Now that the general Hubpages population can join the Hubpages ad program I have to wonder, is it worth it? I have been with Hubpages about two months and have only gained a couple clicks on Adsense.
Do I have a better chance of making money from the HP program, or should I stick with Adsense and see how it works out for me?
I was one of the original nine beta testers back in January and February and if the Panda update had never happened, I'd be heartily endorsing the HubPages Ad program. My February earnings were up by 37% overall from January.
However, since the algorithm changes that Google applied in late February, I've found earnings on both programs have declined greatly. Compared to February, my AdSense is now down 80% and my HubPages Ad revenue is down 65%.
I think it's deceptive of HubPages to use the results the original group were seeing before the changes as the sales pitch to the rest of you to get you to join the program.
Why do you think it is deceptive? Do you not think that the relative increase (decrease) in income with/without Ad revenue is about the same before and after Panda?
If Hpads raised revenue before Panda I would expect it to do the same after Panda, and would even expect the percentage increase to be about the same. Total income may well be down now, but not as far as it would be without HPads. Or do you disagree?
I don't have any baseline stats by which to make a comparison anymore. I'm about to turn off the HubPages Ads for the entire month of May so I can get a clue as to how AdSense does without them. Ask me that question again in July or August.
relache, it's interesting that HP didn't drop as much for you after the change. It seems like I hear most people complaining about the loss of Adsense revenue, so the HP program doesn't seem that appealing at the moment.
The problem is that most of us joined the HP program right about the time of the Panda update. Everyone's Adsense income declined at that time - so for most of us, it's impossible to say how much of the decline was due to the HP program and how much was due to Panda.
The only way to check is to switch it off for a while and see whether (and how much) Adsense recovers.
You should also be sure to compare on an eCPM basis, which normalizes your earnings against traffic.
The Panda update might have also changed the distribution of your traffic and not only the total level, so it might not be a complete comparison, but assuming an overall lowering of traffic but similar distribution among your Hubs, an eCPM calculation might give some insights.
Jason, if I no longer get AdSense clicks for two months and lose my AdSense account (because Google closes it), that would be it for my HubPages account, too, right?
Since I can't speak on behalf of Google, I would contact Google and ask if your AdSense account would be in jeopardy if it didn't get any clicks for a while.
Oh, okay. Appreciate this suggestion. I'm also thinking maybe I really need to write some Hubs aimed at Google AdSense ads so that I have *something* coming in again to keep the account viable.
Jason, I just heard back from a PeggyK on the Google forum who is a Top Contributer saying, "I've never heard of anyone having their account disabled for inactivity, so that is unlikely to be a problem."
This is a relief to hear. Thanks for suggesting I ask!
It isn't, and it shouldn't be. You should be using the right metric, which is eCPM, and not total revenue. Even if you were to look at the latter, February is 10% shorter than January, the Panda update hit February 24th, and you enabled HubPages Ads around January 20th - maybe a per-day average of January 20th-February 23rd vs the first half of January might be more illustrative.
We have no control over how much traffic Google or other search engines send you. We have considerably more control over how much you can earn on each visitor you do receive.
Assuming your traffic is not seasonal, then testing AdSense-only and AdSense+HubPages Ads is probably a good idea. Comparing apples to apples (eCPM) would be the best way of evaluating the relative benefit of each approach.
My Hubpages program eCPM is 3X my eCPM on Adwords. Much more successful here.
Keep in mind that turning on the HubPages Ads does not turn off your Google Adsense. Although it might be true that you might have fewer Google ads due to the space taken by HubPages Ads.
I've turned Hubpages Ads on, so that I can have the best of both worlds.
It isn't an either or-- you can have both adsense and Hubpages. I have other blogs that are monitied with adsense and still get some adsense clicks from Hubs as well. The Hubpages program is like an added income stream from my hubs and frankly, is nicely making up for the drop in traffic I experienced after Panda. I'd say you have nothing to lose by signing up and seeing what happens
Tough question and I doubt it really has an answer.
For myself, adsense is down as a result of HPads, but I feel that HPads more than makes up for the loss. At the same time, however, adsense is also down as a result of Panda update and low traffic figures. How much decline is due to individual reasons I really don't know.
You may want to continue Adsense only for another month or so and get a better feel for what it will do. Then ad HPads and see if total income changes. It is really too early yet for you to have a good feel for adsense, and may be for another few months. You may even want to wait for your first payout before enabling HPads. Or you may want to play with it right now and see what happens. Your call.
Thanks for the quick reply. The fact that I am new to Hubpages is what makes me hesitant to try it out. Adsense is still slow for me, so I wouldn't really have any basis to compare the two.
It's too bad you can't enable it for certain hubs to compare those with hubpage ads vs. adsense ads.
Adsense/HpAds didnt balance out for me - so I went back to just adsense, but I enjoyed a higher average click than most...
BUT ...a very clear drop in amazon/ebay sales accompanied my personal trials with hpads. The flashier ads either
a) drive away traffic due to the unattractive, unfocused ads
b) attract exits to the ads
Either way, HPads decimated my amazon, sales came back the moment I turned it off.
Using HpAds or any rev program will be different for each user based on what type of traffic they attract. There is no blanket truths on how to monetize. Certain styles and topics will benefit more than others.
I've never enabled the HP program and my Adsense is almost the same as it was before the Panda squatted digested bamboo shoots all over HP. My Amazon sales are slightly higher, as a matter of fact. I don't know what to think!
Interesting, unfortunately as a resident of Colorado I am not able to use Amazon, I wish I could.
In my experience if you can't use amazon because of where you live, then write articles purely aimed at Adsense. If you do that then I think you may do well with the new ad programme.
The reason I say this is because I have written over 95% of my hubs aimed at Amazon sales. And although my revenue has dropped I continue to reach payout each month with it. My Adsense pre-algo change was just over the min. payout each month so it was never really that great. Since I joined the new ad programme my Adsense is less than half what it was from Hp's. This leads me to think that the new ad-prog doesn't work with Amazon based hubs and will only work on hubs specifically aimed at Adsense. I aim to continue with the ad-prog until I make payout, then revert to just using Adsense.
That's great to hear, Randy! Must be the type of traffic your hubs draw?
mmmm what to do .. what to do ?
I was looking forward to adding HP ads but there does seem some doubt. That said, I'm still only earning a few pence here and there so in for a penny ... here I go !!!
I just switched off HP ads, at least for the remainder of the month. It will be interesting to see if/how my AdSense/Amazon are affected.
I experienced steady earnings I just decided Id rather put all effort into Adsense at the moment even if they have some low paying ads
I'm not concerned about my Google Adsense revenue on hub pages going down because I haven't really made squat with it to begin with.
I just signed up for the hub pages ad program yesterday, it sounds interesting.
My Adsense money did go down, but the HP ads program is making more than I received from Adsense. If I add the 2 together, I am now making more.
A note to this though is with 60 hubs, I was only making $15/mo with Adsense alone previously. I wasn't a high earner with Adsense.
Adsense is now dead on Hubpages
You may as well get a few cents out of the ad program i.e. about $4 per 1000 impressions.
Overall, I haven't lost a dime joining the HubPages ad program. I am making what I did with AdSense having enabled it, despite traffic being down. I'm tinkering some of my hubs, and I, too, will most likely switch the program off for a month or so down the line to see how things stack up once I go through the chances to my hubs to make them better after the Panda update.
I would say, for people who earn little from AdSense or just here and there, the HP ad program is worth trying. It takes away from AdSense, but is a steadier earner.
Since joining the ad program, I have not seen much actvity on my Hubs. Granted, I do not have many, and I was not seeing traffic much before anyway. I don't think my topics are all that popular, and the SEO I tried to do didn't do much at all.
I might be a bad writer, I don't know. This is the first time I've tried to publish my own stuff.
I was not making much on Adsense, however, since I enabled the HPAds, I've seen it grow. Within three days I had made as much as I had with Adsense in the last month.
My humble opinion is that if the hubs are of quality content and visitors like them, over time HPAds will prove to be the better of the two.
The only thing that I don't like is to see my HPads earnings when I sign into my account, it may be childish, but I like to check on it every few days.
by Paul Deeds6 years ago
Tomorrow, March 3rd, we are excited to officially launch the HubPages Ad Program, a major new way for you to make money from your HubPages traffic. The HubPages Ad Program provides an optimized mix of premium ads from...
by kmackey326 years ago
Has anyone had any luck with this? I am thinking about turning it off as I have not made any adsense this month and I have only made a few bucks from hubpages.
by FootballNut19 months ago
I was wondering if Hubpages offer a revenue sharing HTML code that can be implemented into the hubpages members own websites.The Hubpages Ad programme seems to work better than google adsense in respect of how much can...
by Jasmeet Kaur2 months ago
My experience with google ad program is not good!! I am shifted back to hubpages earning program.After reading a post on hubpages that google ad program pays better than hubpages ad program, I deactivated my hubpages ad...
by Jason Menayan6 years ago
Hello everyone! We're happy to announce that we're opening up the HubPages Ad Program to all Hubbers ahead of schedule!All interested Hubbers are now eligible to participate in the HubPages Ad Program, an additional...
by Dedicated Content Curator6 years ago
So, I expected a lot of the Hubpages ad program, but I think I'm disappointed -v- what I think I could get from Google.... so switching it off for 2-4 weeks to try to do some comparisons.Anybody else done that? Anybody...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.