Controversy - Hanging Gardens of Babylon Facts and Five Possible Locations

Source

Were They Real?

Hub Question:What happened to the Hanging Gardens of ancient Babylon? Asked by bethperry.

The Seven Wonders of the Ancient World were a big part of the Elementary School curriculum when I attended school. In my city, they were also a standard part of the architecture of open air shopping centers until nearly 1980. These attractions brought additional customers to the local shopping centers for a day of sightseeing and shopping.

The Hanging Gardens of Babylon and the Tower of Babel

A 19th century interpretation of the Hanging Gardens of Babylon, with the Tower of Babel in the background. Image often found in textbooks.
A 19th century interpretation of the Hanging Gardens of Babylon, with the Tower of Babel in the background. Image often found in textbooks. | Source

Models of the Hanging Gardens

In Central Ohio, the Great Western Shopping Center was a huge retail complex of department stores, smaller shops, a movie theater, banks, and several restaurants. the open air mall also included seven large displays of reproductions of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World in its parking lot.

Visitors from out of state drove all the way to Central Ohio to see these reproductions and local school children visited them often as an elementary school field trip until the 1980s.

The model of the Hanging Gardens of Babylon was very lifelike, with terracing and actual plants, but no one knew where Babylon was located at the time. The exhibit looked much like the color image from the 18th Century featured above.

The Sialk Ziggurat

The Sialk Ziggurat, based on the archeological record.
The Sialk Ziggurat, based on the archeological record. | Source

Were the Gardens Hanging or Standing at a Height?

Rather than hanging gardens, many researchers agree that the garden plants stood in containers on the successively indented steps of the pyramid-like ziggurat in Babylon. Legend has it that the gardens contained many pools and fountains as well as plants, but this is unsubstantiated by the archaeological record of findings as yet. It is evident, though, that irrigation was used to bring water to the top of the structure to water the plants in a trickle-down effect of some sort.

The oldest ziggurat found to date is the Sialk ziggurat of 3,000 BC, although one part of it in the rear looks to be from around 7,500 BC. Located in Kashan, Iran it stands near the Fin Garden in the same city. The Fin Garden contains many pools and other water installations, all of which have a cooling effect in hot, dry weather. The Hanging Gardens of Babylon may have been arranged similarly, with pools and fountains among ornamental and even food plants.

What Was the Location?

Professional, academic and amateur researchers disagree upon an assumption by many that the Hanging Gardens of Babylon existed as such. While sources discuss what form the gardens took and the possibility of their reality, several state that the gardens may have existed in 600 BC as part of the structure of a ziggurat that was a standard architectural element along the Euphrates River during the era. The exact location of the gardens has been a matter for discussion until 2011 and that year's new evidence, but discussion continues still.

Some researchers feel that there are two questions:

  1. Did the Hanging Gardens of Babylon Exist? and
  2. Were they located in Mosul or Nineveh?

Several sources report that there is no mention of hanging gardens at all in the relevant cuneiform record of Babylon and, surprisingly, also no mention of King Nebuchadnezzar II’s wife Amyitis, for whom the King supposedly built the gardens in his desert climate in order to remind her of her greener homeland, Persia. The archaeological record shows that the Euphrates River has moved since those days, burying western portions of civilizations and the remains of the Hanging Gardens and its ziggurat for future excavators to find. Still other researchers feel that the Babylonian gardens were in Nineveh. The latter may be true, based on 2011 information found in Chaldean documents of the era (discussion and reference below).

If the Hanging Gardens existed, which the Chaldeans confirmed in writing, then the gardens and their ziggurat were buried when the Euphrates River shifted course with recurring floods, or were pulled down in war. Archaeology is an ongoing discipline and excavators continue to work at older digs looking for new evidence and artifacts and may find some new evidence near the rebuilt Babylon today. We do not know yet, but the Hanging Gardens might have been on the Marduk ziggurat that was dedicated to that Babylonian sun god.

Some Newer Evidence:

Patricia Casas-Agustench, Albert Salas-Huetos and Jordi Salas-Salvado; Mediterranean nuts: origins, ancient medicinal benefits and symbolism. Public Health Nutrition December 2011 14 : pp 2296-230.

The archaeological record shows that in or near the year 2000 BC in Mesopotamia, the Chaldeans left clay tablets on which they had written information. They described walnut groves in the Hanging Gardens of Babylon, along with pistachio trees. This seems clear evidence of the existence of the hanging gardens.

The Chaldean language is Neo-Aramaic and spoken on the plain of Mosul, where Nineveh was located. This might suggest that the hanging gardens were in Nineveh. If so, their current location as a rebuilt city means that the ruins were carried downstream as well as buried (see map below).

"Belsazar's Feast" by Rembrandt

"MENE", "MENE", "TEKEL", "UPHARSIN"
"MENE", "MENE", "TEKEL", "UPHARSIN" | Source

What Happened?

Babylon fell in battle to the Persians in 539 BC, which means that the Persians may or may not have pulled down the hanging gardens in battle.

According to the works of the scholar Herodotus and Daniel 5:1-4 (the Bible):

In October, 539 BC, King Belshazzar (two reigns after Nebuchadnezzar II) held a feast in Babylon for 1000 party-goers, but used sacred vessels and utensils that had been stolen from the Temple of Jerusalem, for toasting other gods, even others than the usual sun god. A great disembodied hand immediately appeared and wrote on the wall in Aramaic the famous words “MENE, MENE, TEKEL UPHARSIN." Daniel was called to interpret: "God hath numbered thy kingdom and finished it (written twice). Thou art weighed in the balance and found wanting. Thy kingdom is divided and given to the Medes and Persians"

Regardless of whether the gardens were pulled down or not, the Euphrates River changed course during flooding and likely buried most of Babylon, whose ruins finally surfaced and were dug eastward of the river, where they sit today. However, part of the ruins still lie beneath the riverbed of the Euphrates, waiting.

Five Possible Locations In Iraq and Iran

show route and directions
A markerAl Hillah -
Hillah, Iraq
[get directions]

A possible site of the Hanging Gardens

B markerNineveh (Mosul) -
Al-Mosul, Iraq
[get directions]

In early 2012, a preponderance of evidence points to this being the site of old Babylon. If so, ruins were carried downstream to Babil.

C markerKashan, Iran -
Kāshān, Iran
[get directions]

Location of the Sialk ziggurat and the Fin Garden.

D markerBabil, Iraq -
Bābil, Iraq
[get directions]

The current Babylon site, rebuilt.

E markerBirs, Iraq (formerly Borsippa, called Babylon) -
Qimmat Dashti Bird Ghriban، Iraq
[get directions]

Source

Research Completed from 1899 - 2014

The ruins of Babylon were found as crumbled stone walls in 1899 during archaeological research sponsored by British museums and academic institutions. In 1983, Saddam Hussein began to rebuild the city, etching his name on the bricks used in construction. His project was interrupted by the War in Iraq in 2003.

The ruins today are located largely east of the Euphrates River.

The US Army Corps of Engineers entered Iraq during Operation Enduring Freedom in 2003 and unfortunately, did further damage. However, later in 2003, the US military and others began helping Iraqi agencies rebuild the ruins of Babylon as a historical preservation project. The photograph below illustrates a rebuilt city that looks very plain in 2005. In May of 2009, Iraqi leaders reopened the rebuilt city to the public as part of a cultural tourism outreach.

In early May 2013, two decades of research findings brought Dr. Stephanie Dalley of Oxford University to the conclusion that the gardens were built in Nineveh by the Assyrian ruler Sennacherib. However, a bas-relief images of the gardens that originated in Sennacherib's palace was discovered in the 1840s, but crumbled away. Someone made a drawing of the bas-relief at the time of discovery, but no one is old enough at this time (the 2010s) to attest to remember and actually attest its validity. We have only the drawing in a pre-Civil War era book in the UK and no validating evidence.

Another confounding circumstance is that researchers think that since Assyria conquered Babylon, then Assyria took the name of New Babylon, That is a possibility. reportedly, Sennacherib took the names of the city gates of Babylon and used them anew in Nineveh after Nineveh fell in 689 BC. A good piece of evidence is that Dr. Dalley also feels that ancient historians who visited Babylon to see the gardens actually visited Nineveh, based on specific descriptions found in their writings.

show route and directions
A markerEuphrates River -
Euphrates River, Iraq
[get directions]

The river near old Babylon.

B markerTigris River -
Tigris River, Iraq
[get directions]

The river near Nineveh.

Babil (Babylon) Iraq in 2005

(www.news.navy.mil/view_single.asp?id=23141)
(www.news.navy.mil/view_single.asp?id=23141) | Source

In interesting DVD about the Hanging Gardens

Click thumbnail to view full-size
Part of Fin Garden, IraqAn Interpretation of the Hanging Gardens in 1726 (18th Century). Directory for the historical Persian Fin Garden.
Part of Fin Garden, Iraq
Part of Fin Garden, Iraq | Source
An Interpretation of the Hanging Gardens in 1726 (18th Century).
An Interpretation of the Hanging Gardens in 1726 (18th Century). | Source
Directory for the historical Persian Fin Garden.
Directory for the historical Persian Fin Garden. | Source

#14/30

More by this Author


Comments 17 comments

Michael J Rapp profile image

Michael J Rapp 4 years ago from United States

Interesting Hub. Like many wonders of the ancient world, the very existence of the Hanging Gardens is open to debate. I like to think the stories are rooted in fact, or else they would not have perservered for so long.


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 4 years ago from North America Author

Yes, I'd really like to see a hanging gardens of this type today.


Reginald Boswell profile image

Reginald Boswell 4 years ago from Alabama

Useful information for an aspiring historian also the map can be a great teaching tool in religious or secular settings, voted up.


bethperry profile image

bethperry 4 years ago from Tennesee

Patty, fascinating! If they are under water or otherwise covered it certainly would be wonderful to see them unearthed. And I agree, seeing this kind of garden used in today's architecture would be lovely.

Thanks for posting and voting up!


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 4 years ago from North America Author

I saw that the Trump Tower in NYC features about a dozen blooming trees standing on the outside at a group of windows. It's a similar idea that might be expanded maybe.


WD Curry 111 profile image

WD Curry 111 4 years ago from Space Coast

I love stuff like this. I bet they existed and were located in the ancient city of Babylon.

I think the reference to the mall was interesting. It made me think that maybe the Rastafarians are right, and our culture is Babylon. They may be off a little. It seems more like Pre-fab-a-lon to me.


Trish_M profile image

Trish_M 4 years ago from The English Midlands

Hi :)

Fascinating subject.

I really enjoyed reading this :)


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 4 years ago from North America Author

Pre-fab-a-lon. I like that.


GoodLady profile image

GoodLady 4 years ago from Rome, Italy

http://www.gardenvisit.com/garden/isola_bella

Thought you might like to see this! Nothing as spectacular the Babylonian Hanging Gardens (what research, thanks so much for your Hub), but it's the same sort of idea isn't it? Inspired by the Hanging Gardens.


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 4 years ago from North America Author

Some of the photos over there are pretty interesting.


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 4 years ago from North America Author

I'm sure that Hubbers have done work with terraced gardens, so I'm going to attempt an RSS feed n this Hub to link them up.


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 4 years ago from North America Author

I'm sure that Hubbers have done work with terraced gardens, so I'm going to attempt an RSS feed n this Hub to link them up.


drbj profile image

drbj 4 years ago from south Florida

Thanks to your extensive research, Patti, it would appear that the Hanging Gardens of Babylon or Nineveh may have suffered a fate akin to that of the sunken city of Atlantis. Thanks for this excellent historical update.


"bohemiotx" 4 years ago

Good article. I'm glad they have 4ft X 8ft raised gardens nowadays. The Tower of Babel story always depressed me. I prefer to recognize that languages, such as the Indo-European differentiated into Latin and later the Romance family. French and Romanian split off first. You can read some Portuguese if your Spanish is intermediate to advanced!


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 4 years ago from North America Author

drjb - That sounds right! I hope we find more of the garden structures.

bohemiotx - I just read about the Basque language on the Genographic Project website and no new information was in the new release. Still not related to any other language.


CelticWillow67 profile image

CelticWillow67 4 years ago from Central New Jersey

Found you by hub-hopping, and very glad it brought me here! Very interesting and well researched writing. Voted you up and very interesting! :-)


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 4 years ago from North America Author

I find some very interesting things by Hub-Hopping as well, CelticWillow67. I am glad you find this one. It will be interesting to see how well the rebuilt Babylon in Iraq draws visitors. I don't think it has a garden, but it would be a nice addition.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working