When a Hub author selects "Comments must be approved before they appear" in their comments capsule, you as the commenter don't have the opportunity to preview or edit your comment once you click "Submit".
You do have that opportunity when the author doesn't select that option.
It would be good to have that flexibility of review under all circumstances. I've made plenty of errors, or had second thoughts on comments I've made, and then clicked "Submit", thinking I'd get a chance to review and possibly change my comment.
We don't get any warning that a Hubber has this feature enabled.
So, please, either give us a warning or enable an edit function.
I guess I have only posted on Hubs where comments had to be approved. -- I was not aware that the editing feature was possible for comments on other Hubs.
I'm not sure what the default comment capsule's features are when you join HP. Perhaps the default is that you will allow comments on your Hub only after you approve them. It's been a long time since I've been a newb! And, I don't have any secondary accounts.
But I'm surprised that you haven't experienced that ability to edit one of your comments before it evaporates into the ozone. You get five minutes to fix it.
I agree. I always check my comments carefully but I’m sometimes surprised when I actually see them displayed on the screen and realize that I didn’t express something very well. I would love to be able to edit the comments instead of immediately seeing them disappear for approval.
I may have misunderstood what you meant originally. oops - oh, well.
My misunderstanding probably came from the fact that I don't comment as much as I should () and had not noticed the correlation between the edit function (which, yes, I have seen) and the author's choice of pre-approving comments or not.
I do still like your suggestion, though!
That's odd. Is this a new development? I'm sure I've edited comments in the past after getting a message that my comment might not be visible until the author has approved it.
I don't see the logic of blocking edits. If the message doesn't appear until it's been approved, that will nearly always be after the expiry of the 5-minute editing window, so it doesn't allow people to game the system.
I have the "must approve" setting on my hubs. I don't want spammers to get free temporary exhibition space!
I noticed that when I went to comment on your Hubs.
Off the topic a bit here, but I find that refusal to show a comment as made is kind of, well, not too friendly. I understand it when someone is writing controversial Hubs (it's a way of deflecting flaming stuff) or Hubs that are only there to make sales (it's a way of not getting into a conversation when you only want to make bucks).
But your Hubs are entirely engaging and scream out for conversation. If you find a spammer or scammer who makes a comment you don't like, then just deny the comment; meanwhile, please open up your engaging topics for all of us to put in our two cents or pence. Love your stuff.
by Sid Kemp3 years ago
Hi Hub Techies!I'm running IE 9 on Windows 7 Ultimate, SP 1.This is a very precise situation:In this situation:1) I write a comment on a hub.2) The hub author has organized comments in reverse chronological (newest at...
by Liz Elias4 days ago
So, I've always thought it was the polite thing to do to reply to commenters, and thank them for their time and input, and I've made an effort to do so consistently.However, I'm wondering if this is now being...
by Jackie Lynnley9 months ago
I got a message to check my comments and was sent to my Tom Dooley hub and I cannot see any comments there although there should be some!How can this be my problem? I have nothing to do with whether comments are showing...
by Bev11 days ago
I just notice that a comment was approved on one of my hubs on Feltmagnet. It said "Status: Admin Approved. ip: 22.214.171.124". That's not me. I have all my hubs set so that I have to moderate...
by Marina15 months ago
Happy Thursday, everyone! In August we pre-announced a new tool that fixes common spelling and grammatical errors across the site. Today, Editbot, the first iteration of the tool, is live on a small percentage of Hubs...
by Nathan Bernardo2 years ago
I notice sometimes, it seems, I can edit or delete a comment I've made on the forums, and then other times I can't. Is there a reason for that? Edit: I'm editing this post 2 hours after I posted it, for instance. So,...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.