Been getting comments from people who are not hubbers (or at least aren't logged in as hubbers). They leave links back to their websites which are clearly on-topic. That tells me they're looking for hubs on the same topic as their site, just to get the link back.
Now, the comments are relevant and good, and the link is nofollow, obviously, but I still feel a tad uncomfortable about these being comments made solely for the link back.
What do you think? do you approve these kind of comments or not?
thats how the system works .. if you dont ever seek out comment links yourself then no need to reciprocate, but if it seems they have read the article and responded intelligently whats the problem?
your not losing visitors or traffic from some random link at the end of your articles in the comments.
in the end, if your uncomfortable then mark it as spam.. i very rarely approve comments w/ visible links
I'm glad you share your opinion of visible links shown on comments. I decided months ago not to approve any comments which link outside of Hubpages. Even if it's about the same topic as my Hub, I don't approve I simply delete. Thank you.
I recall a few that I allow simply because the comments are relevant and added something to the hub. Most are just denied and never to be seen again.
If the comment is relevant I leave it, link or not. After all, is this not what we do when we are backlinking? We'd hate if everyone marked our own comments as spam on other forums just because we included a permissible link.
Wouldn't the number of comments we receive on a hub improve our hub in terms of SERP's? Therefore, unless it is an off topic link, leave it.
The key differentiator being if the link and comment are related to your Hub topic,that's good.
If someone comes and leaves a random comment and link with no bearing to your hub, it's spam.
Agree with everyone that if the comment is on topic, post it. If not, delete. I always thought the more comments the better, and is basically more content added to your hub.
I would have to agree with everyone else on this issue. If it's related and relevent and intelligant leave it. I've not had to deal with this issue, but if it would seem that they have read the hub and give insight no harm no foul Hope you find the answers you are looking for
Are comments always nofollow? If so I'll leave them in - I've been deleting them from my hubs (especially finance related hubs).
Thanks for all the feedback everyone. Yes, the links to outside pages are always nofollow. I just suspect that while the content of the comments is legitimate, these people are probably using automated processes to find the hubs.
When I get these kinds of comments on my blog, with keywords for anchor text, I just allow the comment and delete the link. Just to clarify, I do have clear guidelines openly stated about this and my blogs are dofollow.
I think what I'll do is keep an eye on this kind of comments for quality and decide accordingly. Thanks for all the feedback!
by The Write Life9 days ago
Someone left a good comment on my Hub and also dropped a link to their site. The site is right on point with the subject and looks like quality. I would like to approve it, just wondering how Google sees it, whether...
by Salma Hassaballa3 weeks ago
Hi Hubbers, what should I do in response to a comment that is attacking my article, should I ignore, or approve and stay silent, or approve and reply to his/her comment. thank you
by Michael Willis6 years ago
It there a way we can allow comments and at the same time "Disallow" the hyperlink? Especially for the non-members of Hubpages.Sometimes the comments are OK to allow, but I may not want the link on my...
by mega16 years ago
This has probably been addressed elsewhere but I haven't found the answer yet. Is it ok to post a link to your own hub in the comments section to someone else's hub on the same or similar subject? I just...
by Michael Kismet2 weeks ago
A visitor to one of my hubs left a long, passionate, and relatively well-written comment..But he threw in some f-bombs.. Should I approve it?Will Google penalize me for allowing comments with some profanity?
by BoCot9 years ago
Hello, I am wondering why some of the comments I made to hubs was posted as unapproved comments. Others said this comment, whats the difference?BoCot
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.