jump to last post 1-10 of 10 discussions (20 posts)

Hub was flagged and unpublished

  1. jim10 profile image73
    jim10posted 7 years ago

    Hi I had a Hub for over a year about how to make some extra money online with paid surveys. They are all reasonable places I have tried and had success with. All of a sudden today I got an email that it is unpublished because it violated the terms of use. I can't find any reason why it violated. Where can I get help and figure out what I need to delete from it to publish it again.
    The only links I have are to Cash Crate My Survey and InBox Dollars. Does anyone know which one is considered bad. None of them are scams or make you click on ads to get money. It doesn't seem like this breaks the rules to me. I have always had great positive comments from fellow Hubbers on it too. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

    The hub was called my favorite paid survey Sites


    1. 0
      Louidam1posted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Jim this also happen to me yesterday.  Hubpages told me that Google Adsense does not approve GPT (GET PAID TO) websites and can get your account with them banned.  Someone is going around peoples hubs and flagging them.  I had mines up for several months.  I'm so upset!

      1. jim10 profile image73
        jim10posted 7 years ago in reply to this

        Yes I saw your hub and it was great. It is really sad but you are probably right someone is probably going through these and flagging them recently. I bet their's is still up though.
        Hubpages really should allow us to recommend reliable sites that we like and want to talk about. I am pretty disappointed.

        1. 0
          Louidam1posted 7 years ago in reply to this

          I can't believe people can be like that.  We work so hard on our hubs for them to just flag it.  I'm pretty sure they also have GPT hubs but don't want to have competition.

  2. Misha profile image75
    Mishaposted 7 years ago

    Jim, you will have better luck emailing team at hubpages dot com smile

  3. Marisa Wright profile image93
    Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago

    Did you have only one link to each site?  Was it a reasonable length, not just an ad for paid survey sites? If so, beats me - all you can do is email the team and wait for a reply.

  4. pauldeeds profile image
    pauldeedsposted 7 years ago

    According to the Google AdSense Program Policy:

    Sites with Google ads may not include or link to content regarding programs which compensate users for clicking ads or offers, performing searches, surfing websites or reading emails.

    I suspect the hub you are talking about runs afoul of this rule.  All hubs most comply with the AdSense Program Policy.  Unfortunately, both cashcrate and inbox dollars seem to fit the description.

    1. yoshi97 profile image88
      yoshi97posted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I found two of my own hubs that were toeing the line on this one, so I removed out the links (the other content was fine without it, so I kept it). Thanks for making it all a bit more clear.

      Sometimes I think one has to be a lawyer to thoroughly read these policies and make sense of them. smile

      So Paul ... I have this Aunt in Nigeria who just passed away and is looking for a way to move her money to the US ... smile

    2. relache profile image87
      relacheposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Paul, is this sort of info going to be added as one of the "no-nos" to the splash screen that people see when they make a new Hub?

  5. jim10 profile image73
    jim10posted 7 years ago

    Well thanks for your help everyone. I really didn't think that these ones would have counted because that isn't all you can do on them. They are not scams in anyway and I thought adsense mostly didn't like scams and unreliable sites. I see I can take off the Kontera ads I will see if I can get rid of the adsense ads on them and repost it. If not I guess I just won't link to them or will try to find a workaround. It would be awesome if Hubpages could add a list of places you should not link to that would be a lot more helpful.
    Sounds like Google is the king of double standards then. Oh well they practically own the net.

    1. pauldeeds profile image
      pauldeedsposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      When we have identified a place that you can't link we automatically display a warning on your hub, and we won't allow it to be published (if it's a new hub).  However, at any one time we don't have a comprehensive list of places you can't link.  Mostly, we add to the list as we discover them in hubs ourselves or hubs that have been flagged by readers.

      That said, if you are making significant money from Google AdSense (or hope too), it's a really good idea to stay on top of what they allow.

    2. sunforged profile image69
      sunforgedposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Sorry, that happened to you Jim, but removing adsense wont help you, as hubpages still needs your page to be compliant for their uses.

      Sounds like an article that needs to be on your own website

      And those sites kind of are scams...they create payout levels that most users never reach, I couldnt ethically support any of them.

      You actually spend time as a user at those sites and get a check in the mail?

    3. darkside profile image84
      darksideposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Commercial hubs must have Adsense turned on. To be non-commercial they can't have outbound links.

  6. fireatwill41 profile image61
    fireatwill41posted 7 years ago

    I recently published a hub that had to deal with treasure trooper. I removed all outbound links to that site and it still remains unpublished and needing revision. It seems like sites that are pay for anything (surveys, cash offers, etc) are not allowed as hubs. I am thinking about taking my hub, deleting it, and posting the content on my own website but I will never rank for the keywords I am looking for through my own site unfortunately. I am going to delete the hub as I see no other option since the content can't even talk about pay to "insert activity here" site.
    It is unfortunate because I was beginning to rank in the search engines for the keywords I was looking for. Guess I will have to optimize for other keywords.

  7. jim10 profile image73
    jim10posted 7 years ago

    Thanks again,

    Sunforged yes I actually do very well on cashcrate by doing the 2 surveys of the day and by getting referrals. Mysurvey is great and I just got my second check for $100 by filling out very short surveys. As for In Box Dollars. It isn't that great for its compensation. Seems a lot lower than the others for surveys. But whenever I buy something online I check to see if I can go through their site and get a discount or rebate. It works great for that. So I do get money back that way. I buy my pet supplies and I think my wife uses it to buy from Old Navy online for the kids.   

    Darkside thanks,
    So maybe if I make it noncomercial and just talk about them. I really theink they are great sites and want to share my success with others. I know a lot of people are coming on here to find ways to make money that are not scams.

    Maybe I will start a blog about them then. It is just a shame I can't share it here I had lots of great comments with people thanking me.

    To be honest I have seen lots of other hubs on here that talk about this topic. I'm guessing they will eventually face the same problem as me.

    1. 0
      Nelle Hoxieposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      If you have adsense on your blog, it's best not to go into these areas. You could put your account jeopardy.

  8. Hoop-A-Joo profile image60
    Hoop-A-Jooposted 7 years ago

    Mine got flagged as well.  And mine was not even about particular program or site.  It was just general reviews and based on debate going on helium  while back.  At the bottom, I had put 2 link I have used for a while, and was worked for me.  I did email hubpages but also I took away those link and add some explanation on text and submit for publication.  I don't think this is fair that it suddenly flagged and they should have give me proper explanation which or what part is violating hubpages or google TOS.

  9. Hoop-A-Joo profile image60
    Hoop-A-Jooposted 7 years ago

    Funny thing is I still found lots of hubs taking about surveys, GPT stuff and not flagged yet.  Most of Odd Jobs & Making Extra money area talks about survey, GPT stuff. Why some are still allowed to published and some are not? What is the guideline here? So confusing..

    1. relache profile image87
      relacheposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      It means the ones that still exist haven't been flagged or otherwise weeded out by the Hub team.

  10. jim10 profile image73
    jim10posted 7 years ago

    So if this is the case then my best bet is to create a new Hubpage account. Then make a similar hub without  entering in my adsense and amazon id numbers etc... Then I should be able to keep it up for a year or so when it gets flagged. But obviously that would be wrong so I won't do that.
    I guess I will make a blog just dedicated to these sites and I won't connect it to my adsense.
    I'm still waiting to hear back from the hub team.
    I'm not sure how worried I am about keeping adsense. I make more in 1 month from cashcrate than I did in 2 years with adsense. So I would rather direct traffic there. But thanks for everyones input.