This is just a FYO post really, but for the second time I have received a counter-claim through the Google DMCA notice from a Chinese site.
The first time, someone here pointed out that what they replied on this form, in Chinese, actually said something to the effect that they apologised and would remove offending material.
Google apparently doesn't bother to use their own translate service, and see the returned form as a counter-claim, requiring your having to pay a lawyer to take the matter further.
On this second form I received, Google have more or less they are washing their hand of the whole affair, because as far as they are concerned this returned form is a counter-claim.
It isn't. It is a language problem. But this is something that could effect all of us.
I have replied to Google, but don't actually expect them to pay any attention as they did say they were waiting to hear from my legal representative.
Trouble is, the site replied that they would take the offending material down immediately, and haven't.
Thanks for reaching out to us.
We have received the DMCA counter notification provided at the bottom of this email in response to the complaint you filed with us. As described in 17 U.S.C. 512(g), by this e-mail, we are providing you with the counter notification and await your notice (in not more than 10 days) that you have filed an action seeking a court order to restrain the counter-notifier's allegedly infringing activity. If we do not receive such notice from you, we will not remove the AdSense publisher from our program.
If you have any questions please contact our DMCA agent at 650.214.4053.
The Google Team
email@example.com to firstname.lastname@example.orgReply - More info Sep 20Options ▾
AutoDetectedBrowser: Internet Explorer 8
http: // edu.sina.com.cn/en/2011-08-20/192162224.shtml。
http:// www. 360doc.com/content/11/0821/12/7093384_142129429.shtml
I don't know what I am going to do, if in a few days, this site still carries my content.
Last time it was taken done straight away, but this one is still live. I put the a space after the http bit to deny them a live link.
This is absolutely absurd. I'm sure Google is completely aware that legal proceedings would cost far more than any damages awarded.
It is a simple matter of hands being washed, I'm afraid.
I have just received another response from Google, where again another Chinese site has used the counter-claim notice but put on it (in Chinese) "sorry, we'll remove offending material", or words to that effect, and they have indeed taken their article down.
One from yesterday is still up.
Is this a scam, Chinese sites using the counter-claim notice perhaps knowing that most people won't involve lawyers, and so they get away with it?
Or is it a genuine language problem with some sites hitting the wrong button?
I have been following this, and I am so upset and disgusted at how this is affecting you, Izzy!
Is there any place on the original DMCA form that you file where you can leave a comment? to alert G in advance as to what might happen? (I don't mean the DMCA's that you have already filed, but any in the future.)
I would love to see some sort response to this thread from people who know the law. I'm not certain that a lawyer would have to be involved, but I could be way off-base. But even if you can be your own legal representative, I don't think it's right that you should have to do that, in view of the information you have provided about this situation.
You know, there maybe is - you get a space to say what part of your article or site has been copied, don't know if they would accept a note in there saying that Chinese sites issue counter-files with a message in Chinese saying they will delete.
I don't think I'll bother issuing any more against Chinese sites though, if the Google algo was working right they should be able to see the dates of publication which ends any argument.
Also, I wonder about contacting Google's "DMCA agent" at the phone number they gave? Could you do that via Skype or some other cheap method?
Izzy, what a terrible situation. I found another person complaining of the same issue on reddit - his entire site was copied, and there is a link to his issue here:
http://www.reddit.com/r/WTF/comments/e3 … it_500000/
One guy recommends seeing if the proof of service on the counterclaim is messed up (I don't know what a "proof of service" is - do you?). If that "proof of service" is not right, then you can notify google that the counter-notification is bad and get them to take down the site or turn of the google ads.
I hope you can get Google to pay attention to this. If all a plagiarizing site has to do is file a counter-claim, then there will be no stopping content thieves.
That link was really interesting, thanks
Unfortunately, I am just a writer like yourself and not terribly technically minded to know what they are all talking about.
I just don't think Google cares about small-fry like us. Probably those Chinese sites were getting millions of hits from inside China and making Google loads of money, while mine is hardly getting any visitors at all, thanks to the Chinese sites being above mine in Google search.
Here's what I am up against - http://www.google.co.uk/search?sourceid … eal+names.
Oh, Izzy, I am so furious!
I followed that link and couldn't find your article at all.
Then I put quotes around the search term to narrow it. That allowed your article to "rise" to the bottom of page 3!!!!
At the bottom of page 1 (on the narrowed search), there was a link to an article about how some articles had been removed (from SERPs) in response to a DMCA complaint. Of course, when I checked out that article (on ChillingEffects), they were talking about your complaint. But that still didn't allow your article to be found where it should have been - at the top of page one!!
That is one of the problems with having a slapped domain, I'm afraid. I'm glad you saw my problem, all the same.
I've issued DMCAs to every site that has that text. I did that a few days ago. I have a feeling that nearly all the ones I am seeing now are new sites as the whole of China seems to have claimed that article as their own.
What a pity I am not getting the views
It is simply outrageous. If Panda was supposed to stop things like this, then it has been an abysmal failure. I couldn't get your result on the first page until I put the search statement in quotes.
I truly hope that the rest of the DMCA's result in the takedown of the plagiarizing sites.
I won't matter anymore.
I just check the same search string in quotes in GoogleUK, Google.com and Google.cn and each have over 500 exact match results.
I am not chasing that many up. They can keep it if it means that much to them.
Over to Google to lift the slap.
Edit: I already filed about 40 DMCAs and got a couple of sites before that to take the stuff down. It is growing each day.
by IzzyM5 years ago
One of my newer hubs was copied by a Chinese site and ranked higher than mine in Google search results. It was a university, and I wrote to them threatening them with a DMCA and they complied and took their copy...
by Kylyssa Shay17 months ago
A few of my hubs have been copied by a site hosted by GoDaddy. I looked up their page about copyright infringement and something about the DMCA wording and the way that the counter notice was worded made me a little...
by Lori J Latimer17 months ago
Perhaps this is old hat and I didn't read the memo, but just wanted to let you know (I informed HubPages) that web host service dot org has hacked HubPages. http : // webhostservice . org/ They have inserted their url...
by Janis Leslie Evans8 days ago
I'm having a difficult time locating an email address to submit copyright infringement to Google. I found a site called Lumen but it was very involved and confusing, asking for a lot of information about the thief I...
by Glenn Stok20 months ago
Do you have stolen hubs on sites hosted by WholeSale Internet, Inc.? I have found that they refuse to obey DMCA takedown notices and the copyright agent hides behind his secretary. I never can get passed the...
by Kylyssa Shay2 years ago
I filed a DMCA report for a page that copied my hub. The hub existed as a lens since 12/12/10.The content is obviously and clearly copied and even mentions that it was taken from Squidoo at the top. Yet Google rejected...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.