Capt. Jonathan Davis's Incredible Tale

There were many gunfights in the Old West. Some were famous and made their way into the annals of history. Others may have been more dramatic and deadly, but never attained great fame. Such is the story of Captain Jonathan R. Davis, James McDonald and Dr. Bolivar Sparks. Although major newspapers across the country carried the story it soon became old news and eventually, virtually forgotten.

The three were heading for a quartz mine near Placerville, California December 19, 1854 when they were set upon by a band of 14 blood thirsty cutthroats. James McDonald of Alabama, was immediately shot and killed, his pistol still in its holster. Dr. Bolivar A. Sparks, of Mississippi, fired twice and was struck twice before he fell mortally wounded. Now only Davis, a South Carolinian, stood to fight.

His white hat made him an easy target. Or so his attackers thought. To their utter amazement Davis drew his two pistols and began firing into their midst. What the band of desperados didn’t know was they had picked the wrong man to tangle with. Captain Davis was known as one of the deadliest gunslingers in the Old West. The barrels of his revolvers had barely cleared leather before a pair of dumbfounded bandits bit the dust.

The outlaws returned the fire, but the mutton chopped Captain’s aim proved to be much more accurate. By the time his pistols were empty, seven outlaws lay dead. Davis then drew a Bowie knife and waded into what was left of the group, neatly sidestepping the barrage of bullets tearing through his clothing.

Three more fell as he slashed and stabbed his way forward. The gang leader briefly stopped to survey the scene of carnage surrounding him. Angered at the lone man standing before him who had decimated virtually all of his men, he made a last desperate charge brandishing a four-foot cavalry saber. The gang leader promptly lost part of his nose and one finger for his folly. One more lost his life to Davis’s blade and the rest were quickly dispatched with knife wounds. Three would later die from their injuries and a few were fortunate enough to escape with all their members intact.

A party of three amazed miners witnessed Davis’s valiant action from a nearby hilltop, but by the time they arrived to lend a hand it was all over. The trio found Captain Davis tending to Spark’s wounds and surprisingly, the surviving attackers as well. They also saw a bloody scene with eleven men sprawled on the ground. Eight were dead, three were soon to be and the rest were regretting the fact they woke up that morning. The end total of 11 dead became an official Old West record for the most killed in a single battle by one man.

Captain Davis received two minor flesh wounds during the fray. It was reported there were 28 bullet holes through his hat and clothes…17 through his hat and 11 through his coat and shirt. The miners searched the dead bodies and found $491 in gold and silver coin, four ounces of gold dust, seven gold watches and two silver watches which they had stolen from 10 others who had crossed their path earlier.

When things had quieted down, the group buried the dead in shallow graves. Davis took the loot and carried his friend down the mountain to his home. Sparks ended up dying a few days later and Davis donated the money to Spark's family.

At first, nobody believed Davis’s outlandish tale even though the 3 witnesses swore to the facts and signed depositions describing what they had seen. Davis offered to lead the disbelievers to the grave site. There were no takers.

Davis was born in Monticello, South Carolina on August 5, 1816. In December 1846, he enlisted in the Palmetto Regiment of Volunteers to serve in the Mexican War. He was quickly promoted to second lieutenant, and fought honorably in many battles.

In 1848, after being wounded in action at Churubusco, he was Mustered out of the army with an honorary rank of Captain. He later joined the California Gold Rush and was known for his skill with a pistol and as a fencing expert.

More by this Author

  • The Old West Wagon Trains
    4

    Life on a wagon train could be extremely harsh. These hardy souls arose very early each morning before dawn to prepare for the day. A normal routine would be to start the fire, prepare breakfast, gather the livestock,...

  • Cold Blooded Outlaw Sam Brown
    13

    Sam Brown was said to be the meanest, cold blooded killer ever to set foot in Nevada Territory. He was known to have killed between 15 to 20 odd men, some for absolutely no reason whatsoever.

  • The Ruthless Outlaw Cullen Baker
    8

    Cullen Montgomery Baker was without a doubt, one of meanest, cold blooded killers in the Old West. He once shot and killed a black slave woman simply because he didn’t like her looks and Cullen Baker did not like...


Comments 6 comments

Nils Visser profile image

Nils Visser 5 years ago from The Low Countries

I'm really beginning to enjoy these hubs of yours. You've taken what used to be a series of visual impressions (from childhood play, tv shows, movies and visiting a few places in the Western US) and made them become alive by introducing the actual people who inhabited these places, in a conversational tone which, to me at least, strikes a good balance between matter-of-fact and well rationed superlatives and adjectives. I try to do the same for Medieval England and France, talk about the real people who lived there, not the cardboard cut-outs. So, keep 'em coming. As an honorary Okie (lived there), I'd love anything on some of the outrageous characters amongs the Sooners, if I may be so bold as to replace a request.


femmeflashpoint 5 years ago

If it weren't for a Carolinian accent, I could maybe fall in love with this guy!

How suave rico! I'd never heard of him until I read it here, and so glad you've managed to come across it and fill us in!

I loved it! Voted up, up, up!

P.S. I mean no offense to my Carolina friends and kin. Those accents are a challenge for my ears, lol.


vicki goodwin profile image

vicki goodwin 5 years ago from Winchester Kentucky

What a great article. I loved how you brought him to life. I enjoy reading about history and you are gifted at providing great information. Thanks!!


JY3502 profile image

JY3502 5 years ago from Florence, South Carolina Author

Nils, I'm sure I have more already done. But I writem when I findem.

Femme, why are you falling in love with him...he was army and besides I taught him everything he knows.

Vicki, thanks. I try very hard.


femmeflashpoint 5 years ago

No worries JY - you know my heart will always belong to the Corps, lol.

But, still, what a guy! Courage and valor warrants kudos!

And, since a Marine taught him everything he knew ... well then, that explains everything, doesn't it?


Jroll 2 years ago

This would make a great movie! I'm surprised Hollywood has never done it given that the story has been around for quite some time and is completely true. There've been more old west movies about unsubstantiated accounts and fables and yet here we have the real thing.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working