Today on my Hub: http://hubpages.com/hub/Do-I-have-Chron … s-Symptoms I got this message:
"Treating Tonsillitis with Antibiotic" is a copyrighted articles, you must remove THIS article, otherwise, you will be reported for copyright violations.
by playhomes Inc.
I published my article last July! This guy's earliest comment is 2 Months ago?
Am I really in violation of a later coming article? They aren't even related, mine is about a personal experience with Tonsillitis his is about treating it with Antibiotics....
What should I do? Is it something I should ignore?
Well, a comment isn't a DMCA notice, and if I Google Playhomes Inc it doesn't come up, so it may just be a rather twisted kind of spam. Does the name link anywhere?
If you can find your article copied anywhere else on the net (i.e. by him), you should hit him straight back with your own DMCA.
Understood. It seems like he's trying to just eliminate the competition.
I think you misunderstand relache, he posted the comment on MY article saying that my article was in violation of his article so I need to remove mine. Sorry I didn't make that clear.
unless you are a medical professional, I would be very careful about writing an article telling people how to make a diagnosis.
you might want to put a disclaimer on your hub stating that you are not a doctor and to check with a doctor first. he's probably referring to the content about diagnosing a medical condition.
Good advice, I'll put the disclaimer in the hub now.
Whoops! I didn't even think about that I always saw the part in the Hub to add links to other Hubs, never imagined someone would be upset that I linked to them!
Ack! I didn't think about that, I will keep that in mind for next time.
SO many lessons learned today. Thanks for all the support! Amazing
Richard A Great Big IGNORE they haven't a leg to stand on. Treat anything like this with a grain of salt in future, you could have written an Hub, in the time wasted, on playhome, long and short, they were never worth bothering with.
You're not even the author of the Hub which the person is complaining about.
What are you worried about and why?
Okay, I just sent Playhomes a friendly message suggesting we just forget everything and enjoy providing different sources of information to the community. Let's hope they drop the topic.
I wouldn't have done that, because it reveals your email address to someone who is possibly a spammer.
Was the name of his article hyperlinked in the comment? Or linked via his username? If so, the comment was purely an attempt at spam - though why he thought you'd approve it, goodness knows.
If you put your hubpage in article checker http://www.articlechecker.com/ the only duplicate content that comes up is either your own hubpage or insignificant terms.
It would appear this person has a hidden agenda, possibly a link building campaign using your dofollow comment area.
After reviewing your hub they are talking about the link toward the bottom . You apparently linked an article that belongs to them, my recommendation is to ask permission to continue using it and apologize letting them know that you were not aware that there were any copyright infringments. Your hub is fine like I said it is simply the link.
FYI: http://hubpages.com/hub/Cure-4-Tosilitis playhomes is a hubber let him know that you linked his hub, I believe he thinks you stole it but it is to his/her benefit.
I always ask permission before I use a link or a pic on my hubs it is only a lesson learned.
AEvans, if a Hubber complained about someone linking to his Hub, he's an idiot!
Richard, you don't have to ask a Hubber's permission to link to their Hub. You've done him a big favour by linking to his Hub. It's not a copyright infringement in any way, shape or form.
Having said that, I would remove the link if I were you, since he's been so ungracious. Anyway, you want visitors to leave your Hub by clicking on your ads, not by going to another Hub and clicking on their ads!
It's good practice to provide links to other relevant Hubs and websites, but put the links at the bottom of the Hub, below the comments.
YOu had to read farther into my comment at the beginning I ran with what all of you were saying and then I did my research and it was another hubber. Everyone was ranting about what should be done, yada, yada, yada but I looked into it, silly you ran with the first half of my comment too! loloolo **sigh** all of us do it.
The links I was refering to based on everyone's comments were outside links not internal.
To avoid the fuss I just decided to remove his/her link. I've already sent one message to no reply; would rather not provoke things.
You did fine none of us normally ask permission to use internal links but if some of the hubbers do not understand they get a little sassy, lololo don't worry you did not do anything wrong and I also e-mailed them and explained that to them too. It was a good hub by the way and you also noted a disclaimer which was perfect!
Sound like this Hubber "Playhomes" is a bit of an idiot. Firstly he should be delighted that you have linked to his hub as it should help to increase his traffic. Secondly you have not infringed any copright by using a link to his hub without stealing his text. Thirdly, his hubscore is so low (71) that his sheer ignorance of what gets traffic to his hubs is obvious by his complete lack of hubscore, (not to mention he only has 1 fan).
I would ignore it if I were you as I am sure the team at hubpages will soon point out to him how beneficial your link to his hub can be if he complains, plus you have done nothing wrong as far as I can tell!
PS. posted on that guy's hub too and tried to expain to him why he is missing the point as to how beneficial a link to his hub can be, plus what a compliment being linked to is, not to mention the potential income this can encourage. He may well delete my comment, but at least he will have to read it first and see that I actually have made very good arguments for him not throwing a strop over an internal link back to his hub from another hubber.
Actually, just in case this person does delete the comment I left on his hub, this is what I wrote:
"It is also worth mentioning that if another hubber links to your hub on their own hub (based on it being on the same, or a similar subject), it can be very beneficial to your hubpage traffic, and therefore potentially very lucrative, as well as encouraging further followers/fans to join your club.
It is a huge compliment to be linked to on another's hub as it shows they appreciated your work as high quality. They have also not infringed on any copyright by simply adding your link to their links capsule, as it isn't as if they stole your text.
I am sure you know where I am coming from on this and hope you can see that your hub was clearly recognised by a fellow hubber as being of a caliber worth being associated with. I hope this helps to earn BOTH of you more income, as it should do if Hubpages works as it normally does when fellow hubbers link to other hubber's hubs.
Happy New Year"
@ Misty that was a wonderful thing to do! Hopefully my e-mail and your comment will make them understand and just like Marissa said they would be an idiot if they did not want another hubber to link to their hub. Happy New Year Misty!
Thanks AEvans, it needed to be said, and I am sure you too covered this in your email, otherwise, how else do these newbies learn "what works". Anyway, Richard did this guy a favour and didn't deserve a slap in the face for it, (I would be grateful if a hubber linked to one of my hubs).
Happy New Year to you too
Misty and AEVans, very kind of you to help him out. In fact, this whole thing has renewed my own interest in HubPages and hopefully he will continue to build his account further as well! Thanks again everyone.
Ask where they think youn stole it from, check the dates, if it as after yours, threaten him back, and file a DMCA complaint against their ISP1
by Aficionada6 years ago
This is actually three questions.1) Is the average of all of the individual HubScores significant in any way? Does that number affect or change anything?2) In discussions of the Suggested Links Tool and HubKarma,...
by AsherKade7 years ago
hey, I wrote a nice hub recently linking my hub to a fantastic hubber related to my topic. Though I thought it was a great honor, it made that hubber mad. Is linking a hubber occassionally bad ettiquette???
by Grace Marguerite Williams4 years ago
Disagreements regarding a hub is expected and normal. Sometimes such disagreements can be quite emotional and intense. However, it is quite declasse to write a hub mentioning a hubber with whom you...
by Mom Kat4 years ago
This has happened to me a few times. I'll leave a comment or give an answer in the Q&A section... and I will get attacked (for lack of a better word) by some other Hubber who has a different point of view or...
by Mark Knowles7 years ago
A step in the right direction from google blogger/blogspot.About once a month, I spend a day tracking down work that has been copied and getting it removed, or a backlink or the adsense account closed. Today is the day....
by LongTimeMother2 years ago
I respect the work of many hubbers, but at the very top of my list is 'peeples'. I am a great fan of this extraordinary woman and when you go to her profile page you will see why. Peeples is now homeless. Follow this...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.