I realized today that when I post an article to Redgage or certain social media sites like FB it puts a thumbnail of the first image of my Hub next to my text. Of course I am very careful to attribute every picture used in my work, but how the heck do you attribute that, or do you even have to? I know I can stop it from happening on Redgage, but how do you prevent it on FB? For that matter, wouldn't anyone who shared my content on FB face the same issue?
What is standard practice on this?
The image is linked to source with facebook, so if it is attributed here, you are covered, locations like pinterest and maybe redgage which save a copy of the image might open a different set of issues as you are inadvertently sharing an image without credits which could be passed on thousands of times.
That's what bugs me about Pinterest - their TOS says you mustn't pin copyright images but the casual user isn't going to notice that warning.
I'm willing to bet most of the images on Pinterest ARE copyright or Creative Commons licensed, so they're all illegal. Worse, Pinterest's TOS say they retain the right to use or SELL those photos in perpetuity.
It's really, really useful to read up on this court case. Basically, Fair Use absolves you of copyright violation based on Four Factors which must be judged in court. Wikipedia covers the Four Factors in the initial case really well.
Initially, the court ruled AGAINST fair use -- see the links above for why. Then Google appealed and got this decision reversed.
See why Google's use of thumbnails in image search was eventually ruled Fair Use.
The key factors are:
1. The use is transformative, providing a service the original image didn't (locating something)
2. The amount of the original work excerpted was NOT substantial -- a thumbnail, not the whole work
3. The impact on the original work's potential commercial value or marketability wasn't effected
Pinterest (I think) fails on 2 and 3. A full-sized copy of a photo distributed for free very definitely impacts the marketability and value of that photo.
But -- if I'm understanding that court case correctly -- a social bookmark with a small thumbnail would pass factor 2 the same way Google did, and it's too small to compete directly with the original work's commercial value and potential market. (In fact, it may help it.)
by WriteAngled4 years ago
I'm wondering if anyone can enlighten me on copyright and attribution issues with respect to products sold on Amazon. If I write a hub that focuses specifically on one or more Amazon products, where do I stand with...
by Mary Hyatt20 months ago
I see Hubs where beautiful photos are used and are from Pinterest. The photos are usually credited as being from Pins. Are we allowed to use those photos??
by Kelley Eidem8 weeks ago
Here is a heads up if you're looking to increase your page views.In the last 24 hours, Pinterest has been the source of over 1,100 visitors to my Hubpage along with nearly 3,400 in the last week.They've sent nearly...
by Eric Dockett11 days ago
Some of the redesigned sites are not showing the attribution SOURCE link for photos. I see this on sites where the author bio has been moved to the center. On sites like Spinditty, which have not yet been changed over...
by LetterWriter5 years ago
I want to write a HUB and it will discuss about a dozen online images. I want the reader to be able to see the images as I include them with my writing in my HUB article. I could try to get approval for all of them, but...
by Eugene Brennan6 weeks ago
I've done this on a few hubs. Maybe it's a good idea because if someone does an image search, the photo with text relevant to the content of the hub can stand out amongst the competition.What do you think?
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.