I now have 11 hubs that are not indexed by google - nothing published since July 12 (the last one was published on the 9th and indexed yesterday). Normally I've seen then set up with 24 hours, occasionally in 48, but now it's 8 days and not done!!??
Hi Wilderness, I posted a similar question a couple of weeks ago, asking how long people found it took google to index their hubs. Some replied with timeframes similar to yours, that their hubs were indexed in hours.
I haven't had that kind of success. Perhaps its a function of the number of hubs one has and the number of external links pointing to the hubs as well. If a hubber has several indexed hubs pointing at a new hub, it should get picked up by google sooner.
I only have 10 hubs, so far 8 are indexed. The two that aren't were written & published in the past four days.
It would be great to see them indexed sooner, but then again, I have a website that is 2 1/2 months old with 21 pages and only 11 have been indexed by Google.
I think I remember seeing that post, and times reported were all over the board. I remember thinking that "I'm glad it isn't me" but had no idea why it wasn't. Now it is, and I wish it weren't - I've tried some new subjects and styles and want some traffic numbers to use as a rough feedback as to what is successful.
I had wondered about links as several are a different enough subject that they just link to themselves and not to or from my other hubs, but some are not and have multiple links from my other hubs.
Some use popular keyworods, some do not.
The only thing that is different at all is that I went through many of my few hubs and re-did them, even changing the whole keyword emphasis in some. All of those took only a couple of days to re-index, and I wouldn't think it would have much effect on the rest, anyway.
I checked on one of your older hubs.
When searching for it via "Toyota Prius Review" term, I went down at least 4-5 pages deep and did not find it.
However, when I typed in the exact wording of your hub title. I was able to find it on the second page of listings.
Toyota Prius - A Hybrid Car Review
A little over a year ago we bought a 2006 Prius and have driven it since then. Herein lies that experience, with the hybrid pros and cons of the Prius ...
hubpages.com/hub/Toyota-Prius-A-Hybrid-Car-Review - Cached
Just a thought (and probably irrelevant), I noticed that on some of your Hubs you have an RSS feed to your other Hubs with a description.
If it's a long Hub that probably doesn't matter, but if it's a short one, you could be introducing too much irrelevant material and diluting your keywords too much.
I do interlink my Hubs but only if they're related.
A couple of things I notice about the Hub:
This review is going to be read by non-owners, so you're not going to sell accessories. You need to maximize Adsense ads for the car. With a photo at the top, you've wiped out the prime position top-right-hand Adsense ad.
I did a search on the Google keyword tool using the "exact" match. "toyota prius review" gets 2,900 searches a month and "hybrid car review" only gets 1,000.
Marissa, I don't think that anything you might say about my hubs is irrelevant to me - thanks for the comment whether "irrelevant" (your word) or not.
I'd never thought about keyword dilution with the rss feed - a good point and I will check my shorter hubs and perhaps remove the description. I use internal links, as I'm sure you noticed, where it is relevant, but add the feed because....well, just because I guess. Maybe if they like the writing they'll want something more.
A good point about accessories (you really did go through it!) and one I'm aware of. My thinking is simply that I might find one or two one day that already own and want something - an impulse buy. I didn't see any reason not to use the Amazon ads, so put them in.
I moved the top photo into the top paragraph, flushed right. It made no difference in the number of ads as there wasn't one there anyway, although I don't know why not - I intentionally kept that space clear for adsense.
Yes, those numbers for searches are probably too low to bother with. On the other hand, "hybrid cars" shows 201,000 searches with the green competition bar only about half way over - if I put both in the title and text, I hope to pick up both and I would expect some searchers of "hybrid cars" to want to see a review. Or am I guilty of faulty thinking again?
On a side note, Marisa, your help and comments here are invaluable to me - I surely appreciate them.
I used to take the same view, but then I realized that my Amazon ads, being more colorful than most Adsense ads, were distracting from the Adsense ones. Generally, it's best not to include Amazon ads unless you can find really good products - you're just enabling a "tyre-kicker" click that might otherwise have clicked an Adsense ad. Remember you get paid even if nobody buys anything from the Adsense ad.
Have you read my Hub on optimizing your Hub layout? The top right-hand corner is the prime position for your Adsense ads. So your Hub needs to start with a text capsule, long enough to allow that corner ad to appear. Use the 'preview' function and fiddle with the length of the first capsule until it's long enough for the corner ad to pop up, but not much longer.
That means your first photo has to be next to your second text capsule, no higher.
Yes, I've read it and am following it. The hub in question was written before I knew about the adsense placement, but I've checked and it will take a photo. What I hadn't realized was that a top photo would eliminate that flushed right position for adsense as well as a photo there. I'll have to play with the length of that capsule again and see if I can get an ad in there.
I never thought about the distraction of an Amazon capsule, but I'll bet you're right there. I realized that any Amazon clicks probably wouldn't pay off, but you never know. I think your thought over-rides that, though.
Just a correction about the green competition bar - from what I've seen and been told it's not actually for our use. It's an indication of the competition between other advertisers meaning no value for keyword research. To find out your competition for keywords:
1. Google the string of words such as "black bow shoes". If lots of them have those keywords in order you have comeptition. If most are something like "black and brown bow shoes" you know people aren't specifically targeting that keyword as much.
2. Download the google toolbar (only useable with FF and IE, not chrome ) and check the PR of those pages. Obviously if they have say a PR6 it'd be almost not worth it to compete. A PR1 or 2 is competeable.
And just a clarification on amazon adverts. I know some people do place amazon ads high up top right - but only usually if it's a sales hub. If you want adsense and amazon clicks, place the amazon boxes lower...
*Waits for Marisa to correct me* I confuse myself a little with this stuff sometimes and I'm always learning!
That's pretty much what I do, except for the toolbar. I'll have to try that - I've drug my heels as I have too many toolbars already, but maybe it's worth it.
Yes, my Amazon capsules are mostly lower down. I really need to go into and clean up some of my earlier hubs as I've learned considerable in the last few weeks.
Now off to do some of the rss linking suggested by sunforged down below.
Just to be clear, if you have a photo at the top of the Hub, it eliminates the top right Adsense ad. If you remove the photo but your first text capsule is too short, it eliminates the top right Adsense ad.
The only possible way to get that top right-hand ad is to have a text capsule on its own as your first capsule. Your photos can't start until the second capsule.
I have noticed the same thing, so I usually try to place the photo between the first and second text capsules.
And you are right, of course. The text capsule was too short, in spite of the fact it looked big enough. I lengthened it and moved the pic and voila! an ad appeared. I'll remember to check that it's big enough and not go by appearance.
Just submit an article to ezine backlinking to your hub and it's almost 100% that it will get indexed (based on my experience)
All I can say is that the Hub I published three days ago is indexed. It's not something I pay that close attention to.
Well, Relache, if I had 190 hubs of experience under my belt, I wouldn't pay any attention, either! On the other hand I keep an eye on my traffic as a very rough guide as to which hubs are useful, have good SEO or are well received. Mostly the SEO and that's something I'm really working hard on learning and want that feedback.
i don't either. i know i am supposed to though, reading some of the top hubbers around here. sometimes people tell me i am and i just go really?
I'm looking into it. Occasionally we have seen Google slow down indexing. It usually speeds back up after a few days.
I would highly recommend you change your title.
Toyota Prius - A Hybird Car Review is what it is now.
A Toyota Prius Hybird Review might work better? I am only basing it on those who are looking for a "hybird" know it's a car. Toyota does make a lot of products, but not with "hybird" attached.
Or you could use - A Hybird Review - Toyota Prius.
Just a thought. Just trying to help.
See, now, Cags - that is part of my ignorance. I've been assuming that a search for "Prius Review" would pick up my title fine, but if I remove the word "car" then a search for "hybrid car review" won't.
That kind of thing happens all the time to me on my own searches, with google highliting the searched for words in a title and seemingly ignoring the ones I don't search for.
I've been using the keyword tool to find highly searched for terms and then trying to build a title around perhaps several of them - this was one of my earlier efforts along that line. Is that a bad idea and google not search for both scattered words as well as direct phrases as I thought?
Your title only needs to get attention.
The "keywords/tags" you use work for indexing, based on search terms.
So, it makes no difference if the word "car" was in the title. It can be in your keywords "prius hybird car" or "hybird cars" or "toyota cars" or "hybird car review".
The title should be, for all intended purposes, as short and direct(but keyword rich).
I could be wrong, as I am not a professional.
'Sigh' I can see it's "back to school" for me today. I thought I had read that it was quite important to include the primary keywords in the title and even the URL if at all possible as it carries more weight with google. From doing my own searches it also seems important they be in the summary text so I make sure they show up there, too - I usually write my own instead of taking the default.
So much to learn, so few years to do it in......
Actually I don't agree with Cagsil. Not wanting to be rude, Cagsil - you're a great writer but you're not a SEO guru!
The advice from people like Sunforged is to write your title for Google's benefit. Your summary is to catch the reader's attention.
So your title needs to include the best possible combination of keywords in the order people type them into search engines, which is why "toyota prius review" is better than "hybrid car review".
Hey Marissa, no offense taken and don't consider it rude. If I am wrong, then I'm glad there are people who know more about than I do. I'm limited in the SEO knowledge, because I've not taken enough time to dive into it, but only a little bit.
Cagsil, it's a common mistake. As writers we've grown up with the idea of a 'catchy' title, because in a magazine or newspaper, that's what works.
On the internet, the opposite applies. If your title isn't boring, you're probably doing it wrong. That's because Google uses your title first to judge relevance, so it's vital to include the phrase or phrases people are most likely to type into a search engine.
You can compensate for the boring title by writing a 'catchy' custom summary, because that's what appears under the title in the search engine results.
Ryan has a good video (you'll find it on my Optimize your HubPages Hub) which explains how tweaking your title to include the right keywords can make a dramatic difference to your traffic. I tried it, it works!
Ah. I have wondered if the order really matters as few people will run a google search for an exact match. It didn't seem to make much difference if there were a few extraneous words in the string - google just seems to ignore them.
Your comment makes me wonder, too, about plurals or other suffixes or prefixes - do they matter or does google not care?
I've played with search strings, doing actual searches, and decided that extra words matter, but usually not a great deal. An extra word, or lack thereof, might get top spot instead of second or third, but either one is fine with me! As my "work" only encompassed a dozen or so searches it doesn't make a very good statistical base and could be way off, however.
People don't consciously search for an exact match. The point is, Google presents the exact matches first.
So what the keyword tool is telling you is that 2,900 people every month type in the exact phrase "toyota prius review" - and if they do, the sites with that exact phrase in their title will be at the top of the results. Sites with the title "toyota prius hybrid car review" will appear but they'll be lower down.
Extra words added at the end won't make a difference but breaking up the phrase will. So you could have a title like "toyota prius review - my first hybrid car" if you want to get "hybrid car" in there.
Actually, 2900 searches isn't bad. There's not much point in targetting keyword phrases that attract thousands and thousands of searches - because you're not the only one who's noticed, and there are bound to be millions of internet marketers already targetting the really highly-searched ones.
Got it, I think. This will make some difference in my keywords, but not too much. I'll just have to remember to leave the phrase itself alone as much as possible and add words at the beginning and end.
And no, 2900 searches isn't too bad. Some of what I've used is in that range, although I try to get closer to 10,000. I also do a regular search using the chosen keyword and look at how many results I get. That's mostly what I've been counting as "competition" so the lower the better to a point.
Ok - It seems your on your way ..but still confused a little on the basics.
Get some backlinks: http://hubpages.com/hub/Easy-ways-to-pr … to-my-site
How to optimize your hub (on page)
although I iwsh, it was truly my advice, this is really common knowledge that can be found at respected sources like google webmaster tools, SEO moz and Matt Cutts blog.
For example: facebook is NOT a worthwhile backlink ..in SEO purposes( they rewrite your link and it is nofollow) if you have a large following it has diretc traffic potential..but its not going to help you get indexed any quicker
When doing your keyword research be sure to change the settings to "Exact"
I was not speaking of using rss feeds within your own hubs, but rather at external locations (the only real requirement for a BACKlink)
http://www.google.com/search?q=rss+subm … =firefox-a
If you wan to try SU and the other social bookmarking (not backlinking) sites ..true in the long run , something like a 3 to 1 ratio would be best in the ling term ...but the worst that happens is they would cancel your account - so if you dont feel like being careful, then dont..its still better than doing nothing
Thanks, sunforged for the words of wisdom. I do indeed have a lot to learn and skimming your first link (a thorough reading will have to wait till later) only emphasizes that. That's OK - this post is now bookmarked.
I do use the "exact" setting in the keyword tool, as well as do an actual search as I don't really find the little green bar to be very accurate. It also gives me an idea of what kind or article can be found with that search and sometimes it surprises me and doesn't match very well.
I still need to learn better just what a rss feed is and how it works. Haven't used them except internally because I don't know yet. I will, though.
I quit using SU mostly because some hubbers seemed to feel it could hurt HP as a whole if too many people got banned for posting excessive links to hubs. Might be so, so I quit. Besides, SU links always gave me a few views and then quit entirely.
Betcha I study some of that doggoned sunforged's hubs. If I can just get the next hub out of my mind while I do it I might even learn something!
Thanks again, sunforged.
Well, sunforged, I think your advice was spot on. I used your hub on rss sites and put 8 rss feeds each onto about 10 different sites, one feed for each of my groups. As many of the sites ask for a general topic and my hubs are just all over the place it seemed reasonable to group them by groups and submit a rss for each group. I did this yesterday morning.
As of today all my hubs are indexed but 2, and one of them was published late last night. The other one published at the same time is indexed as of this morning. I've even gotten 10 google hits on one hub that indexed sometime last night.
Thanks for the hint. Now to see if it just might translate into traffic....
The title is one of the more important things when ranking for key words, however hybrid car reviews is probably a pretty competitive keyphrase.
odd- I checked a couple of your latest - no signs of being indexed.
I checked my latest (7/13) - it has been indexed.
Maybe get out there and get your profile backlinked - it will get crawled more often and in turn your latest hubs should get crawled quicker..
Perhaps do some rss submissions too so your automatically getting a few links out there everytime you publish
Now, I had not thought of backlinking to my profile. I had considered asking my wife to backlink from FB, but her friends and all are just relatives that won't do me any good. A backlink might help here, though - I'll have her do it.
I currently use a rss feed on each hub to the "hot" hubs - perhaps "latest" would be better?
I don't have any other real presence on the web except HP so no way to backlink. I don't twitter of use FB or any other social site. I did post a few to stumbleupon, but then began reading here that I needed to post others stuff at maybe 10 - 1 and wasn't willing to spend the time to do that and get followers (or whatever they're called there) and all so I quit using them. I do use hubtrails and buzzsawmill, but that's it.
You can find a balance in good keyword use and catchy title witha little creativity
but most importantly, that title has to show up in a reasonable location to stand a chance of being clicked - catchy doesnt help if you cant see it.
a good summary can save a boring (seo based) title for your human searchers benefit
The green competition bar is for ADVERTISERS - you are a publisher. the tool is not designed for us.
I have 3 or 4 over the last few days that aren't indexed either. I even went and created backlinks to my profile and to the hubs. Nothing as of right now.
I do agree with most of the things you said, but I would like to point out a few things which I have observed(some points are evn off topic)
1.As you've already said, the google keyword tool is for advertisers and though it is a very helpful tool but if you are serious about making money online, you should go for more powerful keyword tool like Market Samurai or MicroNicheFinder. The google keyword tool just tells you how much a advertiser is willing to pay for the keyword but it does not tells you how likely a visitor is going to click on the ads. I have a couple of quotes hub which rank very high and gets a decent traffic from google but havn't earned me anything. And when I checked in market samurai the visitor value(SEOV) of that keyword is 0$.
2.Also,I would beg to differ with you on the PR point. If your hub is properly optimized for the particular keyword and the PR6 isn't then you can outrank them. For example, my hubs on soccer jerseys. It currently ranks 4th for the term "buy world cup soccer jerseys"(during the world cup was at number 2) and that hub is a PR0
let's just say from what i have seen it does not happen immediately but it does not take forever either
If its any consolation, I published a hub a month ago that has still not been indexed. I can't find it in a google search even when I include its title keywords and 'hubpages'. It had a few hubpages views in its first week, but nothing at all since.
It is more than 1000 words, not keyword stuffed, and on a good search term (high searches, low results). Loads of research went into it, and it is also an Amazon hub.
I'm getting paranoid because I can't find it.
I guess its just a waiting game...
Izzy, try searching for the URL - that's how I can tell if it's indexed. At least I think that the word "cached" means indexed - I have one hub right now that shows up but is not cached.
Also read above here a post from sunforged about using rss feeds. It seems to have helped a great deal - I answered his post with some details.
I've had his hub open on rss feeds all day but not got round to doing anything with it. Its only one hub I've not got indexed. There may well be others, but this one was one of the first I wrote after the whole SEO stuff sank home.
It's not there even with the full url
Well, don't quote me here - just repeating what I think I understand from the old-timers, but speed of indexing may depend a lot on the number of incoming links. That's why rss feeds may help a lot, and they really did seem to. I don't know what effect they might have on traffic, but I got 11 hubs indexed overnight after putting in some 80 rss feeds (about 10 to each hub).
After my studying and fixing hubs so a rss feed would pick them up in groups it only took about an hour to do it all, and future hubs will automatically be included, of course.
Yes I've read a lot of positive comments about the whole rss feed thing, but haven' tried it yet. Tomorrow...
Sorry being lazy and not read whole thread so this may have been covered.
Google only indexs two pages from one domain for each search. So if you have written a hub about 'electric toothbrushes' but google loves two more hubs more than yours, you won't see it indexed.
So do this search: "electric toothbrushes site:hubpages" (you don't need to put the quote marks in) and it will bring up every hub with that keyword. If your hub is on the list, then google has indexed it, its just loving two hubs more than yours. Don't despair. check out the other 2 hubs and see what they are doing and how to make yours better.
Lol - love the attitude. I'm all for instant gratification so I'm not all that suited to this internet marketing lark. I want success and I want it yesterday.
That's me, too, Gracey - 5 minutes is plenty of time for google to do its thing!
LOL, I noticed! I love your enthusiasm! I wanted to be as enthusiastic but I guess I've lost that youthful feature. <sigh>
Never mind, I got a £100 cheque from the Premium Bonds yesterday for the first time ever, then I got a letter from a share holding company who I hadn't informed when I moved abroad. Seems all my dividends have been lost in space since then, and I am now to collect a cheque for over £1000! Oh and google have told me my cheque is being prepared for my first payout, and Amazon isn't far behind. I think I should buy a lottery ticket tomorrow for the Euromillions LOL
Or you could just share with us poor newbies here.....
I could.. but then again I won't because I'm not a christian LOL (see other threads).
BUT...because I'm not miserable, you are welcome to come over and share the cheap red wine I've got in (and I mean really cheap - carton cheap!)
You're on! My total adsense earnings to date wouldn't buy even a small cheap carton, so I gotta beg. Gonna be a long swim, though.
Woo hoo Izzy - hopefully taht'll give you a nice confidence boost.
You need to post your good news all over the forums so people can reply with those fancy celebtrating pictures they can do - sorry all I can manage is a
Hey - no te precupe - that means no worries. I can't say I've got enough money to not have any worries - I might be sorted for a month if I'm lucky. I really need to get in gear and get really serious because all this SEO stuff is starting to sink into this ancient grey matter I've got, and the reality is I need a minimum of €1000 a month to live off. €2000 would be better, and here I am on a euro a (good)day
Spain is a dire place to be when you're skint. The lottery is just a distant dream because I've had my three good things, haven't I? Even if I worked my ass off for one for them.
I'm wondering why my website indexes 3rd on 1st page for one particular keyword when I use my firefox and then 9th on my friends laptop and then different again on my cell phone??!?
I think its got something to do with your being signed in or something - thinking of Google - have you got a google email address?
Yes, google searches are personalized based on user history and location if your logged into ANY google accounts - gmail, analytics, adsense. calender etc.
Try a service like scroogle.org (use scroogle scraper) to see a result more like an average searcher would see.
In advance, Im sorry, but if you have searched your ranking before and this is the first time using a tool - you will most likely be disappointed by the difference
Sunforged! Thought you might show up about now. I took your advice from yesterday on rss feeds (see above reply to you) with, I think, great results. Might just be coincidence, but I doubt it. Thanks.
Im happy!! I responded to your comment on the rss hub. You will most likely never have this issue again since the rss will update as you write new hubs
I have this hub: http://hubpages.com/hub/silver-wrapping-paper
which has not gotten indexed even after 7 days. I am starting to get it indexed myself now.
I ll bookmark it on social media sites especially on propeller, digg and twitter. I hope it will get indexed soon.
My hub that according to my stats has a $$$$$ potential is the only hub that google will not index. Google did pick it up when I first published it but dropped it soon afterwards and hasn't picked it up since then. My latest hub also has a $$$$$ potential and has not been picked up by google yet either though it's only been published for a few hours!
How are you checking to see if your hub is indexed? I just searched your swiss travel hub title (full title) and it's there. You may well not be ranking anywhere for the keywords you've chosen but that doesn't mean the hub isn't indexed.
Also I wouldn't pay too much attention to the $$$$$, it's not an accurate indicator of what you will earn.
I am not indexed for either of my Nova Scotia hubs. To check if I'm indexed in google, I am copying and pasting the url into the search box. Do you know if I might be doing something wrong?
Susana, I just checked again and it's actually just one of my Nova Scotia hubs, "Nova Scotia Resorts" that google will not index. Not sure why it picked it up initially but then dropped it!
Yep, I can't find it either. I see you have a Xomba page coming up with exact the same title, so I'm wondering if google chose to index that one and not your hub. I would change the hub title a bit so that it's different to the xomba page e.g. "Nova Scotia Resorts: Canada Vacations" or something like that, edit the summary, update the page with a bit more text and then ping it. Hopefully that will do the trick!
I have noticed a significant difference in indexing speed depending on the topic of the hub/article/website.
I created a basic "earning money online" blog to use for general backlinking purposes across all of my writing. Following my usual techniques it took 2.5 months to be indexed - I believe it is because google notes that there are 15 billion other sites on the same topic. This compares with less than a week (and in most cases a few days)for brand new websites on medical topics.
It does seem likely that google is taking the obvious steps needed to deliver quality content to its users on competitive topics by applying a type of time filter to get rid of those who aren't in it for the long run.
by Gary Anderson19 months ago
But I am wondering why there seems to be competition in the real google world and no competition showing for it in the external keyword tool world?
by Dobson6 years ago
I am wondering about a new strategy i am trying. What I am doing is putting an RSS Feed into my best performing (Viewed) hubs with my latest (not indexed by Google) yet hubs. IS this a good way to have them...
by Butch Tool18 months ago
Hello, dear fellows, I am hoping that someone with more experience may be able to direct me to any free resources that will help me learn how to become an SEO master. Primarily, I want to learn how to do in-depth...
by ARainey21 months ago
Hello,I've been on hubpages for about a week. There is only traffic from hubpages and mturk on my traffic tab. How long will it before I start to get traffic from google. All of my articles are...
by M. Toni2 years ago
I've been on here for a few years, and I guess I never really understood the point of these scores. They don't seem to provide any real value to the user and I can't convince myself that they add value because they...
by Earl Noah Bernsby3 years ago
I can here the snippers approaching.Snip, snip.Snip.
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.