Lately, I've had several comments from other hubbers who leave a link to their hubs. For example, let's say they read my hub on "Appaloosas." They leave a comment like "Great hub. To learn more about horses, read this:..." Then they leave a link to their hub about Quarter Horses. Is this rude? What do you guys think?
Sounds rude to me, not much helpful for you in a comment like that and a hollow help for them
I had a hub on human trafficking and saw a similar hub on this topic. Had a read and left a comment congradulating the author for addressing the topic and offering to link up the hubs but don't need a link in there. To my mind its all about relevancy, if the comment has little relevancy and is just self promoting its rude and likely to be deleted.
Yep! The comment place is not for promoting. It says so right under the comment box.
"Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites"
Mornin', habee-sometimes I think these folks mean sincerely to be helpful, but most times I do find it rude, almost insulting. Do you know what I mean?
I'm not sure it's necessarily rude to leave a link, but still, I've always felt that if I am going to leave a link in any context, I want to do it as an after thought. I make a valid comment and then I may leave a link. Sometimes. In a place like HubPages one obviously need not leave a link of any sorts since your comment itself is essentially a link in and of itself. The manner in which the links are being placed in the way that you describe seems more suggestive of commenting simply to leave a link and nothing more, and THAT, on the other hand, I would consider rude.
Yes, I think it is very rude. They are promoting themselves by using your hub.
This happens especially when your hub hits a 100 hubscore. I see it as being rude, tacky, and very self promotional. Let's face it if all a person can say about your hub is "Great Hub, Now take a look at mine"... that's just wrong.
So yes, I delete it and if it is someone new, I usually send them an e-mail explaining why! If the comment seems sincere and the hub really does enhance mine then I might allow it once in a while. That's my two cents...
i go back and forth with this. if my friends do it, they are just sharing some stuff with me, so i don't mind. in fact, i appreciate it. if it's a stranger, i read it carefully and i can usually tell if they sincerely want to share their own thoughts or are trying to promote their own hubs. but to answer the question i don't think it's rude.
but those UGG spammers, THEY are rude!
Has not happened to me but Yes it is rude I would deny the comment then send an e-mail asking them to please refrain from doing that.
It's all about relevancy for me too; And of course the general 'tone' of the comment, meaning if it's a brief: 'great hub, here's my link' kind of remark, yes, it's rude. But if someone takes time and effort to contribute something to the discussion and the link given further elaborates or is relevant to my hub, then I don't mind.
I have a published writer as a fan who often comments on my hubs and posts a link to relevant chapters from his book (on his website); I actually love it, because his comment always 'adds' something to the discussion and the link further helps. I guess one can always tell if someone is blatantly trying to promote their own hub, or is genuinely interested in your work.
I have linked other hubber's hubs to mine, but I've contacted them privately first. I think them leaving a comment and a link to their hubs it blatant self promotion, and I don't allow it. There are more cordial ways to promote your hubs. These people are not interested in making contact and friendships. They are interested in self promotion. And since that's the case, I'm not interested in them, either.
Life is about relationships, I have decided. Relationships that are good always get us where we need to be, give us the resources, income, and joy in life that we hope for. When people are not concerned about their relationships and are willing to do such one-upmanship without any concern for human interaction, I just hit the delete button.
For what it's worth.
Yes, Daniel, I've done that via private emails, also. Like, "I have a hub on this topic, too. Why don't we link them?" If the other hubber agrees, I link his to mine and he links mine to his - that's a two-way street that might benefit both hubbers.
Is it rude? Far as I'm concerned, yes. And I delete their waste of time comments. If you do a quick check, you'll usually find that they've wandered around similar hubs (to yours and theirs) writing 'nice hub' then dropping a link to their own.
I'm with Ivorwen - and she said the above far more concisely too
While it's always nice to get a compliment, even a perfunctory one, the addition of one's own link seems to negate any actual complimenting that might have been going on.
In short, yes, I think it's rude, mostly because of the link. I understand that it's more polite to ask permission to place a link on someone else's work, or at least MORE polite to write a comment that has some substance and then provide a link that's actually pertinent to the hub.
I say that if you don't ask me to link in an email and just put it in a comment then yep R-U-D-E and it will be deleted. But if you ask through email to link something then I will happily link it.
Speaking of UGGs...does every other person on Earth sell those things?? lol
I was thinking of getting into that business... just kidding
what? You don't think I could do it? I'll TRY not to spam you hehehehehe
No but sometimes my most evil laugh sounds like a little girl laugh. scares my parents, friends, and hubby
Is it actually creepy around the kids tho?
That sort isn't creepy with the kids at school, the cartoon evil laugh cracks them up every time tho
Oh yea when I was working they wanted me to chase them using the creepy cartoon laugh. They screamed and laughed and had a blast. the teachers and parents would crack up too.
It was cute...I miss it too but oh well hopefully soon I'll get a new preschool job
You should be in demand at preschools if they know whats good for em!
BTW Total Thread Hijack! MMWwhahahahaha!
awww....you have a little girl laugh crazd? cute
Habee, you bet it's rude to leave a link in your comment box. I had an "argument" with a newer hubber a while back who left his totally unrelated links in everyone of his comments. Same goes for those that become your followers with those nifty comments like "I follow you now you better reciprocate and follow me too"
Now that we've discussed your question how about reading my new hub [www.mynewhub.com] (just kidding)
have a great Tuesday afternoon everyone
You have to admit that we are very pleasant and polite hijackers
I'm glad to see this thread. For as long as I've been on here, I've always felt kind of like a "crumb" for not approving those links. Still, my reaction is to be irked when people do it. Besides, I don't want to be looking at links to see which ones "meant well" and which ones are nothing but pure spam.
by northweststarr6 years ago
A common problem for all writers, taking other peoples' suggestions and criticisms gracefully is essential to the process. I personally, welcome any and all advice from my readers that is constructive and true. I find...
by Faith Reaper3 years ago
I know that it is against HP rules for someone to place a link in a comment of a hub, but is it okay for someone to place a link in a comment when answering a question, even if it directs people back to their hub? ...
by BaliMermaid6 years ago
If a visitor to any given hub makes a comment I believe that's a good thing. But what if that visitor leaves a link, usually embedded into their name, to another website or another hub. Thsi has happened a lot and...
by Brie Hoffman7 years ago
Does anyone ever get other hubbers making comments and then plugging their own hubs by pasting their urls in the comments section? What do you do..do you allow it or deny it?
by Susannah Birch6 years ago
There has been some controversy over comment feedback on hubs recently:http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/52513As well as people who aren't fond of "low quality" or "I'll comment on yours if you comment on...
by stevemark1220008 years ago
It is important to actually read the hub you are commenting on. It seems that every time I publish a hub I get at least one comment saying something that proves they didn't read the hub. In the future I will be deleting...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.