Empiricism - The Rise of Rationalism

Rene Descartes
Rene Descartes

Empiricism - The Rise of Rationalism

Western thought was dominated by Aristotle's philosophy throughout the Middle Ages. But with the advent of the Scientific Revolution in the 16th century, Aristotelianism and it's empiricist account of knowledge was heavily challenged.

It is tempting to associate the rise of modern science with the success of observation and experience. But even more important than observation and experience was a new willingness to reject sensory experience as superficial and misleading. Modern science put a new emphasis on controlled experimentation and mathematics. This caused a profound realization that the world was often not what it appeared to be, which led to rationalism. It appears that the sun is orbiting the earth, yet Copernicus and Galileo proved the opposite to be true. In other words naïve observation got things backward.

As would be expected then, the three great philosophers of the early modern period were rationalists and not empiricists. They were Rene Descartes(1596-1650) Baruch de Spinoza(1632-77), and Gottfried Leibniz(1646-1716). They were impressed by the 'new sciences' and rejected Aristotelian empiricism while emphasizing the importance of abstract thought and deductive reasoning.

Rationalism - the idea that the world can only be known through reasoning and not experience - was given a new boost by the onset of modern science. Lets take an example of Descartes; the melting wax. In liquid form it has very different properties from a solid object. From sensory experience you know that it is different now, yet you judge it to be the same thing. What you know is the enduring object itself, and you know it with your intellect, not your eyes. What is called seeing is in fact judging. When I see a book lying on the table, am I seeing it? For Descartes(as for Plato) the answer would be no; what I see is a flux of shifting shapes and colors, and I think, 'This is a book'.

Descartes argued that we cannot acquire our ideas from sensory experience, because that would be like thinking that sound waves are actually travelling through telephone lines when we speak, when in fact the lines just relay electrical impulses that trigger the sounds of voices in telephones. So although many of our ideas seems to come from sensory experience, the ideas themselves already had to be in our minds in the first place. Descartes concluded that ideas were innate.

To sum up - The Scientific Revolution was driven by the rationalist principle that objects in the visible world are often not what they appear to be.

More by this Author


Leave me a Comment about Empiricism - The Rise of Rationalism 3 comments

stephane86 6 years ago

Your article is interesting. It has always been my understanding that empiricism is actually at the heart of the scientific revolution. The Scientists of the 17th century were driven by the conviction and belief that the world was real, and that it had an actual, rational and intelligible value. In reality, they owed much to the Scholastic theories of the Middle Ages, and I think, the new emphasis of reason played a greater role in the realization of the new conception of the world that tended to enclose human reason in a prison of deterministic causality.


Amy Becherer profile image

Amy Becherer 6 years ago from St. Louis, MO

My understanding of rationalism is next to nothing so please take that into consideration. I wonder where this concept leaves the blind, or intellectually limited. For instance, a low IQ does not necessarily prohibit recognizing a book as a book. My question would be the idea of color. It is a universal chart recognized by everyone, but the color blind. Rationalism would say we don't see the colors, but rather we "think" blue, green, reds. How, then, does it follow that everyone recognizes blue as blue, green as green and red as red? Extremely well written, thought provoking read. Thank you


CWanamaker profile image

CWanamaker 5 years ago from Arizona

Very good hub.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Source: The Bedside Baccalaureate

    Click to Rate This Article
    working