5 Problems With Today's Educational System

Where I am coming from...

I am teacher. This is my fourteenth year of teaching. I have predominantly been teaching in Australia. I have taught in a rural school and two city schools. I am currently teaching overseas. I teach Mathematics and Science to high school grade students. The opinions that I express below are my own and may or may not represent other teachers views. That said,here are what I think are the 5 major issues today in the educational contexts that I have taught in.

The five major issues

1. It's not my fault!

2. Cult of the individual

3. Everyone is a winner

4. Life is good so why try harder...

5. Administrivia

Its not my fault.....

Our society has taken the no blame approach too far. By this I mean no one takes responsibility for anything. Think about it. When you get a new car insurance policy and you read its guidelines, one of the first things that it recommends after an accident it not to accept responsibility. It warns you not to utter statements after an accident like " I am sorry it was all my fault".

This response has gone to ridiculous extremes in schools. I have seen students committing a transgression and when I have questioned them over it, their response has been " I didn't do it" even though I have seen the behaviour with my own eyes. unsurprisingly this bizarre response is reinforced by parents. A real life example I have witnessed occurred when a student threw his shoe on to the roof. He then climbed onto the roof to retrieve it. A duty teacher saw this and took him to the deputy. The deputy principal called the boys father and the fathers response was " so what's the problem... he was getting his shoe back". Lets not worry that the boy might have fallen off the roof and permanently injured himself and or others. If that had occurred the parents response would have been "my sons hurt and its all your fault... why didn't a duty teacher stop him".

I am not claiming that all parents are unsupportive of school discipline, guidance and proceedures but those that are not supportive or downright antagonistic have increased since I started teaching.

2. Cult of the individual

In schools the cult of the individual as in society is at its zenith. The individual is the most important and students are well aware of their rights. What is lacking is the reinforcement of responsibility.

Students and much of society only want the rights i.e I have the right to do what I want with no regard to the rights of others... This is played out everyday in classrooms when one student continually misbehaves impacting on the rights of all the others to learn.

The sense of community due in the West to the minimizing of families and our own self righteousness is on the increase. This is of course felt in schools where teachers try to foster a sense of community with students who increasing have poor communication skills and an inflated sense of their own self importance.

How does this effect education.. well learning is a social phenomenon and without relationships it is that much harder.

3. Everyone's a winner

In Educations quest to make everyone feel good about themselves, no one really fails anymore. This is setting up the youth of today to believe that they can succeed at anything. Whilst in theory this sounds admirable in reality we are creating monsters who never get told " you cant".

This sets up sudents who enter the workforce with an unrealistic ideal. If you continually dont submit your reports on time your boss wont say " good try better luck next time" he or she will say" 'you're fired!"

4. Life is good why try harder...

Life in Australia is nice. The weather is good, there is enough space and if you don't work these things are still true. Some students have realised this and have decided to take the approach if I don't try.. I cant fail and my life will still be OK...

This means that a significant group of students don't try at school as they know that the Australian taxpayer will pick up the bill in terms of welfare for the rest of their lives.

5. Administrivia

Or excuse me when do I get time to plan for my lessons. In the time that I have been a teacher the accountability that teachers must show has increased.. this means that there is less time to plan for students and more time to fill in forms and attend meetings.. Ironically those teachers who struggle get rewarded with more time to do these things by being given extra time off or less responsibility as they cant be trusted. Whilst the capable ones just get more work to do.

These issues in a nutshell are my top 5 reasons that education is in the doldrums. How to fix these issues....

1. Parents need to be more involved in their child's education and in their childs life... A good teacher is no substitute for caring and concerned parents/guardians

2. Pay teachers what they are worth. Teachers are one of the most important groups in our society they educate our most precious resource our youth.

3. Give teachers back the time they need to do their core buisiness... teaching and planning for teaching.

Comments 8 comments

sarovai profile image

sarovai 7 years ago

Students needed more attention from bothsides parents as well as teachers to get grooved for a healthy society.This hub will give some sort of awareness bothsides.


Anthony Manzo 6 years ago

There is not single solitary School of Education anywhere on the planet that is seriously dedicated to answering the seminal question of Professional Education: Which are our Best Practices daily Teaching practices? For this reason Teacher Education remains chaotic and schools are ill served. Please consider being the institution to pioneer this elementary reform.

In the evolving tradition of Freakonomics, there sometimes are very simple and cheap solutions to very complex questions to which an industry becomes blind. Educational reformers and especially Secretary of Education Arne Duncan could greatly advance educational practices in the USA as well as the rest of the world by taking one absolutely essential step prior to extending the school day or other such radical and expensive and dislocating proposals.

With may be asking the wrong questions or not realizing that the question has been raised but not answered but merely exploited. The lack of an answer - or even a set of protocols - for determining which are our Best Methods leaves us without the most substantive seeds of content from which most all practical science proceeds. Logically it also leaves us without a core curriculum in basic pedagogy; in effect we have no grounds on which to claim that we are even capable of providing Teacher Education. Apart from a few very broad and somewhat ambiguous statements there can be, and is, a very great variation in what teachers are being taught about teaching from campus to campus and even classroom to classroom. I have been trying for many years to bring some greater level of awareness to the need for us to work collaboratively toward something of a dynamic algorithm that any and all can participate in for identifying Good, Better and Best Practices, and as importantly, the shaping of the means by which these determinations would be made generically and in specific situations. Progress in Professional Education should proceed at light speed from this point forward, for once all stakeholders - teachers, professors, school leadership, state and Federal Departments - will share some common referents. A new and real authority will exist, KNOWLEDGE.

Please consider my cobbled together, and admittedly relatively personalized, effort as a mere example of what is possible and necessary. It has provisions for empiricism, choice, situation, and most importantly for putting the best methods now available in the hands of millions of teachers, K-16. It is not a one-size-fits-all equation but rather one that is a contract between project directors and teachers to better regulate a currently unregulated market, namely, identification and choice of teaching methodology.

Thank you,

Anthony V. Manzo, Ph.D.

Professor Emeritus

Lake Forest CA

Here is a URL and opening page...

http://bestmethodsofinstruction.com/

14,073 Visits Since 01/01/2008

Best Methods of Instruction

Beta Site for the Teaching Optimization Rubric & Choice (TORC) System: a Reflective Model for Identifying and Classifying Good, Better, Best Practices in Classroom Based Instruction


cmcelvee profile image

cmcelvee 6 years ago

I personally agree about the 'it is not my fault' idea you presented. I'm working on getting my degree in music education and it sucks seeing things like this happen. There are teachers out there that we have to observe for a certain amount of hours, and honestly, they are not what I envisioned education to be. They sit around and wait for things to happen all around them, and when something doesn't go as planned, they look at the students and blame them. It's my personal philosophy that if the students aren't learning anything, then it's the teacher's fault. There are no exceptions. Anyone can learn anything at any age.

Good article...


elearning guy 6 years ago

i also agree with this... and it sucks that these things are easily avoidable


chinenye idabor 6 years ago

how is it true


Abdul Majid Najar 5 years ago

We have to change our educational system from an Instructor to Facilitator to understand a child in a clear way method,we have to choose experiential way of teaching and forget conventional(formal education) system of teaching,eg;by play way method/Icebreakers,Short Anecdotes,Life Skills,Communication Skills by providind the children mock phones to let them understand the telephonic skills and the Communication ettiquattes.

Thanks

Abdul Majid Najar

Gudoora Pulwama

Tehsil and Distt-Pulwama

P/o-Inder(192301)

najar_labs123@rediffmail.com

9697321959


hiit 4 years ago

That's what I call a "great hub". Thank you so much.

Ron from http://www.intervalstraining.net


Ali Sambo 2 years ago

A little bit useful bt not what am looking for

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    More by this Author


    Click to Rate This Article
    working