jump to last post 1-9 of 9 discussions (21 posts)

A walk to remember vs The Notebook

  1. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
    Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago

    Answer, which one do you like the most?

    Q.1: In reference to Novels 'A walk to remember' or 'The Notebook'

    Q.2: In reference to Movies 'A walk to remember' or 'The Notebook'

    1. Kekemapa profile image60
      Kekemapaposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      1. I haven't read the novels.

      2. Haven't seen The Notebook, and A Walk to Remember made me cry at first, so that wins.

      1. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
        Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        I would say that IF you have any interest in romantic novel reading (I assume there will be some interest as you are already connected to a writing websites i.e. hubpages) you should read the novel "The Notebook". It's very well written.
        The story of A walk to remember is always a remarkable one in my eyes, and so does the novel too. But "The Notebook", in terms of novels, is superb.

        1. Kekemapa profile image60
          Kekemapaposted 6 years ago in reply to this

          Thank you Hunbbel Meer. I think I'll read The Notebook big_smile

    2. Insight1987 profile image61
      Insight1987posted 6 years ago in reply to this

      Both films, from what I've seen in clips, trailers, etc., are brain-dead.

      But, there's a funny satirical clip called "The Handjob," where all the melodramatic, cliched pronouncements of the film get replaced with... other words.  big_smile

      You can see how over-the-top the film is, just by seeing those clips.

  2. smackins1974 profile image79
    smackins1974posted 6 years ago

    On both counts I would say that "The Notebook" wins hands down.

    1. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
      Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      smile Indeed it is smile

      But I found "A walk to remember" (movie) as really sweet, cute and remarkable, and even better than the Notebook.

      However, "The Notebook" (novel) is better than its competitor smile

  3. MissE profile image82
    MissEposted 6 years ago

    A WALK TO REMEMBER!!!!!!!!

  4. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
    Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago

    By reading all of the above answers, I realized that this INDEED IS A DIFFICULT QUESTION, and I am not the only one, who is really confused about it big_smile

  5. KristenGrace profile image61
    KristenGraceposted 6 years ago

    Movie: The Notebook
    Reading: Walk to Remember

    1. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
      Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      My vote is exactly the inverse of it tongue

  6. profile image0
    blatvaposted 6 years ago

    In novels, and movies, A walk to remember always wins. It always makes me cry... and it's just really beautiful.

    1. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
      Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      The screenplay of that movie took me somewhere in the heaven.

      It's so BEAUTIFUL, so serene, so cute and SO simple. I just loved the movie, and watched for soooo many times.

      1. Kekemapa profile image60
        Kekemapaposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Thanks Hunbbel Meer. I think I will read The Notebook!

        1. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
          Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago in reply to this

          You're welcome smile

          And I bet you will find a million people out there who are in love with the movie "the notebook" too smile
          May be you would like to see it, after you finished with then novel smile
          Enjoy smile

  7. prettydarkhorse profile image61
    prettydarkhorseposted 6 years ago

    movie cinematography and screenplay - A walk to remember

    But overall impact spec. storyline - The Notebook

    I didn't read both novels.

    1. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
      Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      I myself loved the screenplay and cinematography of the AWTR, the most.

      And I would definitely suggest you to read the novel of "The Notebook", because if you loved the movie that much, you are going to love the book EVEN MORE! smile

      1. prettydarkhorse profile image61
        prettydarkhorseposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        ok, I will check amazon. Thanks.

  8. Bellamie profile image60
    Bellamieposted 6 years ago

    A WALK TO REMEMBER was a pretty good movie, but not as believable as THE NOTEBOOK.  I have seen THE NOTEBOOK several times and would watch it again and again, but A WALK TO REMEMBER......not so much.  It's THE NOTEBOOK, hands down!

  9. Tina Kachan profile image48
    Tina Kachanposted 6 years ago

    I have seen both movies. Loved both of them, but Notebook more.
    A walk to remember included several stereotypes which I didn`t like that much, but still a great movie.

    However as far as the books go, I have read only Notebook. When I started reading the book, I knew it would be better than the movie as books always do. But I didn`t know it was going to be that good. So if you loved Notebook as a movie, you are going to fall in love with the book. smile

    1. Hunbbel Meer profile image91
      Hunbbel Meerposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      Yes Tina, you are 100% right smile
      I also found the book, to be more interesting and lovely smile

 
working