for some time for its primary keyword and then suddenly was DROPPED and didn't even show up in the first couple of hundred SERPs in Google. (Yahoo, Bing and the others were unaffected.) According to Analytics, it was dropped on August 6th and just came back sometime today.
The only changes I've made were over the past few days where I reduced the number of tags and brought the keyword density down from 5.38% to 4.46% and voila! It's back to #1 on Google and the traffic stream has started again!
I'm guessing that reducing the keyword density did the trick? Any other input?
Interesting point. I'm curious though, where did you find the keyword density percentages? Google Analytics somewhere?
This is very interesting. I found a site once which recommended quite a low keyword density and I spent some time tweaking a couple of Hubs. Then I did some more reading and discovered not everyone agreed, so then I wasn't sure what to do. Maybe I should revisit.
Oh, and how on Analytics did you work out it had been dropped? I'm useless with that stuff!
I read a while back that keyword density should be no less than 2% but no more than 5% -- tops. But I didn't pay too much attention to it because I thought MSN is the only one who still looks at keyword density as a rating factor -- or is it Yahoo. No matter. Neither bring me much traffic.
I could tell from Analytics just by going to Content, Top Content and selecting this particular hub. It was pretty darn obvious from the graph when it was dropped by Google. It went from approx. 100+ views per day to almost nothing -- and overnight.
Many of the "experts" would suggest keeping keyword density below 2% for Google. But many now also believe it's unimportant - it should just be a natural density for the length of page.
I quote from the seomoz.org blog
Number of Keyword Repetitions - It's impossible to pinpoint the exact, optimal number of times to employ a keyword term/phrase on the page, but this simple rule has served us well for a long time - "2-3X on short pages, 4-6X on longer ones and never more than makes sense in the context of the copy." The added benefit of another instance of a term is so miniscule that it seems unwise to ever be aggressive with this metric.
Keyword Density - A complete myth as an algorithmic component, keyword density nonetheless pervades even very sharp SEO minds. While it's true that more usage of a keyword term/phrase can potentially improve targeting/ranking, there's no doubt that keyword density has never been the formula by which this relevance was measured.
Read the full post on perfectly optimized pages here - it's well worth it!
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/perfecting-k … timization
BigMike, I so totally agree! I don't give much thought to keyword density in the content as I write, but that's because I always assumed it was meaningless in the world of ranking. I forgot about the other side of it, though. At what point is it considered keyword stuffing? I do believe that once I hit 5%+, Google got a little pissed off!
I really think it had nothing to do with it, but if you are convinced you could teach us all something by changing it back and seeing if it disappears again. I personally have never seen it have an impact on a page that was written in legible English.
by Thomas Byers8 years ago
I thought I would start publishing some search engine tips to help everyone to get some extra hits from the search engines.1. Long TailDo you know what the Long Tail is. Its where you use a 3-5 word title for your Hub...
by Ru-an6 years ago
I heard someone say that if possible your hub title should be the exact keyword that you use as your main keyword, if you want to rank high in search engines. But that doesnt allow for a catchy title which will get you...
by Susana S5 years ago
I don't think I'm alone in thinking that the main thing that has dragged hubpages down in this latest algo change is the amount of crappy content posted on here over the years. I understand the reasoning behind the...
by jasoncox836 years ago
Ok this is not for promotional, only as an example of a recently published hub.http://hubpages.com/hub/Is-Space-Travel-Worth-The-CostThat or feel free to visit my hubs pick a random one..Although a few I understand why...
by Nathan Bernardo3 years ago
I guess it seems simple: Too many keywords, too often, in one article. But what if your title is nothing but keywords, yet they are relevant? Is that too dense? I understand that tricksters try to pack irrelevant...
by Syed Hunbbel Meer5 years ago
Hello everyone. I am here seeking for some guidance in SEO and keyword density thing.Can you people please help me by telling some of the most important things that count in SEO, that will eventually lead our hub to be...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.