jump to last post 1-25 of 25 discussions (44 posts)

Can you have too many comments?

  1. Dolores Monet profile image91
    Dolores Monetposted 7 years ago

    Will having too many comments posted on a hub be a cause for concern? Could too many comments make a hub less google worthy? I have one hub with over 200 and that seems excessive.

    1. profile image0
      L. Andrew Marrposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I wouldn't know. I'm not loved enough tonguesmile

  2. habee profile image89
    habeeposted 7 years ago

    I've wondered about that, too!

  3. wyanjen profile image86
    wyanjenposted 7 years ago

    If you edit the comments capsule, you can set it to display a limited number.

    If you set the initial display to 10 comments, the rest of them will not be deleted. Just hidden. There is an option then for readers to see the rest of them if they want to.

    I'm not sure if this has an effect with google. Since they are not displayed, does google scan them?

    1. Beth100 profile image85
      Beth100posted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I didn't know that!!!  Thanks Wyanjen!  I don't have a problem with 200 yet (maybe in the future...hoping!) but it's good to know. 

      I appreciate all feedback that I receive, respond to each and delete the negative, non-related comments.  The power that the "delete" button holds!!!  smile

  4. Dolores Monet profile image91
    Dolores Monetposted 7 years ago

    I have no idea. I've been here for a year and amaze myself at how little I know.

  5. profile image0
    Crazdwriterposted 7 years ago

    I don't get enough comments on my hubs to worry about it...sorry can't help smile

    1. Mamelody profile image62
      Mamelodyposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      That makes the two of us tongue

    2. drej2522 profile image85
      drej2522posted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I think it is definitely a good problem to hsve! smile

    3. goldenpath profile image82
      goldenpathposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Halelujah, sister!  At least I'm not the only one....  sad

      1. Stevennix2001 profile image82
        Stevennix2001posted 7 years ago in reply to this

        me three.  i don't get that many comments either.  that's why im always happy when i get them.  smile

    4. Jane@CM profile image60
      Jane@CMposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I'm in the same boat at Crazd, but the comments I do get are very nice.

  6. thisisoli profile image54
    thisisoliposted 7 years ago

    I have has a couple of hubs which seem to have created a lot of rather spam like comments.  The are kind of relevant, but I have often considered removing the majority of them to keep things tidy.

  7. Cagsil profile image61
    Cagsilposted 7 years ago

    From what I've come to learn. Every new comment to a Hub, give the scanners of GOOGLE to pick up on something fresher than the last time it checked the hub.

    This proves to GOOGLE the hub is actively getting traffic, because things about the hub keeps changing. This helps in indexing.

    Changing of keywords, adding or subtracting other components, can be helpful.

    Can you have too many comments? I think so. I appreciate the comments I get, but the ones that are extremely old, like at least 3-6 months old or older, could be a disadvantage. Not sure. Besides, if there are TOO MANY comments, it makes the hub itself extremely long and makes it very difficult to obtain newer comments.

    Hope that was helpful. smile

    1. wyanjen profile image86
      wyanjenposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Don't let the hub get too long...
      Just set the comments capsule to limit how many it displays. smile

  8. thisisoli profile image54
    thisisoliposted 7 years ago

    Yeah Cagsil is right, there is definately a benefit in that respect!

  9. Ann Nonymous profile image59
    Ann Nonymousposted 7 years ago

    From someome who still has hubs without comments I can't imagine what you are going through! I almost envy you!

    1. thisisoli profile image54
      thisisoliposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      Don't worry, with a bit of persistance you will all get there!

      1. Ann Nonymous profile image59
        Ann Nonymousposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        Aww, thanks so much for the encouragement! With people like you on the hub everything on the hub is possible, huh? Thanks again! Now I better get to work......

    2. Dolores Monet profile image91
      Dolores Monetposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      It's really only the one. And lots of the comments are like - wow, nice hub. and when i was hungry for comments, put them in, plus, I didn't want to be mean.

  10. SandyMcCollum profile image79
    SandyMcCollumposted 7 years ago

    Just mho, but I've read hubs and then when I went to comment on it there was such a long line of comments that it made me feel that my comment won't be noticed and that there wasn't anything I could add to it, they'd said it all. So I'm in favor of limiting them to a number that doesn't overwhelm the reader. Like, 10.

    1. Marisa Wright profile image93
      Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      I've had the same reaction!  I don't have many Hubs with high comments, so I don't have the problem - but I never approve comments that say "good Hub" or "thanks".  And I don't reply to comments unless I have something meaningful to say, for the same reason.

  11. thisisoli profile image54
    thisisoliposted 7 years ago

    I might have to start doing that, for the record though, I always read the comments and fanmail that I receive!

  12. wyanjen profile image86
    wyanjenposted 7 years ago

    Me too - I read and respond to all comments.

    I get it about the long line making you feel like a tag-along. I usually don't comment if I have to scroll a couple pages.
    It's more of a patience thing with me smile
    No, I don't have enough of it smile

  13. sunforged profile image71
    sunforgedposted 7 years ago

    My opinion is no, as mentioned, each new content is "new content"which gives you the positive impression of updating and fresh ..both very positive to google.

    People actually reading and scanning that content contributes to your page view time and the comments add to your word count...all factors which are plusses to search engines.

    "Spammy comments" are ok..as long as they are not partnered with spammy links...kill the links as mcuh as possible. (including ones that may be snuck into the username w/ non registered commenters) ...if your a stickler about keyword density ...lots of irrelevant comments, ie chit chat , could negatively effect that ranking factor and/or make your work look less authoriattive to a non -hub viewer


    as for the readers who compalin about scrolling past lots of comments, try using the "page down"or ├źnd" buttons on your keyboard!

  14. Stevennix2001 profile image82
    Stevennix2001posted 7 years ago

    well, i can't speak for everyone here, but i love getting comments on hubs to be honest, as I enjoy reading and responding them. smile

  15. profile image0
    cosetteposted 7 years ago

    you can never have too many comments on your hubs. unless they are spam or mean ones, that is.

    1. Stevennix2001 profile image82
      Stevennix2001posted 7 years ago in reply to this

      yeah, but sometimes mean ones can be beneficial as long they're criticism on how you can improve.  like when i wrote a film review for "50 first dates", a guy left a rather very unflattering comment to me, which in turn forced me to reevaluate my own critique style, to get better.  Heck, I even started to read more of Roger Ebert and Peter Travers critical work, for more inspiration so I could review a film like they do.  Therefore, a bad comment can sometimes be beneficial if you look at it as constructive criticism to improve. 

      however, if the comment that's something that NOTHING to with the hub and just says something like, "your an idiot or.....blah blah blah."  then i'd just delete it.

      1. profile image0
        cosetteposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        yeah...one time this woman wrote:

        "f--k off b--ch" on two of my hubs. those were the kinds of comments i was referring to. ah, fun..... big_smile

        1. Stevennix2001 profile image82
          Stevennix2001posted 7 years ago in reply to this

          oh sorry.  i get what your saying now.  i do agree with you.  i think comments like those should not be tolerated on hubpages.  im sorry to hear that happened to you.

      2. rebekahELLE profile image91
        rebekahELLEposted 7 years ago in reply to this

        that is a great example of how you can take criticism constructively and be a better writer! good for you.

  16. Dolores Monet profile image91
    Dolores Monetposted 7 years ago

    cosette, I think if the people who leave such awful stuff don't see them displayed, they'll go play nasty somewhere else.

    thank you all for the great info - on the idea that you are refreshing the hub for google. I really appreciate getting comments, it's just nice. And I like to leave comments. We all like a bit of encouragement.

  17. wyanjen profile image86
    wyanjenposted 7 years ago

    You can go back and deny some of the older ones, if they just say "good hub" or something and you don't need/want them anymore.
    smile

  18. CarpetDiem profile image77
    CarpetDiemposted 7 years ago

    I'd love to have your problem. smile
    If they are good and add CONTENT, I'd say the more the merrier. Google loves content, and the more diverse it is, the more searcher will probably find you.
    But if the comments are fluffy one-liners like "nice hub" or "thanks", I'd remove them.

  19. bigmikeh profile image81
    bigmikehposted 7 years ago

    I remember reading somewhere that an established blogger (outside HubPages) couldn't work out why he lost his first page ranking for a keyword. He thought it might be excessive comments and deleted most of them, and got his first page back. It may have been coincidence, but there is a possibility that too many comments could dilute the original text to where the Google ranking suffers.

    1. CarpetDiem profile image77
      CarpetDiemposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      hi big mike,
      I wish you could find a link to that.
      It seems like more (quality) content would help, not dilute... but I think we agree it depends on what is in the comments. smile
      I just hope someday I have to worry about this. smile

    2. rebekahELLE profile image91
      rebekahELLEposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      that is interesting. it makes sense. I think too many comments can take away from the hub content itself, although there are certainly times when the comments add richness to the content.

      but I do agree, too many and the hub page can lose its originality. Ive seen some amazing hub content with only one or two comments. I think they get lost, there are so many great hubs on this site.

    3. Marisa Wright profile image93
      Marisa Wrightposted 7 years ago in reply to this

      This is why there's sometimes friction between the "commercial" Hubbers and the "social" Hubbers.

      Social Hubbers are more likely to leave "great Hub" type comments and expect the Hub owner to respond with an equally meaningless "thanks" comment.  Commercial Hubbers are more likely to delete the comment and not respond at all, to avoid deleting their Hub content as described above.

  20. mel22 profile image60
    mel22posted 7 years ago

    I think too many comments make the page look bad but heres a link to a post I made which would be be a way of mimizing the look of too many comments while still allowing 'fresh' new comments 2 be seen in the eyes of google like Cags was saying!

    http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/33104#post724527

  21. molson5070 profile image76
    molson5070posted 7 years ago

    Google will reward you for having many comments as the page looks fresh BUT make sure your keyword density is not being watered down by the extra comments. Remember a keyword density under 2% is not good as google will not view your site as relevant

  22. johnshade profile image78
    johnshadeposted 7 years ago

    well comments do help because a comments are indexed as well e.g. someone types into a search engine what someone says in a comment or similar it will bring traffic to your Hub.
    I have landed on pages in the past due to comments being related to my search term

  23. Pcunix profile image89
    Pcunixposted 7 years ago

    I have had to cut off comments on some posts at my main site because they were just repetitions of things that had already been said several times already.   

    It can be really annoying when someone scans a post and immediately jumps down to post their two cents without reading a single other comment.  That's especially true when whatever they have to say has been said several times.

    I had to start moderating all comments there sometime back because of that.  I hope I don't have to do that here, but I suppose eventually I might have to.

  24. freecampingaussie profile image37
    freecampingaussieposted 7 years ago

    I havent had that problem, with all my hubs I am up to 3 comments ! So maybe I am doing something wrong ?

  25. rebekahELLE profile image91
    rebekahELLEposted 7 years ago

    if I read a hub that has a zillion comments, I generally skip the comments or read a few, and then post my comment. I've seen hubs that have commentaries for each comment, I simply don't want to use my time reading all of those comments if I'm taking some time to read hubs.

    I do moderate all of my comments, most of them I accept, a few I haven't.


    you've only been here a short time. welcome! sometimes it takes a while for people to find you. it helps to post comments on other people's hubs if you find some you really enjoyed reading.
    some hubs don't get many comments, that's o.k. too!

 
working