One of my hubs was loaded onto 68 articles 4/3/11. I checked other people's hubs. HubPages articles were loaded onto 68articles on 4/2/11 and 4/3/11.
So far I've found hubs from Viking305, ryankett and kyle246 that have been copied.
They may have removed the hubs that were there, but the bot is still loading new ones. If your hub isn't there, it's only a matter of time before it is.
Now, what do we do?
I just wanted to say "thank you" for the forum post. All of the comments here are informative to me. I've never looked around anywhere to see if anyone has stolen my hubs - I tend to doubt that anyone would even want to say the things I sometimes say.
I'm sort of hoping that some of you guys who are making more, and have more to lose. . . .inadvertently knock out the problem for the rest of us.
Every time I read a Sunforged comment about internet matters - I realize how little I know. . . . .:=P
Cagsil, what are you saying? We just keep filing DCMAs? Do you think that will stop him?
My post was only for the purposes of showing that others are aware. That's all.
I don't know the exact process. I would think it would be a stepping process. Meaning, one step leads to another step, until you no longer have them.
You filing against the location is one thing. If not responsive, then you file with ISP? If the ISP does nothing, then I would suppose higher authority would be next, but could cost heavily.
At least that is my take on it.
Yes, you should continue to file DMCA with adsense and BlueHost (if BH is still their Host)
Probably, many HUbbers became lazy and did not file after the site seemed nullified, but one can still access the cache to show the evidence of theft and a history of theft should be documented in order to convince BlueHost to discontinue ALL services to the the thief.
Yes, they are. If anyone is wondering what to do next, send a DMCA form to email@example.com
Here's a link to a DMCA form people can use, created in Word:
http://www.dreamweaverresources.com/for … /index.htm
Grrrr.... I just found another one of mine I missed the first time, so I filed another DMCA. I was so shocked to see that site back up...
Well only one of mine was up there last night, but now all of my articles that were previously on 68articles are all back.
It looks like everyone else's are too.
Barstewards have got two of mine as well. Have just filed a DMCA.
Is there any point to these DMCAs? After all, the site came back up after only 2 days. Obviously the hosting service does not give a toss.
I did resend the DMCA and got the following response:
"This domain is not hosted with us. Here is the current nameserver information;
The IP address for their website is 184.108.40.206 Brinkster Communications. Please feel free to contact us again if we can be of further assistance."
I looked them up on www.whois.net and they were listed as being hosted by Bluehost. Perhaps whois.net listings aren't necessarily up-to-date.
I got the same. I guess send a message to the new host and keep cracking on the AdSense thing
What a Great Opportunity for Hub Pages to actually give the Internet Thieves a serious message!
These thieves are gaining access to our articles from here... nowhere else.. From within the site!
Most of us wish to continue to publish our original content here.. but until HP Actually take a more supportive and proactive stance and attack the scraping problems here.. they are effectively encouraging thieves like this to continue to steal new content before we even get it identified by the search engines!
There is a writing comp on at the moment.. Entirely New Material and able to be scraped by thieves that tie us up for hours filing DMCAs and continually having to check the duplication of our work!
Is management here going provide us with some realistic advice on the required actions from HP to Help - those that can help us to help the site... by writing and protecting our content so that won't be stolen?
Non Action Here Amounts Completely To: Apathy!
Apathy - Is when one has given up, or can't be bothered, or wrongly measures the factual value of a 'problem' as being of a higher value than the efforts required to remove the 'problem!'
A Well Quoted Example of Apathy Was: That Nero Fiddled as Rome Burnt! - The Fire Won!
So... I guess if we wish to enjoy the pleasures of Rome (as hubbers) then we need to once again attack the problem personally.. as it seems the standing ovation for the concert performance is perceived to be more important than attacking the thieves who are Stealing The Damn Seats!
So roll up the sleeves again and start filing more forms!!
- Amazing World we live in
- One Where Thieves Can Be Stopped, but Where Many Think... So What? Someone else can do it
OK Cool... Team Work AGAIN will do the job Again!
THX WriteAngled... Clearly BLUEHOST Are Sick of it Too!
Now We Collectively ATTACK the New Host! - AND The NEXT ONE.
AND HUB PAGES.... If You EVER Needed Legal Proof of Intent To Defraud... Now You Have It.... WHAT Are You GOING TO DO About It? This Group have in their possession 1000's of stolen articles.. They consider that content to be their own, as they continue to move that content to wherever they see fit! THAT Is The Problem! - And THAT Is the Fraud!
Because of the legal implications involved when it comes to copied content, especially regarding the legitimacy of our complaints, hubpages cannot act on our behalf. they can give us advice, but can't really do much more. those who work for hubpages who have had their own hubs copied can take action on their own behalf, but they cannot help us. this is because hubpages does not know, for a fact, that even I write original content. I could have stolen it all out of a book. in the dmca thing that you file, you must swear that your content is your own. hubpages cannot, however, swear under the penalty of perjury that my or your content is original work. only I can, only you can.
melbel you are 100% correct! I am the only person know the originality of my content.
Oh PLEASE.... Stop Pussyfooting Around with a Thief... Wake Up!! You Are Missing The Point that I was making! - Attack The Problem.. Head On.. Don't You Understand How To Trouble-Shoot a Business Problem?
What excuse will you make when the Site Has Not Only Lost all of Our Content.. But Also All of It's Credibility?
The 'Problem' That You REFER TO.. is solved with a Simple Executed DEED OF AUTHORITY TO ACT ON BEHALF OF THE WRITERS! - In a Specific Sense!
I Have 30 Years of Corporate Legal Experience.... Do You Want Me To Plan a Legal Action for those who don't know how to do it?
Please... Be Real... We Are Talking About Full Scale Theft...
This is the Fourth Time This Has Happened on This Scale since I've been Here - And Each Time A Few of Us have Solved The Problem for Everyone Here AND HP... So.. This is NOT a New Problem.. It Is Merely One Which Has NOT BEEN A Priority To the Site To Remedy! Okay? ... Where were you on all those occasions?
There are a hundred things that HP can Do.... Starting with a 2 second communication with All the people here who are worried about their work!!
- Are you telling me that that is beyond the management of any genuine company that relies the content and the writers?
- The Problem Is More Likely: That HP Actually doesn't KNOW What to Do about the problem.. which is BTW a threefold one! That may well be more accurate than you would wish to Have Known!
- You know, this is a thankless task.. I'm sick of not getting sleep and trying to sort out problems for others who don't respect my loyalty and commitment anyway!
@ Chamilj... Please THINK BEYOND the Box Before you show that You Can't...
I'm sure somewhere in your life someone has told you that Skinning Cats is a task that can be done in more than the way you may consider
I Posted a Phone Number... I have No Idea what your time is in the States... Mine is 4.00am ... Could someone there use their rights as a Copyright Owner and RING the Hosts... they will be receptive and won't Not Listen.. if you present the facts!
no, but they do know for a fact that hundreds have been stolen by one site. That's without having to bother with looking at any nitty gritty of individual content. Surely they can file a complaint & threaten legal action on behalf of their members?
can anything preventative be done to deter thieves - software or something?
If hubpages doesn't take action, I think confidence will be lost & more good hubbers will leave.
Can someone tell me what you're talking about? I'm kinda new and hoping that nothing bad happens to me.
It's A US Service On Seller... To me it looks like they are supported by either NameCheap or Host-Gator.. (only by the packages I see here)
Ring THESE GUYS If You are in the States....
Speak to the head of their legal Dept and advise them that they are going to get 500 DMCA's within the Next 24 hours!
Brinkster Communications Corporation
2600 North Central Avenue
Phoenix, Arizona 85004
Tina, thanks for posting this. When I checked last time, they didn't have any of my articles. Now they have several- off to file DMCA (never done that before). GRRRRR!
yep ALL my hubs are back on there
I'm going to contact google tonight. contacting their host is worthless, they'll just move again.
something I've found helpful in the past when my content has been copied is look up where some of there other content is stolen from and contact them.
I've never done this before, but I filed a DMCA through google (since the site uses adsense). Will that work?
Just saw your Brinkster contact info.. where did you get that info?
They are located in the right area to be the true hosts.
Write Angled got it from Bluehost... they Hate Mr 68
Address your emails to their HQ which is via Brinkster's Communications
So the email address is: firstname.lastname@example.org
Delivery to the following recipient failed permanently:
Technical details of permanent failure:
Google tried to deliver your message, but it was rejected by the recipient domain. We recommend contacting the other email provider for further information about the cause of this error. The error that the other server returned was: 550 550 5.1.1 <email@example.com>: Recipient address rejected: User unknown in relay recipient table (state 14).
ok no probs.. I'll find another one.. cheers
I did what WriteAngled did and emailed firstname.lastname@example.org, plus email@example.com for good measure!
Then hit them with this: firstname.lastname@example.org
Didn't you say that before?
ZZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzz sorri another allnighter
68articles is no longer hosted by BlueHost
the nameservers reflect the site "www.hostable.com" as the new host.
Since, no DMCA information is easily found I suggest using the 800 number above to find out how this site plans to react to finding out they are hosting a pirate site.
800 phone calls cost the owner money and this site looks like a small reseller they will probably react quickly especially if one points out these threads.
I just phoned this number. The person I spoke to didn't seem very sure of copyright, he said that the individual HubPages articles didn't say that they were copyrighted, so because they are on the Internet they are free to be posted elsewhere.
But he was talking to someone else on instant chat about 68articles while he was talking to me.
He said if the site comes down, it may not be until tomorrow.
He's invited people to email email@example.com to complain.
So we can flood them with emails or phonecalls, it's your choice.
Still, if the site gets pulled and he still has his Google account, he could set up somewhere else.
Oh, I told him to read the HubPages forums
It must have been wilderness he was chatting with. He was talking about it in the other thread, about Philip.
obviously, he is an idiot.
i wouldnt take his suggestion to email, i would guess that those will go right to the trash.
every 800 call costs money or deducts from the balance for the month, i think he should be literally paying for his lack of knowledge and unprofessionalism.
I'm not in the US, so I emailed firstname.lastname@example.org which is cited on their Contact Us page.
What's your time mate?
Yep they are resellers (look like one of HostGator's) and they will react positively if we each make the appropriate contact.
They are a Division of Brinksters Comms... The details including 0800 # I posted earlier.
- So there are 2 Phone numbers.. and double the opportunity to have 68articles taken down.
I wonder what his statutory registration details will identify with this host? - That's something else that HP could act on!
They might use the legal email address for known parties only. Has anyone tried email@example.com ?
I submitted 5 DCMA reports to Google. Maybe they'll lose their adsense.
A problem for some of us (I'm speaking of myself here) is that we don't have a clear enough concept of hosts, ISP's, and such. I have the guts to make a phone call, but I wouldn't know quite what to say. If someone could outline a script for me, with some added details that I might need to know, I would be happy to do it. I would love for one of you guys to write a Hub that would serve as a template for the future - i.e., what to say or write to whom at what level. Or point me to that Hub, if it already exists.
Okay - I just checked over there (68 a's). I have previously assumed that none of my articles were there, but some are, so I have reason enough to complain on my own behalf.
Okay, I filed a complaint with Adsense, and somehow I ended up getting two different DMCA forms to open up. (I'm not sure how it happened, because I had a whole bunch of windows open at the same time.) Anyway, I filed both of them. All of that was for just one article. I plan to do the same for all of my other copied articles later today.
I also sent an e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org, and I checked out the 68articles page on Facebook and sent a "report" form there. That did not offer a comment box for sending any additional text, so I just reported it as "Spam or Scam" because that seemed to be the closest - I mean, it is a form of a scam to say that they "invite" or "allow" authors to submit articles for publication, when that is not even close to the truth!
I just found an article of mine in 68articles. I just filed a DMCA and sent emails to email@example.com and firstname.lastname@example.org. Now I'm going to file a complaint with Adsense. I found so many articles and poetry copied from my friends here HP and they are not aware of this. I better let them know.
He is on Twitter as 68article
I am about send out a message on Twitter saying he's stealing our articles and ask people to retweet.
Yep.. Good Stuff.. It's Like Playing that Game 'Wackamole' - where those little mole things come up from out of the hole and you have to hit them on the head.. Only this time it is a Turkey that keeps popping up!! So.... Each Time this Turkey pops up.. We have to knock it back down again!
Good Work everyone... but keep filing your DMCAs.
And when he pops back up again... hit em on da head again!
'This Account Has Been Suspended' -
- That's what the host has done.. Taken Them Down!
- So yeah Tweet the thief for awhile, so everyone knows he is a Crook... what's he going to do? Sue Us?
For Him... ALL Publicity is Bad Publicity!
Good job everyone, I called this number 6:30 pm last night (888-725-2701) 24/7 - and they said that as long as we wrote an email already, they will look into it. I also send an email to email@example.com prior to calling them. I filed April 1 DMCAs, but of course the URLs changed since then again. Good to know it was suspended.
I think google have removed 68 from their index too. I did a search on both chrome and IE browsers and while it is still listed in the search results, both browsers couldn't find the webpage. (Not even the suspended notice that was there before.)
Im still seeing a account suspended page- but it looks abit different.
This one is Hostgator branded, so at least we know for sure who the reseller account was through for future reference.
Ok, Firefox is showing the hostgator page. But on my travels I found another site I think is run by the same twat - 68share.com.
Has the same adsense ID.
I hope he loses his account!
"I just phoned this number. The person I spoke to didn't seem very sure of copyright, he said that the individual HubPages articles didn't say that they were copyrighted, so because they are on the Internet they are free to be posted elsewhere."
If this happens again tell them that you do not need to leave a copyright notice for an article to be copyrighted.
You should also mention that since the music industry around the world banded together to protect music works from theft, we can now use the laws created to protect music to sue hosts, as well as file a DMCA complaint. Mention that you are going to file a cease and desist and that if the material is not removed within the time specified in the cease and desist notice they will be accountable for all legal fees and damages.
I have reported spam on all this guys facebook pages, and twitter page.
If you see any more of your duplicated work remember to send it to Google, get the guys adsense account banned!
Keep an eye on the url. I think it'll be back up within hours.
I think the guy running it is going to be shi**ing himself now because he has another huge site monetized with adsense - 68share. Probably all stolen software too.
by sunforged5 years ago
(create your DMCA quickly)http://www.devcredits.com/index.php?mod=dcma****The Adsense DMCA process seems to have a bug ****** Skip to process for legal notice to BlueHostDozens if not hundreds of individual Hubbers...
by Dale Hyde3 years ago
I wanted to share an email that I received four days after filing a DMCA complaint against copied material I found upon searching. This is not the first positive result I have had from various DMCA complaints...
by Audrey Selig5 years ago
There is so much of this going on that it may not be worthwhile to mention. Since I know that this site is not cooperative, I sent my DMCA complaint to Google. My hub is copied word for word with all the lovely...
by Thomas Swan2 years ago
So another "C" came up in the copied hubs section today. As usual someone had stolen one of my hubs.... words, pictures and all. I wanted to send them a DMCA complaint. However, there was:1. No "contact...
by agilitymach2 months ago
I just found that one of my Hubs was stolen in June 2014 and published in a magazine. I wouldn't have found out about it except that they have now put their magazine on-line. It was stolen by a slick looking...
by Ellen2 years ago
I'm very grateful to Hubpages for putting the little red C on our dashboards to warn us when our content has been copied.It didn't take me too long to hunt down the content thieves on a couple hubs and send out DMCA...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.