So, since Panda (or since the HP ads thing came out and I signed up for it... I can't really tell which given I'm mainly too lazy to look very hard into it)... my earnings have all transferred to HP ads and only a trickle of Adsense.
Do HP ads populate INSTEAD of adsense, but not totally (since I am still getting that trickle)? lol. Do I have to pick one or the other?
If so, which one pays better?
I find HP ads much better than adsense. However that's probably because due to the topics I'm writing on (mostly pure science), google struggles to find ads that are relevant to my content - hence no clicks. HP ads pays per impression, so I don't need to worry about trying to attract more relevant ads or make people click on them.
Basically, it depends on your hubs. If adsense works for you, you'll probably earn more with them. Otherwise, HP always gives trickle income, so long as you have traffic.
I have been using HP ads since the beginning. I make more money with HP than Adsense. I have made more in three months with HP than I did in a year with Adsense.
HP Ads program is only good, if you have high volume. You could get a mix of adsense, but it will mostly be that trickle, while HP Ads are active.
If you were to turn off HP Ads, then your adsense is likely to go up, because it dominates ad spacing. Thus, more ads.
Which is better? I cannot say, because I don't use HP Ads, because my traffic isn't high enough. This has been proven by my testing of HP Ads on my hubs. It crushed my adsense, but didn't make up for that loss.
Just my experience with it.
I agree with Cagsil. In my own research, if you have high traffic coming to your hubs, the HP Ad Program will make you the most money on average. You'll still earn some AdSense revenue but nothing like it was pre-Panda.
I know I'll be waiting for the holiday season to come around as that's when I make the most money with AdSense to see how the HP Ad Program effects the outcome.
I vote for Adsense myself. I had HP ads on for a very short time and it killed my Adsense earnings. As soon as I turned it off, my Adsense earnings went back and now they're better than ever.
Not a fan of HP Ads..I guess some people like the program but it's not for me.
I switched my ads off for two weeks in May but my Adsense was still pants so I switched them back on again!
Currently I'm earning about $10 a month on Adsense and about twice that on HP ads. Which is rubbish considering that pre-Panda, I was within a whisker of making monthly payouts on Adsense alone
I have very low traffic and found that switching off Hp ads gave me better Adsense. I also don't like the way HP ads are going with their pop up that's not a pop up thing.
I've been signed up for HP for just over five months, but with HP ads, I've earned already half of the total amount I've earned on Adsense in just over one month.
Also, the HP payout threshold is lower so I'll see that money before I'd ever see a payout from Adsense. Finally, I haven't seen any decrease in my Adsense numbers since signing up for HP Ads.
Hope it's okay if I bump this thread, as I have the same question as Shades and would love to hear more people's experiences with turning the HubPages Ad Program on or off, especially people who are or were making monthly payout with Adsense.
Before when I've switched HubAds off my AdSense has been so low I've chickened out and turned HubAds back on. However, this month, I've kept them 'off'and I've had some really good AdSense days and it looks like for me AdSense is now better.
Although Panda has reduced my traffic the CTR on AdSense is sometimes quite high and value of clicks is good too. The other reason I favour AdSense is I can track the performance of each Hub and also use AdSense on other sites such as Blogger.
One advantage of HubAds is earnings per day are very steady but seem to be lower than when the scheme started. The other issue is having separate accounts for each user. My secondary user only earns a few dollars a month so payout takes a long time. I prefer to have all my earnings in one pot (regular payouts).
I use Hubads and this month I am running $6.40 (H) + 0.20 (A)= $6.60 per thousand views.
That's just what I am getting, obviously. Adsense was running under $5 so I will be sticking with Hubads.
Of course Hubads run in most of the Adsense places, so you don't get the same Adsense results with it turned on. But I hope people are comparing total earnings, not just adsense, in making decisions.
$14.00 is my record for a day on adsense.
.80 cents is my record for a day on HP Ads.
It's probably a fools bargain to run HP ads, but it's what I'm doing. I like to KNOW that I'm getting something every day for this. With adsense sometimes I go days and days with nary a penny. Nowadays, a $3.00 adsense day is a good day.
I don't know what the best thing to do is, it's an evolving card game, and Google keeps it's cards close to it's chest.
HP Ads is still bringing more in for me than Adsense ever did. I'm going to stick with it for a while.
I earn nothing on Adsense most of the time. HP Ads earnings were falling consistently and ended up at about a quarter of what they paid at the start - not that it makes much difference in real terms. At the moment, I have HP Ads turned off, because I am embarrassed by how trashy they make hubs look.
How different are they from google ads? I can't say I have noticed....
I had HP ads on for one week when I received an invite during the 2nd wave but I thought the earnings were a little less than my Adsense and wanted to experience the high spikes I always get with Adsense. Plus HP ads were making my Adsense earnings drop
Surely people compare CPM when making this decision? Because liking to see an adsense spike is a weird thing to lose money over in the long run.
All of my personal sites run Adsense, so no point changing HP
Since I continued to make my monthly Adsense payout after the Panda incident, I have not tried the HP program. I've already made payout this month and would like to make a comparison between the two programs.
However, this month is on a pace to be my best Adsense month ever, so I will not be experimenting with the HP ads any time soon. Though it does make me wonder what the difference would be.
my vote might go for HP ads since there is less 'revenue sharing' ( a nice term for taking too much of your revenue IMO )
I keep hearing people talk about pop ups. I guess this happens only in the states as no matter which person's hubs I am reading I get no pop ups ever. I wonder if pop ups would go away if people switched to a medium setting of commercialism. You can set each individual ad as high medium or low level of ads onthe page. Or does that not make a difference in U.S. to pop ups?
AdSense ads are almost always on topic with my Hubs. HP Ads used to be, but now are not. If I write a Hub about road food, why do I want some ad on that Hub about acne treatment or IKEA furniture?
I've had a first payout from HP, and my second is whispers away, but as soon as I get that second payout, I'm going back to AdSense.
especially that there is so many subjects that HP does not accept that it is so hard to see any earnings...why? because the subjects that HP accept does not interest buyers at all! Adsense is much much better!
right now,HP ads are earning me three time more each month than adsense...
by Sherry Hewins7 days ago
A few days ago, I noticed that a lot of people were talking about changing from HP Ad Program to Google AdSense. I had tried that a few years ago, but switched back pretty quickly because I earned better with HP....
by Sally Gulbrandsen6 days ago
Feeling slightly apprehensive and even a little guilty for having done so! Do HubPages earn a share of my Adsense earnings and what would the effect be if everyone switched to Adsense?
by Bema Self16 months ago
First, please forgive me if this has been asked a hundred times already. I've tried searching through the forums, but without a better search feature, it's difficult to find out if someone has already asked about the...
by Mike Russo4 years ago
Is google adsense only paying for clicks and not impressions? My adsense earnings have almost gone down to nothing. Has anyone else experienced this?
by Nathan Bernardo4 weeks ago
Some people have said they've turned off HP Ads and just use Adsense and actually make more money from Adsense. I'm considering trying that out and was curious how much more some of you are making just through Adsense....
by Whitney6 years ago
For those of you how received a full month of payment, or close to it, for HP ads, did you notice any changes in your Adsense earnings for the month of March?I did!!! Bad!!!My average earnings for Adsense went from...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.