"Your recent question "Is HubPages becoming too nitpicky? It seems like everything gets flagged these days. What gives?" has been removed because it encouraged a discussion rather than a Hub or short answer. Surveys and poll-type questions do not belong in the Q&A section. To engage in a discussion or conversation, please post in the Forums section at http://hubpages.com/forum/, or for private conversation you can contact another Hubber directly from their profile page."
It seems my questions are getting flagged these days. What has happened to HubPages? Is this part of a crackdown from advertisers?
Google came down hard on many websites, including HubPages, due to being considered "spammy" sites, with little value.
It's been frustrating for many people, but it's a necessary thing.
I just had 2 questions rejected today. I know what you mean. Why bother have a Q and A if the answers are going to be too short or too long. They have to be perfect and it's tickin' me off.
Necessary my A**. Yes and no questions are ok. What's wrong with those?
What is necessary is for HubPages to try to recoup our ranking and traffic by limiting and removing spam and short, nonsensical Hubs.
I've had many questions closed on me too. I don't like it, but that's the way it goes. Maybe the question is better asked in the Forum. The Q/A feature has a lot of limitations, including only one answer per person.
I've kind of given up on that myself.
If enough people give up on it, maybe they'll just shut it down. One can only hope.
The questions are meant to be the sort of thing you could write a hub on. Seems clear enough to me. Not to ask for help using hub pages, bitch about hub pages, post long rants, etc etc.
No. It's part of HP's new TOS. The question is better suited to the forum. But I suppose you're seeing the irony in what it is you've asked.
I don't think our rules have changed too much recently (certainly not in the Q&A section), we're just getting better at enforcing them, and communicating the problems to users.
This happened to me too. I asked a question if people were participating in the April writing contest and my question disappeared.. just went to limbo or something... then came the notice that my question was best asked in forums, same as what you got.
They really need to start nitpicken the religious crap on here....
Absolutely kmackey32! Aren't those questions more of discussion questions anyways?
I think so and I hate them dicussions. Seems its always arguments of what religion is better....
I know. If you go on the Hopper, about 5 out of 10 hubs are Christian. And they are not original content, they are ripped straight out of the Bible. I'm really disgusted after 6 months of writing and no money. Even many of the hubs in the contest are full of graphs and maps, but are just about personal vacations, something listed as boring to readers in the first place and not encouraged as interesting content. There seems to be a double standard for a certain group.
Can anyone tell me what the questions thing is about? I haven't taken much interest but Hubpages seem serious about it. Is it supposed to be a rival to Yahoo questions? Or is it an SEO thing?
I thought the Question section was to be about a Question Asked that would inspire a Hub be written for the answer.
I just looked through the questions list and found this gem:
Is all the processed foods damaging our organ?
It made my day.
I wanted to alert an author here that her hub had been stolen by 68Articles. Since she had disabled the direct messaging facility, the only way I could attempt to reach her was by addressing a question to her.
However, the question has been wiped. Obviously, some subjective interpretation of what is or is not a question is more important to the petty bureaucrats running this site than the fact that someone was trying to help an author maintain her rights over her work.
This plus the banning of Pearldiver is the last straw. No more hubhopping. Let the paid lackeys clean up this site as far as I am concerned. I will not waste any more effort trying to help.
Pearldiver was banned?!
This site has gone bonkers.
Totally with you on the hubhopping thing. I don't get paid to hubhop, so I won't do it.
WriteAngled, this problem pops up in the forums from time to time, and I do wish HubPages would rethink the Q&A section - it lends itself to misunderstanding too easily.
The Questions section is NOT a place to ask simple questions of other Hubbers about Hubbing. It never has been. The place for that is in the forums.
The Questions feature is a way to ask a question to which you would like a long, thorough answer, preferably written as a Hub. Always has been.
I think the HP team has never paid much attention to moderating it, so inappropriate questions have been allowed - and that's now changing. But the rules haven't.
I can see why you used the section as you did and I would probably have done the same - let's hope the Hubber concerned read it before it was wiped! Maybe you could email the HubPages team and ask them to pass on a message?
As for PearlDiver - I saw him making nasty attacks on a couple of Hubbers yesterday, which I thought was out of character. I thought at the time, he's heading for a ban. Remember, most bans are only for a few days to give the culprit a chance to cool down - it's not permanent. You can only be banned permanently if you repeatedly offend, multiple times.
I did offer to do so, despite being told that our policy is fascistic.
I don't reckon that hubbers think you are fascistic- whatever they might say. They think you are their Mom (or maybe older sister) and are just downright unreasonable for complaining when they break their toys over the other kid's heads.
I think some Hubbers think of me as the evil stepmother, but some definitely think I'm "The Man." There are some pretty amazing conspiracy theories around myself and HubPages as a whole. I'm not whining about it. I signed up for it when I took this job.
(For the record, my mum thinks it's hilarious that a major part of my job has to do with rules enforcement, since I was... ahem... not the model child.)
What a thankless job moderating the forums must be.. I just wanted to say that I appreciate all the efforts you Maddie Ruud and the HP staff put in to make life easy and pleasant for everyone here!! Thank you Law enforcement officer !! lol
aha so you are getting your own back on us....... it is your mum's fault.
I have not yet gone through that email account for today. If you did subsequently offer to do this, than thank you; I will pass the details to you.
The first message I received was abrupt, hectoring, unpleasant and did not take any account of the circumstances nor make any such offers. It is hardly surprising I reacted in similar vein.
I will give you the benefit of the doubt and assume it was a poorly written message programmed into some computer some time in the past to be spat out automatically at offenders when a moderator's finger pressed the button.
I got my question recently removed too, but this discussion gave me quite a lift! Thanks for this useful advice!
I see a lot of questions that would belong on MyLot or Yahoo answers rather than here. I agree, they are meant to inspire hubs not ask a question that belongs on Dear Abby.
by Susannah Birch4 years ago
I haven't seen a thread on this (feel free to post the link if there is).Hubpages will soon be giving ad share for questions.From the Hubpages weekly newsletter:While some of these Questions are winning prize money, all...
by Midasfx6 years ago
I think it would be nice if we could earn money from our questions here on hubpages. Still with the 60/40 split just like on our hubs.The only thing I would think would be people posting too many questions, so maybe...
by Austinstar14 months ago
To date, I have been denied permission to ask and/or answer questions because of revenge? mark downs by disgruntled hubbers. I get blocked for a while, then un-blocked, then blocked again. Also some of my Q&As are...
by Rik Ravado6 years ago
The new Feed Facility (that I quite like) means I become aware of loads of really silly questions that new 'hubbers' are asking. Unfortunately I find myself replying with equally silly answers (I know its...
by Paul Maplesden3 years ago
All of us that have visited the question section know that much of the content there is of very questionable quality. It's difficult to see how many of the questions really contribute to the community or discussion on...
by Reality Bytes6 years ago
That Anthony Graber broke the law in early March is indisputable. He raced his Honda motorcycle down Interstate 95 in Maryland at 80 mph, popping a wheelie, roaring past cars and swerving across traffic lanes. Anthony...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.