jump to last post 1-44 of 44 discussions (173 posts)

Am I the only one left who has been Google slapped?

  1. IzzyM profile image85
    IzzyMposted 4 years ago

    Everyone I know here seems to have their Google traffic back. I don't know about Randy, he hasn't posted recently.
    I am taking a long hard look at my writing, and I guess it falls at every hurdle, somehow.
    Yet when I search Google for many topics, I see first page results that I should be able to beat easily, because the topic has not been well-researched, contains infactual information and is badly written, not to mention copied from reliable sources.
    Some of those front page results are from other hubbers, who have written hubs that could have been written better by a 10 year old.
    What is wrong here?

    1. Dorsi profile image90
      Dorsiposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Izzy, how much has your traffic declined and when did it start declining? I got Google/Panda slapped bad but have recovered. I have noticed another dip though in the last few weeks.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        My traffic has declined now to July 2010 levels, when I had been here 9 months, and had very little traffic to speak of, and a fraction of the hubs I have now.

        I was never one of those hubbers who came here and found instant traffic.

        Round about July 2010 I learned how to write for search engines, and saw my traffic levels soar right through until February, 2011 when Panda hit.

        Even so, I saw a 50% decline in traffic that slowly rose throughout spring and summer.

        Then subdomains were brought in and I saw a huge rise followed by an almost total collapse on August 10th 2011.

        I should probably shut my mouth at this point, because there are those that would say I have many hubs under my belt which are frankly embarrassing. And they may well be right.

        I find the whole field of marketing to be embarrassing.

        We rave on about products we have no experience of, but you know, you have to be rich to be able to afford to buy and try everything.

        That said, I have never promoted any products that a lot of people have described as a rip-off.

        I do actually check these things, even though I have not bought or tried them.

        So it is not my marketing skills (or lack off) that are held up to public scrutiny, but something else.

        I know not what. I write well enough to correct other people's errors, but still Google hates me - why?

        1. FloraBreenRobison profile image60
          FloraBreenRobisonposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          I wish I could help you but  I have no idea why. As someone who joined after Panda, I simply can't fathom why some people are being hit more than others. My guess as to other people are, like CMHypno below, there are indeed others  who haven't recovered but don't go in the forums.

    2. Winterfate profile image99
      Winterfateposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      No, IzzyM, you are not alone. I'm also in the club, and I'm pretty sure a few more Hubbers are as well.

      Nothing I'm doing seems to be working. It's maddening, but on a positive note, this situation has motivated me to actually go and write that fantasy story I've always wanted to write. smile

      Here's to hoping that we get out of the hole soon. smile

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Oh well done you on that writing. I keep wanting to, but I am far too lazy!

        Sorry to hear about your traffic too. My six months is almost up, maybe it will return on its own, who knows?

        1. Winterfate profile image99
          Winterfateposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          My story is now at 16 pages. I'm determined not to get lazy this time. I understand where you're coming from, since my poor discipline in writing is what keeps me from writing anything longer than a short story. smile

          But, you could try what I'm doing: Write for one or two hours a day, no matter how much or how little results from it. Little by little, you can get it done! big_smile

    3. girlgonestrong profile image59
      girlgonestrongposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      The stuff I'm trying to rank is improving position and traffic, but my Adsenes CPC values have gone down significantly.  I've made changes to how things are displayed, removed ads that are underperforming, and instituted new traffic measures and now have to wait and see if the changes take.

      As to your Hubs lacking in rank, a lot of people here don't understand SEO at all.  You can't just put up some good content and hope that Google "likes" what you have to say and pops you to the #1 spot.  Content structuring counts so where you place your keywords in the text count.  Did you bold/italic the keyword in the content somewhere?  Is the keyword in the first/last paragraph?  Other things, which you have no control of on Hubpages, are important too.  This includes the Title Tag and H1 tags.

      Finally, the biggest factor about ranking is backlinks.  You have to build backlinks to your content to rank.  If Google has to choose between your well-written content with zero backlinks and someone else's content on a different site with 150 backlinks....the other site is going to get picked.  You don't hear a lot about backlinks here on hubpages.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I think that's a bit presumptious of you to assume I had no idea about SEO. Many hubbers are very well-learned in this area. Where did I talk about rank? I assume you mean page rank which has everything to do with number of backlinks and not content. Most of my hubs are optimized thank you very much, and not only that, they did exceptionally well before I was viciously slapped down by Google on the 10th of August 2011. I had many many hubs in the #1 spot on Google for their keywords, and have lost the lot.



        If you hang around to learn, you will find that Hubpages frowns upon what they term excessive and spammy backlinking, and will unpublish hubs that show this, as well as kick the user off the service.
        150+ backlinks has to be spammy!

        They prefer you wait for natural, organic backlinks to come, and they will, although doing a little backlinking yourself is OK too, just not going overboard.

        Many hubs have done exceptionally well in the past, based on well-written content and the power of the Hubpages platform, and as far as I can see, nothing has changed there.

      2. Aficionada profile image92
        Aficionadaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Six days in with two Hubs, and this is your contribution to this thread started by one of the best Hubbers here? Have you done any background reading at all about this situation and the issues discussed here?

        I thought I had seen just about everything from know-it-all newbies, but this is waaaayyyy on up there, and I can't tell whether I'm gasping from shock or from laughter.

        1. IzzyM profile image85
          IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Thankyou Aficionada!

          I've no doubt girlgonestrong does know what she is talking about for 'out there on the web' but not for here on HP.

          1. Aficionada profile image92
            Aficionadaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            You are probably right, Izzy, and you are being much kinder to her than I was.  I should probably modify my scorn or backtrack a little.  But it certainly did not appear that she has read the entire thread.  And she certainly could not know much about your account or situation! 

            She doesn't seem to know that you wrote a terrific Hub suggesting some of the better ideas that she mentioned in her post (or maybe that one has been moved?) - the one about on-page optimization.

            1. IzzyM profile image85
              IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

              It's still there! Thanks for that smile

        2. Jean Bakula profile image97
          Jean Bakulaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          It is clear that a huge percentage of hubbers are newbies if they are giving you advice on SEO Izzy. It amazes me that people don't even bother to look at your account and see your accomplishments before they write. I was finally seeing decent traffic in Oct and Nov, even half of Dec, and now it's way down. I think I'm a decent writer, and after 15 months never even got nominated for a hub nugget or had my presence acknowledged in any way. Then somebody writes a hub about a recipe or how they give their dog a bath, and they win them. Maybe I'm feeling pissy, or over thinking things, but I read a book sometimes to have material for one of my hubs. Everyone dissed Helium, but I wrote 10 pieces there and at least several of them were purchased. You have to be a favorite here and it's to the point I haven't been writing as much. I have my book to market, and am exploring other sites.

          1. IzzyM profile image85
            IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            Traffic must be down across the board, or else we wouldn't have been given the advice to 'spring clean'.

            Even the success stories are down, most of them though I don't see any of the posting to complain. Probably warned against it.

            http://hubpages.com/success/

            Jean don't get too down about things. You had a traffic rush at the best time of the year. Don't forget that January is normally quieter anyway.

            As for HP accolades, sorry but they don't pay the bills either, so I wouldn't worry about them!

            I wouldn't even worry about favoritism here, what counts is search engine traffic.

            Although it is true that some of the favorites get an extra boost from HP in the form of a high PR backlink, if you continue to write well, your hubs should find their own place in the search engines, eventually.

            I started this thread feeling really down, but now I feel re-energized by some of the comments here.

            Eggs in a lot of baskets is a good idea, for now and forever.

            1. Jean Bakula profile image97
              Jean Bakulaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

              I guess you're right. You never steered me wrong yet. It's easy to get attached to HP when the going's good. It gives us freedom, it's not really formal, and for the most part, everyone is pretty nice and tries to work together. It seems like everyone is trying to figure out what's going on, but it's good to diversify. I'm glad you feel better.

              1. Marisa Wright profile image92
                Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                Tell me about it!  I (and others) have been tearing our hair out, watching Izzy fret over her HP account when she could've created so much in the last six months if she'd only managed to leave HP alone for a while and build some websites instead!

                But I know why - HubPages is addictive, especially if you're a solitary online writer.  It becomes your online home.  It took me a long time to discover I could stop writing Hubs while still being part of the community here. Maybe we should start HubPages Anonymous for recovering Hubaholics...

                1. wilderness profile image96
                  wildernessposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                  But I don't want to recover (just published another one, too).

                  1. IzzyM profile image85
                    IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                    I just totally missed that post you quoted!

                    As I can't find it either (an age thing again) I just to add that I have got my own web sites and blogs.

                    I don't spend nearly as much time on them as I should.

                    I have been given the advice, I know where to go, and what to do.

                    But I do like it here!

                2. Randy Godwin profile image93
                  Randy Godwinposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                  Yes, both you and I found out the hard way about only writing in one place, eh Marisa?  I wouldn't advise anyone to only write in one place these days as both terms and online conditions change too frequently to ever place much trust in any content site. 

                  I think E-Books are perhaps the way to go now!  smile

                3. IzzyM profile image85
                  IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                  HPA, love it!

                  That's me, stuck in the doldrums with my account, but can't let go like many people have done.

                4. Jean Bakula profile image97
                  Jean Bakulaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                  My husband thinks I'm addicted, I think he's jealous I spend so much time on HP. But when I began checking out more sites, it's more time. Sometimes I find myself wishing he would fall asleep on the couch, so I didn't have to feel so guilty that I'd rather be writing. I love him, but I can't stay off the computer! Marisa, you always gave me good advice too. I am shocked at these people who have been on for a week and are telling experienced people like Marisa, Izzy, Wilderness, and Randy (I always see you on the forums) how to go about their writing!

                  1. Randy Godwin profile image93
                    Randy Godwinposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                    Ha!  I've not been on the forums for a week, Jean!  I've been on a 7 day ban thanks to the anonymous mods here on HP.  yikes

      3. sunforged profile image65
        sunforgedposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Perhaps you should examine the platform in more depth. As you do have control of such things if you know what the Hubpages term is  - read some source code before making assumptions

        1. IzzyM profile image85
          IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          +1

      4. TIMETRAVELER2 profile image93
        TIMETRAVELER2posted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I was very interested to read your reply as you seem to know a lot about SEO.  I'm new here and have been trying to do some things such as putting key words in my titles, repeating them when possible and including them in my closing lines, but I'm getting butkus on views.  However, I have checked a few of my articles on Google and some have come up on page 1...but the views from Google are abysmal.

        I find backlinking very difficult, as the backlinked articles have to match what you're writing about, and that doesn't always work out.  Also, I understand hubpages limits you to two non hublink backlinks per article. That's pretty confining.

        I'd love for you to write a hub that includes all of the info you just mentioned plus more so that I can have it all in one place.  Your info seems to be much more in depth than some of the others I've seen.  If you've already done that, please let me know the title as I'd very much like to read it.  Thanks.

        1. Marisa Wright profile image92
          Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Bear in mind that Google now personalizes search results. So other people are not seeing the results you see. Try searching for it on scroogle.org, that will give you the true picture.

          Also, if you're typing the title of your Hub into Google, you will always end up on page 1 - but no one is searching for your title,so that means nothing.



          What do you mean by "the backlinked articles"?  Do you know what a backlink is?  I think you're confused about the two link rule:  when you're writing a Hub, you can have only two links out to the same website.  There's no limit to links coming IN to your Hub.

          There's a lot more to SEO than could possibly be learned from one article. Sign up for a free trial of Market Samurai or Keyword Academy and spend a month watching the videos. Then you'll begin to have some idea.

  2. CMHypno profile image89
    CMHypnoposted 4 years ago

    Hey Izzy I'm going to break my self-imposed forum ban to show some solidarity (only other person I have done it for is the Queen!).  My traffic also hasn't picked up since the August plunge.  I also haven't seen Randy around in a while, so don't know how he's going.

    I've taken a fair few hubs down, and from my broken hub links so have a few others, so I reckon that there is a lot of folk that have just quietly faded away.

    Don't beat yourself up and listen to any negativity as I have just read your shark hub and it is excellent

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Thank you ever so much smile

      I had stopped writing hubs but you know the writer within us is stronger than we are and I just kinda accidentally got back to it.

      I need to get over it, but I just plain don't like putting articles someplace else.

      1. CMHypno profile image89
        CMHypnoposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Izzy, I hate to see you so cut up about this.  Take Lissie's advice and do some writing elsewhere and get your confidence back.  As she suggested, there seems to be a thriving community of ex-hubbers doing well over at Wizzley.

        I have hubs that have 5 stars for time on page that get no traffic and some with 1 that do, so am not entirely sure that time on page is the whole answer either.

        But as the saying goes 'no point in crying over spilt milk', so don't waste valuable time and energy in getting depressed over HP, move your hubs, write articles elsewhere but try and stay in 'go-forward' mode.

        We have such a short time to be happy and a website, however great it used to be, is not worth this anguish.  Write that best selling novel instead!

        1. EmpressFelicity profile image83
          EmpressFelicityposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          +++1

          I am happy to write more hubs, *IF* I know they stand a chance of gaining an audience and/or income. But if I feel my efforts are better directed elsewhere then I have no qualms about moving on. You don't owe HP anything. Your relationship with HP should be an equal relationship, with both parties deriving benefit from it. If you're not feeling the benefit, then don't stay on out of a misguided sense of loyalty.

          The fact that it's possible to have a "slapped" account here on HP, but find that hubs within that account do perfectly well if unpublished and republished elsewhere, should tell you something. Namely that it ain't your writing that's the problem.

  3. FloraBreenRobison profile image60
    FloraBreenRobisonposted 4 years ago

    I've read your writing Izzy, and it just can't be your writing. No way.

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Thank you sweetheart,you have no idea how much your words have helped me smile

  4. Polly C profile image85
    Polly Cposted 4 years ago

    Hi Izzy,

    I really don't think it is your writing though I don't know what the answer is. This is my main hubpages account but I have another one which used to have 130 hubs on - mostly, but not all, sales hubs. I just didn't want to mix them with my very different hubs on this account. I was not making any money and quickly realised that quite a bit could be made from amazon. Last Christmas was excellent and then not so good with Panda.

    So I stopped writing much on this account and concentrated all my efforts on the other one. When the subdomains came out, my traffic shot up and I was really pleased. Like you, I lost most of my traffic very abruptly on Aug 10 and it has never returned with the exception of two days. I made changes, nothing worked so I left it and gave up and wrote some more hubs on this account instead.

    About three months ago I set up a third account and decided to test the waters by moving my hubs to see what happened if they were on yet another account. I have done it very gradually and so far moved only 11 - at first nothing much happened but now, although it is a very low traffic account (and what would you expect with 11 hubs) I am getting more google views than the orignal account, which the hubs originated from.

    Interestingly, with one hub that I moved, I forgot to delete the original and didn't notice for ages - neither account came up as duplicate. When I discovered the error I realised that the hub on the new account had outranked the original by quite a lot - in fact it was on the first page whereas the other one was far behind. Not good.

    The long and short of all this is that I'm not sure it has much to do with the writing at all, but I don't know what the problem is. I do remember, with my slapped account, getting this robotxt message spring up on the screen just before I lost all my traffic but not sure what that meant.

    This account is quite the opposite - traffic is only going up, but unfortunately it does not make much money as many of the hubs are not very commercial.

  5. IzzyM profile image85
    IzzyMposted 4 years ago

    Thanks everyone for responding, and especially those of you who said my writing was OK.

    I think I only started suspecting my writing was suspect when Paul from Hubpages pointed out that my writing did not read well aloud.

    I am ever so sorry about that. I do not know how to fix it.

    I may just have to write a best selling novel to disprove that theory (I wish!)

    All this has left me with serious doubts about my own abilities, and considering that writing was one of the few things I knew I could do well at, this hurts to the core.

    "The long and short of all this is that I'm not sure it has much to do with the writing at all, but I don't know what the problem is. I do remember, with my slapped account, getting this robotxt message spring up on the screen just before I lost all my traffic but not sure what that meant."

    Polly, you said this. You got some message that you didn't understand. I don't understand it either, but then again, I didn't get that message.

    Anyone?

    1. FloraBreenRobison profile image60
      FloraBreenRobisonposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I think that was a nasty thing for Paul to say.. I am familiar with doubting my abilities at something I thought I'd excelled in. For me it was singing and I was told by someone that I should stop singing in public. That stung until I discovered that she insulted everyone, including children. I was 21 at the time.  So I ignored that woman. I would say ignore Paul. you do know how to write. Goggle is just looking for something other than skill at writing. Who knows what.

    2. Polly C profile image85
      Polly Cposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      It was a very fleeting message, I could have missed it if I wasn't looking. I don't know if it is significant or not, but definitely coincided with my downfall! Could it not be the writing at all, but some kind of error to the subdomains?

      You are a good writer, Izzy, and I remember thinking that most of the hubbers who claimed to have been affected were also good writers. I fall short on the technical side of things so haven't a clue how to fix it.

    3. Dorsi profile image90
      Dorsiposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Gosh Izzy I just don't know. Your writing is easy to read, great spelling and grammar from what I can see - with very well researched topics. I just don't have a clue.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Thankyou! Seriously thank you because it is very easy to feel totally worthless when Google suddenly drops you.
        So thanks smile

    4. Jean Bakula profile image97
      Jean Bakulaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Izzy,
      You are a very good writer, and have given so many people excellent advice. I asked lots of questions, and many people gave me bad answers, but your advice was always sound. And who reads this stuff aloud anyway? We aren't doing books on DVD. Go write your novel.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I am reading a brilliant book just now about vampires.

        Do they work for HP? Lol only joking.

        The book is originally Belgique and translated into English.

        It's called 'Let The Right One In' by John Ajvide Lindqvist, and was the inspiration behind 'Let Me In', whatever that is.

  6. Jason Menayan profile image61
    Jason Menayanposted 4 years ago

    Izzy:

    You are a good writer. No one said you were a bad writer, not even Paul. When he said some of your Hubs sounded awkward when read out loud, he meant something like this (taken from one of your Hubs):

    There is something scary about the cat shape, and put women in a cat costume and you have something that is both scary and sexy. Sexy cat Halloween costumes have a timeless look. As an adult, you could buy one and keep it at the back of the wardrobe for use year after year.

    Adult Womens Halloween Costumes Black Feline Kitty Cat Catwoman Costume Dress Theme Party Outfit Roma
    The Adult Womens Halloween Costumes Black Feline Kitty Cat Catwoman Costume Dress Theme Party Outfit Roma is available in sizes small/medium and medium/large.


    I will say to you what I said to Randy: this is not a good demonstration of your writing ability. It sounds decidedly keyword-stuffed, almost spun, and a repackaging of the stuff you would see on an Amazon page. It also seems to demonstrate that you are not personally knowledgeable about the products you are reviewing and hoping to sell via Amazon.

    Amazon sales pages are dangerous to begin with, because while they might convert really well in terms of earnings from each visitor, Google might very well consider them doorway pages, which they're on record as disliking. And keyword stuffing is never a good idea, despite some advice you can read online to the contrary.

    In addition to being a talented writer, in our interactions I know you're a reasonable person so I hope you can understand the motive behind this critique.

  7. IzzyM profile image85
    IzzyMposted 4 years ago

    Aye aye aye aye.

    I hear you.

    That first paragraph you quoted was so good, everyone leapt on board and stole it.

    The second paragraph sounded like something from Amazon. Pitiful, but there you are.

    Are you saying I should unpublish this one hub?

    I will and the others like it, if necessary.

    I am actually failing to see, so need some help, in knowing which hubs Google hates.

    Will ubpublishing just the one hub place the rest back somewhere decent in the search engines?

    Or I am forever destined to walk in dark shadows?

    1. Jason Menayan profile image61
      Jason Menayanposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I don't know enough to advise you here. It would be helpful for others who might have plunged and did some "surgery" on their Hubs, and saw a rebound, to weigh in here.

      That Hub was just one example. Do you have others like it? I can understand the appeal of Amazon sales Hubs in the pre-Panda era, but nowadays I think you have to tread lightly.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I read every post about the collapse/return of traffic.

        I have read everything everyone has to offer on the topic.

        Some people have had their traffic return when they deleted the last post before the latest Panda hit, or the last few hubs.

        Some people did nothing and their traffic returned.

        Yet others deleted all their poorly performing hubs, and their traffic returned.

        Yet others like me, did nothing but add more quality hubs to the www and everyone but Google likes them.

        So then I went back and deleted the poorly hubs....nothing

        So, added them back onboard and deleted the good hubs I had.

        Annihilation. Google liked my good hubs!

        Put them back.

        Look, I'm only a stupid old woman at this stage in my life and I don't know what to do.

        Delete all my Amazon hubs that used to work....?

        1. Jason Menayan profile image61
          Jason Menayanposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Well, it appears that if an account "plunges" it affects the good along with the "bad," very much like Panda swept away a site's traffic without regard to the good-quality stuff.

          1. IzzyM profile image85
            IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            I need some help Jason. Please. What are the 'bad hubs' I need to get rid off?

            1. Jason Menayan profile image61
              Jason Menayanposted 4 years ago in reply to this

              I would unpublish Hubs with short "average time on page" as indicated by Google Analytics. That's what we recommend in the LC entry.

              1. IzzyM profile image85
                IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                Well you know something Jason, I have very few of them. In fact, I have none. Either people read my hubs in their entirety, or they don't read them at all.

              2. IzzyM profile image85
                IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                Jason, is there any way you could ask the powers that be to translate our hubs into foreign languages?

                I only ask because I only found out tonight that a young diabetic friend of mine lost his toe through diabetes.

                I wrote a hub about the danger of this only last year.

                I never even knew he had this problem, no doubt he did his research online like the rest if us.
                If he saw my hub he passed it by, because it was written in English.

                This lad is in his 40s at the most, but could pass for 25.

                Toe first, foot next, whole lower leg next..know the story.

                That is what we are here, everyday experts.

      2. seanorjohn profile image79
        seanorjohnposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        i just don't understand what is going on.

  8. Richieb799 profile image62
    Richieb799posted 4 years ago

    I just wanted to point out that I don't believe these areas; 'well-researched, contains infactual information and is badly written' are what Google puts most emphasis on when ranking your work.

    Not saying that hubbers should neglect these though, I am a strong supporter of well written content but Google might turn a blind eye to 1 or 2 spelling mistakes, I'm not even sure the bot picks up spelling mistakes.

    Obviously duplicate content and spun articles can be detected. I see what Jason is pointing out and I am guilty of basing some product hubs off information in Amazon summaries when I have made the odd Amazon targeted hub

    The first part Izzy wrote sounded really good, but this part does look keyword stuffed:

    Adult Womens Halloween Costumes Black Feline Kitty Cat Catwoman Costume Dress Theme Party Outfit Roma
    The Adult Womens Halloween Costumes Black Feline Kitty Cat Catwoman Costume Dress Theme Party Outfit Roma is available in sizes small/medium and medium/large.


    I have mainly targeted all of my effort towards Adsense now.

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Do you know, I have never done that well when targeting Adsense as I have with targeted Amazon hubs?

      When trying to learn how to write for Adsense, I accidentally targeted Amazon.

      When I realised my earning potential with Amazon,I dumped trying for Adsense.

      Now Adsense and Google are not the same - same company but different departments.


      My Sexy Cats hub, that Jason has mentioned now as well as Paul, brought me loads of traffic, loads of Adsense clicks, but not one single sale.

      I've no idea of the type of ads they used to carry, don't forget I am not in the USA and don't even see their adverts.

      I am grateful to Jason because he has told me, in not so many words, that this hub is partly the reason why Google hates me.

      This is easy to fix, but what else is wrong?

      I have not seen reasonable traffic for nihgh on six months. What else is wrong?

  9. sagebrush_mama profile image82
    sagebrush_mamaposted 4 years ago

    Still suffering the ill effects of the year of the Panda on my account, too.  Sigh!

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Awww, I am so sorry, email me if you need an ear to lean on.

      1. sagebrush_mama profile image82
        sagebrush_mamaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I spent some time in the last year learning more about Squidoo, and didn't do too badly there through the holidays.  Also worked on some blogger stuff, plus took Lissie's advice from a few months ago, and worked on getting a better feel for Wordpress.  Just letting my hubs wait it out a bit, while I learn new things.

  10. Aficionada profile image92
    Aficionadaposted 4 years ago

    There is a video by Matt Cutts in which he discusses several things that can be checked to diagnose the problem when a publisher discovers a drop in rankings.  He referred specifically to the robots.txt issue.  It is probably worth looking at, but I'm not sure we ourselves have anything to do with robots.txt. (Not sure.)

    I transcribed the gist of the video (practically - maybe not totally word for word, I forget) here; my post also includes a link to the video.  Both may be worth checking out.

    http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/84035?p … ost1827598

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I have had a LOT of reports of problems from robotstxt on my webmasters account - which of course is new since sub domains came in.

      As it is totally outwith my control, I refuse to accept liability.

      Am also told that it doesn't matter.

  11. Mutiny92 profile image87
    Mutiny92posted 4 years ago

    You are not alone.  Mine is still down.  I unpublished all but 40ish hubs and did cried in my milk for several months.  That was a hard one for me to deal with because the 250-300 hubs that I unpublished made a decent amount of money before the plunge. 

    After a few months off, I created a second account and decided to start again.  I changed my focus completely and decided to write hubs that were laser-focused on a particular area and answered a particular question. 

    Anyway, I only have 23 hubs published on that account, but I have twice the traffic as this account. 

    I suspect the reason is somewhere in the following:
    - I wrote new hubs on that account that answered a VERY specific question and began most with "How to ..."
    - I wrote much longer hubs (most are over 1,000 words - as compared to this account where most are 300-500)
    - I abandoned the "doorway hub" idea and went to the other extreme by only have a VERY small amount of amazon products per hub.  My amazon sales are still languishing, but I can play with that later.
    - I experimented with several different topics - some started receiving views from google for the keywords targeted within hours (scary-fast!), others did not see any movement for weeks or even months - I have no idea why.
    - I had failures.  These were ones that languished for several months with minimal views.  I unpublished them even though Google was CLEARLY wrong by not ranking them very high!  ;-)  It was much easier to unpublish on that account than it is this one...this one is my first.  I figured that if the articles weren't swimming on their own, they were dead weight and dragging me down.  I may have been wrong, but it seems to be working so far.

    It is completely anecdotal, but I think that unpublishing the vast majority of my hubs of this account is working...my views are up, albeit not substantially.

    So no - you are not alone, but at least in my case, a new account and a fresh start has helped.

    It was very painful to unpublish sooooo much work on this account - I fear I have more to go.

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      You see? You cried when you felt the need to unpublish. You unpublished hubs you thought might be bringing your subdomain down.

      Who the Hell are these Google people anyway?

      I read, today, or was it yesterday, two or three articles that made me cringe.

      Page 1 Google results, so all those folk who feel that Google is now up to scratch are really showing their own ignorance.

      OK Google is run and schooled by children,but this is a writers' site. Or supposed to be.

      I'm sorry. but we are a long way from decent results.

  12. Xenonlit profile image60
    Xenonlitposted 4 years ago

    Somebody had a link to here:

    https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools … -url?pli=1

    I indexed my Hub pages and WordPress account and my views have tripled. Still not that great, but it sure has helped.

    Here's the Bing index toolbox:


    https://ssl.bing.com/webmaster/SubmitSitePage.aspx


    Yahoo was supposed to have something, But it looked to be too big for me.

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      And something here helps me, how?

  13. IzzyM profile image85
    IzzyMposted 4 years ago

    hey nothing matters too much when you hear your kid singing like this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3d63dYCrVg&sns=fb

  14. Lissie profile image85
    Lissieposted 4 years ago

    This is the last time I'm saying this to you Izzy - that account is doomed - stop wasting time worrying about which bit the google algorithm, doesn't like. Un-publish them and move them elsewhere - or ignore them - but you are truely wasting your talent and time there. 

    I am churning out "amazon doorway pages" over at wizzley and they are doing juts fine. Its a hubpages issue you have here nothing to do with you or your writing. Time to move on. IF you like the forums fine - but you will notice that a lot of us have moved to publishing elsewhere.

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Babes, I think you might be right. Maybe it is time I moved on elsewhere. This is painful here now.

  15. LuisEGonzalez profile image81
    LuisEGonzalezposted 4 years ago

    My traffic has fallen to what it was 8 months ago even though I have instituted some changes which are supposed to increase traffic.....hmm

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I am sorry to hear that, Luis.

      1. Cardisa profile image91
        Cardisaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Hi IzzyM, first I want to apologise for my ignorant reply the other day when you mentioned Panda. I had no idea what exactly you were talking about and as a hubber who joined post Panda I can't fully understand.

        I can assure you that your hubs are excellent and I have seen crap displayed on first page of Google when the best articles are on page four or five.

        I wish I could help you because I do see your frustration.

        1. IzzyM profile image85
          IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          No worries, Cardisa. I didn't think your reply was ignorant either, so no need to apologise.

          And thanks smile

  16. Mutiny92 profile image87
    Mutiny92posted 4 years ago

    You can always expirement and unpublish a few of the hubs you think are particularly unappreciated by google and republish them under a new account here. Wait a bit before republishing so as to avoid any duplicate content issues.

    If they perform notably better, it helps to tell the story about this account.

  17. Marisa Wright profile image92
    Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago

    Izzy, there is absolutely nothing wrong with your writing!



    Personally, I wonder if that's part of your problem, right there.  Is it possible you learned your Market Samurai lessons too well?  You might recall I sent you a link to a Google blog post - they said they were targeting was sites which don't write for their readers but instead "generate content by attempting to guess what might rank well in search engines".

    Pre-Panda, that was the recipe for success, which is why you did so well.  Post-Panda, the fact you've got no "specialist subject" and instead write on  a wide variety of topics (including subjects associated with spammers, like Hoodia), all with keywords repeated in every heading and sub-heading, and all promoted heavily, might just have left a big footprint that told Google you were "generating content by attempting to guess what might rank well in search engines".

    I've previously brought up the issue of keyword density - I found a couple of your Hubs had a density up over 6% and you weren't worried.  Once again, it worked for you pre-Panda - but this is now.  No one knows the percentage Google uses, but the consensus seems to be that even 5% is too much.  You may be getting hit for keyword stuffing - and remember, the words in the ads count too.

    The other highly relevant quote from Google is:

    "low-quality content on some parts of a website can impact the whole site’s rankings, and thus removing low quality pages, merging or improving the content of individual shallow pages....could eventually help the rankings of your higher-quality content."

    If you're able to take Hubs from here, publish them elsewhere and have them do well, then it suggests your good Hubs are getting dragged down by the "bad" ones.   

    I think you do know what's a good Hub and what's a bad one. You just have to get over the mindset of, "oh, I can't delete that Hub, it  was one of my best earners pre-Panda".  That was pre-Panda.  It's possible the features which made it work so well pre-Panda (like heavy keyword use in titles and sub-headings etc) are the very things causing the trouble now! And I'd certainly be deleting anything that's on an over-exposed subject, unless it's still earning good money.

    Of course it's still all guessing, but those quotes are from Google itself.

    1. Cardisa profile image91
      Cardisaposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Marisa, you might be on to something here. What has worked well for me is using only 5 key phrases - one main which is included in the title and one more time in the body and four others scattered anywhere. This method I discovered a few months ago when researching Google keywords density. I don't worry so much about percentage because I don't know what percentage Google uses to rank the hub.

  18. LeanMan profile image82
    LeanManposted 4 years ago

    I may be talking absolute BS but I was reading some rubbish about words that Google does not like such as "murder" (CMhypno - you have this in several titles) and cannabis (Izzy) as well as having a downer on anything medical if you are not an established medical site. Maybe the removal of anything in the slightest bit controversial may help??? It can't make things worse to unpublish a few and see if it makes a difference.. I remember checking someone else s accounts a few weeks ago that had plunged and he had several hubs about forex in amongst his other hubs..

    Otherwise I really don't know!

    Or maybe it is just the Google sandbox and it will all rebound back to normal after 6 months or so..

    1. WriteAngled profile image92
      WriteAngledposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I do not think medical hubs per se are the problem. Possibly my medical hubs do not work against me, because I reference and link to the medical journal literature to back my statements. I also know a few hubbers get a massive number of views on hubs about somewhat prurient medical topics. I haven't checked whether they reference the literature or not in those hubs.

      I am wondering if tabloid-style ("yellow press") sensationalist subjects can bring down a sub-domain if there are too many of them. That would include murder stories, celebrity gossip and such like.

      Going by a number of specific hubbers who have reported big drops, I'm fairly convinced that hubs specifically focusing on Amazon sales are bad news now.

      1. Susana S profile image90
        Susana Sposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I don't think amazon hubs are bad news per se, it's just the ratio of them on a subdomain that has to be looked at. If you think about a subdomain from google's point of view then a high proportion of sales pages/doorway pages/affiliate links is probably going to look rather spammy and low value (even though the actual pages might offer great info).

        If overall the subdomain has plenty of quality pages that point to high quality internal & external sources and don't have any aff links in them, then it will help dilute the ratio of affiliate links within the subdomain and keep it below the (possible and unknown) threshold.

        That's my theory anyway!

        1. PaulGoodman67 profile image89
          PaulGoodman67posted 4 years ago in reply to this

          +1  I agree, Susana.

    2. CMHypno profile image89
      CMHypnoposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Hi LeanMan, thanks for your suggestions. I'm gently removing a lot of my hubs, although I think that it is a very sad world if you can't use certain words in your writing without being penalised.  It would be nice if the world was all kittens and bows, but I write a lot of history hubs where unfortunately murder and mayhem were commonplace.

      The big G is beginning to remind me a lot of certain religions, where only the one true and approved word is allowed LOL!  What happened to free expression in writing?

  19. WryLilt profile image86
    WryLiltposted 4 years ago

    This account has picked up but my Amazon earnings account is still in serious slap mode. Used to get me 90% of my Amazon sales - gone from about 250 daily views to maybe 3 and never risen.

    Then again, I'm aware that sales articles are the new "naughty."

  20. LeanMan profile image82
    LeanManposted 4 years ago

    Does anyone have an account with many Amazon sales hubs that is still going strong??

    1. Susana S profile image90
      Susana Sposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I don't know of anyone that has a high ratio of amazon hubs, that hasn't tanked.

      1. WryLilt profile image86
        WryLiltposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        True. I'm thinking of writing some non-sales content but then I'm like...phsaw no, eggs in one basket and all. I have plenty enough eggs here!

        1. Susana S profile image90
          Susana Sposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          You could always unpublish some hubs instead of writing more - that worked for me.

          I was away on holiday most of last August and not online, so I know exactly what I did when I got back and it was just two things. I unpublished 7 hubs that had historically low time on page (under 1 minute) and removed my referral trackers from links. At the time I thought of these minor tweaks as very inconsequential, but something there did the trick.

          As it turned out the hubs I unpublished happened to be sales hubs - mostly amazon but one or two were affiliate hubs for other products. At the next panda run in Sept my account recovered and has stayed recovered (for now at least).

          EDIT: I should add that the pages I unpublished had never received much in the way of sales or ad clicks which led me to believe that most visitors were bouncing back to the search results, rather than bouncing towards an income for me!

          1. WryLilt profile image86
            WryLiltposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            Thanks Susana, might give that a go! Easier than publishing new stuff!

            1. IzzyM profile image85
              IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

              Wrylilt, if your other subdomain was also hit in August, you might might want to wait a bit longer to see if the sandbox effect lifts after six months, which is nearly up.
              I am holding off any major changes until after February, basically because I have tried tweaks and they haven't worked. So its a major overhaul, which I really don;t want to do.
              Mind you HP are at the unpublishing again, so I've yet less hubs to worry about (they took away another one tonight, but I just republished another to keep the numbers up lol)

              1. WryLilt profile image86
                WryLiltposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                Ok thanks. I might use both pieces of advice then. smile

                This is also why I'm loving my own sites at the moment. smile I know the issues, I make my own rules, and it's clear why I'm in trouble if I get in trouble.

  21. IzzyM profile image85
    IzzyMposted 4 years ago

    Thanks everyone for all your comments and ideas.

    Yes sorry it did all really get to me last night, especially as I know of a few hubbers off-site who were fellow plungers, but have recently got all their traffic back, and then some.

    At least two of those accounts have a high proportion of Amazon hubs, so its not that.

    Nor is it the style of writing - what could be termed keyword stuffing - because those accounts have not been changed from pre-Panda, yet traffic has returned.

    I, myself, am now seeing Google love on one hub. It has gone from 2 or 3 views a day to almost 100, and nearly all those views are from Google.com, the rest from the other Googles.

    If they hate my whole subdomain, why send traffic to one hub? Doesn't make sense.

    This hub pre and post-Panda had views in the 100s, and now it seems to be partly back.

    Other 'dead' hubs are picking up Yahoo or Bing traffic, but those search engines are a total mystery to me.

    I would say that round about 90% of my portfolio is dead.

    I did unpublish my cannabis and my 'medical' hubs. They were out of circulation for well over a month, and it made no difference whatsoever, so I put them back. Don't know why, they don't make money without ads. I guess it is because they get hits, and some traffic makes me feel better.

    I also wonder how much HP have to do with all this. When I want to add an in-text link in a hub, on a topic I already have several other hubs about, my hubs never seem to be in the list of 'suggested' hubs. Why is that?

    Lissie is right, it is time to move on.

    Leave the hubs here to do whatever, and just write new articles elsewhere. I hate the thought of losing all that 'ageing' many of them have acquired.

    1. Marisa Wright profile image92
      Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Maybe Sunforged can chime in here, but I've heard him say that once the Hubs have dropped out of the SERPS, they've effectively lost their "ageing" anyway.  So leaving them on HP doesn't offer them any advantage - you may as well move them elsewhere and start afresh.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I would have thought they would lose their ageing if they de-indexed. Simply moving down a few hundred pages should not lose them their age, or does it?

        1. Marisa Wright profile image92
          Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Good question - so none of yours are de-indexed, then?  I thought if you were sandboxed you were de-indexed,so does that mean it's definitely not a sandbox situation?

          1. IzzyM profile image85
            IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            I don't honestly know if none of them are de-indexed, there are too many to check unless someone knows a shortcut. There are 599 results listed for site:izzym.hubages.com but I don't know if all my hubs are there, or if that number is made up of forum posts or whatever.

            I know the Googlebot only crawls about 200 hubs per day.

            Google said there wasn't a problem with my account when I asked for a re-inclusion request.

            I'll maybe go check, but I thought 'the sandbox' was a kind of mythical, unspoken about place that Google never admits exists. If sites are de-indexed, they have a direct issue with Google, but when they are still indexed but way down the list, is that not the sandbox?

  22. relache profile image87
    relacheposted 4 years ago

    Izzy, I think part of what may be hurting your Hubs is weak tagging. 

    You have a lot of nonsense words on what looks like all of your Hubs, words that all start with "iz."  You also have tags like '60 day challenge' that don't relate to the actual topic of the Hub.

    That little stuff adds up especially when it's happening to an entire subdomain.

    1. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      That is interesting. I never was much good at tags but the 60 day challenge one was for off-site promotion, but hey  it doesn't seem to be working now so maybe I should take them off. The iz ones will give me a lot of work as they are rss feeds, but as I have learned now how to do proper rss feeds I could get to work on that.

      Yeah, good idea, thanks, worth a try.

      1. sunforged profile image65
        sunforgedposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Unfortunately, its not as easy as linking to a FAQ but if you did a tiny bit of searching about how tag pages are configured here at HP you would know that they are meaningless now.

        I wont explain. That would be boring. Tags are pointless here no hinder/no help - just internal navigation tools

        Perhaps HP announced it at one point, have to look at the page code otherwise

        1. IzzyM profile image85
          IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Whoaa! Wait a minute, I'd starting working on getting rid of my iz tags. Are you saying I am wasting my time?

          Each feed is pretty big because I have a lot of niche hubs on the same topics.

          Please explain, and thanks by the way for pointing out something I didn't know either. I'd love to learn more about tags if you have the time to explain.

          I knew they were internal, obviously, but was never that sure about how they affected search engines, or not, as the case may be.

          1. sunforged profile image65
            sunforgedposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            Hp neutered the tag pages, they are noindex. Internal links from the main Hub domain to your subdomain, arent helping or hurting you.

            Why the hell would Google care if you had link called Iz?

            That nitpicking foolishness will drive you nuts. Time better spent moving forward developing new content, new places, even here at HP in new accounts.

            Until the moment someone shows you a graph of their account "plunging" then a log showing their edits, date marked with an accompanying graph of a positive effect .. Just close your ears.

            way to many variables and you have way to many hubs to really listen to every pet theory

            Do a search for some really really difficult term - something in insurance or medical - look around at the top page, tell me if those link titles mean any more to you or the content of the page then "iz"

            Tags at HP were unique beasts, one cant call them anything but a "link" now, and a link to a noindex page at that

            1. IzzyM profile image85
              IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

              Thanks, you have saved me a lot of work smile

    2. sunforged profile image65
      sunforgedposted 4 years ago

      Ill throw in some more untested, invalid advice.

      I read somewhere that Google dislikes the use of the color pink in some niches, they also feel that British spelling should never be shown to US readers.

      You might also try and read it out loud. The use of meme talk and images of "kittehs" is shown to be crucial in other niches.

      Have you tried "tweeting" them?

      You should revisit every single article and add 10% new content and add links to only authoritative sources that start with the letter H.

      - You will drive yourself nuts running in circles trying to reverse engineer your SERP's change, especially if you don't make your own changes in a very,very formulaic and trackable manner. which, I think may drive you crazy in its own.

      Have you tried a brand new account yet? Tried moving a select number of hubs to a new "niche focused" account .. or any other more radical changes? The little tweaks hardly seem like they will be worth the huge effort it would take across your rather large portfolio .. you really need to test and watch after each one

      1. CASE1WORKER profile image85
        CASE1WORKERposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I plunged for two months- 90% drop overnight- ( I think it was August) two months to the day- traffic increased  and has maintained its levels.
        What did I do? Got rid  of two hubs that were topical when written but with no lasting search value and then started another account!!
        You work is good as is CMHypno's, it may be that after a six month sandbox you will emerge ( six months must be up soon), if not, you can change and add and delete all you want, but it may be that you would be best to remove some of your  portfolio of work to other sites- therefore reducing the opportunity for another "Panda" shock.

        How is the new account going?

        1. IzzyM profile image85
          IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Its up and down like a yoyo. I've started ignoring it, it gets on my nerves.

          Maybe I should have tried niche topic writing, with a username to match.

      2. Mutiny92 profile image87
        Mutiny92posted 4 years ago in reply to this

        the new account has worked well for me so far.  I have significantly more views on that account with significantly FEWER hubs.  Whatever is tainting the other account can be speculated about, but at the end of the day, the new account really seems to have made a huge difference.  Nothing like a clean slate and a fresh chance to get you re-motivated!

    3. Greekgeek profile image97
      Greekgeekposted 4 years ago

      I can't really speak to most of this because I came back to HP after Panda had done its worst. But I might have two items that could help:

      1) You feel embarrassed about marketing. So do I! What helps get me past my embarrassment is to write reviews of things I LIKE AND USE. That way, I know what I'm talking about, I care about what I'm talking about, and I can stand behind what I'm talking about. I can give pros and cons. I can share photos. It's so much easier to sell stuff -- and more useful to your readers -- if you recommend things you know well and sincerely would recommend if a friend asked your advice. Don't worry about whether it's something that's liable to draw a hefty commission. You're more likely to make a sale, or at least get the reader to Amazon where they might buy SOMETHING.

      2) The whole tags issue. This might help? What's the difference between keywords and tags?

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        That is an excellent article thanks. I'd already started working on one group of my iz tags and so had to complete or I'd have left some hubs out.

        I don't know if HP will now unpublish my other hubs that have those tags or not, but each feed is pretty massive so I don't see why they should. Hope they don't anyway, because each of those feeds have been used extensively in off-site promotion and it would be a shame to lose that.

        Your hubs has filled in a lot of blanks for me, because it puzzled me as to why some people reported that changing their tags increased their traffic, and now I know why.

        I saw before that they were hidden from the search engines, but still wasn't sure of their exact purpose apart from creating internal links.

        The other thing I worry about is categories.

        I write a LOT about sharks, but somehow placing the hubs under 'Pets and Animals' seems to be the wrong place, so most of them end up under Education and Science where there doesn't seem to be a correct category for them, unless I just put them in Oceans and Seas, which isn't strictly the correct place either.

        I'm guessing, and trying to put them under categories where they did well before...wonder if that has anything to do with Google dropping me like a hotcake? Probably not, but worth a look, no?

    4. Mark Ewbie profile image80
      Mark Ewbieposted 4 years ago

      Hi Izzy.

      Seems to me that your main account is screwed.  It's a shame that HP don't make it easier to move pages between accounts. Especially now we have subdomains.

      I know you would lose valuable aging, but if it's screwed anyway doesn't matter what age it is.

      I would remove the Shark articles, create an Izzy Shark Id, and publish them all under one new account.

      Make sure when you put them up again that they are all squeaky clean in terms of decent content.  Not saying anything negative to you, because I haven't read many of your shark articles, but personally I have published some real crap, and it is taking me a long time to go back through and weed it out, fatten it up, etc.

      Sunforged is right about advice.  You can take a rough view on what people are saying, but they are not you, and they don't have your account.

      And I know nothing either of course. Just seems it might be worth a shot.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Good idea, thanks Mark smile

      2. Marisa Wright profile image92
        Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Good idea, but why not on a separate blog?  If you're going to move them, the URL changes anyway. May as well move them out.

        1. Mark Ewbie profile image80
          Mark Ewbieposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Only because I think Izzy loves HubPages.

          1. Marisa Wright profile image92
            Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            Yes she does, as do I.  However, unlike me, Izzy has to make her living at this.  She can't afford to be sentimental.

            1. IzzyM profile image85
              IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

              Yeah well the pressure is off on that quarter now, as I am moving home soon and won't need an income.

              Just as well....!

        2. IzzyM profile image85
          IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Well I just spent the last hour learning how to make a new email address with Gmail (its all changed now), and have set up a new focussed hub account, but I am planning on making a shark website at some point.

          Not for making money because my shark hubs have never made money, but they are interesting.

          It is actually just as easy for to write afresh as it is to copy hubs over anywhere, so I wrote a new hub too smile

          1. Marisa Wright profile image92
            Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            You're lucky in that regard, I find creating totally new material on the same subject a pain.

    5. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago

      These were the top two results when I looked.

      http://www.webduckdesigns.com/pages/web … andbox.php

      http://www.bigoakinc.com/seo-articles/g … effect.php

      I am definitely in the sandbox, and nothing I do or change will bring me out any earlier, so I guess I just have to wait it out.

    6. viryabo profile image86
      viryaboposted 4 years ago

      Izzy, I feel your distress, and was in a similar boat a couple of months ago, so I decided to try out a few things which seem to be working.

      1) I opened two other accounts and had each in a specific niche.

      2) I unpublished hubs related to those niches from here, waited for about 4 weeks, and republished them in the other accounts as per relevance.

      3) I unpublished, some hubs from this account (my main), literally threw them in a bin (with so much pain and anguish too, but hey...). I concluded that they were dragging me down.

      4) Stopped adding new hubs but instead, taking those left one by one and started to rework them, cutting out repeated keywords, checking for typos, rewording some titles, removing all unnecessary "bold" wordings, etc.

      5)I switched off HPads on this account and decided to stick with Adsense. I turned on HPads for one of my new accounts, its earning peanuts at the moment but im experimenting, so im cool with that.

      6) I reduced considerably my Amazon capsules as I wasn't getting much sales anyway, but lo and behold, as soon as i did that, I started to get very steady sales from Amazon. I dont know why/how, but who is complaining?

      7) Started a few websites based on those hubs that bring me good traffic. I get 100% Adsense, and a couple of them are doing fairly well.

      8) I read through Robins hub and tried to follow what she wrote about improving traffic, to the "T".

      9) Removed all challenge and contest tags.

      Then traffic started to inch up here, and now its higher than Pre Panda levels.

      Its such a long process and i still have miles to go as im continuously upgrading.

      How i arrived at this?

      I took some "HARSH ADVICE" (not given to me directly, but to others) while reading forum posts. Mostly, if i may say, from Marissa and Relache. I barely comment in the forums, but i seek out what they say and it is helping me in no small measure.

      You will be okay Izzy and you MUST believe that all is not lost. You seem to me a very determined woman who wants to get things back to normal and i admire your fighting spirit, because despite your continuous plunge, you still find time to write new, and great hubs too.

      I dont write half as well as you do, so i cant really claim that this will work for you, but it certainly worked for me.

      Relax and take it slowly, probably one hub at a time. Cut out the sentiments and throw out the ones you know are under-performing. Or better still, use them for a new website. 

      Set a goal and go through them all. Yes, you have over five hundred hubs, but once you split them into 2 or 3 different niche related accounts, it wont be so hard.

      Dont despair. With patience and your strong determination, you will probably see improvements much sooner than you expect.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Thank you so much for taking the time to write me such a detailed response.

        As the six months are almost up, I am as well waiting a couple more weeks to see if anything changes on its own - as I said already I am basically lazy and the thought of going through this many hubs fills me with dread - then start doing the things you suggest. smile

        1. PaulGoodman67 profile image89
          PaulGoodman67posted 4 years ago in reply to this

          I started this milarky later than most people in this thread, but I really think that I will probably stick with a 200 hub maximum for a HP account - for the reasons you've outlined.  I think Google will keep changing the rules quite regualrly from now on and big accounts, which worked in the past, can seem a little unweidly nowadays, if you have to go through them looking for potential problems and then editing them.

    7. Max Dalton profile image81
      Max Daltonposted 4 years ago

      Hey Izzy,

      I had a traffic drop after the first of the year. I immediately filed a reinclusion request with Google and waited a week. After nothing happened, I removed a handful of low-performing hubs and my traffic came back over the course of the next week and has continued growing steadily.

      I hope you get this worked out. I enjoy reading your hubs, for what it's worth :-)

      Max.

    8. Amanda Severn profile image88
      Amanda Severnposted 4 years ago

      Hi Izzy,

      My traffic was absolutely dire from August onwards, so much so that I stopped writing Hubs altogether, and concentrated my energies elsewhere. Then, just before Christmas I saw something posted by Will Apse about the value of adding polls to your hubs. I thought it might not do any harm to try, so I added a poll to my (previously) best performing hub. Et Voila! Suddenly, since mid-December my traffic is back to pre-Panda levels. I find it hard to believe that adding just one poll had this effect, and it was a probably an enormous co-incedence, but I'm delighted to actually be earning again. Anyway, I hope it will come together for you eventually. There's so much dross on the net, that good writers surely have to float to the top sooner or later.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Congrats on your traffic return!

        Quite a few people have seen a recent return of traffic without making any changes. It's all weird.

        I'm coming to the conclusion that it is my sales hubs, I have a huge proportion of them, some of which have never done well.

        I tried unpublishing some of them and it never worked. I started renaming the ones entitled "Buy...online", but lazy as always, didn't get more than a few done.

        I have far too many hubs!

        What Paul says above about limiting accounts to 200 makes perfect sense when something like this happens.

        That is not to say this will happen again.

        The 'sandbox effect' is applied to new domains. And unless HP change us all back onto the main domain, it shouldn't happen again.

        Everything should settle down inside a year of the change.

        When I started this thread I was feeling really down about it all, but now I feel more philosophical about it all.

        I'd been adding in loads of new, quality, non-sales hubs to no avail, and it is true, it does get to you after a while seeing all that hard work going to waste.

        But maybe when the sandbox is lifted, those new hubs will strengthen my subdomain and make it better than ever.

        Who knows? Fingers crossed.

        1. Amanda Severn profile image88
          Amanda Severnposted 4 years ago in reply to this



          I think you're right Izzy, and the great thing for me is that once the traffic returns, the money comes in for things that were written long ago, and it just keeps on rolling (well, hopefully!)with little or no effort on my part!

        2. Marisa Wright profile image92
          Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Oh Izzy, sometimes I think you're your own worst enemy!  Why on earth would you add more new Hubs to an account that's not working?

          If it's a sandbox issue, I guess those new Hubs will pay off in the end - but they'd have paid off just as well on another account, where they'd have more chance of earlier success.

          But if it's a Panda issue, and you haven't been able to identify the problems that caused you to be hit, then adding new material is just wasting your hard work, as you say.   In particular, if the problem is a few "bad apples", it's not a proportional thing - it doesn't matter how much good stuff you've got, the "low quality" posts will still get you slapped.

    9. LoriSoard profile image79
      LoriSoardposted 4 years ago

      Not happy with the slow climb since starting to post hubs seriously in the last couple of months. Hoping it picks up eventually. If not, hopefully I have at least I have a few solid articles I've written.

    10. Will Apse profile image88
      Will Apseposted 4 years ago

      Izzy-

      The worst thing anyone can do if they have been Google slapped is nothing.

      I would set the stats to total views and unpublish the bottom third for a start. I admit that didn't get my second account up and running again but that had nothing but affiliate hubs. Anyone who has plenty of solid non-affiliate pages could do better.

      Also, I have seen some of my affiliate hubs in this (my main account) get sandboxed. If I remove the affiliate ads (Amazon in my case) they usually pop out of the sandbox.

      So getting rid of all affiliate links could be an option. You could add them back carefully to successful pages later.

      Any of my hubs with low read times get the axe as a matter of course- affiliate or otherwise.

      Also the option of moving pages once they are out of the Google cache is a serious option. I took my best pages from my second account to Wizzley and they started making money after a few weeks.

      Why Wizzley? Well it may crash and burn since it is new and ultra commercial bu it won't hurt my account here and, maybe the management over there know what they are doing. I only need them to avoid Panda for a few months to get a reasonable return on my effort.

      1. Marisa Wright profile image92
        Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Agreed!   The way I see it, even if you do the wrong thing, you stand some chance of success.  In particular, unpublishing Hubs doesn't mean wasting work - you can always use them elsewhere, so you haven't lost anything.

        1. PaulGoodman67 profile image89
          PaulGoodman67posted 4 years ago in reply to this

          I'm gonna give Wizzley a go too, although they effectively reward you for publishing more hubs/pages, which almost encourages low quality, in some ways?  They are supposed to be fairly well vetted so I hope that's not the case!

          1. Marisa Wright profile image92
            Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            I think it makes sense to spread your work around - for one thing, as you've observed, once you get more than 200 articles on any rev-share website, it gets unwieldy to update when rules change (as they inevitably do). 

            One possible solution for surplus Amazon Hubs is to create a review site. I recently came across a Wordpress plugin (www.myreviewplugin.com) which marks up each of your posts with Google rich snippets.  I'm thinking this should prove to Google that you're writing a serious review not a landing page?

            1. IzzyM profile image85
              IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

              Talking of landing pages, I was writing a new hub this evening (not on this account) and I went to add an in-text link, and Amazon results came up!

              ?

              Anyone else?

              Is this something new?

              1. GinnyLee profile image95
                GinnyLeeposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                It's been there for a little while.  There are a couple of options between amazon and hubs.  I use it every now and then, but I am fearful of having too many links back out to amazon, so I stay away from them mostly.

                1. PaulGoodman67 profile image89
                  PaulGoodman67posted 4 years ago in reply to this

                  Rather than moving sales hubs, I am gonna create some new material for now at Wizzley.  I have deleted a few crappy sales hubs from here and also pretty much erradicated any Amazon ads on non-sales hubs.

                  I agree that spreading eggs between baskets isn't a bad idea, the only thing to be wary of is the other extreme of
                  spreading oneself too thinly!  :-)

                  1. IzzyM profile image85
                    IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                    Talking of thinly, I now have 3 other subdomains, and I have already confused myself.

                    Easily done at my age!

                    What are the rules exactly about forum posting when we have different personalities?

                    I know I couldn't use my other names to flame, but I'm not a flamer anyway, but can I use them to forum post? Or not?

                    I'd like to see those other accounts get a bit of interest from forum users, is it OK to say it's me, Izzy, and post, or is it OK to not say anything, and post?

                    1. Marisa Wright profile image92
                      Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                      I wish I knew.  I thought the rule was you had to pick an identity and stick to it - however since then, I've seen people use different accounts.  I think the rule is that you can only use one persona on a particular thread.

                    2. rmcrayne profile image94
                      rmcrayneposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                      Here's what HP says:

                      Multiple Accounts: While we don't prohibit having more than one HubPages account, we ask that you stick to a single persona in the forums. The deceptive use of multiple accounts, especially in a single thread is prohibited. The use of secondary accounts to circumvent a forum ban is also prohibited.

                  2. Marisa Wright profile image92
                    Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                    But is it really possible to spread oneself to thinly?  Provided they're not paying you direct, it's not a problem - all your income from multiple sites goes into one basket.

                2. IzzyM profile image85
                  IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                  Really? Thanks for responding.

                  It's a new thing to me smile

    11. Bard of Ely profile image88
      Bard of Elyposted 4 years ago

      My traffic is down too and as you can see my Hubscore is only at 90 now which is the lowest it has been since my first year here!

      1. Will Apse profile image88
        Will Apseposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        My traffic is at a lowish point but I don't think either of us has been Google slapped. I am expecting mine to go back up again.

        1. rmcrayne profile image94
          rmcrayneposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          My traffic has been unusually low for a couple days, down about 30%-40%.  Given that I have followed this thread, reading just about every post, it does give me cause for a little paranoid concern.

          1. Sally's Trove profile image97
            Sally's Troveposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            I, too, have read each post in this thread. My traffic, like yours, has been going down, although over the last two months instead of over a couple of days. This, after a huge surge starting in August 2011. I don't know that I feel paranoid about this, more like clueless. What I'm thinking about now is that there's an equalizing process going on, totally dictated by Google. By equalizing, I mean content is being ranked based on readers' patterns (as gathered by such things as Google Plus), and readers' patterns are shifting, perhaps away from the "content rich" and into the "easily digestible" and the trend-based. One thing I do know is that the majority of my traffic comes not from search engines in general but from Google in particular. If I want traffic to my Hubs, Google needs to be appeased. But anyone who might know how to do that isn't sayin', so to speak, unless they work for Google and know what the magic formula is but share it only with, perhaps, their pets.

            From everything I learned in this thread and from the advice of others with whom I've been conversing over time, I decided to unpublish my most poorly performing Hubs (poor performance measured by lack of Google traffic and also by lack of time on page). Maybe doing so will strengthen what remains in my subdomain here, maybe not. But I'm also off looking for new venues.

            @IizzyM, what happened to your Hubs here has not happened to mine in such a drastic way. Yet, the punch hurts. It really is time for me to move on from investing my writing in a shared site like this one. I do think there are good reasons to maintain a presence here, maybe for the purpose of feeding into online venues I own outright, at least for as long as HP continues to be a credible business. The cliche about not putting all your eggs in one basket was never more true than now.

            1. PaulGoodman67 profile image89
              PaulGoodman67posted 4 years ago in reply to this

              I suspect time on page is the important one.  Google's concern is about what it considers low quality, or not relevant material achieving high positions in the search results - lack of traffic almost by definition means that a hub is not in this category.  On the other hand, as Paul E and Jason have said, a hub could be getting lots of traffic and earnings and be considered "low quality" by Google, because, for instance, they consider it to just be a doorway to Amazon.

              My traffic has slumped badly too recently (although not crashed).  Like Will, I am hoping that it is essentially just a seasonal drop and there will be a gradual recovery over the next couple of months.

      2. shibashake profile image84
        shibashakeposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        This thread on Webmaster World has an interesting discussion on Jan Google algorithm changes.
        http://www.webmasterworld.com/google/4402875-9-30.htm

        Some people are saying that changes in traffic could be from the new social Google+ integration. Others speculate that it could be because there was a refresh on long tail keywords.

    12. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago

      I don't think ebooks are the way to go.

      I think everyone and his grandmother has jumped aboard the ebook bandwagon, and the public are not better served.

      They are in some cases, because many a brilliant writer would never have been discovered had not not been for ebooks.

      BUT, and its a big but, we also have the biggest plagiarists on the web stealing other people's writings and ideas and putting it in their ebooks.

      Real-life 'friends' of mine got ripped off big time at the start of the ebook revolution.

      They paid $100 for an ebook promising them the secrets of how to make a great pizza.

      They paid for this, unknown to me, while I was working with them helping them set up a pizza parlour.

      They are not friends or they would have confided in me that they didn't have a clue, not just about how to make pizzas, but how to use the net, because there a million free recipes out there.

      So they got got their fingers burned.

      Who else did?

      Do you really thing the public want more of that?

      Find a publisher for your writings. It may take a bit longer, but published works do better long term, apart from those who get lucky breaks.

      1. Lissie profile image85
        Lissieposted 4 years ago in reply to this



        So not true - basically now if you want to be published in some genres you should have your book up there and selling so that the publisher knows there is a market first.

        Also why would you as a successful author want to pay the middleman, and make your public pay more because of it. One of the best scifi books I've read recently is from hubpages own http://www.amazon.com/The-Galactic-Mage … B006VCZMVS - he couldn't get a publisher - the book was a bit different you see ...

        1. IzzyM profile image85
          IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Oh Lissie I am only trying to inject a bit of realism into the thread.

          Yes there are exceptions, and Hubpages in the whole is home to an enormous creative writing talent.

          In fact, writers here are probably better placed to write books than most of our top authors who need editors and proof-readers to take out the spelling mistakes etc.

          That is your biggest expense in the middle-man thing. Paying someone to fix your own errors.

          Then again, agents need their cut, printers need theirs, and at the end of the day, there are not a lot of JK Rowlings around, who became a multi-millionaires through their writings. (she did get a lot of help from the British government, all the same)

          I have taken a kinda sideways step, and wrote that site that sells books.

          It's still on the front page of Google, though God knows how when I ignore it, but I need to put my creative talent there and add everyone and every book to it, which is a huge undertaking for one person, but can be done.

          If I removed myself from these forums.

          Point is, we can market ourselves quite well. Only I haven't written anything, but if I did... lol

    13. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago

      And now that I have totally taken over this thread, can anyone explain to me why, after Google send the bots round, as they do at least every half hour according to Analytics real time, I get a flurry of traffic right after, that tails away?

      1. Randy Godwin profile image93
        Randy Godwinposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Perhaps the penalty has to be removed while the bots do their thing.  But who knows, this is merely a guess.

        1. IzzyM profile image85
          IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Do you see the same, Randy?

          It's like they like what they see, but then they 'phone home' and get told 'forget it!'

          1. Randy Godwin profile image93
            Randy Godwinposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            Nope, I don't even look anymore, Izzy!  If my traffic rises I'll know it without frustrating myself checking all of the other ways.  It's not worth it to me. smile

    14. Don Simkovich profile image59
      Don Simkovichposted 4 years ago

      One of my hubs published in Aug '08 didn't get any traffic until March '09 and it's my highest producing hub. The traffic dipped along with my others and then two days ago it reached the highest levels ever. It dipped yesterday.

      I occasionally add a new sentence at the beginning. I've been going into my other hubs, tweaking the titles, and adding a bit new content. We'll see if this sustains.

    15. EmpressFelicity profile image83
      EmpressFelicityposted 4 years ago

      Reading this jogged my memory.

      I remember reading a forum post way back (might not even have been here) about the robots.txt file.

      It's a file used by site owners to give search engine crawlers/robots instructions about whether to index that site (or page(s) within that site).

      http://www.robotstxt.org/faq.html
      http://www.robotstxt.org/robotstxt.html

      1. WryLilt profile image86
        WryLiltposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Confused as to relation to topic? I believe this may be used on some images/certain types of index pages, but otherwise would not be an issue on HP?

        1. EmpressFelicity profile image83
          EmpressFelicityposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          I don't know. I only put it out there because that's what was in the message that Izzy said flashed momentarily on her screen all those months ago.

          Perhaps a member of staff can explain whether such files are used on HP and if so, whether they're relevant to the Google-slapping issue and if/how it's possible for a person with a slapped subdomain to go about fixing them.

          Though it's 2.30 am on a Sunday in California so I don't think any of us should hold our breath.

          1. IzzyM profile image85
            IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            It didn't flash up on my screen (or if it did, I missed it), I was quoting it happening to someone else (using inverted commas instead of the proper quote syntax). Was it Jean is happened to?

            It is relevant here because someone lost all their traffic immediately after this message popped up.

            But if its a file used by site owners to give search engine crawlers/robots instructions about whether to index that site (or page(s) within that site), could a mistake have been made resulting in someone losing all their traffic?

            Or not.

            It's not something I know a lot about. Or anything about for that matter, really.

            But the whole subdomain switch must have been a huge amount of work and mistakes can be made.

            1. Polly C profile image85
              Polly Cposted 4 years ago in reply to this

              It was me, but I've no idea what the relevance is, if any.

              1. IzzyM profile image85
                IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

                So sorry Polly. I'd started that reply before I realised your comment was too far back in the thread to be seen from the reply box!

    16. viryabo profile image86
      viryaboposted 4 years ago

      In my newest account, hubbers leave comments on some hubs or my profile and end it with "welcome to hubpages".

      It feels so strange not being able to say "oh hi XYZ, its only me, viryabo".

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        LOL, on one of newest accounts a hub greeter stopped by and commented about how professional my hub looked for a newbie. I replied something along the lines of how I only write about x,y,z. And then she cottoned, "oh, oh a niche account"! lol

        1. viryabo profile image86
          viryaboposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          lol

    17. incomeguru profile image84
      incomeguruposted 4 years ago

      IzzyM is one of the great hubbers most of us try to emulate. I posted a thread some days ago, titled "is this another google panda" when i noticed traffic to my best hubs declining at an alarming rate. Surprisingly, after deleting less performing hubs, traffic has started rising again.

      1. IzzyM profile image85
        IzzyMposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Thank you for that 'great hubber' bit though I am not so sure it is true LOL, but happy to hear you got your traffic back!

    18. incomeguru profile image84
      incomeguruposted 4 years ago

      Of course with your level of success here, you still remain one of the great hubbers. If you don't know, then let me you this, some of us are looking for ways of matching your success.

    19. PaulGoodman67 profile image89
      PaulGoodman67posted 4 years ago

      I got the worst traffic I've seen for months yesterday.  Yes, I know that Saturday is a bad day and January is a relatively bad month, but this traffic was almost on a level with Xmas Day or New Year's Eve.  The worrying thing is that my traffic hasn't crashed but has been gradually worsening over the last few weeks (despite me writing more).  I hope I can turn things around with the work I've done at diminishing Amazon capsules and hubs.

      1. rmcrayne profile image94
        rmcrayneposted 4 years ago in reply to this
    20. skyfire profile image72
      skyfireposted 4 years ago

      I don't know who spread the word for pages with amazon links being "doorway pages" but considering the success of some of the other affiliates with that strategy, this sounds funny to me.

    21. Richieb799 profile image62
      Richieb799posted 4 years ago

      I notice it requires a lot more backlinks to get our pages ranking higher compared to when I first started, I think online marketing and writing is becoming a lot more popular and niches more scarce.

    22. Bianu profile image61
      Bianuposted 4 years ago

      Some of my hubs start off with very low traffic. Then pick up after about six months. What if I delete a hub just as it is about to take off.

      Is there no science to this Google traffic challenge?

      1. Randy Godwin profile image93
        Randy Godwinposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Nope, no science at all!  Google has gotten too big for their britches and seek to rule the internet in their favor.  Otherwise, where did their latest huge profits come from after the Panda introduction?  I sincerely hope they are scrutinized closely by those authorized to investigate those breaking the anti-trust laws in this country.

    23. IzzyM profile image85
      IzzyMposted 4 years ago

      Yet others are seeing a jump in traffic. http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/92005
      Guess Google hasn't finished...

     
    working