I have tested HubPages ads and saw that it lowered my Google AdSense CTR by a LOT. That said, obviously I started making money with the HubPages ads. Since, in the past, AdSense was my breadwinner across my hubs and personal blogs, I just decided to go with that, so I removed my hub ads. I may reconsider, but I need some perspective.
Which scenario is most true for you:
A: With both HubAds and AdSense enabled, I earn more than I did before (with just AdSense.)
B: With both HubAds and AdSense enabled, I earn about the same as I did before (with just AdSense.)
C: With both HubAds and AdSense enabled, I earn less than I did before (with just AdSense.)
it's not possible to tell since HP ad started just after adsense Panda slapped us.
Google traffic is much lower for me so HP ad is making me money right now
The same happened when I had HP ads on, so I thought I'd turn them off for a month to see what went on with AS without the HP ads. The AS went up substantially. My "challenge" is that I turned off the HP ads after the additional ones had been added. So I don't know how I'd do with the extra ones.
When I had both enabled, it was C for me. AS looked like it was going up slowly, but I have reason to think it may never have been going to go to where it was before. Problem was, HP ads had gone down to only about $2/$3 and change a day, and at that rate I was going to be "REALLY C" (earn even that much less than I'd been earning before).
Other complicating factor: Subdomains came out after I turned off HP ads.
Over the last few weeks with AS only my AS daily averages are still in a range that's a fraction of before. At the rate I was earning on HP ads when I turned them off, if I take a chance of letting my AS go back down to under a dollar day (or a dollar a two a day) that would mean I'd either be equal or less than what I am this month (which is "way less" than I did pre-Panda).
So, if that's the still the daily averages I'd be getting from HP ads, going with HP ads could mean guaranteeing myself of earning that fraction of pre-Panda earnings. With the present creeping AS ads only I'm not sure they won't go up. Neither do I know that if I use HP ads again now, my AS still won't creep up (I did see a couple/few $5 days before turning HP ads off) or HP ads won't be higher than that $2/$3 a day they'd dropped to before I turned them off.
I "sacrificed" about a hundred dollars a month from HP ads (plus or minus) in order to see what AS would do. Subdomains happened, so now I may have to choose to (perhaps/perhaps not) sacrifice the monthly AS to see a) how HP ads would do now, and b) how much/whether AS continues to creep up (and how high on average).
I'm going to do that, but I want to wait and let the AS go up some more this month before doing it.
Thanks for your responses. Still trying to figure out if switching to HubAds is a viable option. Lisa, let me know how your switch does!
by Marisa Wright5 years ago
I switched off HP Ads one week before the end of April (I was going to wait till the end of April, but had to go away for a few days so did it early).I've now compared the first three weeks of April (with HP Ads...
by Suramya.K5 years ago
I just de-activated my HubPages ads program and I was wondering if someone has any experience to share. Did your AdSense revenue increase after de-activating HP ads?
by Ben Guinter5 years ago
I'm curious if anyone has tested by a month to month basis whether or not you make more with Adsense alone or with HP Ads?It's impossible to do a true split test, since each month will be different, but I'm curious to...
by Elsie Nelson5 years ago
I will admit right off the bat I don't think my comparative studies between having HP ads on versus off have been very scientific. However, I am NOT impressed with my earnings when I have HP ads on. What I...
by Dr. John Anderson6 years ago
I think it is related to images being used for the HUB ads and Google ads. When I turned off the Hub ads my adsense revenue rose significantly. I think it is because the block of adsense ads to the right of the column...
by Shadesbreath5 years ago
So, since Panda (or since the HP ads thing came out and I signed up for it... I can't really tell which given I'm mainly too lazy to look very hard into it)... my earnings have all transferred to HP ads and only a...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.