Ok, so someone left a comment on a hub of mine. They have replaced their name with an external link and I'm not sure whether to keep it or delete it.
I could keep it but what if it is Spam and pushes my page in google down? The link they posted is more or less a new site so I am not sure of the implications as yet.
What do you suggest? Thanks!
dont sweat the small stuff
if the comment is garbage, delete it, if your just a little bit concerned about negative effects of outgoing link to a spam site (bad neighborhood) than delete it
In most cases the comment was only created for the backlink anyway, its not like they will come back and be angry with you
nowadays, i never accept the one sentence "great hub" .."thanks " comments that even hubbers leave...just because of the slight decrease in my keyword density it creates (not that i focus on this..but my cost/benefit analysis says no crappy comments
just deny it. i never add links to my hubs...and those especially since they are kind of spammy.
cosette, that's not very considerate, when you consider that you would probably want to take advantage of the same feature if you were commenting on someone's blog.
Provided the comment is good and their site isn't spammy, I think it's courtesy to approve it.
Thanks for that Sunforged - more wise words from a wise hubber!
The thing is, its a really good comment and it points to a relevant site that uses adsense too!
I wanted to delete it because it was a blatant backlinking attempt, backlinking works in my favor if I'm the one doing it. Does a back link placed by that site on my hub help my ranking?
For the one who placed it, its a backlink
For you its an outgoing link, the old flagship hub standards recommended 10-15(I think) outgoing links, I assume because of a perceived SEO benefit.
You seems to be aware of the risks of outgoing links to bad/spam sites.
As a marketer who makes a majority of my income from online sources - I severely limit and control all exit points from my articles and pages ..i want an adsense click or a purchase, having outbound links to competitors or non-partnered sites is rather rare for me but that doesnt go as far as caring where a commenters name is linked to
but in general, if it bothers you at all, just delete it
you could even copy the comment and post it with your own account sans outgoing .link lol
Sunforged, does that mean you don't agree with the recommendation to include outgoing links? I used to take the same attitude as you - it seemed daft to offer visitors alternative, non-paying ways to leave my Hub or site.
Lately I've been going back and adding a links capsule (right at the bottom, under the comments) after being told it was important to have links to other reputable, related sites.
thanks for clarifying this point, as I do hesitate at times to make outgoing links even though it can open in a new window, I wonder.
It means i trust that Hubpages put research and knowledge into their formula for the flagships - so i think the external links suggestion must have a purpose
But since my hubs perform well for the keywords I target and I know that backlinking is the single most important factor in ranking, I do completely disregard that suggestion.
whatever seo benefit exists I believe controlling and limiting a visitors exit options is equally as supported in the internet marketing field
I do stick stuff below the comment box, i always stick a rss feed and/or news feed, sometimes random amazon or ebay capsules to give an early boost to the hubs starting score and stuff of that sort, ..I mean all those capsules are filled with links to reputable sites arent they?
But in all reality, sticking a list of URL's before or after your comment box isnt going to hurt...once they have read that far, I think they are already lost as "customers"
If it's a relevant, well thought out comment, I'll approve it.
Just remember, there will come a day when you will be doing the same in order to get a back link.
very true, and I never add a link somewhere unless I have been there before and feel it's relevant to the topic.
That day has long come and gone years ago! Just wasn't sure how hubpages took it! Thanks guys!
by Faith Reaper2 years ago
I know that it is against HP rules for someone to place a link in a comment of a hub, but is it okay for someone to place a link in a comment when answering a question, even if it directs people back to their hub? ...
by Ben Zoltak6 years ago
Well, I hope I am posting this in the right spot. I've been on Hubpages now a little over 3 months, and am enjoying it thoroughly, all the writers here have been great. I have done a lot of research on increasing...
by KnowledgeAnywhere5 years ago
I have been on hubpages for two months. I have read multiple articles on SEO and backlinking. Ninety percent of my hubs do not have backlinking. But I choose for a while to say no backlinking. It...
by Sally Gulbrandsen8 days ago
I have someone who keeps on adding a link to their comment. Thus far I have denied the comments, what should I be doing with them. The comment is always nice but I think they are just using me to promote...
by Richieb7996 years ago
commenting on your hubs?just wondering because someone just did on mine, Im just thinking it would of been more polite to ask if we could of done a link exchange, that way we'd both benefit, now im stuck between...
by Audrey Hunt17 months ago
I seldom find a comment to my hubs hub that include a business link. Are links allowed in the comment section? Do you reply or do you delete the comment? Thanks.
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.