I've just seen that one of my hubs has been flagged up as having been copied. Someone has copied it word-for-word on Yahoo Answers. What should I do about this? And will my hub score suffer as a result?
You will need to file a DMCA complaint with Yahoo, and they should take the duplicate material down.
You will likely be penalized until it has been resolved, although you may ask HubPages to review it as explained here:
WE, you DON'T get penalized by HubPages when someone else copies your work to another site. Hubs don't get moderated when someone else steals the content and puts it elsewhere.
You only incur a HUBScore penalty if you publish duplicate material on this site.
Then why has the OP's content been flagged as duplicate? Would that not require her to resolve the matter?
Because people use the word flag indiscriminately/inaccurately and you aren't paying attention to what she is saying. She didn't say it was flagged as duplicate, she said it was copied, and is now posted on Yahoo Answers.
I've had Hub content stolen and put up elsewhere and still had that Hub rank 100 here while I worked to get the stolen content taken down.
Here is what she said: "I've just seen that one of my hubs has been flagged up as having been copied."
How can you say she isn't saying that it has been flagged as duplicate?
Flagged as duplicate is a warning, not a penalization. Either way, she got it removed. No need to argue...
Yahoo will quickly get back with you and remove the stolen content. Yahoo Answers is bad for stealing content, I've had to have many Yahoo answers stuff removed where they've stolen hubs.
It's a service that HP provides for us, so that we can go chasing people who've duplicated our work. People see that word "flagged" and think it's a negative, but it's not necessarily.
I reported a copy to Yahoo Answers and they took it down very quickly.
Thank you for your reply Website Examiner, and for the link. I'm not sure what DMCA means, but I will read your link and hopefully it will all be clear. (Apologies for any confusion I've caused by accidentally posting my question twice..)
DMCA means Digital Millenium Copyright Act.
There is a procedure where the host may have a legal obligation to take down material when a complaint is filed. The other side of the issue is that hosts are usually not liable for copied content, as long as they take it down once a DMCA complaint has been filed.
Here is a link to the instructions for filing a DMCA with HubPages. Note that you cannot file your complaint with HubPages, but must go to Yahoo, so this is just to give you an idea of how it works.
Thank you so much for explaining this. I contacted Yahoo last night with the standard DMCA text, and they just got back to me to say that they have taken appropriate action. I've had a look at the Yahoo Answers webpage and the offending post has been removed! This is a great result.
My intention in posting to this thread was not to get into a semantic debate, and I'm sorry I allowed myself to be baited into one.
What I want to reiterate, especially now that the focus has been shifted, is that content that originates on HubPages and then is republished elsewhere does not incur any sort of HubScore penalty, but content that is published somewhere else on the web first and is then republished here does.
Thanks everyone for your replies. I filed a DMCA complaint and got a quick response, (less than 24 hrs later), from Yahoo saying that they've taken appropriate action, and the post where my hub was copied has now been removed. I'm very grateful for all the advice you gave me.
FYI, the message that appeared at the top of my hub was as followed:
"Your hub may not be in compliance with our publishing guidelines. Please review the automatically generated warning below, and correct the problem if possible. These warnings are only visible to you, the author.
COPIED: The content of this hub may have been copied on another site."
And I've just noticed (belatedly), that if you click this last sentence, you also get this:
"Some or all of the text from this hub appears to have been duplicated on another site. While your hub is not being penalized on HubPages, if this is your original content and it has been copied without your permission, we recommend that you protect your copyright by filing DMCA complaints with sites listed below, as appropriate."
Wish I'd realised that before!
by Mary Hyatt20 months ago
It took almost two weeks, but my copied poem is now gone from a Blogger's post! This poem was copied verbatim when it was published here. I had tried to file a complaint using the form we are...
by Audrey Selig5 years ago
There is so much of this going on that it may not be worthwhile to mention. Since I know that this site is not cooperative, I sent my DMCA complaint to Google. My hub is copied word for word with all the lovely...
by akeejaho8 years ago
I am kinda flattered, but mad as a wet hornet. Has anyone here ever heard of barryrutherford? Well, compare his Hub, Bipolar,more on this subject, and So, whats wrong with being bipolar? I mean, good...
by DK3 years ago
This forum is a place for you to post hubs that you think are clearly of low quality and need flagging. Committed hubbers should follow this forum and check these hubs posted for quality when they have the time. If a...
by Peg Cole2 years ago
Hooray! For months now I've been trying to figure out who to report the "alleged" infringement on one of my hubs where 9 links to ads have been placed. Whenever I would click the link it would take me to an...
by Andrew7 years ago
This hubber copied an Article from docstoc. I can't believe it. He also copied others. hubpages.com/hub/How-To-Copy-DVD-To-CDUncatched By Google search he answered the request asked 2 weeks ago.Cached article on DocStoc...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.