I have a hub that has been published for months, and had many views and comments. I recently was told by HP, that it had a broken link, so I fixed the link. Now the hub is in "submitted" section for 2 days and still pending.
Is this normal now to make any minor changes such as broken link to have your popular hub be unpublished for days before it approved?
Your Hub would not be unpublished just because of a broken link. Are you sure there wasn't something else wrong with it?
I send an email to Jason and still after days both hubs are in pending status! Are moderator so busy now a days?
Jason is not a moderator, he can't help you. The correct email is team@hubpages.
cookingdiva, you can go here to send them your querries..
Cooking Diva, other than an a broken link, were there other explanations by HP? A broken link is a warning other than an action to unpublish your hubs.
I had a broken link only yesterday, I fixed the error but the hub wasn't unpublished. As Marissa said there maybe something else wrong.
Now you have raised this in the forums Jason may see it and let you know the real reason. They don't normally unpublish hubs for broken links. How many links do you have in this hub, have you fixed the right one? You could try emailing them, but they are busy, have the advertisements been removed?
Hiya cookingdiva, I also have had lots of broken links in my hubs, but the hubs were not unpublished.. just asked me to fix them, and when I did, the hubs were ok. If your hub was unpublished because of a broken link, it must be mistake. Go email HP and ask the moderators what was wrong with your hub. Also, if your hub was unpublished, HP should have emailed you why it was unpublished in the first place. Good luck and let us know what happens.
We don't moderate Hubs for broken links.
cookingdiva: I would follow others' advice here and reread the emails that were sent to you. I can't help you on the Kate and William Hub because it looks like you've deleted it.
Yes, I never had problem with broken links or minor fixes before, published hubs were all stayed published. This is first time so I asked, if there were any new changes that I did not know about.
It is not Kate and William hub. It is learning about cookware brands. It had only broken link, and I fixed it. I have fixed broken links before and hubs were okay but not this time.
I have 2 hubs pending right now for days. (both for different reasons, I added a bulk of new writing on other one)
Cookingdiva, there are two options: either you're missing something, or the moderator made a mistake. As Jason says, a broken link is not a valid reason to unpublish a Hub. A prohibited link is.
Did you get an email notifying you about the Hub being unpublished? Can you quote what it said for us?
Is the black warning still visible on the Hub? What does it say? Are there any links you can click on for further information?
If you've checked all that and there's definitely nothing else mentioned, then send an email to team@hubpages, because it's a moderator mistake and they need to look at it.
I never got an email from HP about broken link, I saw that when I logged in my account and only thing I did is fix that link and clicked "done editing". That is all. I have done that in past without no issues, I am not sure this time.
There were no other warning and it has been pending for 3 days and other hub which I added new text (only text, no links) is pending for over a week.
This simply does not make sense. I have been trying to follow rules but this is very annoying to say the least.
Thanks for the explanation, that makes more sense now. This is a totally different situation.
Your Hub wasn't unpublished by a moderator. What has happened is that you've fixed a broken link and clicked "done editing", and instead of saving as normal, it's been automatically unpublished.
Did you get any kind of message when you clicked "done editing"?
As Misty said, if that Hub ever had warnings on it before (for prohibited links, too many Amazon ads etc), then it may have had a flag added - which means every time you make even a tiny change, it has to go through the submission process again.
It sounds very much like that is what has happened to your Hub. I assume you've already emailed team@HubPages to ask them to look into it?
The problem is not a broken link. If you didn't get an email about what the problem is and why your hubs are being moderated before publication, well then you need to contact support and ask them to send it again.
An unpublished hub does remain pending for a few days. I had one unpublished for duplication. So, I re-wrote it and re-submitted days ago, and it is still pending.
If the hub has ever been penalised or unpublished in the past, then republished after edits, any further edits can result in the hub being unpublished until it is reviewed manually.
I may be missing something here, but I have seen this happen to others in the past (it may even have happened to me on one or two occasions, but I am not certain).
I must agree that from what you say in this thread it sounds like a newbie moderator's mistake though
Thank you for seeing both side. Like I said I found broken link issue when I logged in to "my account" section. No email was sent and there has been no other notes/warning.
Possibility of moderator mistake seems likely right now. I hope to get this resolved soon.
by Ray Choiniere aka Cagsil5 years ago
Hello,I try not to make waves with "How Hubpages Operates" and I am not sure if this singular problem is having a huge effect or not.But, I've noticed that many hubs I had connected to other hubs via...
by Marisa Wright4 years ago
My account is showing several broken links which are not broken. They are all links to other Hubs.
by Mike Russo19 months ago
Have you had this happen to you? I searched for the highlighted broken link but I could not find one. So how do you clear the notice?
by katiem25 years ago
Don't let this happen to you.As most of you know my Mother is is failing health and I've been traveling a lot trying to take care of my Mom, spend as much time with her as possible and get back home for my kids, busy to...
by Eric Dockett15 months ago
I just found a (!) warning on one of my Hubs, due to two broken links to my own Hubs. Clicking on the links led to 404 error pages. But the pages the links were supposed to go to still exist, and are still published and...
by Asep Muklis4 years ago
I'd submitted three articles to day but none of them, published. Why?
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.